Breaking a business contract with Orange early
Breaking a business contract with Orange early
Author
Discussion

flyingjase

Original Poster:

3,095 posts

262 months

Thursday 25th June 2009
quotequote all
I made a big mistake in signing a 2 year business deal with Orange of which we are 3 months in. I stupidly believed the sales bloke’s spin that Orange had as good coverage as Vodafone. The Orange service is terrible, it constantly cuts off when you are travelling. In a 10 minutes conversation today I had to call back 4 times and that was travelling down the M4, hardly the middle of nowhere. It’s very frustrating to say the least.

The problem is Orange want £21k to terminate the contract which is ridiculous (we pay £2k per month inc data / international calls etc). I’ve approached Vodafone who will contribute £11k as a sign on bonus if we sign up to a 2 year deal with them. This would be £1200 per month for shared minutes, obviously with international calls on top.

£10k is still too much for me to pay for a silly mistake of mine, so does anyone have any inside information or any idea of a strategy as to how I can narrow the gap between the termination fee and the sign on bonus? eg a clause in the Orange contract I can use to reduce the fee or any other way of getting more money out of Vodafone?

FYI, we have 20 blackberry handsets soon to be 22.

Any help gratefully received

Jason

touching cloth

11,706 posts

270 months

Thursday 25th June 2009
quotequote all
Are you sure it's the network itself and not phone related. I am on Orange and live in the M4 corridor and have to say I have no problems with coverage pretty much wherever I am in this area. Worth ruling out before taking a hit.

flyingjase

Original Poster:

3,095 posts

262 months

Thursday 25th June 2009
quotequote all
touching cloth said:
Are you sure it's the network itself and not phone related. I am on Orange and live in the M4 corridor and have to say I have no problems with coverage pretty much wherever I am in this area. Worth ruling out before taking a hit.
Every handset in the business has the same problem.

That said, we're all operating Blackberry Javelin's so I suppose in theory it could be a handset issue.

I have a very irate workforce at the moment!

miniman

30,231 posts

293 months

Thursday 25th June 2009
quotequote all
We have exactly the same issue with Orange - terrible coverage, with BB Pearls and other phone-only handsets. The M4 corridor is a bloody nightmare frankly. If you find a way out I would love to hear it.

JustinP1

13,364 posts

261 months

Thursday 25th June 2009
quotequote all
flyingjase said:
I made a big mistake in signing a 2 year business deal with Orange of which we are 3 months in. I stupidly believed the sales bloke’s spin that Orange had as good coverage as Vodafone. The Orange service is terrible, it constantly cuts off when you are travelling. In a 10 minutes conversation today I had to call back 4 times and that was travelling down the M4, hardly the middle of nowhere. It’s very frustrating to say the least.

The problem is Orange want £21k to terminate the contract which is ridiculous (we pay £2k per month inc data / international calls etc). I’ve approached Vodafone who will contribute £11k as a sign on bonus if we sign up to a 2 year deal with them. This would be £1200 per month for shared minutes, obviously with international calls on top.

£10k is still too much for me to pay for a silly mistake of mine, so does anyone have any inside information or any idea of a strategy as to how I can narrow the gap between the termination fee and the sign on bonus? eg a clause in the Orange contract I can use to reduce the fee or any other way of getting more money out of Vodafone?

FYI, we have 20 blackberry handsets soon to be 22.

Any help gratefully received

Jason
If you were told that the coverage was as good an Vodaphone, then you have not made a mistake - you have been misrepresented.

I would speak to someone high up in Orange telling them about the situation, and that you are looking to cancel on this basis and want to do it in a 'nice way'.

At the end of the day, should you just refuse to fulfil the contract there is nothing that Orange can do, apart from take you to court. If you have already made it clear to them that you have been misrepresented and would therefore be willing to fight any claim, they would then be happy to negotiate.

If you called their bluff, and at the end of a protracted dispute where they will get nothing unless they sue you, if you offered £11k after this, they would snap your hand off.

Neil135

197 posts

249 months

Thursday 25th June 2009
quotequote all
I've never lived it down changing all of our phones to orange. I was told by orange sales that they were going to share transmitters with vodafone which was a lie. We have 5 months left can't wait to change. Has anyone used o2 cause all my lot want iphones next

touching cloth

11,706 posts

270 months

Thursday 25th June 2009
quotequote all
Blimey seems we are quite lucky with Orange, my users (albeit a fairly low number of just 7) are scattered around the M4-M3 area with a bias towards Heathrow during the day, but we are I guess fairly static after that which may help. We must just be lucky with the areas we operate, in that we have adequate pockets of coverage, certainly seems I am in the minority hehe

Have to say I pretty much agree with the above that if you are brave enough to walk away and let them fight you for it, then offer them the £11k (that Vodaphone are stumping up anyway) before it gets to court, then I reckon they would be pretty foolish to fight you for more.
But it's not without risk and potential grief.

dunning

169 posts

217 months

Thursday 25th June 2009
quotequote all
our company phones changed from vodaphone to 02 Recently.
gotta say the 02 one hasnt really let us down yet.
that's in a delivery wagon travelling all around the uk, in and around all the little villages people usually have trouble getting a signal in.

