Vodafone rip off - 15,000 % overcharge !!!
Vodafone rip off - 15,000 % overcharge !!!
Author
Discussion

Henry-F

Original Poster:

4,791 posts

276 months

Tuesday 18th February 2014
quotequote all
A word of warning to business owners.

We have a number of mobile phones within the organisation several of which are with Vodafone. Not the cheapest of the mobile providers and we have struggled with coverage compared to the newer providers at times. But I'm an old fashioned sort of chap who has had mobiles for over 25 years. My first mobile was direct with Motorola, came with it's own carrying handle and very definitely didn't fit in your pocket. The charges were eye watering but that was how things were then. We got moved to Vodafone, they stopped our analogue airtime and forced us onto the digital network. With great sadness the Motorola 8500X was retired. But I still saw Vodafone as a pillar of the mobile communications universe. Hell, Jenson and Lewis have their logo permanently emblazoned upon the torso, head, feet, underpants and probably toothbrush.

But I digress. Fast forward to the current day and I was handed a mobile phone bill for one of our employees which included a charge of £280 for data. Now I'm a man of the world, I won't deny that I'm partial to a drop of pornography from time to time so I could see how usage might rack up. Cold winter evening, phone in hand showing young lad with boyish good looks skipping through the forest, his clothes getting snagged on the various branches until...... hey we've all seen the video. No? Just me then !

Closer inspection showed data usage totaling 187MB. It's quite hard to quantify a MB in terms of what you get for your bytes but cost wise 500MB would typically cost you £5 on a monthly basis. So at 187MB the young man wasn't pushing the boat out quite as much as I had first assumed. The problem was that Vodafone charge £1.50 per MB. That works out at £750 rather than the usual £5 that is a staggering 15,000 % mark up.

Yes, you read that correctly. Vodafone have ripped us off to the tune of 15,000% over charge.

Worse still when I called the people who organise our mobile phones - a green fruit with a big seed famous for it's oil in Italy and often used to garnish cocktails. They just shrugged their shoulders. Yep, that's right mobile data is charged at £1.50 per MB on your plan. No warning messages, no questions, you just browse away whilst they try and keep up pocketing your cash. 18 minutes surfing the interweb, that will be £47 please sir. It would be cheaper to wander into The Booby Trap and enjoy their young fillies for 18 minutes. Even without their 3 for 1 offer !

So if you are on a Vodafone plan or have organised your mobile phones check your contract carefully for over usage charges or charges where no data usage has been agreed. Indeed make sure that where you don't make provision for mobile data none can be used. We are lucky, it was only one employee and over 2 months we are a "mere" £500 down.

Be warned !!!

Henry smile

+ mod note: No naming and shaming please +
+ Just seen this and edited posts accordingly. Sorry. I see the Business section as more of a business owner to business owner backwater ! +



Edited by Henry-F on Thursday 20th February 11:41

Simpo Two

93,087 posts

296 months

Tuesday 18th February 2014
quotequote all
Sadly that seems to be how many companies boost their profits these days - put it in the small print and hope you don't notice. It does not seem a good way to do business IMHO.

Mr Overheads

2,635 posts

207 months

Tuesday 18th February 2014
quotequote all
Correct it's an absolute minefield. You need to ensure that each SIM has the correct contract for the phone it's going into. i.e. if it's a Voice and Text contract DON'T put it into any smartphone. How did your employee end up with a Voice SIM in a Smartphone? Was he issued witha spare sim lying in a drawer or has he swapped it to a different device?

The worst case I've seen was of a truck driver that watched 2Gb of video in one day (he put his cab phone sim into his iPad apparently) and that incurred £3k of cost in one day in the UK.

All the networks have the same exorbitant charges for data used on a non-data sim. We often put data on every sim regardless because if the bolt-on costs say £5 per month you might get back £125 in subsidy so in effect they pay you £5 to add a new data connection.

Mobile phone fleet procurement is a speciality of mine and it's rare for us to not find at least 40% reduction in costs by accumulation of marginal gains.

Or are we talking about Roaming here? Which is a whole different set of complications.


98elise

32,878 posts

192 months

Tuesday 18th February 2014
quotequote all
We got stung when smartphones first came out. My wife bought the phone without a data package as she had no need of internet on the move. There was no warning that the phone would do that its self though.

We ended up with massive charges in the first month, even though the phone had been back with them for repairs for half the time.

I compained and was told that nothing could be done to prevent the phone from using mobile data, and I would have to suck up the charges.

I did a bit of research and found that they could add GPRS bar to the account, and it would stop. When asked specifically about that, they agreed to do it. No more big bills.


Henry-F

Original Poster:

4,791 posts

276 months

Tuesday 18th February 2014
quotequote all
No the charges weren't for roaming. A Vodafone contract on Vodafone in the UK.

