what to do when you discover your idea is already out there
what to do when you discover your idea is already out there
Author
Discussion

bulb763

Original Poster:

870 posts

265 months

Tuesday 2nd June 2009
quotequote all
Sitting at work, dreaming of world domination, I come up with a few good ideas - amongst the many bad ones - that I think are new / novel, suit my skills and would be worth pursuing. But after a bit of reading up it inevitably turns out that not only are they already out there, they are up and running in a big way and have been for some time.

I find it very dis-heartening to find that the idea has actually been turned into what seems to be large, succesful and growing business because I just can't see that there is any hope of me being able compete.

I guess there isn't really a particular point to this post, other than to air my feelings... Anyone else got any thoughts on the subject they'd like to share?

edc

9,695 posts

282 months

Tuesday 2nd June 2009
quotequote all
If you can't beat 'em, join them?

CHIEF

2,270 posts

313 months

Tuesday 2nd June 2009
quotequote all
make it better, faster, cheaper, have a better location etc.

StevieBee

15,516 posts

286 months

Tuesday 2nd June 2009
quotequote all
It is often said that there is no such thing as an original thought, simply a thought to make something that already exists, better.

Paul McCartney said that for every song he wrote, there were at least 5 he didn't because he believed he had heard them else where.

Keep thinking and looking and if you come up with something someone else is doing, then just work out how to do it better.

JustinP1

13,364 posts

261 months

Tuesday 2nd June 2009
quotequote all
bulb763 said:
Sitting at work, dreaming of world domination, I come up with a few good ideas - amongst the many bad ones - that I think are new / novel, suit my skills and would be worth pursuing. But after a bit of reading up it inevitably turns out that not only are they already out there, they are up and running in a big way and have been for some time.

I find it very dis-heartening to find that the idea has actually been turned into what seems to be large, succesful and growing business because I just can't see that there is any hope of me being able compete.

I guess there isn't really a particular point to this post, other than to air my feelings... Anyone else got any thoughts on the subject they'd like to share?
If that concept were true, there would only be one company in each sector, the rest couldn't compete.

There are plenty of advantages a smaller company has, less overheads, more flexibility. You just need to work on what you HAVE not what you don't have.

Avis the hire car company one used this slogan very successfully:

"Avis - The second largest car rental company. We try harder."


My company carved out a particular niche in a market. We started with a single established competitor.

We changed the game and the pricing system of the whole market and grew the market considerably. Two years later the old competitor changed their schemes to match ours. Just today I have been given a heads up on a new company which must be the tenth in the last 5 years who have copied our concept and even particular quirks of it almost word for word.

Nothing we can do but keep ahead. You have every chance. Go for it, and you can still be the market leader.

ShadownINja

80,186 posts

313 months

Tuesday 2nd June 2009
quotequote all
Why does one business mean you can't do it? Imagine what would have happened if Omega or Breitling had ever thought, "Dunno why we do this, everyone wants a Rolex?" back in the '50s. Or Microsoft had thought, "Well, IBM will give the job to that other company."

bulb763

Original Poster:

870 posts

265 months

Tuesday 2nd June 2009
quotequote all
As far as I can see there is one established company in several EU countries - expanding all the time, patents on their technology, 8-figure turnover, broad set of important skills in the organisation - along with various other competitors which have no doubt seen the success and copied. I also wouldn't bet against them having exclusive contracts with their "suppliers", of which there are a limited number, and are key to the whole thing. Against that, I have virtually no relevant skills or experience, very little resources, and it seems I am late to the game :shrug:

Maybe a less pesimistic attitude wouldn't see exclusive deals as a problem, but they certainly appear to be tying the market up, which is of course an obvious and sensible thing to do, and is what is so frustrating.

Good to hear different attitudes to the situation though smile

JustinP1

13,364 posts

261 months

Tuesday 2nd June 2009
quotequote all
bulb763 said:
As far as I can see there is one established company in several EU countries - expanding all the time, patents on their technology, 8-figure turnover, broad set of important skills in the organisation - along with various other competitors which have no doubt seen the success and copied. I also wouldn't bet against them having exclusive contracts with their "suppliers", of which there are a limited number, and are key to the whole thing. Against that, I have virtually no relevant skills or experience, very little resources, and it seems I am late to the game :shrug:

Maybe a less pesimistic attitude wouldn't see exclusive deals as a problem, but they certainly appear to be tying the market up, which is of course an obvious and sensible thing to do, and is what is so frustrating.

Good to hear different attitudes to the situation though smile
So what is it exactly?

Thurbs

2,782 posts

253 months

Tuesday 2nd June 2009
quotequote all
When I started it was against Siemens & Mott McDonalds. Being David is great fun, chiefly because Goliath doesn’t have a clue how to deal with you. Comments like "they have destroyed MY market" make it all the more worthwhile.

The key is to differentiate in as many ways as you can.

bulb763

Original Poster:

870 posts

265 months

Tuesday 2nd June 2009
quotequote all
JustinP1 said:
So what is it exactly?
online take-away ordering

Mr POD

5,153 posts

223 months

Tuesday 2nd June 2009
quotequote all
http://www.impactinnovation.co.uk/index.htm

My mate is a partner is this 'gorilla' brand image consultancy. They win, by being cheaper, faster, more enjoyable and more flexible than the big boys.

