Changing directors just before insolvency
Changing directors just before insolvency
Author
Discussion

mjb1

Original Poster:

2,585 posts

190 months

Thursday 20th February 2014
quotequote all
Had a customer (trading as ltd company) contact me the other day to say that they were 'closing their doors', and inquiring to the value of equipment that they had previously bought from me - and would I be interested in buying it back?

Quick look on duedil shows that the owner (bloke I've always dealt with there) is majority share holder and was sole director from inception until very recently. He's retired his directorship and someone else (likely his girl friend) has just become the new sole director. Also, a new company was formed around the same time, with two of the original company's shareholders as directors, so obviously associated with previous owner in some way.

Now I've no idea how he plans to wind up the company, but it's a reasonable hunch that it owes a fair of money. Current assets are -£200k and total liabilities are £200k. He was always an awful payer of bills, I'm just thankful that he doesn't owe me anything at present.

I can see why he might want to get his name off the company as a director just before it goes under, so he doesn't appear connected to it. But these days, 5 mins on duedil or similar shows all, so is there any point?

Steffan

10,362 posts

259 months

Friday 21st February 2014
quotequote all
mjb1 said:
Had a customer (trading as ltd company) contact me the other day to say that they were 'closing their doors', and inquiring to the value of equipment that they had previously bought from me - and would I be interested in buying it back?

Quick look on duedil shows that the owner (bloke I've always dealt with there) is majority share holder and was sole director from inception until very recently. He's retired his directorship and someone else (likely his girl friend) has just become the new sole director. Also, a new company was formed around the same time, with two of the original company's shareholders as directors, so obviously associated with previous owner in some way.

Now I've no idea how he plans to wind up the company, but it's a reasonable hunch that it owes a fair of money. Current assets are -£200k and total liabilities are £200k. He was always an awful payer of bills, I'm just thankful that he doesn't owe me anything at present.

I can see why he might want to get his name off the company as a director just before it goes under, so he doesn't appear connected to it. But these days, 5 mins on duedil or similar shows all, so is there any point?
Change the name the game is the same and Co is a well rehearsed process nowadays. Sadly. If the man knows the game and has tame liquidators the Co will trade (probably losing money and building debt)until six months from his resignation. Then he is possibly (but not certainly) safe. Some individuals are not not honest and seek extra profit by fiddling. I suspect your assessment is correct if you know any creditors I would advise them informally and help keep the losses down. Commonplace I regret to say and still largely effective.

Terminator X

20,999 posts

235 months

Friday 21st February 2014
quotequote all
Is he possibly just attempting to avoid being "blacklisted" so that he can still be a Director at the next company?

TX.

TVR MAN

1,038 posts

253 months

Friday 21st February 2014
quotequote all
The liquidators/administrators will be required to report on the conduct of all directors within the 3 years leading up to the insolvency.

Ean218

2,046 posts

281 months

Friday 21st February 2014
quotequote all
TVR MAN said:
The liquidators/administrators will be required to report on the conduct of all directors within the 3 years leading up to the insolvency.
Big deal? There's no-one listening.

TVR MAN

1,038 posts

253 months

Friday 21st February 2014
quotequote all
Ean218 said:
Big deal? There's no-one listening.
Hah - well, yes, chances are that nothing will be done unless the directors have done something terrible and there is evidence.

joewilliams

2,004 posts

232 months

Friday 21st February 2014
quotequote all
You now know well enough to refuse credit - but many people will just deal with him as they find him or give away credit in the excitement of bagging a sale.

Far too few companies include regular credit checks of customers & suppliers in their normal routines.

TheD

3,144 posts

230 months

Friday 21st February 2014
quotequote all
I had a company do this to me. Bought 2k of equipment then went bust. He changed it over to his sister just two weeks before. He knew fine what he was doing. It is theft and yet nobody cares. He had done it three times before seemingly and I have since heard he has started again. I went to everyone to get my cash back (trading standards et al)and they all said sorry nothing you can do. In a sad turn of fate he actually got the police to warn me to leave him alone as he said I threatened him. As if I would ever do that. The

Billsnemesis

817 posts

268 months

Friday 21st February 2014
quotequote all
For years I have been advising clients that credit control starts with deciding who you do business with

johnfm

13,751 posts

281 months

Saturday 22nd February 2014
quotequote all
TheD said:
I had a company do this to me. Bought 2k of equipment then went bust. He changed it over to his sister just two weeks before. He knew fine what he was doing. It is theft and yet nobody cares. He had done it three times before seemingly and I have since heard he has started again. I went to everyone to get my cash back (trading standards et al)and they all said sorry nothing you can do. In a sad turn of fate he actually got the police to warn me to leave him alone as he said I threatened him. As if I would ever do that. The
What was the retention of title clause in your sale contract?

You need to make sure you retain title to your equipment until paid.

TheD

3,144 posts

230 months

Saturday 22nd February 2014
quotequote all
johnfm said:
TheD said:
I had a company do this to me. Bought 2k of equipment then went bust. He changed it over to his sister just two weeks before. He knew fine what he was doing. It is theft and yet nobody cares. He had done it three times before seemingly and I have since heard he has started again. I went to everyone to get my cash back (trading standards et al)and they all said sorry nothing you can do. In a sad turn of fate he actually got the police to warn me to leave him alone as he said I threatened him. As if I would ever do that. The
What was the retention of title clause in your sale contract?

You need to make sure you retain title to your equipment until paid.
He told me his staff took the equipment and he hadn't a bit of it left. I informed him, and the police, that it then must be theft. Not a thing was done apart from taking a statement. Phoned and phoned and was just brushed off. To say I was just a wee bit angry at the attitude of the police is an understatement.

Steffan

10,362 posts

259 months

Saturday 22nd February 2014
quotequote all
TheD said:
johnfm said:
TheD said:
I had a company do this to me. Bought 2k of equipment then went bust. He changed it over to his sister just two weeks before. He knew fine what he was doing. It is theft and yet nobody cares. He had done it three times before seemingly and I have since heard he has started again. I went to everyone to get my cash back (trading standards et al)and they all said sorry nothing you can do. In a sad turn of fate he actually got the police to warn me to leave him alone as he said I threatened him. As if I would ever do that. The
What was the retention of title clause in your sale contract?

You need to make sure you retain title to your equipment until paid.
He told me his staff took the equipment and he hadn't a bit of it left. I informed him, and the police, that it then must be theft. Not a thing was done apart from taking a statement. Phoned and phoned and was just brushed off. To say I was just a wee bit angry at the attitude of the police is an understatement.
As Billsnemesis said earlier on here deciding who to give credit (or not) in business is vital. Not an easy decision but the old adage of "Never lend more than you can afford to lose" still hold IMO. I have seen such appalling dishonesty in business more often than I like. Many businesses no longer offer any credit at all, preferring Credit Card payments etc. Or adopt the standard procedures many businesses use like credit only after 12 months trading if everything is OK and Bank references etc. But there are a lot of less than honest traders about and therefore IMO offering credit is very risky.