Anyone here do SEO?
Anyone here do SEO?
Author
Discussion

okgo

Original Poster:

42,376 posts

229 months

Monday 3rd March 2014
quotequote all
As above, got a fairly basic thing I need to ask about optimizing..

mr_spock

3,376 posts

246 months

Monday 3rd March 2014
quotequote all
Ask away

V8mate

45,899 posts

220 months

Tuesday 4th March 2014
quotequote all
ears

foliedouce

3,095 posts

262 months

Tuesday 4th March 2014
quotequote all
Sorry to hijack thread, but how much is an SEO consultant? People seem to ask for a monthly retainer but don't actually guarantee their work.

If I could pay £x per month for top 3 of Google for agreed search strings I'd do it (not in top 3 = no payment), but nobody seems willing. They also won't explain what they do to earn their cash in any detail - is this a black art or just alchemy?



okgo

Original Poster:

42,376 posts

229 months

Tuesday 4th March 2014
quotequote all
The question was simply how much would it cost to move a website up the rankings in a fairly niche subject?

MrOrange

2,039 posts

284 months

Tuesday 4th March 2014
quotequote all
Pay per hour between £35 and £100 for a good SEO company that transparently shows what they do (very important). The amount of work required varies enormously depending on how good your web dev company is/was at compliance to best practices.

I'd budget a day of time to produce a report outlining the problems with the physical aspects of the site. Correcting those is a can of worms including what it's written in, how good/fast/expensive your web dev is. A well built site by a half decent web dev using something like WordPress might only take a day to get up to scratch.

If you've got a horrible hand-cut mess of a site it could be cheaper to start again. I've tried to base this on a typical, 50 page site with a few design/build iterations under its belt.

Next up is the off-site stuff. Your 1 day of time should have given you lots of back link details, this could be poisonous and takes months to fix if you've had black hat stuff done in the past or months to build a credible link profile. Do it in stages, most bill via monthly retainers for this.

Next up is content planning. You need good quality, original content on the site. That needs a plan and execution - I'd let the SEO company reel off a bunch of topics and then publish the content in-house.

Next up is social media planning. To maximise positions you'll need good profiles on G+, Twitter and FB. If you need guidance on this it can get expensive - do not underestimate the value of getting this right.

Next up is competitive work. You'll need an analysis of what your competitors are doing in this space and a plan to "out gun" them. A day of paid time will give you a plan, deliver that in stages -typically the SEO boys do this part of your retainer.

Next up is reporting. You'll need to know which bits are working and which bits are not. Manually checking positions is flawed, as are most scraping solutions but you'll need something. Start with Google Webmaster tools and consider a tracking app such as Raven or Positionly. Neither are spot on but will illuminate highs and lows.

You'll need to actively manage the SEO company so look for simple but useful measures and targets. It's a huge subject and changes quickly. Don't be tempted to cut corners and listen to "if you think a pro is expensive, you should see how much an amateur costs".

Finally, Most SEO basics "should" have been baked in during the build process, sadly it is frequently missed of or done badly.

/disclaimer: I don't do SEO but my company does, but only as part of a build / support contract. SEO is not black box. Opinions on the subject vary as wide as any subject.

robuk

2,512 posts

221 months

Tuesday 4th March 2014
quotequote all
okgo said:
The question was simply how much would it cost to move a website up the rankings in a fairly niche subject?
Depends on competition basically.

The more obscure and uncompetitive the easier it is.

Cost is a piece-of-string answer, but I always go off the notion those are good will be ranking their own sites and making proper money so what would be the incentive. No doubt those working for agencies and all in one shops would disagree and charge retainers wink

bicycleshorts

1,939 posts

192 months

Wednesday 5th March 2014
quotequote all
foliedouce said:
Sorry to hijack thread, but how much is an SEO consultant? People seem to ask for a monthly retainer but don't actually guarantee their work.

If I could pay £x per month for top 3 of Google for agreed search strings I'd do it (not in top 3 = no payment), but nobody seems willing. They also won't explain what they do to earn their cash in any detail - is this a black art or just alchemy?
Hard to guarantee when Google changes it's algorithm every other month.

SilverPhoenix

82 posts

155 months

Wednesday 5th March 2014
quotequote all
So, the SEO listings on fivequids are probably not worth trying, although they're relatively/very cheap?!

robuk

2,512 posts

221 months

Wednesday 5th March 2014
quotequote all
SilverPhoenix said:
So, the SEO listings on fivequids are probably not worth trying, although they're relatively/very cheap?!
No - avoid.

Basically stuff like that is automated (xrumer etc) which will do comment spam, forum spam and the like.


Ken Sington

3,964 posts

269 months

Wednesday 5th March 2014
quotequote all
MrOrange said:
Pay per hour between £35 and £100 for a good SEO company that transparently shows what they do (very important). The amount of work required varies enormously depending on how good your web dev company is/was at compliance to best practices.

