Planning madness !!!
Planning madness !!!
Author
Discussion

Hobo

Original Poster:

6,654 posts

277 months

Monday 1st December 2008
quotequote all
Have recently exchanged contracts (subject to planning) on some land in West Yorkshire. The property had outline planning (passed in the last month or so) for 6 homes.

Our architect has drawn up a revised scheme of 7 homes (of varying sizes), which will range in price from circa 250k to 500k (based on valuations given last week).

It was our intention to submit the full planning application prior to christmas, however as per normal we had a pre-app discussion with the council. During this discussion they threw up that thier policy had changed & that our application would have to incorporate social housing, at a rate of 20%, ie 1 home. They also mentioned that they are currently seeking 4 bed homes & as such would be one of these which they would be asking for. These homes have been valued at roughly 325k & based on rates given they would be willing to pay circa 100k !!!

This policy is not of thier website & is strictly on a, in thier words, 'site by site' basis. As such they can basically ask for what they want.

Architect, whom also works (or did when they were building) for the large/r developers is currently in discussions with them to see if this can be sorted. My issue is that it was not asked for in outline planning, thier website makes no comments about it, yet they are demanding a home.

Is this correct ? I am obviously concerned about what effect the 'social housing' may have on the saleability of the other homes, as this would be a very nice courtyard style development.

covmutley

3,385 posts

221 months

Monday 1st December 2008
quotequote all
I would say that as there was no requirement on the outline consent they should not impose an affordable housing requirement (assuming if it is just the reserved matters submission rather than a new application).

Ask the council what the status of the policy is. How is it linked to their local plan, has it been the subject of public consultation? If not the policy will have very limited weight.

What are they basing the need for the affordable house on? Check with them if they have an up to date market housing assessment that demonstrates a need which justifies the request.

As a last resort see if they will accept a payment rather than the house if you dont want social housing on the site.

covmutley

3,385 posts

221 months

Monday 1st December 2008
quotequote all
Apologies, missed the bit about the new full application!

As it is a new application the Council can now ask for affordable housing. My other comments on the status of the policy etc still apply.

The Moose

23,709 posts

240 months

Monday 1st December 2008
quotequote all
if its a 4 bedder they want valued at 325k, and will only give you 100k for it, you are out 225k (obviously!!). now if you think of the potential impact of "social housing" on the value of the other houses, lets be conservative and say a 10% decrease...

7 houses, average value: 350k = 2,450,000
6 houses, average value: 315k = 1,990,000 (& 1 @ 100k)
difference = 460,000

surely it would make sense for you to supply them with a privately owned house in a neighbouring location etc so that a) the originally estimated values are not changed and possibly the feel of the area is not changed and b) the council gets their 4 bedder which will cost you less than the 460k loss of profit you would be making!

sorry - just typing whilst i think - hope it makes sense!

Cheers

The Moose

ginettag27

7,161 posts

300 months

Tuesday 2nd December 2008
quotequote all
OPP is almost worthless, as I think you're finding out...

As above, I would ask to see the relevant policies, but guess your architect is already on the case.

I would have thought your development is too small to warrant affordable housing..

Hmm....


ETA : You (or more rightly your architect!) need to look through the Local Policies and see where affordable housing is mentioned. Most have a policy along the lines of "Circular 6/98 establishes the site size threshold at which it is appropriate to negotiate for affordable housing. This is 0.5 hectares or above (or developments of 15 or more dwellings)." Although this could have changed recently, due to the downturn. Ideally you need to (almost but not quite) dangle the S106 carrot in their eyes... If the development doesn't go ahead they won't get this.

ETA : PPS3 "“the national indicative minimum site size threshold is 15 dwellings. However, Local Planning Authorities can set lower minimum thresholds, where viable and practicable, including in rural areas. This could include setting different proportions of affordable housing to be sought for a series of site-size thresholds over the plan area. Local Planning Authorities will need to undertake an informed assessment of the economic viability of any thresholds and proportions of affordable housing proposed, including their likely impact upon overall levels of housing delivery and creating mixed communities. In particular, as the new definition of affordable housing excludes low cost market housing in deciding proportions of affordable housing to be sought in different circumstances, Local Planning Authorities should take account of the need to deliver low cost market housing as part of the overall housing mix.”"

Although it does provide them with a get out clause, second sentence... But it's not as if you're coming in just under the 15 dwelling mark.. harsh.

Edited by ginettag27 on Tuesday 2nd December 08:57

_Voyager_

2,782 posts

253 months

Tuesday 2nd December 2008
quotequote all
Sounds like a good opportunity to chip away at the land price if you ask me.

Hobo

Original Poster:

6,654 posts

277 months

Tuesday 2nd December 2008
quotequote all
Still obviously working on this, but it seems they have changed thier policy to incorporate every development of 5 or more to incorporate social housing (ideally 20%).

The way they are working out the price for the social housing seems bizarre to me, and if it is correct, which I think it is, then the reality is that I will only need to subsidise the home allocated to social housing by £37,500, which taking into account it will be a £275,000 home isn't that bad at all taking into account the current market.

A huge chunk of this can be recouped in simple down speccing & no selling fees, etc, etc.

I'm tempted to see if they want 2 houses yes

Horse_Apple

3,795 posts

273 months

Tuesday 2nd December 2008
quotequote all
Hobo said:
Have recently exchanged contracts (subject to planning) on some land in West Yorkshire. The property had outline planning (passed in the last month or so) for 6 homes.

Our architect has drawn up a revised scheme of 7 homes (of varying sizes), which will range in price from circa 250k to 500k (based on valuations given last week).

It was our intention to submit the full planning application prior to christmas, however as per normal we had a pre-app discussion with the council. During this discussion they threw up that thier policy had changed & that our application would have to incorporate social housing, at a rate of 20%, ie 1 home. They also mentioned that they are currently seeking 4 bed homes & as such would be one of these which they would be asking for. These homes have been valued at roughly 325k & based on rates given they would be willing to pay circa 100k !!!

This policy is not of thier website & is strictly on a, in thier words, 'site by site' basis. As such they can basically ask for what they want.

Architect, whom also works (or did when they were building) for the large/r developers is currently in discussions with them to see if this can be sorted. My issue is that it was not asked for in outline planning, thier website makes no comments about it, yet they are demanding a home.

Is this correct ? I am obviously concerned about what effect the 'social housing' may have on the saleability of the other homes, as this would be a very nice courtyard style development.
One quick thought, which may be of no value, is to split the plot in two and sell one part to another legal entity.

Then, after ensuring that the lots are below the local authority's minimum size for affordable housing, build on one with a view to developing the second plot at a later date.

No idea if that would work.

Sam_68

9,939 posts

276 months

Tuesday 2nd December 2008
quotequote all
There are a couple of ways to overcome this; I deal with this sort of issue quite regularly - for example, I've got a 160+ plot site that has just been recommended for approval this week, with 20% affordable instead of the LPA's original 'requirement' of 40%.

Contact me if you wish to negotiate fees...