VAT as a USP
Author
Discussion

flatsix3.6

Original Poster:

756 posts

212 months

Sunday 9th March 2014
quotequote all
I would like to know if using in your advertising the unique selling point (USP) of "we pay your VAT" would the following scenario be OK with HMRC.

You invoice the customer for let's say £2000 + VAT = £2400
You then give back the customer a cheque for £400.

Could this work in principle, I know profit margins on the £2000 would dictate if it was viable.

Edited by flatsix3.6 on Sunday 9th March 11:59

897sma

3,607 posts

175 months

Sunday 9th March 2014
quotequote all
WTF! has vat gone up and no one told me?!!

flatsix3.6

Original Poster:

756 posts

212 months

Sunday 9th March 2014
quotequote all
897sma said:
WTF! has vat gone up and no one told me?!!
My bad

davec1960

7 posts

168 months

Sunday 9th March 2014
quotequote all
If someone was offering me this deal I would expect to pay £2000 not £2400 with a cheque for £400 given back to me. What is the point of raising an invoice for £2400, why not raise one for £2000

Machine Mart regularly have vat free weekends. The small print specifies that a discount equivalent to vat is applied. Couldn't you do something similar

davec1960

7 posts

168 months

Sunday 9th March 2014
quotequote all
If someone was offering me this deal I would expect to pay £2000 not £2400 with a cheque for £400 given back to me. What is the point of raising an invoice for £2400, why not raise one for £2000

Machine Mart regularly have vat free weekends. The small print specifies that a discount equivalent to vat is applied. Couldn't you do something similar

flatsix3.6

Original Poster:

756 posts

212 months

Sunday 9th March 2014
quotequote all
davec1960 said:
If someone was offering me this deal I would expect to pay £2000 not £2400 with a cheque for £400 given back to me. What is the point of raising an invoice for £2400, why not raise one for £2000

Machine Mart regularly have vat free weekends. The small print specifies that a discount equivalent to vat is applied. Couldn't you do something similar
Because I am VAT registered I would have to produce an invoice for £1666.67 + VAT so further eating into the profit margin within the £2000.


DavidY

4,492 posts

315 months

Sunday 9th March 2014
quotequote all
flatsix3.6 said:
Because I am VAT registered I would have to produce an invoice for £1666.67 + VAT so further eating into the profit margin within the £2000.
And do you account (legally) then for giving back £400!!!!

However its done its eats into the profit margin, it's a sale incentive after all!!!

Inv £2000, VAT £400, Total £400
Credit back £400, that is £333.33+VAT
Net Sale price £1666.67 + VAT = £2000



flatsix3.6

Original Poster:

756 posts

212 months

Sunday 9th March 2014
quotequote all
DavidY said:
And do you account (legally) then for giving back £400!!!!

However its done its eats into the profit margin, it's a sale incentive after all!!!

Inv £2000, VAT £400, Total £400
Credit back £400, that is £333.33+VAT
Net Sale price £1666.67 + VAT = £2000
The credit back will be to home owners who will not be registered, so how would you deal with the credit back on the VAT return, would it be classed as a sales transaction and would you have to use the VAT element in the VAT on sales section of the return.

DavidY

4,492 posts

315 months

Sunday 9th March 2014
quotequote all
YOU (or your business) is registered for VAT and YOU are responsible for handling all VAT transactions (into/out of) your business

If you raise an invoice for £2000 (assuming no costs incurred), you charge the customer £400 VAT, (on top of £2000), which you collect and pass onto HMRC

If you raise a credit note for £400 (gross), this is £333.33 credit plus VAT, and you can then effectively reduce your VAT liability by £400-£333.33 = £66.67.

However you look at it, the final transaction is £1667.67+VAT, so you have reduced your Net Sale price by £333.33, you are now collecting £333.33 and passing that to HMRC, which is EXACTLY the same as collecting £400 and then raising a credit note, offsetting £66.37 as £400-£66.67=£333.33

All these numbers assume that you are selling labour only and not purchasing any materials that you could claim VAT back on, they are for example only!

There are no shortcuts here, it is you who is responsible for your business's VAT.

My advice is not to take any shortcuts with VAT.

DavidY

4,492 posts

315 months

Sunday 9th March 2014
quotequote all
flatsix3.6 said:
The credit back will be to home owners who will not be registered, so how would you deal with the credit back on the VAT return, would it be classed as a sales transaction and would you have to use the VAT element in the VAT on sales section of the return.
It's effectively a negative sales transaction

All this boils down to:- its better (and the same price/profit/etc) to do a single sales transaction at £1667.67+VAT at is less paperwork (and simpler to administer) and will cost you less with your bookkeeper/Accountant at year end.

You can either just write a invoice for:-

£1666.67
£333.33 VAT
£2000.00 Total

Or Write

£2000
less 16.667% discount (£333.33)
= £1666.67
£333.33 VAT
£2000.00 Total


Edited by DavidY on Sunday 9th March 16:11

flatsix3.6

Original Poster:

756 posts

212 months

Sunday 9th March 2014
quotequote all
DavidY said:
It's effectively a negative sales transaction

All this boils down to:- its better (and the same price/profit/etc) to do a single sales transaction at £1667.67+VAT at is less paperwork (and simpler to administer) and will cost you less with your bookkeeper/Accountant at year end.

You can either just write a invoice for:-

£1666.67
£333.33 VAT
£2000.00 Total

Or Write

£2000
less 16.667% discount (£333.33)
= £1666.67
£333.33 VAT
£2000.00 Total


Edited by DavidY on Sunday 9th March 16:11
Thanks for the info, there will be materials to off set.

I am not trying to take any short cuts just wanted to know if I went this way on some projects it is acceptable to HMRC, and it would depend how it effects any profit.

davepoth

29,395 posts

230 months

Sunday 9th March 2014
quotequote all
flatsix3.6 said:
Thanks for the info, there will be materials to off set.

I am not trying to take any short cuts just wanted to know if I went this way on some projects it is acceptable to HMRC, and it would depend how it effects any profit.
If you want to sell an item for £2400, to a non-registered person, that invoice has to include the VAT. If you want to then issue them a credit for £400, that credit has to also include the VAT. If you don't, the VAT won't add up to an additional 20% on the final value of the sale, as it is supposed to.