How does VAT work?
Author
Discussion

JapanRed

Original Poster:

1,591 posts

141 months

Monday 2nd December 2019
quotequote all
Hi all,

Can anyone explain how VAT works on small businesses?

If a company turns over £100k is it payable on the whole £100k or just the £15k that’s above £85k threshold?

If my company turned over £100k with £80k profit would I pay £20k VAT and then another £19k corporation tax? Leaving £41k?

I assume I’ve gone wrong somewhere above?
Thanks in advance.

Doofus

34,514 posts

203 months

Monday 2nd December 2019
quotequote all
Once you register, all your 'in scope' sales are subject to VAT, so the full £100k, in your example.

But, of course, all VAT paid on purchases is reclaimable too.

Doofus

34,514 posts

203 months

Monday 2nd December 2019
quotequote all
Does your 100k include VAT or not?

Turnover is typically net of VAT, so either you've invoiced your customers 120k, in which case your turnover is 100k, or you've invoiced them 100k, in which case t/o is 83.333k

IJWS15

2,235 posts

115 months

Monday 2nd December 2019
quotequote all
Does this qualify for the flat rate scheme?

If so the amount you pay HMRC may differ from what you collect.

As above - value of goods/services = £1000

Invoice to customer - £1000 plus VAT of £200 = £1200 total (VAT is separately identified and invoice must quote some information including VAT number) Don't worry about the customer, if he is VAT registered he will be claiming it back from HMRC.

Normal scheme you send £200 to HMRC (quarterly IIRC), on flat rate scheme you pay a percentage of turnover but this makes the accounting simpler but you can't recover VAT on purchases so it may not suite your business.

Your sales, and hence profit, are based on the pre-VAT figure and VAT has no effect on them.

Talk to your accountant, if you are getting into the realms of VAT it is worth having one.


Edited by IJWS15 on Monday 2nd December 17:48

Groat

5,637 posts

141 months

Monday 2nd December 2019
quotequote all
Roughly?

a) You add up all the VAT you've charged in the past 3 months.

b) You add up all the VAT people have charged you in the past 3 months.

a) minus b) is what you owe and if that's a minus number it's what vatman owes you.


Eric Mc

125,754 posts

295 months

Monday 2nd December 2019
quotequote all
And you buy compatible software and register for VAT Making Tax Digital - now compulsory.

UpTheIron

4,058 posts

298 months

Monday 2nd December 2019
quotequote all
Eric Mc said:
And you buy compatible software and register for VAT Making Tax Digital - now compulsory.
Free software is available, although in the OP's case I hope he has an accountant doing it for him.

Doofus

34,514 posts

203 months

Monday 2nd December 2019
quotequote all
Eric Mc said:
register for VAT Making Tax Digital - now compulsory.
Not if his 100k t/o is gross. smile

JapanRed

Original Poster:

1,591 posts

141 months

Monday 2nd December 2019
quotequote all
Thanks for all the replies. I never paid VAT as I provide a healthcare service which is exempt. HMRC are questioning whether it’s truly a service that I provide and think I should be registered.



Edited by JapanRed on Wednesday 18th December 22:34

singlecoil

35,834 posts

276 months

Monday 2nd December 2019
quotequote all
JapanRed said:
I’ve never invoiced for VAT before and I’m not sure the company that pay me charge VAT either as I think they are exempt.
Do you only have one customer? If so, VAT might not be your only tax issue.

JapanRed

Original Poster:

1,591 posts

141 months

Monday 2nd December 2019
quotequote all
It’s defo not an IR35 issue as my accountant ran this past HMRC a few years back and they were satisfied.

Multiple customers, if that makes a difference.

Eric Mc

125,754 posts

295 months

Monday 2nd December 2019
quotequote all
JapanRed said:
It’s defo not an IR35 issue as my accountant ran this past HMRC a few years back and they were satisfied.

Not a guarantee.

Read up on the Dragonfly Ltd case.

Regarding turnover, I assumed that because the OP was asking about VAT registration that he must be already over the £85,000 threshold. Subsequently, the fact that he now tells us that HMRC also believes he should be VAT registered confirms that.

Simpo Two

92,928 posts

295 months

Monday 2nd December 2019
quotequote all
JapanRed said:
I’m really worried that I’m gonna get a mega bill for the backdated VAT if I lose the case....
Interesting. So if the worst happens, would you have a right to go back to all the clients you didn't charge VAT to and say 'Er actually, would you mind sending another 20%? If they are VAT registered they can claim it right back and you can pay the VAT bill and break even.

