It's Friday: Random sole trader questions
It's Friday: Random sole trader questions
Author
Discussion

jon-

Original Poster:

16,534 posts

247 months

Friday 29th May 2009
quotequote all
I thought as it's friday, and half of us are probably bored I'd ask a few random questions that are playing on my mind! These all relate to being a sole trader, not a ltd company.

1) Jeff starts a sole 'tradership' as a plumber. He writes off his tools against profit in the first year. He then decides he wants to be an artist and selling paintings as well as plumbing, so starts buying painting equipment. Is there any reason he can't write these purchases off against profit from the plumbing (providing he invoices for a painting in the future and is planning on making money from it?) There's no "intent of business" listed when registering as a sole trader so I can't see why you can't be flexible.

2) Jeff paints in his home office, which he claims for (i can't remember how to work it out). How is there any validation of this claim?

I'm sure there will be more, but that should start us off!

John MacK

3,170 posts

237 months

Friday 29th May 2009
quotequote all
jon- said:
1) Jeff starts a sole 'tradership' as a plumber. He writes off his tools against profit in the first year. He then decides he wants to be an artist and selling paintings as well as plumbing, so starts buying painting equipment. Is there any reason he can't write these purchases off against profit from the plumbing (providing he invoices for a painting in the future and is planning on making money from it?) There's no "intent of business" listed when registering as a sole trader so I can't see why you can't be flexible.
Does he not depreciate his tools as capital expenses over a few years, rather than all in one go?
Any other capital expenses incurred in the following year would be treated in the same way. But as an artist his purchases would mostly be stocks, e.g. paint and canvas etc, so would be treated differently.
From a tax point of view he would be treated as Jeff Bloggs, rather than seperatly as Jeff Bloggs Plumber and then Jeff Bloggs Painter/artist.

jon- said:
2) Jeff paints in his home office, which he claims for (i can't remember how to work it out). How is there any validation of this claim?
What do you mean by validation?


Answers given are my understanding and should not be treated as tax advice, I am not qualified to give tax advice.

jon-

Original Poster:

16,534 posts

247 months

Friday 29th May 2009
quotequote all
Hi John,

Thanks for the reply.

Re point 2.

Say the new home office for painting is 1/6th of the house. If he was there full time, by my understanding he could claim 1/6th of the rent / bills. As he is a plumber too, and works out of the home most of the day he would only be there in the evenings, and might not paint every evening. How would he work out what % of home costs would be claimable?

Thanks

John MacK

3,170 posts

237 months

Friday 29th May 2009
quotequote all
I thought the home use claim was a flat rate or percentage, so if it is claimed for the plumbing business then it can't be claimed for the artistic business, unless carried out in another room.


Eric Mc

125,921 posts

296 months

Friday 29th May 2009
quotequote all
jon- said:
I thought as it's friday, and half of us are probably bored I'd ask a few random questions that are playing on my mind! These all relate to being a sole trader, not a ltd company.

1) Jeff starts a sole 'tradership' as a plumber. He writes off his tools against profit in the first year. He then decides he wants to be an artist and selling paintings as well as plumbing, so starts buying painting equipment. Is there any reason he can't write these purchases off against profit from the plumbing (providing he invoices for a painting in the future and is planning on making money from it?) There's no "intent of business" listed when registering as a sole trader so I can't see why you can't be flexible.

JEFF CAN WRITE HIS PLUMBING TOOLS OFF AGAINST HIS PLUMBING PROFITS USING WHATEVER TAX REGULATIONS ARE IN PLACE AT THE TIME. AT THE MOMENT, THERE ARE GENEROUS 100% ALLOWANCES FOR CAPITAL COSTS SO HE COULD, IN EFFECT, WRITE THEM OFF COMPLETELY IN THE YEAR HE BOUGHT THEM.

IF JEFF STARTS A NEW ACTIVITY/TRADE AS AN ARTIST, THEN HE IS ENTITLED TO OFFSET THE COSTS INCURRED IN RESPECT OF THIS NEW TRADE AGAINST THE INCOME FROM THE NEW TRADE (BUT NOT THE PLUMBING - WHICH IS A SEPARATE TRADE). IF HE INCURRS CAPITAL COSTS IN RESPECT OF THE PAINTING BUSINESS, THEN THESE CAN BE CLAIMED IN THE SAME WAY AS HE DID FOR HIS PLUMBING TOOLS, BUT ONLY AGAINST HIS PAINTING PROFITS.

IF HIS PAINTING BUSINESS INCURRS A LOSS, HE CAN, IN THEORY, OFFSET THE LOSS AGAINST "OTHER TAXABLE INCOME IN THE SAME TAX YEAR". THIS WOULD REDUCE HIS TAX LIABILITY ON THE PLUMBING SIDE BUT HE MIGHT HAVE TO CONVINCE THE REVENUE THAT THE PAINTING IS A BONA FIDE TRADE AND NOT JUST A HOBBY. HOBBIES ARE NOT "TRADES" AND DO NOT GENERATE "TRADING LOSSES".
WHATEVER IS OR ISN'T ON ANY REVENUE FORMS ABOUT "INTENT TO TRADE", THE PRINCIPAL IS ASSUMED AND THE REVENUE CAN DISCLAIM PERSITENT LOSSES FROM WHAT THEY DECIDE IS A HOBBY AND NOT A BUSINESS

2) Jeff paints in his home office, which he claims for (i can't remember how to work it out). How is there any validation of this claim?

THE REVENUE CAMN ALWAYS ASK THE TAXPAYER TO LAY OUT THE PROCESS BY WHICH THEY ARRIVED AT THEIR "USE OF HOME AS OFFICE" CLAIM.

I'm sure there will be more, but that should start us off!