The chap had been given a phone which had internet capability by a friend. Put the SIM card from his old phone in and thought nothing of it, no messages came up to say charges would be levied and to be fair he wasn't being silly with usage Checked a couple of emails, typical stuff.

It has been a nightmare. Because the phones were ordered through the green fruit famous for it's oil all the normal channels at Vodafone drew a blank, they couldn't see the invoices. I spent two hours calling all over the world, getting put on hold, dropped, hung up on returned to the green fruit famous for it's oil - they had two bites at the cherry with different employees "J" & "B" until finally at the end of the afternoon I spoke with someone in the Vodafone partner support team.

When they spoke to Vodafone they were told that the charge would stand. What they were actually being told was the charge was correct, which technically it is. The length of time we've been with Vodafone has worked against us, we are still on a legacy contract written when mobile internet didn't really exist so the billing is technically correct. What the green fruit famous for it's oil should have done was to then put in a request for a commercial credit or some such thing. They didn't, they just left it to us to stump up the £500. I only found this out when I bypassed the very people who should know what they are talking about and have our best interest at heart. I think the green fruit famous for it's oil are just busy trying to buy contracts without knowing about them or worrying about adding value. They just want bums on seats.

Now I'm talking to the right people at Vodafone I'm hoping common sense will prevail. If not I'll have to let the small claims court decide whether the green fruit famous for it's oil should have lined us up for such a huge risk - for considerably less than we are paying for voice, text and no data their competitors offer voice, text and the comfort of some data just in case.

I'm also not sure how the small claims court will view Vodafone's 15,000% too expensive data charges with no notification to the user whatsoever. To be fair to Vodafone I'm told most contracts these days would send a message as soon as data was used stating there would be a £4.50 charge per 250 MB. They clearly have a big hole in long standing customer contracts.

Longer standing customers will often be business owners keen to preserve numbers (yes I know you can port them over) who will have owned their mobile numbers for a long time and so be less likely to jump ship every 12 or 24 months. Take a couple of minutes to make sure you don't fall victim as we have done.

Henry smile



Edited by Henry-F on Thursday 20th February 11:30

Mr Overheads

2,635 posts

207 months

Tuesday 18th February 2014
quotequote all
Henry

I have a contact at Olive that I was speaking to only last week, do you mind if I talk to him tomorrow and see if he can do anything. If you pm me your Account number or something else that he can use to identify your case I'll take that as a yes and get on with it tomorrow.

Cheers
D

Henry-F

Original Poster:

4,791 posts

276 months

Wednesday 19th February 2014
quotequote all
Thanks for the offer D. Much appreciated and what PH is all about helping each other.

Having managed to speak directly to the people the green fruit famous for it's oil deal with at Vodafone I have got things under control. My chap at Vodafone is going to call the girls at Olive in the morning, Hold their hands and tell them what to do.

Mobile phone contracts aren't rocket science, Now I'm aware of the problem I'll tidy things up in a couple of months when the contracts come to an end.

We haven't been very lucky when it comes to phones. We were introduced to the green fruit famous for it's oil by a company called 4com plc as part of a plan they had to "save us money". The single worst decision I have made in over 25 years in business. I am planning the celebrations already for November when 4Com and Shire Leasing will no longer exist in my life.

And they say car dealers are a dodgy lot smile

Henry


Edited by Henry-F on Thursday 20th February 11:32

einstein75

120 posts

196 months

Wednesday 19th February 2014
quotequote all
OP, following on from this;

Mr Overheads said:
Correct it's an absolute minefield. You need to ensure that each SIM has the correct contract for the phone it's going into. i.e. if it's a Voice and Text contract DON'T put it into any smartphone. How did your employee end up with a Voice SIM in a Smartphone? Was he issued witha spare sim lying in a drawer or has he swapped it to a different device?

All the networks have the same exorbitant charges for data used on a non-data sim. We often put data on every sim regardless because if the bolt-on costs say £5 per month you might get back £125 in subsidy so in effect they pay you £5 to add a new data connection.
Just playing devil's advocate here evil , I assume you're now educating your employees so they don't go sticking their SIMs into phones that their friends gave them and also making them aware of the consequences? I think the title is a bit misleading, as technically you haven't been overcharged, more a case of being unaware of the charging structure on your account.

Edited by einstein75 on Wednesday 19th February 14:15

2222

295 posts

182 months

Wednesday 19th February 2014
quotequote all
einstein75 said:
OP, following on from this;

Mr Overheads said:
Correct it's an absolute minefield. You need to ensure that each SIM has the correct contract for the phone it's going into. i.e. if it's a Voice and Text contract DON'T put it into any smartphone. How did your employee end up with a Voice SIM in a Smartphone? Was he issued witha spare sim lying in a drawer or has he swapped it to a different device?

