Copyright on Building Plans HELP
Discussion
Does anyone here know how this works?
Potentially buying a Plot that has full planning consent on it.
The owner however does not own the "Intellectual Property Rights" to the plans? i believe this is the term?
Long story but a developer approached owner made offer subject to planning etc, got the planning agreed and done but failed to purchase due to market?
I know that the planning permission belongs to the property but the problem is now that to proceed and get the building regs etc drawn up we will need to use of the plans?
I dont need the electronic CAD versions that the developer owns the rights to as any architect can re-draw and design the drawings and will need to do so anyway for the building regs etc.
My question really is can the developer sue / claim for use of his plans due to copyright if we proceed?
Oh and yes we have tried to offer to pay for the plans but the developer is being stubborn.
Potentially buying a Plot that has full planning consent on it.
The owner however does not own the "Intellectual Property Rights" to the plans? i believe this is the term?
Long story but a developer approached owner made offer subject to planning etc, got the planning agreed and done but failed to purchase due to market?
I know that the planning permission belongs to the property but the problem is now that to proceed and get the building regs etc drawn up we will need to use of the plans?
I dont need the electronic CAD versions that the developer owns the rights to as any architect can re-draw and design the drawings and will need to do so anyway for the building regs etc.
My question really is can the developer sue / claim for use of his plans due to copyright if we proceed?
Oh and yes we have tried to offer to pay for the plans but the developer is being stubborn.
Bottom line is that if you buy a piece of land with the benefit of detailed Planning Consent, you also need to make sure that the legal agreement to purchase includes the rights to the approved design.
So, yes, to answer your specific question, if you proceed and build according to the approved plans, the developer who submitted the application (and who holds the copyright) can, indeed, sue you.
If you can't come to an agreement with the owner of the copyright, you're going to have to submit a fresh Planning Application using a different design (and to answer the inevitable question of 'how different does the design have to be to avoid breach of copyright', that's one for the Lawyers to bicker over). One thing you can pretty much guarantee is that any design close enough to comply with the original Planning Approval will certainly also be close enough to breach the original copyright, hence you WILL need a fresh Planning Application.
The good news is that once the principle of development has been established by one Planning Approval, a revised application of a similar nature is usually pretty straightforward. This is not always the case, though. For example; I've known situations where a developer has wanted to redesign a site that already has detailed approval, only to be told that because the rules on development in areas of flood risk have changed since the original approval was granted, the new application would stand little chance of success.
So, yes, to answer your specific question, if you proceed and build according to the approved plans, the developer who submitted the application (and who holds the copyright) can, indeed, sue you.
If you can't come to an agreement with the owner of the copyright, you're going to have to submit a fresh Planning Application using a different design (and to answer the inevitable question of 'how different does the design have to be to avoid breach of copyright', that's one for the Lawyers to bicker over). One thing you can pretty much guarantee is that any design close enough to comply with the original Planning Approval will certainly also be close enough to breach the original copyright, hence you WILL need a fresh Planning Application.
The good news is that once the principle of development has been established by one Planning Approval, a revised application of a similar nature is usually pretty straightforward. This is not always the case, though. For example; I've known situations where a developer has wanted to redesign a site that already has detailed approval, only to be told that because the rules on development in areas of flood risk have changed since the original approval was granted, the new application would stand little chance of success.
why/how does the owner not own the rights to the drawings for the plot? If he's not paid for the plans then he is not entitled to use them, and if he has paid, then how come he doesn't own the right to use them? sounds fishy to me and be assured, Architects are getting much keener on copyright infringement!!!!
It should be a simple matter of contacting the originator of the plans....even if you have to pay to discharge the Copyright... probably best to talk to a (proper) Architect;)
It should be a simple matter of contacting the originator of the plans....even if you have to pay to discharge the Copyright... probably best to talk to a (proper) Architect;)
dunnred7 said:
why/how does the owner not own the rights to the drawings for the plot? ...sounds fishy to me
No, it seems fairly straightforward and not at all unusual to me. Like the man said:2 5HAN]...a developer approached [the said:
owner, made [an] offer subject to planning etc., got the planning agreed and done but failed to purchase due to market
It is perfectly legitimate and normal for a developer to submit a planning application on land that he is hoping to purchase but does not own, under cover of an 'option' agreement or a conditional offer. Normally, having obtained such permission, there's no way the developer would just walk away from the deal, but we're not in normal times in the housing market, and plenty of developers have found themselves in a situation where it was prudent to cut their losses and walk away from the deal.If the landowner had had a sharp solicitor, then he'd have ensured that the rights to the design on the Planning Permission fell back to him, if the developer backed out, but I've known plenty of deals where the landowner wasn't that sharp.
