Ltd company & shareholders
Ltd company & shareholders
Author
Discussion

V8mate

Original Poster:

45,899 posts

220 months

Thursday 28th May 2009
quotequote all
If I start another Ltd company and invite people to invest in it in return for a shareholding, what happens if they subsequently want to 'remove' their investment?

Obviously, if someone suddenly decides they want their £200k (or whatever) back, it could close the company overnight. Would they have to seek a buyer for their shareholding in order to withdraw?

anonymous-user

85 months

Thursday 28th May 2009
quotequote all
I "think" you would detail how investors would exit within the Memorandum and Articles of Association.

Sure someone will be along shortly to confirm/deny this

P

Hobo

6,654 posts

277 months

Thursday 28th May 2009
quotequote all
You can insurance yourself so that in the event of such a thing happening thier is a policy/money available to purchase the shares (based on the value of the company) from whomever they are passed to (this is the more important matter as I see it).

Basically, if you have nothing in place & a shareholder dies, the shares go to thier next of kin/estate. Unless you have prior agreement these can simply demand the money. Much simpler to draw up an agreement that says the company gets first dibs @ £x/share or something else which suits.

Pretty simple stuff in reality, and much easier to do prior to accepting investment.

flyingjase

3,095 posts

262 months

Thursday 28th May 2009
quotequote all
V8mate said:
If I start another Ltd company and invite people to invest in it in return for a shareholding, what happens if they subsequently want to 'remove' their investment?

Obviously, if someone suddenly decides they want their £200k (or whatever) back, it could close the company overnight. Would they have to seek a buyer for their shareholding in order to withdraw?
All depends on the shareholders agreement and in tandem the articles

I have been in this situation in the early stages if my business and it caused me a nightmare due to the poorly drafted agreements I have mentioned.

I would urge you to do 2 specific things:-

1. Be specific in what you expect from the investor and what they expect from you
2. Go see a lawyer to documnet this and provide for the worst case scenario (and every other scenario)

Trust me from personal experience, money spent now will pay dividends (pardon the pun) later

Good uck with it

J

V8mate

Original Poster:

45,899 posts

220 months

Thursday 28th May 2009
quotequote all
flyingjase said:
V8mate said:
If I start another Ltd company and invite people to invest in it in return for a shareholding, what happens if they subsequently want to 'remove' their investment?

Obviously, if someone suddenly decides they want their £200k (or whatever) back, it could close the company overnight. Would they have to seek a buyer for their shareholding in order to withdraw?
All depends on the shareholders agreement and in tandem the articles

I have been in this situation in the early stages if my business and it caused me a nightmare due to the poorly drafted agreements I have mentioned.

I would urge you to do 2 specific things:-

1. Be specific in what you expect from the investor and what they expect from you
2. Go see a lawyer to documnet this and provide for the worst case scenario (and every other scenario)

Trust me from personal experience, money spent now will pay dividends (pardon the pun) later

Good uck with it

J
Thanks.

On the basis of your experiences, would you still prefer the investor/shareholder scenario to a long-term finance situation?

flyingjase

3,095 posts

262 months

Friday 29th May 2009
quotequote all
V8mate said:
flyingjase said:
V8mate said:
If I start another Ltd company and invite people to invest in it in return for a shareholding, what happens if they subsequently want to 'remove' their investment?

Obviously, if someone suddenly decides they want their £200k (or whatever) back, it could close the company overnight. Would they have to seek a buyer for their shareholding in order to withdraw?
All depends on the shareholders agreement and in tandem the articles

I have been in this situation in the early stages if my business and it caused me a nightmare due to the poorly drafted agreements I have mentioned.

I would urge you to do 2 specific things:-

1. Be specific in what you expect from the investor and what they expect from you
2. Go see a lawyer to documnet this and provide for the worst case scenario (and every other scenario)

Trust me from personal experience, money spent now will pay dividends (pardon the pun) later

Good uck with it

J
Thanks.

On the basis of your experiences, would you still prefer the investor/shareholder scenario to a long-term finance situation?
Good questions and depends on the situation (sorry to be vague)

Personally I would prefer finance unless the investor was bringing more than cash (eg specific skills / network / business etc). Finance is still available from banks and then you retain 100% of your equity. Selling equity now may seem attractive whilst the business is not worth much, but how much is that stake worth in 2,3 or 5 years time? What has your investor contributed towards that value? It's all good at the start, but when your hard work is making your investor rich for little contribution beyond the original cash then that will grate you very quickly.

I bought my investor back out after 18 months - they made a 943% on their investment for doing very little (and certainly not bringing the network to the table they promised) - good for them but as you can imagine not ideal for me. My fault ultimately though for not tieing that down in the shareholders agreement.

That share today is worth 33962% of their original investment, so although at the time the amount I paid to get the equity back was hard (had to sell the house to do it), it seems cheap at today's prices!

Lesson learnt!

V8mate

Original Poster:

45,899 posts

220 months

Friday 29th May 2009
quotequote all
That's really interesting Jason.

I've had a idea for a new business but am entirely unable to fund myself, so am considering the various options open to me. Obviously, from such a start-up position, an investor would be better than a creditor because I wouldn't be saddled immediately with repayments. But as your example shows, in the longer term the risk they shared at start-up can turn into massive success for them.

I guess you have ask whether you could have achieved that success without their cash; because if the answer is 'no' then surely they deserve every reward.

As I said in the OP though, I'm just concerned about their exit options.

anonymous-user

85 months

Friday 29th May 2009
quotequote all
Hobo said:
Basically, if you have nothing in place & a shareholder dies, the shares go to thier next of kin/estate. Unless you have prior agreement these can simply demand the money. Much simpler to draw up an agreement that says the company gets first dibs @ £x/share or something else which suits.
I don't understand that. If you buy shares in a Ltd company you get shares in return for cash. The value of shares goes up and down. Surely if a shareholder (or next of kin) wants to dispose of his shares he has to find a buyer who wants to buy them. How can they just "demand" the money? And what are they demanding? The original price paid or the current value?


therealpigdog

2,592 posts

228 months

Friday 29th May 2009
quotequote all
All depends on what you want to do, but you can permit or restrict shareholders from selling on to third parties, and put price mechanisms in.

Essentially though you have to consider whether there is a market for the shares - even if you are permitted to sell the shares, not many people are interested in buying a minority stake in a business. Also, would the remaining shareholders be happy if shares were sold to a third party they knew nothing about.

Clearly biased as IAAL, but you do need to think it through and do it properly - too many dangers involved if you get it wrong.

PM me if you want a quick chat through some of the issues (it's Friday afternoon and sunny and I'm in a good mood).

Cheers,
Phil

V8mate

Original Poster:

45,899 posts

220 months

Friday 29th May 2009
quotequote all
therealpigdog said:
All depends on what you want to do, but you can permit or restrict shareholders from selling on to third parties, and put price mechanisms in.

Essentially though you have to consider whether there is a market for the shares - even if you are permitted to sell the shares, not many people are interested in buying a minority stake in a business. Also, would the remaining shareholders be happy if shares were sold to a third party they knew nothing about.

Clearly biased as IAAL, but you do need to think it through and do it properly - too many dangers involved if you get it wrong.

PM me if you want a quick chat through some of the issues (it's Friday afternoon and sunny and I'm in a good mood).

Cheers,
Phil
Sorry Phil - have been out this afternoon.

I want to follow up a couple of leads first and get some more views from people who have chosen the investment and/or finance routes. May well drop you a line on another Frioday afternoon though thumbup