Pick any product. Say a garden chair. Design one that is more cool looking than the rest, price it very high to make it exclusive. Sell a set of 4, and retire.

CoopR

957 posts

267 months

Tuesday 2nd June 2009
quotequote all
bulb763 said:
JustinP1 said:
So what is it exactly?
online take-away ordering
So in other words barriers to entry are ~£500 on a decent website, some sales chat with all your local takeaways and ~£1k on some adwords advertising. What are you waiting for wink

Murcielago_Boy

2,014 posts

270 months

Tuesday 2nd June 2009
quotequote all
bulb763 said:
Sitting at work, dreaming of world domination, I come up with a few good ideas - amongst the many bad ones - that I think are new / novel, suit my skills and would be worth pursuing. But after a bit of reading up it inevitably turns out that not only are they already out there, they are up and running in a big way and have been for some time.

I find it very dis-heartening to find that the idea has actually been turned into what seems to be large, succesful and growing business because I just can't see that there is any hope of me being able compete.

I guess there isn't really a particular point to this post, other than to air my feelings... Anyone else got any thoughts on the subject they'd like to share?
In direct answer to your question:
Who gives a F**K if the idea is already out there? Because it makes NO DIFFERENCE. Execution is wayyy more important than the idea.

Honestly mate, I started a business distributing equipment which had been distributed here by companies some 10 years before we started. Not that I'm a necessarily a "success" now, but believe me, it doesn't matter - we totally thrashed and annihilated the competition.
TRULY TRULY inspirational ideas that do not exist in any form out there are typically not even commercially viable - they're too far "ahead" if you know what I mean.

GO FOR IT!

monthefish

20,467 posts

262 months

Tuesday 2nd June 2009
quotequote all
ShadownINja said:
Why does one business mean you can't do it? Imagine what would have happened if Omega or Breitling had ever thought, "Dunno why we do this, everyone wants a Rolex?" back in the '50s. Or Microsoft had thought, "Well, IBM will give the job to that other company."
Good point.

jon-

16,534 posts

247 months

Tuesday 2nd June 2009
quotequote all
It's not like you're trying to invent a new type of bread. Coop said it best. Online ordering of a local product is VERY region-centric product, and there's always money to be made out of local business if done right.

Would be a hard one to make money on though.

CoopR said:
bulb763 said:
JustinP1 said:
So what is it exactly?
online take-away ordering
So in other words barriers to entry are ~£500 on a decent website, some sales chat with all your local takeaways and ~£1k on some adwords advertising. What are you waiting for wink

DonkeyKong

67 posts

211 months

Wednesday 3rd June 2009
quotequote all
bulb763 said:
JustinP1 said:
So what is it exactly?
online take-away ordering
Were you watching "Dave" when you came up with this idea? It was pitched for on Dragons Den. Half the dragons dropped out saying it was too hard. From memory I think two teamed up- even if it was just one, they certainly got their investment.


Plotloss

67,280 posts

301 months

Wednesday 3rd June 2009
quotequote all
Two men look at a village, deciding to open a business each.

The first man notices there are no kite shops, spots a gap in the market, opens a kite shop, realises there is no market and promptly goes bust.

The second man notices that there are 4 newsagents already so there is obviously a market for newsagents so opens yet another newsagent. As part of his business plan he undercuts every other newsagent until they start to go out of business. Once he is the only newsagent he puts up the prices to a profitable level.

Therein lies the fundamental difference between the way that Westerners and Easterners view business.

You dont have to do something that someone else hasnt thought of, you just need to do it better or cheaper or both.


bulb763

Original Poster:

870 posts

265 months

Wednesday 3rd June 2009
quotequote all
Thanks guys, interesting thoughts thumbup As a further thought, how would you guys typically assess an idea, in terms of its viability and likelihood of success? Is it really as simlpe as coopR makes out? I have grand visions of an ebay/amazon-type dominance (with good customer service) with all sorts of features inc. letting customers rate and compare restaurants / dishes, order from "a menu" rather than "a particular restaurant", etc.

The problem as I see it is that I can barely put together a simple html/css webpage. So I either learn as I go along and risk wasting time producing a naf site, or have to try and find a load of cash to get one made. So as far as I can see the barriers are relatively large...

bulb763

Original Poster:

870 posts

265 months

Wednesday 3rd June 2009
quotequote all
DonkeyKong said:
Were you watching "Dave" when you came up with this idea? It was pitched for on Dragons Den. Half the dragons dropped out saying it was too hard. From memory I think two teamed up- even if it was just one, they certainly got their investment.
I thought I'd seen all the DDs, but I can't remember this one.

V8mate

45,899 posts

220 months

Wednesday 3rd June 2009
quotequote all
bulb763 said:
The problem as I see it is that I can barely put together a simple html/css webpage. So I either learn as I go along and risk wasting time producing a naf site, or have to try and find a load of cash to get one made. So as far as I can see the barriers are relatively large...
Dosn't matter that you can't create the website yourself. That's why web designers exist. Running a business is a skill all of its own; don't necessarily try and be all the specialists too.