And if the developer was even slightly clued-up, the rights to the design will belong to him, not his Architect. In fact, most major housebuilders have a 'standard' house type range that all their Architects (and they would normally use several) use to compose a layout, potato-stamp style (with changes to elevational treatments to please the Planners, where necessary).
Sam_68 said:
wilftwo said:
It is extremely rare for developer to have IP rights exclusive to the architect who produced them.
No it isn't. Honestly.If the developer paid for any such design to be created they would have whatever rights over the drawings that they agreed with the architect. Which may include a "non-sell-on" clause, which naturally means not only does the owner of the property not have rights to use the copyrighted material (if my and others assumptions above are correct), but that the architect is not able to sell copies on. There is nothing unlawful about this.
Sam_68 said:
if you proceed and build according to the approved plans, the developer who submitted the application (and who holds the copyright) can, indeed, sue you.
If and only if you use the drawings without permission and infringed the copyright, and the rights owner becomes aware, and can prove this is the case, and is in a position to defend their rights. Which can't be guaranteed, this being a civil matter of course. There is only one copyright in an original work, an example of which is a drawing, you can't break a work down in to consituent parts and claim multiple copyrights- "well the roof design is copyrighted and that's infringed, and the guttering is also copyrighted and that's infringed, but the rest of the drawing isn't"- not true, the totality of the drawing alone will have one copyright, so unless the exact design was reproduced without permission there will not be any reasonable form of action from the right holder.Copyright protects the expression of an idea. It does not protect the idea itself, and does not protect against independent creation. As such, if the originator of the drawings is unable (by virtue of a contract with the developer including a no-sell-on clause) or unwilling (they are not obliged and you'd have to negotiate terms) to grant you a license to use these drawings, you would have to use another architect to design something similar. I would imagine the plot would have initial outline planning showing a general arrangement, and subject to any new design submitted fitting inside those general parameters, any new architect is extremely unlikely to be infringing the extant copyright in drawings already submitted, as they would have been exercising their own independent skill to develop an original work, which will therefore have its own copyright.
The developer is being rather petty about this, you would have thought they'd be grateful of any recompense for an outlay they are not currently able to recoup.
Personally I'd get a price from an architect to construct detailed plans from what's publically available (the planning permission), then offer the developer half that amount to be able to use their drawings. They either say yes or no.
Don't forget, if you used such drawings without permission, and later found fault with them which caused a problem, you'd have no cause of action against the originator as you had no right to use them in the first place. Not somewhere you really want to be on a cold, wet December night when the roof doesn't fit...
Hi Guys
Thanks for all your input.
To try and answer your questions:
Yes the owner was approached by a developer who gave them an Option, at the end of the option the developer did not exercise that option.
The land onwer's solicitor IMO was not the as sharp as he should have been and sadly the Intellectual Property Rights have remained with the Developer.
I completely agree that the developer paid for the plans.
I also am not worried about gaining consent again as the council has now set the precedent but i am trying to avoid the agro and time factor.
My architect feels there is not an issue as the plans are a public document and if i or anyone else wants to proceed any further we will need to get Building Regs Plans drawn up.
My confusion is around the fact that the planning belongs to the land and therefore anybody can now build that site.
I agree with the points raised in as far as no way can the developer fully own the IPR / Copyright to the plans as other wise everytime the architect used a similar detail in another design they would be risking copyright
The issue for me is:
If by looking at the publically available plans and drawing up our own plans and then drawing up the building regs plans will we breach copyright?
Will they be able to come back at us?
Thanks Guys
Thanks for all your input.
To try and answer your questions:
Yes the owner was approached by a developer who gave them an Option, at the end of the option the developer did not exercise that option.
The land onwer's solicitor IMO was not the as sharp as he should have been and sadly the Intellectual Property Rights have remained with the Developer.
I completely agree that the developer paid for the plans.
I also am not worried about gaining consent again as the council has now set the precedent but i am trying to avoid the agro and time factor.
