Want to leave my business and sell my share - best method?
Discussion
Ok, so I've been in business with my partner since January 2011. I know the business inside and out but recently, profitability has been a little low, although turnover is higher than ever. This has led to both of us not being paid a dividend due to the higher than usual costs.
This is understandable but there have been other things; decisons taken without my consent/input, decisons that have backfired on both of us leaving me to sort the mess out and him taking no further part in the mess he created. I've also been suffering from a lack of motivation and working 6 days a week, working longer hours, covering shifts for employees etc. All this slowly but surely saps ones energy.
Now, I have been looking to leave for a while but I want to do it in the best (amicable) way possible and on good terms. Me and my business partner don't really have a friendly relationsip (not frosty, but no small talk and we're not friends either). I own 25% of the business and have been mulling over a few options.
- Leave at the end of the year (which I'm pretty determined to do)
- Give him my shares now - on principle - and tell him he has full financial freedom from here onwards and he if he can guarantee me my original investment capital I will sign my shares over once he pays me my money.
- He can look for another partner {friends, family member) and I'll continue to take a dividend and still leave at the end of the year.
- If options 2 and 3 do not work out, I can sell to someone who he definately will not get on with but will get me a bigger (potentially) price for my share.
- I leave at the end of the year and become a silent partner if he cannot raise the funds and all else fails.
I'm young, I have ambitions and do not want to spend the rest of my life working somewhere that can potentially become toxic, drains my motivation and uses my time up that I can spend with my young family. Money is not even the issue, just the option to move onwards and have a better quality of life.
All opinions welcome.
This is understandable but there have been other things; decisons taken without my consent/input, decisons that have backfired on both of us leaving me to sort the mess out and him taking no further part in the mess he created. I've also been suffering from a lack of motivation and working 6 days a week, working longer hours, covering shifts for employees etc. All this slowly but surely saps ones energy.
Now, I have been looking to leave for a while but I want to do it in the best (amicable) way possible and on good terms. Me and my business partner don't really have a friendly relationsip (not frosty, but no small talk and we're not friends either). I own 25% of the business and have been mulling over a few options.
- Leave at the end of the year (which I'm pretty determined to do)
- Give him my shares now - on principle - and tell him he has full financial freedom from here onwards and he if he can guarantee me my original investment capital I will sign my shares over once he pays me my money.
- He can look for another partner {friends, family member) and I'll continue to take a dividend and still leave at the end of the year.
- If options 2 and 3 do not work out, I can sell to someone who he definately will not get on with but will get me a bigger (potentially) price for my share.
- I leave at the end of the year and become a silent partner if he cannot raise the funds and all else fails.
I'm young, I have ambitions and do not want to spend the rest of my life working somewhere that can potentially become toxic, drains my motivation and uses my time up that I can spend with my young family. Money is not even the issue, just the option to move onwards and have a better quality of life.
All opinions welcome.
If you have a shareholder's agreement then that will show how to proceed.
Failing that the role of being shareholder and the role of being an employee (even if a Director) are quite different and separate. If you want to leave you can leave, if you want to sell your shareholding you can sell your shareholding, short of some agreement saying otherwise they don't legally overlap.
It's also worth bearing in mind that, absent any other agreement, your 25% shareholding gives no power or control. So you can sell them to someone else if you wish but really there is no great benefit to buy in a private company where there is no prospect of being able to sell again. You can sell to someone he doesn't like but it really wouldn't make a difference, unless an agreement says to the contrary that shareholder would have no power and no role in the company.
And if you do sell then the value is just whatever it is that someone else will pay
Failing that the role of being shareholder and the role of being an employee (even if a Director) are quite different and separate. If you want to leave you can leave, if you want to sell your shareholding you can sell your shareholding, short of some agreement saying otherwise they don't legally overlap.
It's also worth bearing in mind that, absent any other agreement, your 25% shareholding gives no power or control. So you can sell them to someone else if you wish but really there is no great benefit to buy in a private company where there is no prospect of being able to sell again. You can sell to someone he doesn't like but it really wouldn't make a difference, unless an agreement says to the contrary that shareholder would have no power and no role in the company.
And if you do sell then the value is just whatever it is that someone else will pay
We had to do a similar thing just this Friday. One partner wanted out, had kidney cancer and it scared the crap out of him. He wanted his share to enjoy the rest of his life.
