HSBC
Author
Discussion

Snapper7

Original Poster:

990 posts

290 months

Wednesday 3rd June 2009
quotequote all
I was in the HSBC (My Bank for Personal and Business) to ask for some advice

I was asking advice on a financial matter because I am looking to have a change of career. To make this change I was looking to research my options and needed to research my planned change of career and if it would be financially viable

I am looking to leave photography and have been considering running a B&B in an area different from where I live. I was looking for what was the best way to finance this move and asked to talk to the mortgage advisor.

I get ushered into a small office with the Mortgage advisor and explain that I would like to sell up and purchase a new property to run a B&B and would like to have some information on the financial costs involved on the new property.

The so called mortgage specialist then picks up the phone and rings their call centre in India, explains that I want to buy a property that will be residential, but I will be letting rooms out on a B&B basis.

The specialist in India can't get his head around the whole Bed & Breakfast aspect and insists that this comes under Buy To Let Mortgages.

I ask if there is a UK Mortgage centre to give this advise, the reply is no, it has all moved to India

Hmm I thought that the HSBC advertises Local Knowledge is important and yet they don’t understand the concept of B&B.

So the then local specialist decides that it is not a mortgage I need, it is commercial finance. I explain that the property is residential, I would be living there and it will be my home. Furthermore under local authority planning it will still be classed as a residential property.

The commercial department would only deal with purchases / businesses in the hotel field

I was asked what experience I had in running a hotel? I replied none and I don't have any intension of ever running a hotel.

But for running a B&B I have lots of years experience of running my own property, I can cook, I have run my own business for over 13 years, I am a photojournalist and understand marketing and publicity, I also have experience in web design. So I have a good chance of being able to market my B&B business successfully. So all in all I have a lot of experience in being able to make this a success as well as putting a good amount of money into the venture.

The answer came that they would not entertain assisting me until I have five years experience in running a hotel.

So with Gordon Brown screwing up the country and a call centre man in India stopping any UK small entrepreneur from running a business, it does not leave me with much hope for this country


ginettag27

7,160 posts

300 months

Thursday 4th June 2009
quotequote all
Just out of interest how old was this mortgage specialist? We had a similar experience (although totally different circumstances) with a chap who just didn't fully understand what he was doing. Luckily after the first meeting we got to see him with an experienced mortgage adviser, who knew the difference between the products.. Fair enough we've got a small endowment mortgage policy and they aren't in vogue, but they should at least know what they are!!

Marcellus

7,210 posts

250 months

Thursday 4th June 2009
quotequote all
I'm with HSBC too for mu business account and they are worse than useless... as for the advert about making life easier in other countries...... I can't move Euros from my Euro account unless I visit the branch in Camden Town...... I LIVE IN THE fkING FRENCH ALPS YOU tt!! how hard is it to grasp that.... after all they send my statements to me in France!!

Snapper7

Original Poster:

990 posts

290 months

Thursday 4th June 2009
quotequote all
The mortgage specialist was middleaged

eps

7,160 posts

300 months

Thursday 4th June 2009
quotequote all
We had some yoof... Unfortunately for him I've worked on mortgage systems...

Redarress

730 posts

238 months

Thursday 4th June 2009
quotequote all
HSBC are without doubt hopeless. We have ,as a company, banked with them since the companies inception in 1981. Our business manager, a former professional (very minor league) footballer in his mid 50's, does not have a clue about business. All he tries to do is sell non core products like life assurance or pensions . As to the mechanics of running a business my thirteen year old daughter has a better idea than him. I actually dispair when I have to deal with him. In the last three meetings he has repeatedly asked for our 2007!! company accounts only to be reminded by my company accounted that he has been sent two hard copies one in the post and one handed by my accountant to the business manager personally by hand in the branch and then after another request we have emailed copies twice to him . How bl**dy enept is that !! If we treated our customers with the contempt that he treats us we would be out of business. With the factories we own,the modern plant we own, vaue of stock and WIP of £300,000 and the value of our order book all valued at just under £2,000,000 all held as security for our poxy £230,000 overdraft I hardly think we could be described as high risk but at our last meeting a fornight ago where we requested a increase in our overdraft of a extra £50,000 he said we may have to consider a distressed sale. HE DOES NOT HAVE A CLUE !!

scotal

8,751 posts

310 months

Thursday 4th June 2009
quotequote all
Snapper
1. The big banks are out to put IFA's out of business at the moment. This unfortunately will mean that anyone looking to do anything remotely financial will have to speak to someone like you have outlined above. (I'm not supporting IFA'dom as a whiter than white profession it isn't, but there are people out there who know what they are talking about, and would be able to sourt that mortgage for you. Or tell you its not possible)
2. The banks advisor should have run through the scenario with you and then sent you away while he did some research on your mortgage options. It may be HSBC can't help, but 'phoning some random on a support desk in India isn't theway to do it.
3. If you spoke to a decent advisor this may well be what would happen.
4. Anyone who thinks that most people working in bank branches (and plenty of other mortgage people tbh) are nothing more than sales people targetted in exactly the same way as any other sales force, you're wrong.
5. Errr if you want me to look at your options (on the mortgage side) Drop me a PM.


Simpo Two

93,081 posts

296 months

Thursday 4th June 2009
quotequote all
Damn, Birmingham. I was going to offer you a percentage of any work your newly photographerless clients might send me.

Oh ys, and don't borrow if you can possibly help it, because you end up with someone else running your life, probably badly.

2 5HAN

702 posts

262 months

Thursday 4th June 2009
quotequote all
Snapper, I’ve personally never dealt with HSBC and have to admit that the way you have been dealt with sounds bizarre especially the so called Advisor you went to see.