Eric Mc

125,754 posts

295 months

Monday 2nd December 2019
quotequote all
Simpo Two said:
JapanRed said:
I’m really worried that I’m gonna get a mega bill for the backdated VAT if I lose the case....
Interesting. So if the worst happens, would you have a right to go back to all the clients you didn't charge VAT to and say 'Er actually, would you mind sending another 20%? If they are VAT registered they can claim it right back and you can pay the VAT bill and break even.
Absolutely he can do that. However, many customers would be unwilling to go along with that - especially if they happen to be non-VAT registered..

Simpo Two

92,928 posts

295 months

Monday 2nd December 2019
quotequote all
Eric Mc said:
Absolutely he can do that. However, many customers would be unwilling to go along with that - especially if they happen to be non-VAT registered..
Agreed - though he could blame it on the HMRC.

If he didn't want to keep the client, how would look to the judge if an unpaid 'secondary' invoice ended up in small claims I wonder?

JapanRed

Original Poster:

1,591 posts

141 months

Tuesday 3rd December 2019
quotequote all
Eric Mc said:
JapanRed said:
It’s defo not an IR35 issue as my accountant ran this past HMRC a few years back and they were satisfied.

Not a guarantee.

Read up on the Dragonfly Ltd case.

Regarding turnover, I assumed that because the OP was asking about VAT registration that he must be already over the £85,000 threshold. Subsequently, the fact that he now tells us that HMRC also believes he should be VAT registered confirms that.
Just read up on Dragonfly case. My business is nothing like that. I work for multiple providers, picking and choosing what days and hours I work each week. Some weeks there is no work and I don’t do anything - multiple contracts have ended with less than a weeks notice. I don’t have any concerns over IR35.

Yes turnover was well over £85k for a couple of years. The annoying thing is that moving forward turnover will be under £85k and has been for several months now (before this issue kicked off).

JapanRed

Original Poster:

1,591 posts

141 months

Tuesday 3rd December 2019
quotequote all
Simpo Two said:
Eric Mc said:
Absolutely he can do that. However, many customers would be unwilling to go along with that - especially if they happen to be non-VAT registered..
Agreed - though he could blame it on the HMRC.

If he didn't want to keep the client, how would look to the judge if an unpaid 'secondary' invoice ended up in small claims I wonder?
Do you mean invoice them anyway and then if they don’t pay take them to court? How far could I backdate a VAT only invoice? Is 3-4 years possible?

Eric Mc

125,754 posts

295 months

Tuesday 3rd December 2019
quotequote all
JapanRed said:
Just read up on Dragonfly case. My business is nothing like that. I work for multiple providers, picking and choosing what days and hours I work each week. Some weeks there is no work and I don’t do anything - multiple contracts have ended with less than a weeks notice. I don’t have any concerns over IR35.

Yes turnover was well over £85k for a couple of years. The annoying thing is that moving forward turnover will be under £85k and has been for several months now (before this issue kicked off).
Has this issue been caused by confusion as to whether the nature of what you do is Zero Rated for VAT or VAT Exempt?
How much of your sales is/was potentially Standard Rated?

JapanRed

Original Poster:

1,591 posts

141 months

Tuesday 3rd December 2019
quotequote all
Eric Mc said:
JapanRed said:
Just read up on Dragonfly case. My business is nothing like that. I work for multiple providers, picking and choosing what days and hours I work each week. Some weeks there is no work and I don’t do anything - multiple contracts have ended with less than a weeks notice. I don’t have any concerns over IR35.

Yes turnover was well over £85k for a couple of years. The annoying thing is that moving forward turnover will be under £85k and has been for several months now (before this issue kicked off).
Has this issue been caused by confusion as to whether the nature of what you do is Zero Rated for VAT or VAT Exempt?
How much of your sales is/was potentially Standard Rated?
They sent a letter out of the blue asking why I wasn’t registered for VAT. Suppose it flagged on their system or someone noticed.

All of the sales will be the same, in mine and my accountants (and the specialist tax company fighting my case) it’s 100% exempt. HMRC have made a very quick decision and state it’s 100% standard rate. The tax company fighting the case have drafted a 3 page response highlighting why we believe it’s all exempt.

Best scenario is that they accept our response but what happens if both parties disagree? Assume a judge will decide?

Eric Mc

125,754 posts

295 months

Tuesday 3rd December 2019
quotequote all
Yes - various levels of decision making can follow on from an inability to decide through normal correspondence, visits etc - chiefly VAT tribunals and maybe the courts.