So we did a deal, just to ease out bit by bit. So that it didn't create a huge hole in the company funds, it will be paid off yearly, a pre-set figure at a time.
There's no point demanding a great big lump sum up front, it'll kill the company.
Leave nicely and with dignity.
So we did a deal, just to ease out bit by bit. So that it didn't create a huge hole in the company funds, it will be paid off yearly, a pre-set figure at a time.
There's no point demanding a great big lump sum up front, it'll kill the company.
Leave nicely and with dignity.
Fishtigua said:
So we did a deal, just to ease out bit by bit. So that it didn't create a huge hole in the company funds, it will be paid off yearly, a pre-set figure at a time.
There's no point demanding a great big lump sum up front, it'll kill the company.
.
Not sure this makes sense unless the company bought his shares??There's no point demanding a great big lump sum up front, it'll kill the company.
.
Limited company with owners choosing to leave profits in the company to allow it to grow?
They can draw dividends or wages at will but choose not to. In order to purchase the shares the remaining shareholders would need to draw money out to purchase thus rendering the company potentially short of cash. Spreading the purchase over a period of time eases the pressure and potentially won't harm the person retiring providing they don't need a big lump sum.
In the OP's case I get the sense that because of the under performance of the company he is possibly going to struggle to realise the value of his investment at the moment. Hence looking for ideas.
Henry
They can draw dividends or wages at will but choose not to. In order to purchase the shares the remaining shareholders would need to draw money out to purchase thus rendering the company potentially short of cash. Spreading the purchase over a period of time eases the pressure and potentially won't harm the person retiring providing they don't need a big lump sum.
In the OP's case I get the sense that because of the under performance of the company he is possibly going to struggle to realise the value of his investment at the moment. Hence looking for ideas.
Henry

Yes, money will be taken out regularly to allow the owners of the business to eat and enjoy life!
When you say "use their own money" the chances are the bulk of the money will be held within the business. A limited company is a very efficient way of growing a business without having to pay personal tax then re-invest the money back as you would do as a sole trader. You pay corporation tax which is crudely half what you'd pay drawing the money out as an individual, leave the money in the business, grow the business then as and when you do need to spend the money you can pay the difference between the corporation tax and personal tax.
A very crude summary with lots of variables but a ladybird book 1 explanation
So drawing the money out as earnings would result in a tax bill. Borrowing the money would result in a debt which the business probably doesn't want, and why pay a third party when the person exiting the company is happy to take payment over a longer period (probably interest free in effect)?
It makes perfect sense to me and sounds like all parties acted for the greater good of everyone involved.
Henry
When you say "use their own money" the chances are the bulk of the money will be held within the business. A limited company is a very efficient way of growing a business without having to pay personal tax then re-invest the money back as you would do as a sole trader. You pay corporation tax which is crudely half what you'd pay drawing the money out as an individual, leave the money in the business, grow the business then as and when you do need to spend the money you can pay the difference between the corporation tax and personal tax.
A very crude summary with lots of variables but a ladybird book 1 explanation

So drawing the money out as earnings would result in a tax bill. Borrowing the money would result in a debt which the business probably doesn't want, and why pay a third party when the person exiting the company is happy to take payment over a longer period (probably interest free in effect)?
It makes perfect sense to me and sounds like all parties acted for the greater good of everyone involved.
Henry

I'm not an accountant and I have absolutely no knowledge of your business so can't really advise you.
If my previous guess was correct and because of recent trading figures you would probably struggle to realise your investment back at the moment then you have to be careful. If that is the case then now is probably not the time to be getting out of the business, you need to make it more profitable so it has a value.
But it sounds as though you're pretty fed up and want to make a move. I have no idea how much money we are talking here. Are things so bad you'd be prepared to just walk away? If so then handing over the shares in principle and relying on future dividends to pay you would be an option but of course if things are so bad and your partner is that useless it is possible the business will fail when you leave, so there is a risk you don't get paid.
Henry
If my previous guess was correct and because of recent trading figures you would probably struggle to realise your investment back at the moment then you have to be careful. If that is the case then now is probably not the time to be getting out of the business, you need to make it more profitable so it has a value.
But it sounds as though you're pretty fed up and want to make a move. I have no idea how much money we are talking here. Are things so bad you'd be prepared to just walk away? If so then handing over the shares in principle and relying on future dividends to pay you would be an option but of course if things are so bad and your partner is that useless it is possible the business will fail when you leave, so there is a risk you don't get paid.
