Health & Saftey FFI Money Raisers- Thieves
Discussion
Time for a rant.
I run/own a small family bakery. We have been running for over 20 years, and have HSE inspections every 12-18 months. our machinery has never changed. Yesterday a snotty nosed Hitler decided one of our small chocolate vats is dangerous. (one that has been inspected 10 times at least already). There is a guard on the front once opened kills the power to the machine. Now if you are utterly stupid, you can with some effort squeeze in behind it and put your hand behind the guard. I mean this is a real effort as the machine is jammed on to a wall.
So she is insisting a guard is fitted behind, even though there is no technical way of doing this, without making the machine unusable.
Under HSE new FFI law, that is it. She has given us 3 weeks to get it sorted, going to charge us for 2 hours work (£250, my solicitor charges less), we can appeal but we have to pay all fees including the fees for the appeals panel and if we win we get it back.
I've honestly had it with this country, no wonder our manufacturing sector has died. I have put the bakery up for sale. Im so fed up with dealing with idiots like this.
Just for the record in 20 years, our accident book has never had an entry.
Anyone else been screwed by these highway men?
what did you do?
I run/own a small family bakery. We have been running for over 20 years, and have HSE inspections every 12-18 months. our machinery has never changed. Yesterday a snotty nosed Hitler decided one of our small chocolate vats is dangerous. (one that has been inspected 10 times at least already). There is a guard on the front once opened kills the power to the machine. Now if you are utterly stupid, you can with some effort squeeze in behind it and put your hand behind the guard. I mean this is a real effort as the machine is jammed on to a wall.
So she is insisting a guard is fitted behind, even though there is no technical way of doing this, without making the machine unusable.
Under HSE new FFI law, that is it. She has given us 3 weeks to get it sorted, going to charge us for 2 hours work (£250, my solicitor charges less), we can appeal but we have to pay all fees including the fees for the appeals panel and if we win we get it back.
I've honestly had it with this country, no wonder our manufacturing sector has died. I have put the bakery up for sale. Im so fed up with dealing with idiots like this.
Just for the record in 20 years, our accident book has never had an entry.
Anyone else been screwed by these highway men?
what did you do?
Exactly, We have a fan that cools the cakes, it is covered in chicken wire for safety, she pulled me up on that too. I took about 10 seconds of squeezing my hand through a tiny gap, to the point where it turned blue, just so I could get the fan blade to hit my finger, which it did.
obviously it did absolutely nothing, not even a scratch to my finger, yet she still took pictures and reported it.
Problem is they are judge Dredds. Judge, jury and executioner, there is no legal due process.
To appeal is a punishment. They have raised over £5.5 million this year through these fines. Totally and utterly disgusting.
If I appeal, I would have to spend all my time and hire a safety consultant to rebuff it, can I claim my expenses, send them an invoice??
No
obviously it did absolutely nothing, not even a scratch to my finger, yet she still took pictures and reported it.
Problem is they are judge Dredds. Judge, jury and executioner, there is no legal due process.
To appeal is a punishment. They have raised over £5.5 million this year through these fines. Totally and utterly disgusting.
If I appeal, I would have to spend all my time and hire a safety consultant to rebuff it, can I claim my expenses, send them an invoice??
No
Edited by GhostDriver on Thursday 20th February 21:58
I know exactly where you're coming from. I sold my small business with the same level of frustration and tiredness at all this kind of thing. I used to be full of energy, positivity and with a 'can-do' attitude to everything in life. After 4 years of running a business, I felt like a down-trodden, almost broken man!
What enrages me lately is when mechanical Prime-Mini droid David Camerbot comes on the TV, and gives it 'that face' whilst earnestly declaring that Britain's small businesses will be the country's saviour to get us out of recession. He's clearly never tried to start up and run a business in the UK, the t
t.
As soon as you open up a business, it's like a million grabbing, grasping hands come flooding through the door, trying to grab as much money from you as possible, whist giving nothing back in return. It seems that everyone (from the Government, to suppliers, customers and staff) thinks that small business = you must be totally loaded and raking it in.
