What do you think of this idea? Does it already exist?
What do you think of this idea? Does it already exist?
Author
Discussion

Somewhatfoolish

Original Poster:

5,104 posts

217 months

Thursday 28th May 2009
quotequote all
How about an 'inventions' wiki?

E.G. Someone creates a new invention, say some super low power microchip because of a new alloy they'd created, and they post it to the inventions wiki. Then someone who understands CPUs says the instruction set is crap, and makes a new one. Then someone else points out that by moving the registers on the microchip the chip can consume a lot less power. These folk could be from anywhere in the entire world.

Or alternatively, how about someone proposes a monorail between London and Bristol, after digging up a mediaeval law that permits it. Then someone else suggests a potential route, whilst a third person designs the dining car, whilst a fourth comes up with a catchy name.

Or perhaps someone comes up with a new anti malaria drug, whilst another designs the packaging.

There are millions of variations on this theme.

Eventually the idea is at a stage where a commercial company can run with it. And then buy it off those who contributed to the invention via me. Anyone who contributed to the wiki would agree to the wiki owner (me) taking 20% and giving 80% to the contributors by my best judgement of relative contributions.

The wiki can also be used for political/philosophical brainstorming and all sorts of other things... actually it's more a brainstorming than an inventing wiki really

Would this be useful to your business? Would you contribute to this wiki? Would you browse this wiki for good ideas? Would you introduce bad ideas on purpose to see if anyone fell for them? Do I have a vaguely sane business model (details can be worked out later)?

PetrolTed

34,468 posts

334 months

Thursday 28th May 2009
quotequote all
Superb. I'd love to see great ideas thrashed out in public. Then I'd go away, implement them and this time next year Rodney...

biggrin

I don't think it's got much commercial viability I'm afraid

jamesuk28

2,176 posts

284 months

Thursday 28th May 2009
quotequote all
Ted speaks words of wisdom, listen and learn.

JustinP1

13,364 posts

261 months

Thursday 28th May 2009
quotequote all
jamesuk28 said:
Ted speaks words of wisdom, listen and learn.
Indeed.

Get a load of people to come up with great ideas for free and in public and hope that if one is any good a big company doesn't just use it?

Kind of like leaving an envelope of money in the town centre and asking a good soul to take it and invest it and give it back to you.

jamesuk28

2,176 posts

284 months

Thursday 28th May 2009
quotequote all
Here is one I had, but can't be arsed developing it or have the skills.

Someone posted in the last few days a reply to a topic and included a link to a turntable / photo booth for cars. Basically giving a 360 degree view of the vehicle and then converting that footage to a flash movie. If you could create a mobile studio and license the service to say autotrader, it would surely make a very valuable addition to their boring photos / lame "video" presentations.

Allowing the prospective purchaser to view the vehicle in 3D would surely be a real benefit, to both seller and purchaser.

If anybody makes a million out of this please send me a cheque for 10%, thanks

PetrolTed

34,468 posts

334 months

Thursday 28th May 2009
quotequote all
This is it:

www.turnstudio.net

They're based near the Ace Cafe.

rpguk

4,520 posts

315 months

Friday 29th May 2009
quotequote all
The fundamental problem is that by having the discussion in public you remove the possibility of patenting any idea that comes out of it (and licensing the patent is where your income would come from).

therealpigdog

2,592 posts

228 months

Friday 29th May 2009
quotequote all
the phrase "designed by a committee" also springs to mind!

Somewhatfoolish

Original Poster:

5,104 posts

217 months

Friday 29th May 2009
quotequote all
Next thing is whether people would be happy to do it for free, and if the website could be non commercial (or funded by adverts or something)... this was plan B...

Cheers coyft for the info, I'll get reading...

gamefreaks

2,070 posts

218 months

Friday 29th May 2009
quotequote all
Thats pretty much how open source software works.

Someone or a team starts a project and then anyone who wants to get involved can do.

TeamD

5,060 posts

263 months

Saturday 30th May 2009
quotequote all
therealpigdog said:
the phrase "designed by a committee" also springs to mind!
ah! A Camel biggrin

Mattt

16,664 posts

249 months

Saturday 30th May 2009
quotequote all
You could potentially implement it as a closed community project, with NDA etc on sign up/application.

Interesting idea, lots of issues to overcome though.

EINSIGN

5,638 posts

277 months

Saturday 30th May 2009
quotequote all
Interesting idea, even if there was no financial gain I think it would be fun to be involved. A lot of ideas don’t amount to anything because people hold them close to their chests, or think they are unique when they are probably not.

How about picking a product and re-inventing here and now to see what happens, need to think of something…

PetrolTed

34,468 posts

334 months

Saturday 30th May 2009
quotequote all
Although I was slightly flippant earlier in the thread, there are of course some elements of this that really do work as someone mentioned with open source, crowd sourcing, wikipedias etc. I had all manner of useful ideas and help given to me when building PH. People were willing to help because they had a sense of involvement with it.

Rather than create a generic ideas site and try and monetise the results, I'd suggest being more subtle. Look for other applications of this model. Create something of worth that other people are prepared to give you some input on to take it forwards.

Solve a problem, create a community, create bonds between people etc but do it with a clear focus.

PetrolTed

34,468 posts

334 months

Tuesday 2nd June 2009
quotequote all
Looks like it does exist:

Just launched: www.quirky.com

Somewhatfoolish

Original Poster:

5,104 posts

217 months

Tuesday 2nd June 2009
quotequote all
PetrolTed said:
Looks like it does exist:

Just launched: www.quirky.com
Cheers - they probably nicked the idea from this thread, the bds!

PetrolTed

34,468 posts

334 months