Could we set up an online eBay rival - PH Auctions?
Discussion
Nothing costs much in the set up of an eBay rival apart from marketing ? When I say not much I mean surely the website and initial server space can't be more than £100k probably a lot less.
Assuming you hit the ground with 20 plus quality eBay sellers (big but not nationals) and only charge a success fee and take an easy feed into the site (so no £ risk no listing hassle) plus a few hundred small sellers ?
But the Ebid issue is purely marketing and in a nutshell why would buyers visit your new start up ?
Anyone up for a challenge ?
Assuming you hit the ground with 20 plus quality eBay sellers (big but not nationals) and only charge a success fee and take an easy feed into the site (so no £ risk no listing hassle) plus a few hundred small sellers ?
But the Ebid issue is purely marketing and in a nutshell why would buyers visit your new start up ?
Anyone up for a challenge ?
JaFool1 said:
A payment processor would be the biggest stumbling block, along with initial marketing costs.
I've always thought Google would try, but alas so far they haven't
I'm not sure why a payment processor would be hard. I've always thought Google would try, but alas so far they haven't

The biggest thing to overcome is the fact that auction sites benefit from network externalities - if you are listing an item, you want to use the site with the most number of buyers, and if you are buying an item you will start off searching the site that has the most number of sellers. The bigger the site, the most successful it will be for this reason - why Ebay is synonymous with auction websites, and why there is only one 'Ebay' with zero sites that really compete with it.
My only suggestion is to start with a vertical, become the best in that vertical, then go from there. All marketing and optimisation should focus on making the PH auction site address the problems with Ebay in this one vertical.
I would say Autotrader is similar to ebay in its monopoly but Motors.co.uk are taking them on - if we specialised and started with a few well filled cats adding cats as we went BUT it needs business support and advertising. We pay ebay £30k a year fees for circa £350k sales not inc paypal fees I would be happy to risk a year of ebay fees as a investment in a new online platform I part owned but we would need at least 10 others or similar or larger size to make it a destination.
My take would be:
Make it easy for people to set up and run their store so it's just a small time investment to give it a go. Add providers by invitation/approval so there's less risk of getting stuck with bad sellers.
Use PayPay or something like stripe to process payment directly to the seller, which would help with fraud risks.
- Business sellers
- Everything buy-it-now fixed price
- No up front fees
- Easy data feed (with the ability to mark it as out of stock but not loose the listing) - perhaps even a real time XML link
- Everyone gets a 'store' page
Make it easy for people to set up and run their store so it's just a small time investment to give it a go. Add providers by invitation/approval so there's less risk of getting stuck with bad sellers.
Use PayPay or something like stripe to process payment directly to the seller, which would help with fraud risks.
OK - a PH traders shopping mall by invitation and no directly competing shops, on here is the online sales skill, the actual programming skill and a good few interesting traders.
Possibly PH would make it part of the site ? the actual PH shopping Mall ? we pay them a cut OR we go it alone - Im up for "something" that isn't Google whoring, ebay hoop jumping and amazon pain.
Possibly PH would make it part of the site ? the actual PH shopping Mall ? we pay them a cut OR we go it alone - Im up for "something" that isn't Google whoring, ebay hoop jumping and amazon pain.
I think you'd have to do something genuinely 'different' to Ebay to succeed. Any proposed store like that is currently trapped between Ebay and Amazon as the two 'go-to' online retailers. Both of them have the power to out-compete on marketing budget and retailer fees. So just offering sellers a slightly better deal (and it can only be slightly better if you've got serious expectations of growth) would be not much of a proposition.
Others have done it - Etsy makes it arts and crafts-y and I Want One Of Those is (I think) essentially a heavily curated version of Amazon marketplace.
You'd need to improve on the sellers' management and presentation in Ebay and provide something more compelling to the customer to get them to return to the brand. Without returning customers, you're dead in the water.
Others have done it - Etsy makes it arts and crafts-y and I Want One Of Those is (I think) essentially a heavily curated version of Amazon marketplace.
You'd need to improve on the sellers' management and presentation in Ebay and provide something more compelling to the customer to get them to return to the brand. Without returning customers, you're dead in the water.
Tuna your thinking of "Not on the high street" I think as IWOT is a pure retailer. The idea of it being a MALL - online - is a good one, it needs some marquee stores that would pull amazon and ebay and jut sell some or all items on the PH mall, these marquee stores would be supplemented by smaller stores and over time it will create a destination.
DSLiverpool said:
Tuna your thinking of "Not on the high street" I think as IWOT is a pure retailer. The idea of it being a MALL - online - is a good one, it needs some marquee stores that would pull amazon and ebay and jut sell some or all items on the PH mall, these marquee stores would be supplemented by smaller stores and over time it will create a destination.
I had a feeling it wasn't IWOT.. glad you got the reference though.The market is ready for a bit of disruption - both Ebay and Amazon have deeply intrenched systems that would struggle to respond to a properly new user/seller experience, and there are some interesting ideas around fulfillment and store front management.
Essentially though, I don't think you could do it without a 'ground up' redesign of the service (rather than just plumbing in yet another online store system) and a solid marketing budget. You'd need to deliver something fresh (not just fresh graphics on a standard store front) or find a new niche (not the point if you're trying to topple the big guys) and then work hard at making users aware of it before you could get anywhere.
Gassing Station | Business | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