My last straw was when the coalition sent round letters saying "Good news! In order to help struggling businesses, we are going to change the business rates levy (already a comedy figure) so that businesses under a rateable value of X will get a year free from business rates, woohoo!"
I was very happy for that letter...until the VOA came round literally within days, and re-valued my rateable value to - guess what? Double what it already was, taking me to - amazing this - back over the threshold of relief. What are the chances of that?
But it's ok - we have the 'right of appeal'....to whom? Why, the VOA office themselves! After a lengthy consultation, you'll never guess what the outcome of the appeal was? I'll leave it to your imagination...
Run a small business in this country? I'd rather have root canal surgery, slide down a 10-foot long razor blade and use my privates as a brake, then finish the day by shaving my head with a cheesegrater.
What enrages me lately is when mechanical Prime-Mini droid David Camerbot comes on the TV, and gives it 'that face' whilst earnestly declaring that Britain's small businesses will be the country's saviour to get us out of recession. He's clearly never tried to start up and run a business in the UK, the t
t.As soon as you open up a business, it's like a million grabbing, grasping hands come flooding through the door, trying to grab as much money from you as possible, whist giving nothing back in return. It seems that everyone (from the Government, to suppliers, customers and staff) thinks that small business = you must be totally loaded and raking it in.
My last straw was when the coalition sent round letters saying "Good news! In order to help struggling businesses, we are going to change the business rates levy (already a comedy figure) so that businesses under a rateable value of X will get a year free from business rates, woohoo!"
I was very happy for that letter...until the VOA came round literally within days, and re-valued my rateable value to - guess what? Double what it already was, taking me to - amazing this - back over the threshold of relief. What are the chances of that?
But it's ok - we have the 'right of appeal'....to whom? Why, the VOA office themselves! After a lengthy consultation, you'll never guess what the outcome of the appeal was? I'll leave it to your imagination...
Run a small business in this country? I'd rather have root canal surgery, slide down a 10-foot long razor blade and use my privates as a brake, then finish the day by shaving my head with a cheesegrater.
And the annoying thing is that you are already paying their salaries from your taxes. And their nice pensions, before your own pension gets any. Hence the extra fee is simply extra tax.
I used to work in agrochemicals. It could take 10 years to bring a product to market, and a day for a numpty in Govt to ban it because if you stuffed a rat with 300 tons of it it died. Didn't seem like an even playing field to me.
I cna only suggest to write to your MP or maybe better, get the fiasco publicised in the local media. They like stories about the hardworking little guy vs faceless beaurocrats. You may not win but you can embarass them.
I used to work in agrochemicals. It could take 10 years to bring a product to market, and a day for a numpty in Govt to ban it because if you stuffed a rat with 300 tons of it it died. Didn't seem like an even playing field to me.
I cna only suggest to write to your MP or maybe better, get the fiasco publicised in the local media. They like stories about the hardworking little guy vs faceless beaurocrats. You may not win but you can embarass them.
Ray you totally get it ...
Someone give this man Vince Cable's job please!
We pay £930 a month rates and £1250 rent. We received a business rates relief letter, to say hard up businesses can apply for a discount. Took fkn ages to fill in this form......
We got £127 off for the year.
We started this business from nothing, working like dogs. We have employed so many people over the years, (in a very deprived area of North London) we've paid so much tax. I am what the conservatives and Dave like to call 'The backbone of the economy' a hard working small business made from literal blood sweat and tears.
As food producers, I've had enough. So much red tape, so many regulations (of course the multinationals manage by hiring one person to manage each of these regulations, something a small business can not).
I've had customers come in, almost in tears when they found out we are packing it in, because we do make some great cakes....
Yet, the day its sold (not long now) is the day I will wake up without a headache and a spring in my step for the first time in about 10 years
Someone give this man Vince Cable's job please!