Henry

Schermerhorn said:
So, in your opinion, Henry, would option #2 be the best solution; give my shares over in principle and the dividend accrued from both mine and his equity be used to repay me back at the end of the agreed term?
If you're giving the shares away, there are no real tax consequences for you. For IHT purposes it will be a gift which is subject to the 7 year rule, but could be covered by your annual exemption.If you are selling them, the way the purchase is funded is not relevant to your tax position. If you sell them cum dividend, the dividend could be used by the buyer to buy you out. You will have a capital gains event on the sale of the shares, and because the consideration is ascertainabe, any gain will be taxed when you sell the shares, not when you receive the money, so think about this.
The sale could of course be exempt if your are entitled to ER, but I don't know enough about your tax position to comment.
Alpinestars said:
Schermerhorn said:
So, in your opinion, Henry, would option #2 be the best solution; give my shares over in principle and the dividend accrued from both mine and his equity be used to repay me back at the end of the agreed term?
If you're giving the shares away, there are no real tax consequences for you. For IHT purposes it will be a gift which is subject to the 7 year rule, but could be covered by your annual exemption.If you are selling them, the way the purchase is funded is not relevant to your tax position. If you sell them cum dividend, the dividend could be used by the buyer to buy you out. You will have a capital gains event on the sale of the shares, and because the consideration is ascertainabe, any gain will be taxed when you sell the shares, not when you receive the money, so think about this.
The sale could of course be exempt if your are entitled to ER, but I don't know enough about your tax position to comment.
How does one (ie HMRC et al) ascertain whether the shares are sold or merely given away? If we deal in cash rather than electronic money transfer, surely there is no way to tell?
Schermerhorn said:
Alpinestars said:
Schermerhorn said:
So, in your opinion, Henry, would option #2 be the best solution; give my shares over in principle and the dividend accrued from both mine and his equity be used to repay me back at the end of the agreed term?
If you're giving the shares away, there are no real tax consequences for you. For IHT purposes it will be a gift which is subject to the 7 year rule, but could be covered by your annual exemption.If you are selling them, the way the purchase is funded is not relevant to your tax position. If you sell them cum dividend, the dividend could be used by the buyer to buy you out. You will have a capital gains event on the sale of the shares, and because the consideration is ascertainabe, any gain will be taxed when you sell the shares, not when you receive the money, so think about this.
The sale could of course be exempt if your are entitled to ER, but I don't know enough about your tax position to comment.
How does one (ie HMRC et al) ascertain whether the shares are sold or merely given away? If we deal in cash rather than electronic money transfer, surely there is no way to tell?
eps said:
Schermerhorn said:
Alpinestars said:
Schermerhorn said:
So, in your opinion, Henry, would option #2 be the best solution; give my shares over in principle and the dividend accrued from both mine and his equity be used to repay me back at the end of the agreed term?
If you're giving the shares away, there are no real tax consequences for you. For IHT purposes it will be a gift which is subject to the 7 year rule, but could be covered by your annual exemption.If you are selling them, the way the purchase is funded is not relevant to your tax position. If you sell them cum dividend, the dividend could be used by the buyer to buy you out. You will have a capital gains event on the sale of the shares, and because the consideration is ascertainabe, any gain will be taxed when you sell the shares, not when you receive the money, so think about this.
The sale could of course be exempt if your are entitled to ER, but I don't know enough about your tax position to comment.
How does one (ie HMRC et al) ascertain whether the shares are sold or merely given away? If we deal in cash rather than electronic money transfer, surely there is no way to tell?
What tax are you trying to avoid? It's likely there is none unless he's paying a lot more than you put in in the first place. So if you put £50k in and he is buying the shares for £100k there is a capital gain, but no tax on £50k in and £50k out. But that's the payment being for the shares, the same money being in PAYE or dividends would have tax to pay.
Schermerhorn said:
This is my thought also. I'm trying to stay within the law and not do anything illegal hence the question. What if my partner wants to do it in a way where he pays no tax and I want to do it in an above-board manner, how does one get to the best solution etc.
What would he be paying tax on? He's either buying something or being gifted something. Other than a potential inheritance tax liability on a gift, he has not entered into a transaction which crystallises tax for him.Gassing Station | Business | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


