Solicitors / contract law.
Solicitors / contract law.
Author
Discussion

jamesuk28

Original Poster:

2,176 posts

284 months

Monday 29th June 2009
quotequote all
I Have a client who invested a large sum of money into a company about 3 years ago. The investment was secured by way of a charge over some land. A contract was drawn up by a Solicitor between the client and the company regarding the investment. Crucially, me thinks, no clause was inserted by the Solicitor regarding a repayment time frame. My client now wants his money back, the company say he can not have it, nor can he enforce it due to stipulation being made in the contract regarding a time to repay.

So is this correct, as there is no clause regarding the timeframe my client is going to have a pretty tough job getting paid out?. I have already suggested that the original Solicitor who drew up the original contract may now face a claim on his PI

RichBurley

2,432 posts

284 months

Monday 29th June 2009
quotequote all
jamesuk28 said:
I Have a client who invested a large sum of money into a company about 3 years ago. The investment was secured by way of a charge over some land. A contract was drawn up by a Solicitor between the client and the company regarding the investment. Crucially, me thinks, no clause was inserted by the Solicitor regarding a repayment time frame. My client now wants his money back, the company say he can not have it, nor can he enforce it due to stipulation being made in the contract regarding a time to repay.

So is this correct, as there is no clause regarding the timeframe my client is going to have a pretty tough job getting paid out?. I have already suggested that the original Solicitor who drew up the original contract may now face a claim on his PI
This is one that I need to talk about with you. I deal with Prof Neg claims, and a good friend of mine is a Company Commercial Solicitor, who can advise as to what standards would have been expected of the solicitor at the time the agreement was reached. Can you PM me your contact number so I can call you in the morning?

Regards,

Richard

Lurking Lawyer

4,535 posts

256 months

Monday 29th June 2009
quotequote all
Without knowing more about the background and what was discussed between the parties, it's difficult to be conclusive but I think the starting point has to be that, in the absence of an express term as to repayment, a court is unlikely to imply one into an arm's length commercial agreement reached between two commercial parties.

The difficulty is that a charge over property isn't a huge amount of use unless there's a power to take possession and/or obtain an order for sale. I'm sure in your line of business you'll know all about the limitations of charging orders..... It may be worth looking at the wording of the charge to see whether it makes any provision at all as to if/when it can be exercised.

On the face of it, I tend to agree that a prof neg claim against the solicitor who drafted the charge and advised on the transaction (if indeed s/he did advise on it, rather than just deal on what amounts to an "execution only" basis, and do what the client told them to do in securing the charge) but their insurers will doubtless want to see evidence that the client has taken all possible steps to mitigate their loss first.

Jasandjules

72,686 posts

260 months

Tuesday 30th June 2009
quotequote all
jamesuk28 said:
I Have a client who invested a large sum of money into a company about 3 years ago. The investment was secured by way of a charge over some land. A contract was drawn up by a Solicitor between the client and the company regarding the investment. Crucially, me thinks, no clause was inserted by the Solicitor regarding a repayment time frame. My client now wants his money back, the company say he can not have it, nor can he enforce it due to stipulation being made in the contract regarding a time to repay.

So is this correct, as there is no clause regarding the timeframe my client is going to have a pretty tough job getting paid out?. I have already suggested that the original Solicitor who drew up the original contract may now face a claim on his PI
Was there no breach clause as well? I.e. in the event of a default the full amount becomes due? No repayment criteria at all? Has your client got copies of all inter-parties correspondence in case there is something in there? Has your client spoken to the drafting solicitor at all and asked him if there was any such clause?

Oh, was the charge actually registered as well? Did the land already have a mortgage?


Edited by Jasandjules on Tuesday 30th June 08:38

jamesuk28

Original Poster:

2,176 posts

284 months

Tuesday 30th June 2009
quotequote all
Guys, Thanks for your help and advice on this. I will revert back to my client and be in touch.

The Contrarian

13,751 posts

281 months

Tuesday 30th June 2009
quotequote all
jamesuk28 said:
I Have a client who invested a large sum of money into a company about 3 years ago. The investment was secured by way of a charge over some land. A contract was drawn up by a Solicitor between the client and the company regarding the investment. Crucially, me thinks, no clause was inserted by the Solicitor regarding a repayment time frame. My client now wants his money back, the company say he can not have it, nor can he enforce it due to stipulation being made in the contract regarding a time to repay.

So is this correct, as there is no clause regarding the timeframe my client is going to have a pretty tough job getting paid out?. I have already suggested that the original Solicitor who drew up the original contract may now face a claim on his PI
Invested as a shareholder?
Must be a shareholder agreement, no?

As a shareholder, he would need to sell his shareholding bak to the other shareholders or the company.

Or has he just lent the company the 'investment' funds, as in a loan. If there is security, sounds like a loa. If so, loan agreement should have detailed repayment clauses.

therealpigdog

2,592 posts

228 months

Tuesday 30th June 2009
quotequote all

On the basis that it was a loan:

In the absence of a stipulated time-frame for repayment the court will also look at what is a reasonable time frame - depending on the amount of money involved I have seen cases where 3 months from a repayment demand was seen as being reasonable (have seen shorter and longer, but to my mind this seems like a fair amount of time).

Serve a formal demand for repayment and then head of down to court if they don't pay.

On the basis that it was an equity investment:

Your client could be in trouble if nothing in a shareholders' agreement or articles. Can always apply to the court to wind up the company and distribute assets - normally elicits an offer to buy the shares.