My architect feels there is not an issue as the plans are a public document and if i or anyone else wants to proceed any further we will need to get Building Regs Plans drawn up.
My confusion is around the fact that the planning belongs to the land and therefore anybody can now build that site.
I agree with the points raised in as far as no way can the developer fully own the IPR / Copyright to the plans as other wise everytime the architect used a similar detail in another design they would be risking copyright
The issue for me is:
If by looking at the publically available plans and drawing up our own plans and then drawing up the building regs plans will we breach copyright?
Will they be able to come back at us?
Thanks Guys
Edited by 2 5HAN on Thursday 25th June 09:50
2 5HAN said:
Hi Guys
I wanted to know if by looking at the publically available plans and drawing up our own plans and then drawing up the building regs plans will we breach copyright? Will they be able to come back at us?
"It depends" is unfortunately the answer. But you can mitigate this.I wanted to know if by looking at the publically available plans and drawing up our own plans and then drawing up the building regs plans will we breach copyright? Will they be able to come back at us?
If all you do is 100% copy the current submitted detailed plans, subject to the caveats I stated above, the right owner can come after you. Whether they will or not, who knows. A strongly worded letter is often all they can afford, things get expensive after that. Given any compensation from a court is purely financial, it's pathetic for them to take this action if the only alternative is financial recompense. Which would not help any case.
If you've produced only a derivative of someone else's copyrighted work then their copyright persists. So the same is true as above.
If you produce something more to your own taste, with modifications in one or more areas (which I would have thought is most likely if you are to live there and/ or any good architect will have their own way or interpreting or designing things anyway) then your argument is always that you've used the Council documentation as your start point (ie the publically available general arrangement, not the specifics), so copyright will not have been infringed, what's been produced may still look like a 4-bed detached (or whatever), but is not sufficiently similar to have been a copy of the extant work. This won't necessarily stop someone having a paddy and sending you threatening letters, in copyright there is no offence of making "unjustified threats" (that there is with other intellectual property). Will they succeed? Will they really want the time/ cost/ aggro? I doubt it, as above the maximum compensation available to them might realistically be compensatory damages- the cost of having the drawings produced independently. Any further claim to special damages would be very difficult to argue, and by the time you've paid Counsel to achieve that you'd have spent much more than you might realistically get back, even if costs (typically only 60- 75% of that spent) are recovered.
Your architect should know what they can/ can't get away with, and should be able to advise on what they'd change in anything already publically available. Your convenancing solicitor should also be able to put your mind at rest with regard to what I'd perceive in this case to be minimal risk.
We are in the process of completing on a site which was in a similar position.
The vendor gave an option to someone who spent a lot of time and money (circa 25k) putting full planning on the land (previously greenbelt), however ultimately had to withdraw when the option ran out as simply was unable to obtain funding (as I suspect is a regular occurence at moment).
We then approached the vendor and agreed exclusivity ourselves, and have resubmitted planning as didn't particularly like his scheme anyway and for the costs involved would much prefer for it to be exactly how be wanted it. The only good thing that did come out of the existing planning was that our submission was done as a revision and as such did not incorporate the recently revised social housing implications which would have been put on the site should it been a brand new application (20% affordable).
The previous plans are copyright and you would need approval to use them, however on the basis you are buying the land and there is no way the deal is going to no go through then surely the other guy would sell you the rights to use them to recover some monies (see no reason why not). Same goes for topo's, ground investigation reports, etc, etc.
We had a previous site which we got diddled out of by an unscrupulous estate agent. We didn't have exclusivity (lesson learnt hard way) and had plans drawn up & submitted. We then spoke to said agent to value the site with a view to start marketing early. Said agent then told a close builder friend of his about the site & the next thing we knew he'd bought it !!! He hasn't applied for planning yet, or started building, however I keep checking site & planning with a view to going legal should he think of using our design.
The vendor gave an option to someone who spent a lot of time and money (circa 25k) putting full planning on the land (previously greenbelt), however ultimately had to withdraw when the option ran out as simply was unable to obtain funding (as I suspect is a regular occurence at moment).
We then approached the vendor and agreed exclusivity ourselves, and have resubmitted planning as didn't particularly like his scheme anyway and for the costs involved would much prefer for it to be exactly how be wanted it. The only good thing that did come out of the existing planning was that our submission was done as a revision and as such did not incorporate the recently revised social housing implications which would have been put on the site should it been a brand new application (20% affordable).