We pay £930 a month rates and £1250 rent. We received a business rates relief letter, to say hard up businesses can apply for a discount. Took fkn ages to fill in this form......
We got £127 off for the year.
We started this business from nothing, working like dogs. We have employed so many people over the years, (in a very deprived area of North London) we've paid so much tax. I am what the conservatives and Dave like to call 'The backbone of the economy' a hard working small business made from literal blood sweat and tears.
As food producers, I've had enough. So much red tape, so many regulations (of course the multinationals manage by hiring one person to manage each of these regulations, something a small business can not).
I've had customers come in, almost in tears when they found out we are packing it in, because we do make some great cakes....
Yet, the day its sold (not long now) is the day I will wake up without a headache and a spring in my step for the first time in about 10 years
Edited by GhostDriver on Thursday 20th February 21:21
Simpo Two said:
And the annoying thing is that you are already paying their salaries from your taxes. And their nice pensions, before your own pension gets any. Hence the extra fee is simply extra tax.
I used to work in agrochemicals. It could take 10 years to bring a product to market, and a day for a numpty in Govt to ban it because if you stuffed a rat with 300 tons of it it died. Didn't seem like an even playing field to me.
I cna only suggest to write to your MP or maybe better, get the fiasco publicised in the local media. They like stories about the hardworking little guy vs faceless beaurocrats. You may not win but you can embarass them.
Im 40 years old and I don't have a pension, my business was to be that. They changed the rules about 4 or 5 years ago so you have to pay Capital Gains tax on retirement from your own business.I used to work in agrochemicals. It could take 10 years to bring a product to market, and a day for a numpty in Govt to ban it because if you stuffed a rat with 300 tons of it it died. Didn't seem like an even playing field to me.
I cna only suggest to write to your MP or maybe better, get the fiasco publicised in the local media. They like stories about the hardworking little guy vs faceless beaurocrats. You may not win but you can embarass them.
Would my MP actually do anything?
I have checked he voted the FFI procedure in.
I could pay the fees, and then I will have a H&S breach against my company name. If an employee ever does hurt themselves, it will not look good. Would probably affect my insurance too.
Simpo Two said:
It is sad that every one worker has one chav and two civil servants to support. Welcome to democracy and socialism.
I'd still bring your MP up to speed with the repercussions of his decision.
funnily enough....I'd still bring your MP up to speed with the repercussions of his decision.
The Jobs worth had a junior in Tow, who took the photos and said nothing. So yup. Two of them.
Im going to write her an email, to explain how it is impossible to fit a rear guard to this machine (it is). If she insists, then I will contact her superior, the local paper, my MP.
I'm just worried if I do that, they will target and harass me even more and find more stupidity. I mean we have 2 huge ovens you can walk into if your really into that kind of thing.
GhostDriver said:
Time for a rant.
I run/own a small family bakery. We have been running for over 20 years, and have HSE inspections every 12-18 months. our machinery has never changed. Yesterday a snotty nosed Hitler decided one of our small chocolate vats is dangerous. (one that has been inspected 10 times at least already). There is a guard on the front once opened kills the power to the machine. Now if you are utterly stupid, you can with some effort squeeze in behind it and put your hand behind the guard. I mean this is a real effort as the machine is jammed on to a wall.
So she is insisting a guard is fitted behind, even though there is no technical way of doing this, without making the machine unusable.
Under HSE new FFI law, that is it. She has given us 3 weeks to get it sorted, going to charge us for 2 hours work (£250, my solicitor charges less), we can appeal but we have to pay all fees including the fees for the appeals panel and if we win we get it back.
I've honestly had it with this country, no wonder our manufacturing sector has died. I have put the bakery up for sale. Im so fed up with dealing with idiots like this.
Just for the record in 20 years, our accident book has never had an entry.
Anyone else been screwed by these highway men?
what did you do?
