Not charged VAT - now what?
Not charged VAT - now what?
Author
Discussion

Alapeno

Original Poster:

1,391 posts

178 months

Tuesday 1st April 2014
quotequote all
I registered for VAT in December, which became effective at the start of Jan.

Long story short, some invoices for Jan/Feb have been issued without charging the VAT, they've been sent out on the old invoice template before we were registered.

I have an accountant that seems to think that I'll have to pay the VAT out of my own money - so 20% of what was taken in, which is a considerable amount.

If it's as serious as this, it's a real problem as I can't afford to just lose that money from the business.

The party that paid the invoices have already filed their VAT return so it can't be back paid to me apparently. My thoughts are surely this has happened before and there must be a simple way of sorting it with HMRC.

Any solutions oh wise PH?

eps

7,160 posts

300 months

Tuesday 1st April 2014
quotequote all
Your accountant is correct.

Du1point8

22,967 posts

223 months

Tuesday 1st April 2014
quotequote all
How did you forget to charge the VAT on the invoices?

If the VAT registration did not get finished in time of the original invoices, you are not allowed to charge VAT, but can send a retrospective VAT invoice once the VAT registration is complete (if my poor accounting skills/memory are correct).

What did your accountant say about the above if you do that other than sucking up the missing VAT?

Rude-boy

22,227 posts

264 months

Tuesday 1st April 2014
quotequote all
Du1point8 said:
What did your accountant say about the above if you do that other than sucking up the missing VAT?
I am not an accountant but I have seen this question (or similar) on here before.

If Client will not pay the extra then you have to pay it out of your own pocket (or at least that of the company). Now what I don't know is if that can then be classed as a loss to offset against pre tax profits - I would assume that it is but woulod want proper advice.

OP I feel really sorry for you but how come it took so long for this to be picked up on? It's 1st April already!

Alapeno

Original Poster:

1,391 posts

178 months

Tuesday 1st April 2014
quotequote all
Rude-boy said:
I am not an accountant but I have seen this question (or similar) on here before.

If Client will not pay the extra then you have to pay it out of your own pocket (or at least that of the company). Now what I don't know is if that can then be classed as a loss to offset against pre tax profits - I would assume that it is but would want proper advice.

OP I feel really sorry for you but how come it took so long for this to be picked up on? It's 1st April already!
Client is more than willing to pay (although we look very silly) but their accountant is telling them they can't pay the extra as it's already been filed with VAT. I assume this is correct.

Call it naivety mixed in with a few personal problems and it just went unnoticed by me. It certainly won't happen again! Bit of a hard lesson to learn really.

Eric Mc

125,921 posts

296 months

Tuesday 1st April 2014
quotequote all
The accountant is technically wrong. Of course they can submit the amended VAT details on a later return - or through a mistake or error declaration. However, it is obvious that he doesn't want to bother - which is understandable up to a point.

What you could do is issue credit notes to cancel the original invoices and then issue replacement invoices showing the correct VAT calculations.

The customer could then process these in the next available VAT return without any real need to make any special adjustments to their returns.

As they are VAT registered, paying you the extra VAT amount is no big deal as they will be claiming it back from HMRC.

JustinP1

13,364 posts

261 months

Tuesday 1st April 2014
quotequote all
Eric Mc said:
The accountant is technically wrong. Of course they can submit the amended VAT details on a later return - or through a mistake or error declaration. However, it is obvious that he doesn't want to bother - which is understandable up to a point.

What you could do is issue credit notes to cancel the original invoices and then issue replacement invoices showing the correct VAT calculations.

The customer could then process these in the next available VAT return without any real need to make any special adjustments to their returns.

As they are VAT registered, paying you the extra VAT amount is no big deal as they will be claiming it back from HMRC.
smile

I think Eric's just saved you a few hundred/thousand quid...!

A virtual pint is in order...

Eric Mc

125,921 posts

296 months

Tuesday 1st April 2014
quotequote all
There is also a legal aspect to it as well.

You would have agreed a price with your customer. That would form part of the terms of a contract.

If the customer is now deciding that they are only going to pay you 80% of the agreed price, that is breach of contract.

OK, the fact that they have paid you 80% of what you need is down to a mistake by you - but you are intending to correct that mistake so that -

a) you get the agreed amount of money from your customer

b) you fulfill your legal obligations under VAT regulations

I would not roll over on this and insist that the matter is corrected properly.

sanguinary

1,598 posts

242 months

Tuesday 1st April 2014
quotequote all
Eric Mc said:
I would not roll over on this and insist that the matter is corrected properly.
This ^.

The accountant is either being lazy, or attempting to wrongly protect their client's interests.

I've dealt with vat credits going back more than one period in the past, sometimes a couple of years.




Alapeno

Original Poster:

1,391 posts

178 months

Tuesday 1st April 2014
quotequote all
Eric Mc said:
The accountant is technically wrong. Of course they can submit the amended VAT details on a later return - or through a mistake or error declaration. However, it is obvious that he doesn't want to bother - which is understandable up to a point.

What you could do is issue credit notes to cancel the original invoices and then issue replacement invoices showing the correct VAT calculations.

The customer could then process these in the next available VAT return without any real need to make any special adjustments to their returns.