JustinP1

13,364 posts

261 months

Thursday 25th June 2009
quotequote all
touching cloth said:
Blimey seems we are quite lucky with Orange, my users (albeit a fairly low number of just 7) are scattered around the M4-M3 area with a bias towards Heathrow during the day, but we are I guess fairly static after that which may help. We must just be lucky with the areas we operate, in that we have adequate pockets of coverage, certainly seems I am in the minority hehe

Have to say I pretty much agree with the above that if you are brave enough to walk away and let them fight you for it, then offer them the £11k (that Vodaphone are stumping up anyway) before it gets to court, then I reckon they would be pretty foolish to fight you for more.
But it's not without risk and potential grief.
This is the thing.

If Vodaphone are offering £11k, then the most the OP can be out of pocket even *if* he is sued and even *if* Orange do not back down and accept a settlement is £10k.

OP, will the problems with Orange cost you more of £10k or profit over the next 21 months? If so, then it is a no brainer.

2 5HAN

702 posts

262 months

Thursday 25th June 2009
quotequote all
We had a similar problem with T-Mobile a few years back, got sold on a promise of cheaper Calls etc etc reception was so poor we never managed to even use half of our minutes.

Ended up calling the regional sales manager and telling him i would stop the DD payemnts as in my opinion they were failing to provide me with the service i was paying for and therefore their product was not fit for the purpose not to mention i had been mis-sold the product.

We got out and went to Vodafone and since then have been great.

As an idea surely if you have only been with Orange for 3 months then the handsets are in good condition??

Can you not sell them on as i take it Vodafone are providing you with new ones?? Or if you are happy with the phones then can you get them unlocked and ask Vodafone for a better offer if you take no new hardware?

If they arent giving you new hardware then the 11K from Vodafone is a very poor incentive for 2k a month for 24 months.

Good luck


pjac67

2,040 posts

283 months

Thursday 25th June 2009
quotequote all
I got out of an Orange contract last year as I live c.200m from an Orange mast and am too close to get any reception at all - I believe this is the problem when travelling ie if you drive close to a mast it will drop the signal (I know this can apply to O2 on the A303 as well....) - was a battle and my contract was tiny in comparison.

jamiebae

6,245 posts

242 months

Thursday 25th June 2009
quotequote all
Can you prove that you were told Orange coverage was 'as good' as Vodafone? If so you do have a case, because it's not, but you'll have a hard time getting them to cancel the deal and it'll take a lot of aggro. However, as others have said, it is misrepresentation so you *should* be able to wriggle out of the deal.

flyingjase

Original Poster:

3,095 posts

262 months

Thursday 25th June 2009
quotequote all
Neil135 said:
I've never lived it down changing all of our phones to orange. I was told by orange sales that they were going to share transmitters with vodafone which was a lie. We have 5 months left can't wait to change. Has anyone used o2 cause all my lot want iphones next
Spot on the Money - this is exactly what I was told which was a load of bull as we has no problems with Vodafone

flyingjase

Original Poster:

3,095 posts

262 months

Thursday 25th June 2009
quotequote all
JustinP1 said:
flyingjase said:
I made a big mistake in signing a 2 year business deal with Orange of which we are 3 months in. I stupidly believed the sales bloke’s spin that Orange had as good coverage as Vodafone. The Orange service is terrible, it constantly cuts off when you are travelling. In a 10 minutes conversation today I had to call back 4 times and that was travelling down the M4, hardly the middle of nowhere. It’s very frustrating to say the least.

The problem is Orange want £21k to terminate the contract which is ridiculous (we pay £2k per month inc data / international calls etc). I’ve approached Vodafone who will contribute £11k as a sign on bonus if we sign up to a 2 year deal with them. This would be £1200 per month for shared minutes, obviously with international calls on top.

£10k is still too much for me to pay for a silly mistake of mine, so does anyone have any inside information or any idea of a strategy as to how I can narrow the gap between the termination fee and the sign on bonus? eg a clause in the Orange contract I can use to reduce the fee or any other way of getting more money out of Vodafone?

FYI, we have 20 blackberry handsets soon to be 22.

Any help gratefully received

Jason
If you were told that the coverage was as good an Vodaphone, then you have not made a mistake - you have been misrepresented.

I would speak to someone high up in Orange telling them about the situation, and that you are looking to cancel on this basis and want to do it in a 'nice way'.

At the end of the day, should you just refuse to fulfil the contract there is nothing that Orange can do, apart from take you to court. If you have already made it clear to them that you have been misrepresented and would therefore be willing to fight any claim, they would then be happy to negotiate.

If you called their bluff, and at the end of a protracted dispute where they will get nothing unless they sue you, if you offered £11k after this, they would snap your hand off.
I will speak to someone senior at Orange but I can't afford to call their bluff. I need the phones for business so can't risk them being cut off, also I need the numbers ported back to Vodafone which would no doubt be difficult or impossible if I didn't fulfil the contract.