I'd budget a day of time to produce a report outlining the problems with the physical aspects of the site. Correcting those is a can of worms including what it's written in, how good/fast/expensive your web dev is. A well built site by a half decent web dev using something like WordPress might only take a day to get up to scratch.

If you've got a horrible hand-cut mess of a site it could be cheaper to start again. I've tried to base this on a typical, 50 page site with a few design/build iterations under its belt.

Next up is the off-site stuff. Your 1 day of time should have given you lots of back link details, this could be poisonous and takes months to fix if you've had black hat stuff done in the past or months to build a credible link profile. Do it in stages, most bill via monthly retainers for this.

Next up is content planning. You need good quality, original content on the site. That needs a plan and execution - I'd let the SEO company reel off a bunch of topics and then publish the content in-house.

Next up is social media planning. To maximise positions you'll need good profiles on G+, Twitter and FB. If you need guidance on this it can get expensive - do not underestimate the value of getting this right.

Next up is competitive work. You'll need an analysis of what your competitors are doing in this space and a plan to "out gun" them. A day of paid time will give you a plan, deliver that in stages -typically the SEO boys do this part of your retainer.

Next up is reporting. You'll need to know which bits are working and which bits are not. Manually checking positions is flawed, as are most scraping solutions but you'll need something. Start with Google Webmaster tools and consider a tracking app such as Raven or Positionly. Neither are spot on but will illuminate highs and lows.

You'll need to actively manage the SEO company so look for simple but useful measures and targets. It's a huge subject and changes quickly. Don't be tempted to cut corners and listen to "if you think a pro is expensive, you should see how much an amateur costs".

Finally, Most SEO basics "should" have been baked in during the build process, sadly it is frequently missed of or done badly.

/disclaimer: I don't do SEO but my company does, but only as part of a build / support contract. SEO is not black box. Opinions on the subject vary as wide as any subject.
And this in a nutshell is why, imho, marketing has become so difficult now. Not only do you have to have your product/message/pricing spot on, but you have to play this game in order to be seen if you don't have a unique product or service to offer. And then Google change the rules every few months. It's like Luke's bombing run on the Death Star; almost impossible to hit the target. And it's why I will probably have to wind my business up in a few weeks time as well.

VEIGHT

2,379 posts

259 months

Wednesday 5th March 2014
quotequote all
Sorry to highjack but can anyone reccomend any good companies for this?

rpguk

4,520 posts

315 months

Wednesday 5th March 2014
quotequote all
bicycleshorts said:
Hard to guarantee when Google changes it's algorithm every other month.
And even if you knew exactly what googles algorithm was and it didn't change then you don't know what resources others are putting in to target the same keywords!

mr_spock

3,376 posts

246 months

Wednesday 5th March 2014
quotequote all
Check out Yoast.com and have a read. I used his free WP plugin and some time and effort and our company web site has moved up the rankings for the search terms that matter to us from page 5 of Google to the 5th result on page 1. I'm no SEO expert at all, and I'm not in the online shop game (which I expect is much harder!) but it worked for us.

MrOrange

2,039 posts

284 months

Wednesday 5th March 2014
quotequote all
Yoast, or other off the shelf solutions are fine for getting the very basics right or, more likely, correcting the cock ups from sloppy web development. There is no magic here and you can do itself with a bit of learning, some tech savvy and lots of time.

If you build your marketing strategy on free search engine listings (aka Google) then you should probably spend a day a week tending those listings and learning how to improve them. Or paying someone to do it if you've not got the time.

Good SEO is rare, as are clients who understand and pay for the amount of effort required to get it right. so the industry is jammed full of non-experts fighting over minuscule budgets from companies who repeat the same mistakes of buying cheap and believing some of the stoopid claims made. That is, actually, a bigger opportunity than many realise.

I'll happily have a 1-1 on this, but not here - too many experts here smile

Message me or search me out; Martin Dower, I run a WordPress agency based in London & Yorkshire.

Andrew[MG]

3,360 posts

229 months

Thursday 6th March 2014
quotequote all
MrOrange said:
Good SEO is rare, as are clients who understand and pay for the amount of effort required to get it right. so the industry is jammed full of non-experts fighting over minuscule budgets from companies who repeat the same mistakes of buying cheap and believing some of the stoopid claims made. That is, actually, a bigger opportunity than many realise.
Ain't that the truth! It's the reason that I don't take on small businesses as clients.

Most people wouldn't use an online lawyer who charges £5, or employ a decorator who just gets 16 year old kids to do the painting for him, but somehow it's OK to trust the biggest part of the marketing of your business to the cheapest people on the internet.

My biggest grip with most people's attitude to good SEO, is that they just never want to be the best at what whatever they do, all they are interested in is keeping costs down. I always ask people "why should you be above x,y and z in Google? In what ways are you better than them or want to become better than them?" They either need to have a good answer or are willing to just throw money at the problem.

Sorry for the rant!