However IMO especially in view of recent events of the last 12 months and the way that all financial institutions have reviewed credit policy your "potential mortgage" would IMO be a Commercial or Business loan.

From what you have said you want to change career and purchase a property and offer a B&B service albeit a small one by the sound of it?
You will i take it be registering as Self Employed and therefore in the eyes of the IR be a business therefore the any potential Lender will see it in the same way???

This doesn’t excuse the HSBC experience but I can’t see a residential lender giving you a mortgage or loan in anything other than a business sense? Therefore i think the advisor was correct to say you will need a Commercial Loan / Finance. As mentioned any financial institution will also want to know you have the experience to do this?

Scotal would you agree??


Edited by 2 5HAN on Thursday 4th June 23:39

Snapper7

Original Poster:

990 posts

290 months

Friday 5th June 2009
quotequote all
Where I would agree with you on the commercial lending points you raise, The HSBC wouldn't consider lending on that front as well.

With regards the the experience required: For running a B&B, I have lots of years experience of running my own property, I can cook, I have run my own business for over 13 years, I am a photojournalist and understand marketing and publicity, I also have experience in web design. So I have a good chance of being able to market my B&B business successfully. So all in all I have a lot of experience in being able to make this a success as well as putting a serious amount of money from my own pocket into the venture as well.

From the research that I have done so far, most B&B owners have converted their properties to do B&B when they purchased the property on a normal mortgage in the first place..

The thing I found most strange is that they would not give me any figures on finances so that I could go away and put together a profit forecast and a cashflow analysis to submit. from ether a mortgage or a commercial finance proposal.

I wouldn't of had a problem if I had walked into the bank and said give me some money for this. But when you ask for some advice on finances so that you can go through the process of researching and looking at the viability of my planned intensions, it is beyond me when they could not offer advice without committing themselves to anything.

JustinP1

13,364 posts

261 months

Friday 5th June 2009
quotequote all
Snapper7 said:
Where I would agree with you on the commercial lending points you raise, The HSBC wouldn't consider lending on that front as well.

With regards the the experience required: For running a B&B, I have lots of years experience of running my own property, I can cook, I have run my own business for over 13 years, I am a photojournalist and understand marketing and publicity, I also have experience in web design. So I have a good chance of being able to market my B&B business successfully. So all in all I have a lot of experience in being able to make this a success as well as putting a serious amount of money from my own pocket into the venture as well.

From the research that I have done so far, most B&B owners have converted their properties to do B&B when they purchased the property on a normal mortgage in the first place..

The thing I found most strange is that they would not give me any figures on finances so that I could go away and put together a profit forecast and a cashflow analysis to submit. from ether a mortgage or a commercial finance proposal.

I wouldn't of had a problem if I had walked into the bank and said give me some money for this. But when you ask for some advice on finances so that you can go through the process of researching and looking at the viability of my planned intensions, it is beyond me when they could not offer advice without committing themselves to anything.
The reason why this happened was the first one - the guy doesn't know what he is talking about.

It is bad enough when the 'international' call centre is taking the frontline queries, and they have to refer it back to the UK for advice, but understandable. However, when a UK specialist employee physically in a branch has to call India for advice there is something very, very wrong.

I left HSBC for two reasons:

The first was when my business 'manager' was so inept I had to explain why my turnover and profit figures were not identical - and explain the difference between the terms.

They had no experience whatsoever in running a business and has been promoted from the 'shopfloor', and all of their decisions were made by inputting figures. I may as well have written my business plan in Chinese.

The final straw was when I came into the branch to withdraw cash from my personal account. Not a huge amount, about £500, but more than a cashpoint would allow. Despite a good handful of the staff knowing my face from my business and personal accounts, I brought in my driving licence and passport in case they needed further ID than my account card and signature.

I got turned away, and was told I could not have my cash without writing a cheque. I explained my chequebook was 30 minutes away, and I was told, tough. Policy.

In speaking to one of the managers, who incidentally was on first name terms with me she knew me that well, she told me it was for security reasons, and through prying, security not that I would commit fraud but actually their own cashiers.

I explained again that whilst this is understood, I don't want to waste an hour of my time for internal issues, and asked if there was any exceptions. For example, what if my house had just burnt down!? Surely I must have access to MY money then without the ashes of a chequebook!?

Of course sir, we can make exceptions. However, wasting an hour of a customers time was obviously not an exception important enough, I said...

As a final gesture I said that if this is the case and no-one in the branch feels that I should not be wasting an hour of my business day then I would move my high six figure business else where... "That is your prerogative, sir.". Bye...

And I have never been in the branch again and my account was moved the same day.

scotal

8,751 posts

310 months

Friday 5th June 2009
quotequote all
2 5HAN said:
Snapper, I’ve personally never dealt with HSBC and have to admit that the way you have been dealt with sounds bizarre especially the so called Advisor you went to see.

However IMO especially in view of recent events of the last 12 months and the way that all financial institutions have reviewed credit policy your "potential mortgage" would IMO be a Commercial or Business loan.

From what you have said you want to change career and purchase a property and offer a B&B service albeit a small one by the sound of it?
You will i take it be registering as Self Employed and therefore in the eyes of the IR be a business therefore the any potential Lender will see it in the same way???

This doesn’t excuse the HSBC experience but I can’t see a residential lender giving you a mortgage or loan in anything other than a business sense? Therefore i think the advisor was correct to say you will need a Commercial Loan / Finance. As mentioned any financial institution will also want to know you have the experience to do this?

Scotal would you agree??


Edited by 2 5HAN on Thursday 4th June 23:39
Never having set up a mortgage for a B&B, I wouldn't know without doing some digging.