Question regarding dismissals/leaving a job.
Question regarding dismissals/leaving a job.
Author
Discussion

fastcaterham

Original Poster:

420 posts

225 months

Thursday 2nd July 2009
quotequote all
Having recently left uni I have taken up a short term placement with a local company.
All the staff in the office are on a 3 month probation I believe. A few weeks ago a memeber of staff who had been there around 2 months handed her notice in within the contractual period as she was due to start another new job. At the end of that week she was called to the MD's office and dissmissed along the grounds of failing to meet targets. Now I had only been there a week but from what I saw and from what others have said her results were not radically different from other members of staff. Now this occured towards the end of last month. She has not been paid her last months pay now for over a month and has consulted a solicitor. Now I understand that under probation an employee has very little rights but I was under the impression that a weeks written notice had to be given along with corresponding pay. Can anyone confirm whether or not this is correct as although I have searched the internet I have found lots of slightly conflicting information.
The reason I would also like to know is that the MD is becoming very target orientated all of a sudden in response to the business struggling slightly and although ~60% of the staff are not meeting his what many consider unrealistic expectations questions are starting to be asked of myself and others. I would be grateful is sombody could clarify where myself and others would stand legally as I get the impression that the MD is hiring lots of people like myself who are desperate for work and cheap, not training them properlly then using them for a few weeks and sacking those that take a while to meet his expectations and getting away with not fully paying them fully knowing full well that the majority will be unable to seek professional legal advice etc. On the other hand maybe its just me being cynical!

Scraggles

7,619 posts

255 months

Thursday 2nd July 2009
quotequote all
time to get CV sorted out

fastcaterham

Original Poster:

420 posts

225 months

Thursday 2nd July 2009
quotequote all
Oh Thanks! I'm actually half way through the placement in question but its made more complicated on my part due to the fact my job there is actually subsidised by a 3rd party.

Tuscanless Ali

2,187 posts

240 months

Thursday 2nd July 2009
quotequote all
I'm sure you still have to give an employee notice, either contractual or statutory whichever is higher, statutory is one week notice.

M400 NBL

3,552 posts

243 months

Thursday 2nd July 2009
quotequote all
Did you check the ACAS website?

On a quick break atm so haven't the time to check it myself.

JustinP1

13,364 posts

261 months

Thursday 2nd July 2009
quotequote all
If the job is very sales or target based, then it is either a job you with thrive in, or you may be OK for a while and lose interest, or just be crap at.

No interview in the world can pick out which type you are every time.

The easiest way is to give someone a trial and see how they do. You may find that as the proportion of people who will be really cut out for that job is as low as 10%. He may be looking for 'stars' as a star can bring in multiples what the average person will do.

Therefore, he may be taking people on with the full knowledge that only one in four is going to last the probationary period.

Unless you are a star, I would be looking for a new job. What happened here is that the employee resigned therefore there is no reason to even keep the seat there with them on it for the next week. Time to give someone else a go.

Road2Ruin

6,563 posts

247 months

Thursday 2nd July 2009
quotequote all
Quite simply its sound like unfair dismissal. Regardsless of how long you work for someone standard dismissal procedures apply (gross misconduct excepted). These standard procedures mean that firstly the staff member has to have a meeting with the oppertunity of a representative with them. The meeting must follw the lines of what has gone wrong, discussion on what has gone wrong and possible resolutions and finally conclusion. There must then be 'reasonable time' for a descission to be made. This could be 1 minute or 3 weeks who knows as long as its considered resonable. The staff member is then informed of the descision and in this case dismissed. They can be dismissed with immediate effect within a probation period. The only problem is that if the staff member has been working for a company for less than a year its unlikey that, if these procures were not followed, any action would or could be taken. If I were her I would just get on and look for another job.

edc

9,695 posts

282 months

Thursday 2nd July 2009
quotequote all
Road2Ruin said:
Quite simply its sound like unfair dismissal. Regardsless of how long you work for someone standard dismissal procedures apply (gross misconduct excepted). These standard procedures mean that firstly the staff member has to have a meeting with the oppertunity of a representative with them. The meeting must follw the lines of what has gone wrong, discussion on what has gone wrong and possible resolutions and finally conclusion. There must then be 'reasonable time' for a descission to be made. This could be 1 minute or 3 weeks who knows as long as its considered resonable. The staff member is then informed of the descision and in this case dismissed. They can be dismissed with immediate effect within a probation period. The only problem is that if the staff member has been working for a company for less than a year its unlikey that, if these procures were not followed, any action would or could be taken. If I were her I would just get on and look for another job.
Less than 12 months service, then next to no right unless breach of contract of discrimination. Obviously, not meeting the contractual (would be surprised if employees here were actually issued with any T&Cs) or statutory notice peiods would be a breach.

If "Standard procedures" equals statutory procedures then these are no longer in existence.

Edited by edc on Thursday 2nd July 13:59

fastcaterham

Original Poster:

420 posts

225 months

Thursday 2nd July 2009
quotequote all
Thanks for the replies everyone. I did check the acas website and it implyed that there would still have to be a minimum of a week notice but I wasn't sure exactly whether this would apply and was hoping sombody could confirm it.
edc you were right in your presumption that nobody was issued with T&C's and from looking at the acas website i think you would be right in sayng that the statutory procedures no longer apply. She already has another job so that aspect is fine but according to her friend who still works with us she has still not been paid and as already mentioned has consulted a solicitor although nothing really seems to have happened yet.
JustinP1 I understand where you are coming from but at present I would say that on average only around 2 members of the sales team are meeting targets out of 10 and even then only about 2/3 days per week. I'm in a unique postion of knowing all this exactly as I've been given the job of keeping track of all the numbers. With regards to me looking for a new job it was not just a case of me but there were rumours going around that maybe a number of us would end up with the chop and he would be looking to get a nearly completly fresh workforce. To be honest though after seeing the difficulty he had in recruiting reasonable people I'm not sure how realisitic this is and judging from the past week the general consensus between the staff based on various going on's is that the company is starting to lose money quite substantially for its size and may be facing an uncertain future. This is all speculation at this stage though so the truth remains to be seen!
Thanks for everyones contributions though.

edc

9,695 posts

282 months

Friday 3rd July 2009
quotequote all
The simple thing to do would be to submit a written request claiming the monies owed for the days worked. Give them 5 working days to respond. If you have no response within that time frame then submit a tribunal claim online.

If not contractual notice then the statutory notice which is probably on ACS website will apply.

TBH whilst submitting the above claim you might as well file one for not issuing the correct notice as it is unlikely that failing to meet targets as described is a summary dismissal offence (of course, state in writing to company that you are also claiming for unpaind notice).

Jasper Gilder

2,166 posts

304 months

Saturday 4th July 2009
quotequote all
If your job is subsidised by a third party if you go, so does the subsidy so you're in a stronger position.

There is no longer a legal imperative on firms to follow legislatively set procedures as the conflict resolution regulations 2004 were repealed at Easter. The new ACAS guidelines provide for proper procedure, but regarding dismissal, access to an employment tribunal for those with less than a years service is pretty limited unless the person can show that they were treated as they were on the grounds of sex, race, religion, trade union activity, pregnancy, asserting a statutory right, refusing to work on the grounds of safety or being on strike.

Notice periods are contractual. If a person is summarily dismissed there is normally no right to notice or pay in lieu of notice, if they are not summarily dismisses ( which is usually for gross misconduct) they are entitled to pay in lieu of notice and would be able to take an action against their ex employer in the county court for breach of contract