The previous plans are copyright and you would need approval to use them, however on the basis you are buying the land and there is no way the deal is going to no go through then surely the other guy would sell you the rights to use them to recover some monies (see no reason why not). Same goes for topo's, ground investigation reports, etc, etc.
We had a previous site which we got diddled out of by an unscrupulous estate agent. We didn't have exclusivity (lesson learnt hard way) and had plans drawn up & submitted. We then spoke to said agent to value the site with a view to start marketing early. Said agent then told a close builder friend of his about the site & the next thing we knew he'd bought it !!! He hasn't applied for planning yet, or started building, however I keep checking site & planning with a view to going legal should he think of using our design.
DonkeyKong said:
If and only if you use the drawings without permission and infringed the copyright, and the rights owner becomes aware, and can prove this is the case, and is in a position to defend their rights.
Very true. But, of course, the OP has given them a 'heads up' by (quite properly) approaching them offering to pay for the rights to use the design. If I were the owner of the intellectual rights and saw someone building my design without permission, I'd wait until the roof were on and they were ready to move in (ie. when they have financially exposed themselves to the maximum), then set the lawyers loose on them. That way, you can hold them to ransom for the largest amount possible.DonkeyKong said:
The developer is being rather petty about this, you would have thought they'd be grateful of any recompense for an outlay they are not currently able to recoup.
Agreed, but I've seen exactly this happen many times. I've lost count of the number of times we've tried negotiate for the rights to a survey, design or report to be assigned to us, only to have the consultant or developer demand the full cost price of the thing. Some people are just bloody-minded enough not so see that getting something for a bunch of work that's gone down the river is better than getting nothing at all. That's just human nature for you, I guess.2 5HAN said:
The issue for me is:
If by looking at the publically available plans and drawing up our own plans and then drawing up the building regs plans will we breach copyright?
Will they be able to come back at us?
The critical point here, as I tried to explain above, is that if you draw up plans that look close enough to the originals to actually comply with the Planning Consent then you can pretty much guarantee that you will have automatically breached the copyright. If by looking at the publically available plans and drawing up our own plans and then drawing up the building regs plans will we breach copyright?
Will they be able to come back at us?
And if you try to implement them under the original Planning Approval, then you don't have a hope in hell of persuading a court that you just happened to independently come up with a visually similar design.
Some Local Authorities still allow what is known as a 'Minor Amendment', whereby the applicant can make minor changes to an approved design without going through the full approvals process again, but even this wouldn't help you, because only the applicant can seek such a minor amendment. (Some Authorities no longer allow Minor Amendements for other, unrelated legal reasons, anyway, but that's another issue altogether).
2 5HAN said:
...you would have to use another architect to design something similar. I would imagine the plot would have initial outline planning showing a general arrangement, and subject to any new design submitted fitting inside those general parameters
...Which obviously raises the issue that any indicative layout attached to the Outline consent also has IP rights associated with it, but that's a whole different bag of badgers. I agree that it's not likely to cause problems in practice, though, if only because by the time it gets tothe outline aopplication stage, it's pretty muddy as to whose ideas are the Architects and whose are the Local Planning Authority's!The bottom line is pretty clear, though, I'm afraid. Unless you're willing to take the monumental risk that the owner of the design rights won't sue you for stealing his design if you copy the approved plans you have only two options:
- Negotiate a payment to acquire the design rights that he is willing to accept, or;
- Come up with your own design, usinge the principles and constraints established by the previous approval, and submit a fresh Planning Application.
Edited by Sam_68 on Thursday 25th June 18:04
some developers are right c**ts
its exactly like the developer who bought our neighbours house depending on planning being approved. Just because we did not choose him to also build our house...he tried his best to make our planning applications fail and our house not go ahead. MADE ME ABSOLUTELY FURIOUS BEYOND BELIEF and still does.
This country needs a good shake up with planning...its all corrupt. The innocent people get shafted
its exactly like the developer who bought our neighbours house depending on planning being approved. Just because we did not choose him to also build our house...he tried his best to make our planning applications fail and our house not go ahead. MADE ME ABSOLUTELY FURIOUS BEYOND BELIEF and still does.
This country needs a good shake up with planning...its all corrupt. The innocent people get shafted
2 5HAN said:
Does anyone here know how this works?
