Advice needed on tax deductions
Discussion
I have been working for a contractor and paying out of my own pocket my accomodation and parking charges which I then have to invoice for and claim back, I sent a seperate invoice for this along side the invoice for the work I completed, from the parking/accomodation I had deducted the VAT which I will claim back but the contractor is deducting 20% tax from the amount I am invoicing them for the parking and accomodation. Is this correct or am I losing out?
Eric Mc said:
Are you a Sub-Contractor in the Construction Industry?
Do you have a Sub-Contractor card and number?
Is it required that contractors deduct 20% tax from what they pay you in respect of the labour costs you bill them?
Do you have an accountant?
Yes, subbie in construction with CIS card, I spoke with my accountant today and confirmed they can deduct it to keep their books balanced, mine will also balance at the end of the financial year.Do you have a Sub-Contractor card and number?
Is it required that contractors deduct 20% tax from what they pay you in respect of the labour costs you bill them?
Do you have an accountant?
Strictly speaking, they should really only deduct the 20% on the labour content of what you charge them. If you recharge separately for materials and other costs, they shouldn't deduct the 20% on those specific items.
At the end of the day, it won't matter too much as the 20% they have taken out is looked on as a "down payment" of your Income Tax liability and you will get credit for it from the Revenue - eventually.
At the end of the day, it won't matter too much as the 20% they have taken out is looked on as a "down payment" of your Income Tax liability and you will get credit for it from the Revenue - eventually.
Eric Mc said:
Strictly speaking, they should really only deduct the 20% on the labour content of what you charge them. If you recharge separately for materials and other costs, they shouldn't deduct the 20% on those specific items.
At the end of the day, it won't matter too much as the 20% they have taken out is looked on as a "down payment" of your Income Tax liability and you will get credit for it from the Revenue - eventually.
Thanks EricAt the end of the day, it won't matter too much as the 20% they have taken out is looked on as a "down payment" of your Income Tax liability and you will get credit for it from the Revenue - eventually.
I'm ressurecting this thread rather than starting a new one, as it's a pretty similar topic!
I'm a self employed, sole trader, currently registered under the CIS scheme. I install satellite / aerial systems and occasionally do this for larger building firms which is where the CIS kicks in. I'm not VAT registered.
I submitted a quote via email for some work for a large contractor, this quote was accepted so the work was carried out. On the quote, I broke it down into materials and labour, and because the materials cost was quite high I showed the EX-VAT price AND then how much it was with the VAT added. I did this to show how it racked up! Obviously I pay the price + VAT for all my materials & can't claim any VAT back.
Now when it comes to getting paid they are refusing to pay the VAT part on my materials costs. Perhaps my mistake was showing how much the VAT was on the materials I bought, but they are adamant that they should not be paying this back to me (as part of the total invoice). There has been no dispute at all or disagreement about cost, except they refuse to pay the VAT I've already had to pay for the materials.
Obviously if I let this proceed, I'll be paying the VAT on the materials out of my profit, and they won't be able to calculate the CIS deductions properly. I've advised them they should pay me the full invoice amount, after working out the materials + VAT price and deducting this from the total before applying the 20% CIS deductions. They are saying this is incorrect and they can't do it like that.
Am I going mad or am I right? I'm sure there will be no problem getting payment if they believe it is due, but how to convince them?
Thanks in advance
I'm a self employed, sole trader, currently registered under the CIS scheme. I install satellite / aerial systems and occasionally do this for larger building firms which is where the CIS kicks in. I'm not VAT registered.
I submitted a quote via email for some work for a large contractor, this quote was accepted so the work was carried out. On the quote, I broke it down into materials and labour, and because the materials cost was quite high I showed the EX-VAT price AND then how much it was with the VAT added. I did this to show how it racked up! Obviously I pay the price + VAT for all my materials & can't claim any VAT back.
Now when it comes to getting paid they are refusing to pay the VAT part on my materials costs. Perhaps my mistake was showing how much the VAT was on the materials I bought, but they are adamant that they should not be paying this back to me (as part of the total invoice). There has been no dispute at all or disagreement about cost, except they refuse to pay the VAT I've already had to pay for the materials.
Obviously if I let this proceed, I'll be paying the VAT on the materials out of my profit, and they won't be able to calculate the CIS deductions properly. I've advised them they should pay me the full invoice amount, after working out the materials + VAT price and deducting this from the total before applying the 20% CIS deductions. They are saying this is incorrect and they can't do it like that.
Am I going mad or am I right? I'm sure there will be no problem getting payment if they believe it is due, but how to convince them?
Thanks in advance
Gassing Station | Business | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


