Anyone know about reclaiming VAT on demos
Discussion
Apparently it may be possible to reclaim overpaid VAT on:
The sale of demonstrator vehicles, daily rental vehicles and courtesy cars (under the second hand margin scheme).
and also:
The bonuses received from the manufacturer in respect of demonstrator vehicles, daily rental vehicles and courtesy cars.
There was a deadline of 31st March 2009, but I think it has now been extended.
All info gratefully received.
The sale of demonstrator vehicles, daily rental vehicles and courtesy cars (under the second hand margin scheme).
and also:
The bonuses received from the manufacturer in respect of demonstrator vehicles, daily rental vehicles and courtesy cars.
There was a deadline of 31st March 2009, but I think it has now been extended.
All info gratefully received.
It relates to the motorcycle trade, one of the dealers known to us is no longer in the trade and has just had a rebate upwards of 100k, I can't seem to find any info on the net on how a rebate is worked out.
I've only been working there a year, so don't know how the margin scheme USED to deal with VAT on demos, then I'll have a rough idea on where to start.
I've only been working there a year, so don't know how the margin scheme USED to deal with VAT on demos, then I'll have a rough idea on where to start.

Tuscanless Ali said:
It wasn't due to selling up.
The reclaim period is for any demo's that were registered between 1973 and 1996, from what I can gather the way VAT was calculated in this period was done wrong hence a few people now getting massive payouts.
Any evidence of these massive payouts? HMRC normally don't repay excessive VAT received by them in error due to the "unjust enrichment" rules.The reclaim period is for any demo's that were registered between 1973 and 1996, from what I can gather the way VAT was calculated in this period was done wrong hence a few people now getting massive payouts.
Hi Eric,
http://www.vatdemoclaims.co.uk/
Have had a similar letter to the above at work, and know about the dealer that got +100k, just wanted to get my head around it.
I am guessing that prior to 1996 VAT was payable as soon as you bought a demo, rather than when it was sold.
Found it:
VAT was introduced in 1973.
Motor dealers could not recover VAT on the purchase of demonstrator cars until 2000.
Despite this HMRC insisted that motor dealers pay VAT on the profit margin in selling demonstrator units and also on any manufacturer's bonuses received, discounts obtained etc.
This treatment was successfully challenged in late 1996/97 although most dealers did not hear about it until 1999/2000 when HMRC agreed that demonstrators should be treated the same as trading stock with, for the first time, VAT claimed on purchase and VAT due on sale.
In separate action HMRC introduced a 3 year cap in 1996/97 limiting any claims for overpaid VAT to 3 calendar years with some dealers submitting claims in 1999 going back to 1996.
This capping was challenged and eventually overturned in July 2002 following a European case involving Marks & Spencer and the VAT liability of teacakes.
HMRC invited claims from taxpayers penalised in 1996 to submit claims by 30 June 2003 and rejected claims made after this date.
HMRC applied various restrictions to the 2003 claims resulting in many being rejected or processed for a lower amount. HMRC's approach put some dealers off pursuing a claim.
These restrictions were themselves challenged and in January 2008 the House of Lords upheld the affected taxpayer's rights to receive a refund of overpaid VAT and HMRC invited any new or outstanding claims to be made by 31 March 2009.
No extensions are expected to this deadline. (I have been told this has been extended)
http://www.vatdemoclaims.co.uk/
Have had a similar letter to the above at work, and know about the dealer that got +100k, just wanted to get my head around it.
I am guessing that prior to 1996 VAT was payable as soon as you bought a demo, rather than when it was sold.
Found it:
VAT was introduced in 1973.
Motor dealers could not recover VAT on the purchase of demonstrator cars until 2000.
Despite this HMRC insisted that motor dealers pay VAT on the profit margin in selling demonstrator units and also on any manufacturer's bonuses received, discounts obtained etc.
This treatment was successfully challenged in late 1996/97 although most dealers did not hear about it until 1999/2000 when HMRC agreed that demonstrators should be treated the same as trading stock with, for the first time, VAT claimed on purchase and VAT due on sale.
In separate action HMRC introduced a 3 year cap in 1996/97 limiting any claims for overpaid VAT to 3 calendar years with some dealers submitting claims in 1999 going back to 1996.
This capping was challenged and eventually overturned in July 2002 following a European case involving Marks & Spencer and the VAT liability of teacakes.
HMRC invited claims from taxpayers penalised in 1996 to submit claims by 30 June 2003 and rejected claims made after this date.
HMRC applied various restrictions to the 2003 claims resulting in many being rejected or processed for a lower amount. HMRC's approach put some dealers off pursuing a claim.
These restrictions were themselves challenged and in January 2008 the House of Lords upheld the affected taxpayer's rights to receive a refund of overpaid VAT and HMRC invited any new or outstanding claims to be made by 31 March 2009.
No extensions are expected to this deadline. (I have been told this has been extended)
Edited by Tuscanless Ali on Sunday 28th June 23:48
Eric Mc said:
Any evidence of these massive payouts? HMRC normally don't repay excessive VAT received by them in error due to the "unjust enrichment" rules.
'Unjust enrichment'! (although of course HMRC got unjustly rich from the error)I wish it worked both ways - I could rob a bank and then claim immunity from jail and tax on grounds of 'unjust enrichment'...
Found out today that the dealer known to us was a car dealer and not a motor cycle dealer as I thought, just need to find out if the rebates also relate to motorcycles.
Boss is going to bring in his old records (He has the last 50 years worth
) to see how the VAT was worked out back in the day.
Boss is going to bring in his old records (He has the last 50 years worth
) to see how the VAT was worked out back in the day.Gassing Station | Business | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