Potentially buying a Plot that has full planning consent on it.
The owner however does not own the "Intellectual Property Rights" to the plans? i believe this is the term?
You're not buying a plot that has full planning consent on it, you're effectively buying a plot which has had full planning consent on it.. The seller should be selling it as such, or include the planning consent with it. There is a big difference - if you're prepared to sit it out, you should be able to either get it reduced in price, or with the planning consent. No one else will be interested in the plot, it's too much trouble.Potentially buying a Plot that has full planning consent on it.
The owner however does not own the "Intellectual Property Rights" to the plans? i believe this is the term?
Does it have a property already on it or is it just a plot of land?
YHM
There seem to be a few misconceptions flying around here. Firstly that the Consent 'belongs' to the land. It doesn't. It was granted to a specific person, subject to conditions which are enforceable on that person, one of which is that works are commenced within a specific time. Secondly, that copyright in the design belongs to the developer. Again it doesn't. In the absence of specific legal agreement to the contrary, it belongs to the Architect.
Whether the Local Authority would object if someone came along and built the approved scheme and complied with all the conditions is another matter, and one which would probably be sorted out at a practical level.
The developer has an implied licence to carry out the design on that specific site, even if this is not spelt out in a contract. He does not have a licence to execute the design elsewhere or repeatedly, unless again this was a specific element of the deal with the Architect. And he certainly cannot object if the architect produces a similar design for another site.
What you have got here is a site where consent has been granted for residential development, which is a lot better than one which is zoned as agricultural, green belt or industrial. That is what the Developer has achieved for the land owner.
You should forget about just carrying out the approved scheme. As Sam says, your options are:-
1. To purchase the right to carry out the design. Just watch out who you purchase it from, and bear in mind that the right to carry out the design is not an assignment of the Planning Consent.
2. To get your own Architect to prepare and submit a new scheme, which clearly has a cost implication. Whether the LA would accept it as an 'amendment' you might wish to discuss with them, but I would have thought that for the future value of your asset you would want a consent in your name as the owner and actual developer.
As to what is 'sufficiently different', you can be sure, as Sam again says, that if it is sufficiently similar to comply with a detailed Planning Consent it will be sufficiently similar to be a breach of copyright. If I was an Architect and saw someone who had not paid me carrying out my design I would without question sue for breach of copyright, probably in the manner which he outlined.
Whether the Local Authority would object if someone came along and built the approved scheme and complied with all the conditions is another matter, and one which would probably be sorted out at a practical level.
The developer has an implied licence to carry out the design on that specific site, even if this is not spelt out in a contract. He does not have a licence to execute the design elsewhere or repeatedly, unless again this was a specific element of the deal with the Architect. And he certainly cannot object if the architect produces a similar design for another site.
What you have got here is a site where consent has been granted for residential development, which is a lot better than one which is zoned as agricultural, green belt or industrial. That is what the Developer has achieved for the land owner.
You should forget about just carrying out the approved scheme. As Sam says, your options are:-
1. To purchase the right to carry out the design. Just watch out who you purchase it from, and bear in mind that the right to carry out the design is not an assignment of the Planning Consent.
2. To get your own Architect to prepare and submit a new scheme, which clearly has a cost implication. Whether the LA would accept it as an 'amendment' you might wish to discuss with them, but I would have thought that for the future value of your asset you would want a consent in your name as the owner and actual developer.
As to what is 'sufficiently different', you can be sure, as Sam again says, that if it is sufficiently similar to comply with a detailed Planning Consent it will be sufficiently similar to be a breach of copyright. If I was an Architect and saw someone who had not paid me carrying out my design I would without question sue for breach of copyright, probably in the manner which he outlined.
0to60 said:
some developers are right c**ts
its exactly like the developer who bought our neighbours house depending on planning being approved. Just because we did not choose him to also build our house...he tried his best to make our planning applications fail and our house not go ahead. MADE ME ABSOLUTELY FURIOUS BEYOND BELIEF and still does.
This country needs a good shake up with planning...its all corrupt. The innocent people get shafted
No doubt, but then most of the pressure to 'change the planning system' is coming from big residential and retail developers who want carte blanche to rape the countryside, and they will shaft the innocent even faster and more thoroughly than the Planners, who are just doing their incompetent best. So be careful what you wish for.its exactly like the developer who bought our neighbours house depending on planning being approved. Just because we did not choose him to also build our house...he tried his best to make our planning applications fail and our house not go ahead. MADE ME ABSOLUTELY FURIOUS BEYOND BELIEF and still does.
