Which eCommerce Software?
Which eCommerce Software?
Author
Discussion

Kinky

Original Poster:

39,947 posts

300 months

Friday 27th March 2009
quotequote all
I seem to be going round in circles here, and would be grateful for any guidance and PH experience and wisdom.

I'm about to build a webshop, which would be managed (on a stock level) by a non-techie.

I obviously want something secure, bug-free (as it can be anyway), and something that's easy enough to install/setup/customise.

I'm quite happy (technically) to set it all up, customise the look and feel, etc, etc, but where I struggle is which software option to go for.

I'm considering OsCommerce, ZenCart, CubeCart and CoffeeCup Cart. Feedback on them seems to vary - but there does not seem to be one that stands out from the rest.

It would be (primarily) a UK shop - so would need to support UK payments, VAT, etc, etc.

I know there's been a few discussions on this in the past on PH - and I have read and digested these - but just grateful for any guidance one way or the other.

Or perhaps there's another application I've missed (the 4 above are the ones I seem to have narrowed it down to).

Many thanks in advance,

K

jamesuk28

2,176 posts

284 months

Friday 27th March 2009
quotequote all
Cubecart 3 or 4 are pretty good.

Stu R

21,702 posts

246 months

Friday 27th March 2009
quotequote all
cubecart gets my vote. OSC isn't too bad either. not used the others.

Kinky

Original Poster:

39,947 posts

300 months

Friday 27th March 2009
quotequote all
I did start this a good few months ago - and started going down the OsCommerce route - but I found it more and more challenging as time went on - in terms of setting up and customising it.

I guess I could go back to it again - but my concern is the day-to-day 'admin' element - which needs to be as easy/simple and as non-techie as possible.

Plotloss

67,280 posts

301 months

Friday 27th March 2009
quotequote all

mb450

429 posts

230 months

Friday 27th March 2009
quotequote all
+1 for magento

WTD

818 posts

264 months

Saturday 28th March 2009
quotequote all
magento is OK if you want huge bloatware...

i'd thorougly recommend http://www.tradingeye.com/department/shopbuilder_f... tradingeye really powerful well developed software, easy to use, manage and customise if required. Accessible, compliant, and very very SEO friendly!

Check out some of the existing stores using it.
http://www.tradingeye.com/department/shopbuilder-s...

Alec

333 posts

257 months

Monday 30th March 2009
quotequote all
We are just launching a couple of ecommerce sites on www.goodbarry.com. Seems like a top service so far. It's hosted Ecommerce so no techie stuff outside bits of markup to do. I'm a programmer by trade and to me it just doesn't seem worth the hassle when you can get out of the box solutions for $40 a month. Drop me an email if you want.

Alec

jamie750xx

60 posts

250 months

Sunday 12th April 2009
quotequote all
Cubecart

OSC is too complex and you will probably end up tearing your hair out trying to figure it out

Cube is UK based and theres a whole loada support from UK users in the forums

Swillsy

181 posts

218 months

Thursday 16th April 2009
quotequote all
Cubecart

best software aswell as having a great community around it

smokingtyre

118 posts

212 months

Thursday 16th April 2009
quotequote all
I've used Actinic catalog for the last ten years. Has good features, especially good for new sites/business as it makes it easy for keywording products and pages.

Graham

16,381 posts

315 months

Thursday 16th April 2009
quotequote all
we've been playing with magento/ trading eye/ goodbarry etc and all seem to have both good and bad..


The real sticking point or us has been a good cost effective payment processor... we've got a number of smallish sites planned, but the costs of payment processing are higher than the blinking margins half the time..

google checkout was looking too good to be true, then they changed the terms and it was....


what deals have people come up with in terms of per transaction and rental rates


cheers
g

( sorry for the slightly off topic hijack)

jabriel

322 posts

272 months

Thursday 16th April 2009
quotequote all
try www.venda.com

more specifially http://www.venda.com/pcat/ecommercesolutions#tabvi...

If you are interested, let me know. I may be able to arrange a slight discount on the monthly fee.

