Small business bank / accounting combo
Small business bank / accounting combo
Author
Discussion

miniman

Original Poster:

28,529 posts

279 months

Tuesday 22nd October 2024
quotequote all
I’m looking at Starling + Xero.

Any opinions / experiences?

FlyingPanda

517 posts

107 months

Tuesday 22nd October 2024
quotequote all
I have exactly that combo. My thoughts:

Starling - superb, flawless integration and easy to set up, really like it.
Xero - slightly tricky to set up, getting expensive if you do more than a few invoices a month and have any staff, but does everything you need pretty well.

My only regret is that after using Quickbooks on another business I recently purchased, I think Quickbooks is more user-friendly and in hindsight would have been a better choice. Thing is I can't be ar$ed to unpick it all and switch now, so I am using both!

AB

18,644 posts

212 months

Tuesday 22nd October 2024
quotequote all
Use Starling + Xero, no problems whatsoever.

StevieBee

14,318 posts

272 months

Wednesday 23rd October 2024
quotequote all
I'm Starling + Quick Books

Starling - No issues whatsoever. On the two occasions I've had to call them, the phone was answered almost immediately and the problems (of my own making) were solved there and then.

Quick Books - My only gripe is that it's all things to all men and not that easy to customise to my particular need. This means I have to navigate through much superfluous stuff. I'd imagine Xero and others to be the same though.

MustangGT

13,464 posts

297 months

Wednesday 23rd October 2024
quotequote all
FlyingPanda said:
I have exactly that combo. My thoughts:

Starling - superb, flawless integration and easy to set up, really like it.
Xero - slightly tricky to set up, getting expensive if you do more than a few invoices a month and have any staff, but does everything you need pretty well.

My only regret is that after using Quickbooks on another business I recently purchased, I think Quickbooks is more user-friendly and in hindsight would have been a better choice. Thing is I can't be ar$ed to unpick it all and switch now, so I am using both!
Most accountancy firms avoid Quickbooks like the plague.

I have found many issues with QBO, including it having the ability to make illegal changes to an invoice after issue.

At this time I am in the process of moving the company accounts from QBO to Xero.

Puzzles

2,994 posts

128 months

Wednesday 23rd October 2024
quotequote all
Starling are excellent at the basics.

IME clients find Xero more user friendly, although they are ramping up the monthly price.

PoorCarCollector

199 posts

37 months

Wednesday 23rd October 2024
quotequote all
MustangGT said:
Most accountancy firms avoid Quickbooks like the plague.
What a load of bollards!! Most accountacy firms are happy to work with both

I've found Quickbooks excellent and prefer it over Xero, but it's down to personal choice

MaxFromage

2,438 posts

148 months

Wednesday 23rd October 2024
quotequote all
MustangGT said:
Most accountancy firms avoid Quickbooks like the plague.
Yes it's gone downhill fast. We would advise a client that we'd have to charge more if we were going to have to interact with it on a significant basis.

Tymb

197 posts

112 months

Wednesday 23rd October 2024
quotequote all
Use Starling + Xero on one business appears to work seamlessly, really quick at updating Xero.
Use Metro + Xero on another business appears to work fine, transactions can take a while to update in Xero.
Prefer Starling to Metro for ease of use.
Two different accountants, both suggested they preferred Xero so went with that so cannot compare to Quickbooks.
I'd suggest have a word with your accountant and see which they prefer.

MustangGT

13,464 posts

297 months

Wednesday 30th October 2024
quotequote all
MaxFromage said:
MustangGT said:
Most accountancy firms avoid Quickbooks like the plague.
Yes it's gone downhill fast. We would advise a client that we'd have to charge more if we were going to have to interact with it on a significant basis.
I have another gripe about QBO now. I cannot set up a single entity to be a supplier and a customer. This means I cannot produce a statement showing all transactions in a single date-order list.

Absolutely useless. I have been working with small and mid-tier ERPs for 35 years or so, never not had this functionality before!

IlPapaMobile

37 posts

33 months

Saturday 2nd November 2024
quotequote all
Mettle & Freeagent have been great for me. I do tend to use Starling as my main account but now it's a proper account the Mettle setup is decent enough it could be used as a main account. Freeagent is spot on, very few issues for me with it.

barryrs

4,829 posts

240 months

Saturday 2nd November 2024
quotequote all
I have Barclays/FreshBooks with an employment hero plugin and have no complaints so far.


tpalmer

88 posts

116 months

Monday 11th November 2024
quotequote all
I don't use them for our primary current account, but do have an account with Tide, due to their biz savings rates. So far have been very impressed, and they play well with Xero.

miniman

Original Poster:

28,529 posts

279 months

Monday 11th November 2024
quotequote all
I ended up going with Freeagent on recommendation of my accountant (and that they provide it FOC as part of the package) and Tide because the Starling setup process was rather tiresome. All seems good so far.