All the networks have the same exorbitant charges for data used on a non-data sim. We often put data on every sim regardless because if the bolt-on costs say £5 per month you might get back £125 in subsidy so in effect they pay you £5 to add a new data connection.
Just playing devil's advocate here evil , I assume you're now educating your employees so they don't go sticking their SIMs into phones that their friends gave them and also making them aware of the consequences? I think the title is a bit misleading, as technically you haven't been overcharged, more a case of being unaware of the charging structure on your account.

Edited by einstein75 on Wednesday 19th February 14:15
Exactly this.
Your issue should be with your employee not with Vodafone and Olive.
You purchased a contract which stated the charges, if your employee takes his sim and changes the phone, why isn't it their fault?

We have thousands of phones with Voda and managed by Olive and look at our contract on an annual basis.

Maybe you should learn a few lessons from this experience wink

Henry-F

Original Poster:

4,791 posts

276 months

Wednesday 19th February 2014
quotequote all
The non data sims now have a block on them to prevent this happening again !

I am struggling to see how a company with the reputation of Vodafone can offer a sim plan which charges UK based users 500MB at £750 rather than the usual £5 for data on their own Vodafone network with no message to warn users. There is simply no justification for it. By their own admission non "bolt on" data is usually charged at £4.50 for 250MB and a message is sent when the user first tries to access data.

I am also struggling to understand how the green fruit famous for it's oil, an organisation supposedly well versed in all things mobile technology can see it as acceptable to have a customer on some obscure "legacy" tariff dating back many years. This in spite of a contract last reviewed and set up in January 2012. It would seem rather reckless to leave customers open to such danger when the alternative is so cheap. I was offered a voice, text and 250MB sim plan for £7 from our land line phone provider this week. That is considerably less than the phone in question costs me. No phones are included in either package.

Henry smile



Edited by Henry-F on Thursday 20th February 11:33

LooneyTunes

9,517 posts

189 months

Thursday 20th February 2014
quotequote all
Henry-F said:
I am struggling to see how a company with the reputation of Vodafone can offer a sim plan which charges UK based users 500MB at £750 rather than the usual £5 for data on their own Vodafone network with no message to warn users.
I realise it doesn't help, but their argument will be that they DO inform the contracting party when they sign up and, if that's a corporate who then fails to advise their users it is not Vodafone who are remiss. Not to mention that for the plan in question £5/500MB isn't "usual", £1.50.MB is.

If the phone didn't have an international bar on it, would you expect a warning before an (expensive) international call was connected?

Engineer1

10,486 posts

240 months

Thursday 20th February 2014
quotequote all
LooneyTunes said:
Henry-F said:
I am struggling to see how a company with the reputation of Vodafone can offer a sim plan which charges UK based users 500MB at £750 rather than the usual £5 for data on their own Vodafone network with no message to warn users.
I realise it doesn't help, but their argument will be that they DO inform the contracting party when they sign up and, if that's a corporate who then fails to advise their users it is not Vodafone who are remiss. Not to mention that for the plan in question £5/500MB isn't "usual", £1.50.MB is.

If the phone didn't have an international bar on it, would you expect a warning before an (expensive) international call was connected?
This you ended up with the wrong sim in the wrong phone on the wrong contract, all because an employee swapped their sim into another phone.

Mr Overheads

2,635 posts

207 months

Thursday 20th February 2014
quotequote all
So 2 lessons:
1) Don't let staff swap sims - if they do they pay any extra charges incurred
2) The contract renewal process was clearly flawed, if you are on a legacy tariff I would expect huge savings (and I'm not talking about using data on non-data sims) by moving to a better tariff that reflects the way users now use their phones. Also if it was last renewed Jan 2012 then that time is now.
[P.S. I would highly recommend getting external advice, nudge nudge wink wink]

Henry-F

Original Poster:

4,791 posts

276 months

Thursday 20th February 2014
quotequote all
The contract runs out in April, it was renewed early with the remaining time added to the new contract.

As I said previously the green fruit famous for it's oil who arranged the contract are ultimately responsible for advising us and making sure we are protected. It is damning that they merely wiped their hands of the problem when Vodafone confirmed the billing wasn't erroneous. They should have known where to go to get the matter sorted.

I find it interesting that people involved in telecommunications see nothing wrong in having a plan which charges £5 worth (to your average Joe in the street) of domestic data at £750.

That's why people make television programmes poking fun at mobile phone sales staff and why the rest of us view the industry with such suspicion. The various plans offered by the major brands are solely there to confuse customers and maximise profits. The layout on websites is intended to deter comparison, whole term costs vary massively when there are only a few pounds difference in up front costs.