This country needs a good shake up with planning...its all corrupt. The innocent people get shafted
cardigankid said:
{There is a misconception that}…the Consent 'belongs' to the land. It doesn't. It was granted to a specific person, subject to conditions which are enforceable on that person, one of which is that works are commenced within a specific time.
Not true. So far as the Local Planning Authority is concerned, a consent is simply a consent. They don’t care about copyright, and they don’t care who undertakes the development, provided it is in accordance with the approved details and conditions.The consent is implementable by anyone with an interest in the land and enforcement action for breach of the consent can be taken against anyone with an interest in the land (though obviously an Authority will try to ensure that any action is taken against the person actually responsible for the breach.
If you look at an actual Planning Approval Notice it will simply say ‘XXX Council hereby permits the development described…’. It will never say ‘XXX Council hereby permits the applicant to undertake the development described’.
If you want to split hairs on legal definitions, the Consent belongs to the Development, but...
{Anorak mode ON}

The Planning Act 2008 said:
…If an order granting development consent is made in respect of any land, the order has effect for the benefit of the land and all persons for the time being interested in the land
{Anorak mode OFF} Where it can get more complicated is where secondary legal agreements exist (eg., most commonly, a ‘Section 106’ agreement). To be valid, such agreements must be binding upon all parties with an interest in the land and will always include clauses to define how the obligations are transferred should the site pass into different ownership.
cardigankid said:
Secondly, that copyright in the design belongs to the developer. Again it doesn't. In the absence of specific legal agreement to the contrary, it belongs to the Architect.
This is true in theory (and, as you say, in the absence of any other contractual agreement between the developer and the Architect), but in practice almost without exception any competent developer will ensure that he has rights to the design.As I stated earlier, most housing developers use 'standard' house types, so they will be careful to ensure that they have exclusively rights to use any designs repeatedly. I've worked in housing design for over 20 years, on both sides of the fence (private practice Architect and Developer) and this is almost always the case. As a developer, you don’t want to be in the situation of looking at a bit of land and thinking ‘that block of flats we used on the Acacia Road site would fit just right on this one’, only to find that the Architect you used won’t give you permission because you’re disputing their last invoice…
Indeed, as I also stated earlier, most well set-up developers have their own standard house type range that all their Architects are told to use - designing new houses on a site-by-site basis is not a cost-effective method of doing business – so there is a fair chance that the Architect didn’t even design the house types used on a particular development.
Most Appointment Documents that I have seen restrict the use of the design information to the specific development, though if this is a housebuilder looking at large number of units using standard plans that would no doubt be a different matter.
I do think all the same 5 Han should exercise caution in assuming that the former Developer is in a position to sell him the copyright.
I do think all the same 5 Han should exercise caution in assuming that the former Developer is in a position to sell him the copyright.
cardigankid said:
0to60 said:
some developers are right c**ts
its exactly like the developer who bought our neighbours house depending on planning being approved. Just because we did not choose him to also build our house...he tried his best to make our planning applications fail and our house not go ahead. MADE ME ABSOLUTELY FURIOUS BEYOND BELIEF and still does.
This country needs a good shake up with planning...its all corrupt. The innocent people get shafted
No doubt, but then most of the pressure to 'change the planning system' is coming from big residential and retail developers who want carte blanche to rape the countryside, and they will shaft the innocent even faster and more thoroughly than the Planners, who are just doing their incompetent best. So be careful what you wish for.its exactly like the developer who bought our neighbours house depending on planning being approved. Just because we did not choose him to also build our house...he tried his best to make our planning applications fail and our house not go ahead. MADE ME ABSOLUTELY FURIOUS BEYOND BELIEF and still does.
This country needs a good shake up with planning...its all corrupt. The innocent people get shafted
dunnred7 said:
If he's not paid for the plans then he is not entitled to use them, and if he has paid, then how come he doesn't own the right to use them? sounds fishy to me and be assured, Architects are getting much keener on copyright infringement!!!!
He may have licence to use them himself, but copying them and giving them to all and sundry is a different matter. Many people seem to assume that paying money gives copyright in return. It doesn't.Gassing Station | Business | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