Have a read of this chap...I run/own a small family bakery. We have been running for over 20 years, and have HSE inspections every 12-18 months. our machinery has never changed. Yesterday a snotty nosed Hitler decided one of our small chocolate vats is dangerous. (one that has been inspected 10 times at least already). There is a guard on the front once opened kills the power to the machine. Now if you are utterly stupid, you can with some effort squeeze in behind it and put your hand behind the guard. I mean this is a real effort as the machine is jammed on to a wall.
So she is insisting a guard is fitted behind, even though there is no technical way of doing this, without making the machine unusable.
Under HSE new FFI law, that is it. She has given us 3 weeks to get it sorted, going to charge us for 2 hours work (£250, my solicitor charges less), we can appeal but we have to pay all fees including the fees for the appeals panel and if we win we get it back.
I've honestly had it with this country, no wonder our manufacturing sector has died. I have put the bakery up for sale. Im so fed up with dealing with idiots like this.
Just for the record in 20 years, our accident book has never had an entry.
Anyone else been screwed by these highway men?
what did you do?
http://www.hse.gov.uk/risk/theory/alarpglance.htm
You need to demonstrate that you have reduced the risks so far as is reasonably practicable. If what you say is true - the bit I've highlighted - then you may have a case for appeal.
You'll also need to look at the PUWER regs as well...
http://www.hse.gov.uk/work-equipment-machinery/puw...
Just on this topic, the best one Ive had over the years....
We had a health Inspector in for one of their 18month routine visits. He said we shouldn't walk into our cold room, because that would mean our shoes would have dirt on the bottom and be a health hazard.
I offered to put monkey bars on the roof so we could swing into it.
He got arsey and in the end we agreed on laying cardboard down in there, which incidentally is totally disgusting as it harbours way more germs than the vinyl food safe floor we have in there that is cleaned thoroughly and regularly according to our cleaning schedules.
We had a health Inspector in for one of their 18month routine visits. He said we shouldn't walk into our cold room, because that would mean our shoes would have dirt on the bottom and be a health hazard.
I offered to put monkey bars on the roof so we could swing into it.

He got arsey and in the end we agreed on laying cardboard down in there, which incidentally is totally disgusting as it harbours way more germs than the vinyl food safe floor we have in there that is cleaned thoroughly and regularly according to our cleaning schedules.
rhinochopig said:
Have a read of this chap...
http://www.hse.gov.uk/risk/theory/alarpglance.htm
You need to demonstrate that you have reduced the risks so far as is reasonably practicable. If what you say is true - the bit I've highlighted - then you may have a case for appeal.
You'll also need to look at the PUWER regs as well...
http://www.hse.gov.uk/work-equipment-machinery/puw...
You Sir are a STAR!!http://www.hse.gov.uk/risk/theory/alarpglance.htm
You need to demonstrate that you have reduced the risks so far as is reasonably practicable. If what you say is true - the bit I've highlighted - then you may have a case for appeal.
You'll also need to look at the PUWER regs as well...
http://www.hse.gov.uk/work-equipment-machinery/puw...
Pistonheads Rocks once again, exactly what I was looking for and couldn't find. Thank you, even more ammo to take on Hitler.
Doesn't change the fact that I've grown tired of all of this and that's pretty sad.
It's all quite tragic; the UK was a pioneer of H&S, which has common sense written into it, and has made going to work hugely safer than it was 40 years ago. Yet we have b
ks like this created because governments are obsessed with metrics and demand both something to measure and regular and predictable improvements in those metrics. Whoever is in charge of such things exists in blissful ignorance of the law of diminishing returns. Being charged for the privilege of being put out of business no doubt puts a f
king cherry on top of this particular bureaucratic s
t sandwich.
ks like this created because governments are obsessed with metrics and demand both something to measure and regular and predictable improvements in those metrics. Whoever is in charge of such things exists in blissful ignorance of the law of diminishing returns. Being charged for the privilege of being put out of business no doubt puts a f
king cherry on top of this particular bureaucratic s
t sandwich.Gassing Station | Business | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