Paying £30 up front for a phone rather than £60 makes a difference of £90. Paying £669.99 up front for your iPhone rather than £39.99 sees you £150 worse off. If you chose to pay nothing up front you are still £70 better off than the mug who chose to buy the phone outright - and electing not to pay the £39.99 up front costs you £80 more over the full term.

The ironic thing is that poor old Wonga and their kind are getting lambasted for much smaller amounts !

As a customer we are merely commodities which gets traded from company to company. Egg Plant sells our contract to Courgette who in turn sell it to Daffodil who get bought out by Potato PLC. We have no say (fictitious names so as not to contravene naming and shaming).

Ah well.

I shall carry on trying to resolve the matter with Vodafone then arrange suitable contracts myself once our current contracts come to an end.

The irony of it all is that the best deal we have currently is my 13 year old daughter's iPhone contract organised whilst drinking tea in our sitting room !

Henry smile






Edited by Henry-F on Thursday 20th February 11:39

Henry-F

Original Poster:

4,791 posts

276 months

Thursday 20th February 2014
quotequote all
Mr Overheads said:
So 2 lessons:
1) Don't let staff swap sims - if they do they pay any extra charges incurred
2) The contract renewal process was clearly flawed, if you are on a legacy tariff I would expect huge savings (and I'm not talking about using data on non-data sims) by moving to a better tariff that reflects the way users now use their phones. Also if it was last renewed Jan 2012 then that time is now.
[P.S. I would highly recommend getting external advice, nudge nudge wink wink]
I'm not sure I entirely agree

The lesson is to make sure there are safety nets on all contracts to ensure a company doesn't fall foul of the mobile tariff minefield that clearly exists.

How do you sit an employee down and tell him that you need £500 off him for data that would cost less than £3.50 on his, his wife's and his daughter's mobile phone? This isn't the 1800's. Good staff are an asset which need protecting. They aren't the enemy, they aren't stupid idiots who need treating like children.

The guy thought he was doing us a favour by responding to emails in his own time and ultimately he was. It just never occurred to him that Vodafone would have a tariff which charged UK data out at 15,000% more than his family phones. Certainly if they did he would expect a little text message to warn him as soon as data was used.

Henry smile

Henry-F

Original Poster:

4,791 posts

276 months

Thursday 20th February 2014
quotequote all
LooneyTunes said:
I realise it doesn't help, but their argument will be that they DO inform the contracting party when they sign up and, if that's a corporate who then fails to advise their users it is not Vodafone who are remiss.
The problem is when you arrange phone contracts through one of Vodafone's partners such as the green fruit famous for it's oil you might not actually see the fine print. You could merely be signing an abridged version drawn up by them.

Henry smile

ChasW

2,163 posts

233 months

Thursday 20th February 2014
quotequote all
We had a work phone pinched but did not discover it was missing for a month after the event. The miscreant ran up a bill of £100k+ downloading from some Eastern European site. We challenged the provider, who have a big arena by the Thames in East London, as to why the abnormal use was not spotted and reported. Apparently the usage ceilings only apply to personal and not business customers. Had it been a private phone the service would have been cut off at £1000. After escalating the issue up the management chain the problem was resolved eventually.

Engineer1

10,486 posts

240 months

Thursday 20th February 2014
quotequote all
ChasW said:
We had a work phone pinched but did not discover it was missing for a month after the event. The miscreant ran up a bill of £100k+ downloading from some Eastern European site. We challenged the provider, who have a big arena by the Thames in East London, as to why the abnormal use was not spotted and reported. Apparently the usage ceilings only apply to personal and not business customers. Had it been a private phone the service would have been cut off at £1000. After escalating the issue up the management chain the problem was resolved eventually.
You can see why though for all the companies getting huge bills because of lost or stolen phones there will be companies losing contracts because the provider stopped their phone at an abitrary limit.

Fidgits

17,202 posts

260 months

Thursday 20th February 2014
quotequote all
Henry-F said:
I am struggling to see how a company with the reputation of Vodafone can offer a sim plan which charges UK based users 500MB at £750 rather than the usual £5 for data on their own Vodafone network with no message to warn users.
I guess they do in a similar way to a car dealer who offers to sell cars cheaper without a warranty, so if it breaks down you foot the bill yourself, or pay more upfront to cover those charges wink

Henry-F

Original Poster:

4,791 posts

276 months

Thursday 20th February 2014
quotequote all
Fidgits said:
I guess they do in a similar way to a car dealer who offers to sell cars cheaper without a warranty, so if it breaks down you foot the bill yourself, or pay more upfront to cover those charges wink
The SIM plan in question is no cheaper than a plan which would have included the data or charged it out at £4.50 / 250MB having first informed the user by way of a text message.

It just happens to be a very long standing plan from a very loyal customer.

Henry smile