As they are VAT registered, paying you the extra VAT amount is no big deal as they will be claiming it back from HMRC.
Thanks Eric! A virtual pint is certainly in order beer

I'll have a look into this/run it by the right people and hopefully get it sorted

The Moose

23,709 posts

240 months

Tuesday 1st April 2014
quotequote all
If the invoice should have been £120 + VAT (£144), but the invoice went out with the total of £120, it looks as if rather than them accounting for it as £120 (as per the invoice), they're accounting for it as £100 + £20 VAT so actually claiming that back.

I imagine this is why they're not keen on rectifying the issue - they've saved a bit of cash. Not ideal for you of course. If your contact there is reasonable, it shouldn't be a big issue. Remember the accountant is instructed what to do by the business.

Rude-boy

22,227 posts

264 months

Tuesday 1st April 2014
quotequote all
The Moose said:
....Remember the accountant is instructed what to do by the business.
Ish.

As in Solicitors are suposed to act on their Client's instructions but you will find that there are some who will reply first and then confirm the instruction later...

Eric Mc

125,921 posts

296 months

Tuesday 1st April 2014
quotequote all
Depends on the relationship.

If they have an in-house accountant/book-keeper, he/she may very well be put upon by management to do things their way.

If the accountant is also the financial controller or a director, then he or she will probably be telling the management what to do.

If the accountant is a third party consultant/outside accountant, then it is likely that the business will rely on him/her for advice on such matters.

counterofbeans

1,092 posts

170 months

Tuesday 1st April 2014
quotequote all
The Moose said:
If the invoice should have been £120 + VAT (£144), but the invoice went out with the total of £120, it looks as if rather than them accounting for it as £120 (as per the invoice), they're accounting for it as £100 + £20 VAT so actually claiming that back.

I imagine this is why they're not keen on rectifying the issue - they've saved a bit of cash. Not ideal for you of course. If your contact there is reasonable, it shouldn't be a big issue. Remember the accountant is instructed what to do by the business.
No, the invoice was issued without VAT so they cannot reclaim any VAT at all

CofB

The Moose

23,709 posts

240 months

Tuesday 1st April 2014
quotequote all
counterofbeans said:
No, the invoice was issued without VAT so they cannot reclaim any VAT at all

CofB
That's exactly my point. However the OP said:

Alapeno said:
Client is more than willing to pay (although we look very silly) but their accountant is telling them they can't pay the extra as it's already been filed with VAT. I assume this is correct.
(bit I'm talking about made bold).

davepoth

29,395 posts

230 months

Tuesday 1st April 2014
quotequote all
The Moose said:
counterofbeans said:
No, the invoice was issued without VAT so they cannot reclaim any VAT at all

CofB
That's exactly my point. However the OP said:

Alapeno said:
Client is more than willing to pay (although we look very silly) but their accountant is telling them they can't pay the extra as it's already been filed with VAT. I assume this is correct.
(bit I'm talking about made bold).
So I'm guessing what's actually happened is that their accountant has also fked up and has filed the VAT return incorrectly, using the invoice total as the "inclusive of VAT" number and then subtracted the VAT from it. Doesn't look too clever for him if that's the case...

tjl

392 posts

203 months

Tuesday 1st April 2014
quotequote all
Was there a vat number printed on the original invoice. From HMRC site -

What a VAT invoice must show
A VAT invoice must show:
an invoice number which is unique and follows on from the number of the previous invoice - if you spoil or cancel a serially numbered invoice, you must keep it to show to a VAT officer at your next VAT inspection
the seller's name or trading name, and address
the seller's VAT registration number
......
the total amount of VAT charged expressed in sterling

So if the customer has tried to recover vat from an invoice without a vat number, or from an invoice where the total amount of the vat wasn't shown, then they presumably have made a mistake which they might like to get corrected by way of credit note an re-issued invoice as others have suggested

The Moose

23,709 posts

240 months

Tuesday 1st April 2014
quotequote all
davepoth said:
The Moose said:
counterofbeans said:
No, the invoice was issued without VAT so they cannot reclaim any VAT at all

CofB
That's exactly my point. However the OP said:

Alapeno said:
Client is more than willing to pay (although we look very silly) but their accountant is telling them they can't pay the extra as it's already been filed with VAT. I assume this is correct.
(bit I'm talking about made bold).
So I'm guessing what's actually happened is that their accountant has also fked up and has filed the VAT return incorrectly, using the invoice total as the "inclusive of VAT" number and then subtracted the VAT from it. Doesn't look too clever for him if that's the case...
Exactly what it sounds like has happened to me...

sumo69

2,164 posts

251 months

Tuesday 1st April 2014
quotequote all
Sounds like the OP's accountant and that of his customer are both a tad "lazy" for want of a better word.

The OP's should have told him to issue a pro-forma invoice for the VAT inclusive price and when registered this should be reissued as a VAT invoice allowing the client to reclaim the VAT element and the OP would not be out of pocket.

There is certainly no issue with issuing a supplementary "VAT only" invoice that would rectify the situation rather than credit notes/replacement invoices so long as both parties accounting records can process this correctly.

David

Jamster123

485 posts

234 months

Tuesday 1st April 2014
quotequote all
I had issue with my Vat number and so hadn't been charging VAT on many jobs. This was for private clients (domestic electrical)

I just done my first VAT return , accountant just told me to to mark down as "no vat charged as awaiting number" on certain jobs....he added as they were private clients it would be unreasonable for me to try and reclaim money from them ( for VAT ) after work was complete. e mentioned nothing about it coming from my own pocket,