Good luck with whatever you choose though.

Kinky

Original Poster:

39,947 posts

300 months

Thursday 16th April 2009
quotequote all
Cheers for all the responses. Some very interesting and thought provoking.

Up front - I've excluded the pay-monthly options. As this is a start-up business, with low AUPs, I really can't justify the costs at this stage. Particularly bearing in mind, I'm pretty au-fait with HTML coding. However, I do see the appeal of the benefits, and will be considering those for another 'project' I'll be working on.

So - of the rest - I was really torn between OSC and CubeCart. It was a tough call - but I've currently opted for CubeCart (V3) - again purely from a cost perspective. It's seem simple to setup - moreso than OSC. The only issue I see is the lack of templates, and ease of customisation. I must confess that OSC with the STS add-on is damn good. But just very fiddly (unfortunately).

So that's where we currently are!

But thanks again everyone, for inputs and opinions. It's always appreciated thumbup

Kinky

Original Poster:

39,947 posts

300 months

Thursday 16th April 2009
quotequote all
I should add that I may well change my mind tomorrow paperbag

loltolhurst

1,994 posts

215 months

Tuesday 22nd September 2009
quotequote all
any update on this how did you get on? anyone used foxycart or have any other recommendations?

maser_spyder

6,356 posts

213 months

Tuesday 22nd September 2009
quotequote all
A lot of people find OSC hard to customise, but it actually isn't that bad if you know what you're doing.

Our sites are based on OSC, and don't look anything like the 'standard' OSC look and feel;

www.fortissimoinstruments.co.uk

What it has in its favour, is a lot of experienced techies and upgrades available, so if you want to make changes, it's not too hard to find an experienced developer that already knows the system.

We just did a new site based on Magento, and what a PITA. Customisation turned in to a nightmare and added a month to the project. I bet with OSC we could have hacked out the customisation in a couple of days, but Magento really fought back at us.

That's not to say Magento isn't any good as the standard product, it's just a pain to make any changes to!

TurricanII

1,516 posts

229 months

Tuesday 22nd September 2009
quotequote all
I am shocked by the lack of people shouting for zen cart.. Very easy to set up on a Debian server, massive support on the forum has had all the answers for me in setting up and customising. Lots of plugins for Paypal payment etc.

dilbert

7,741 posts

262 months

Tuesday 22nd September 2009
quotequote all
maser_spyder said:
A lot of people find OSC hard to customise, but it actually isn't that bad if you know what you're doing.

Our sites are based on OSC, and don't look anything like the 'standard' OSC look and feel;

www.fortissimoinstruments.co.uk

What it has in its favour, is a lot of experienced techies and upgrades available, so if you want to make changes, it's not too hard to find an experienced developer that already knows the system.

We just did a new site based on Magento, and what a PITA. Customisation turned in to a nightmare and added a month to the project. I bet with OSC we could have hacked out the customisation in a couple of days, but Magento really fought back at us.

That's not to say Magento isn't any good as the standard product, it's just a pain to make any changes to!
You do know your SSL cert is out of date?

maser_spyder

6,356 posts

213 months

Wednesday 23rd September 2009
quotequote all
dilbert said:
maser_spyder said:
A lot of people find OSC hard to customise, but it actually isn't that bad if you know what you're doing.

Our sites are based on OSC, and don't look anything like the 'standard' OSC look and feel;

www.fortissimoinstruments.co.uk

What it has in its favour, is a lot of experienced techies and upgrades available, so if you want to make changes, it's not too hard to find an experienced developer that already knows the system.

We just did a new site based on Magento, and what a PITA. Customisation turned in to a nightmare and added a month to the project. I bet with OSC we could have hacked out the customisation in a couple of days, but Magento really fought back at us.

That's not to say Magento isn't any good as the standard product, it's just a pain to make any changes to!
You do know your SSL cert is out of date?
Yes, thanks. Only until tomorrow though. wink

It's a relatively new site, not being promoted at the moment, but will be starting in earnest in the new year.