Tell HMRC or crack on?
Tell HMRC or crack on?
Author
Discussion

Brown and Boris

Original Poster:

11,838 posts

266 months

Monday 6th July 2009
quotequote all
With the agreement of HMRC for PAYE and VAT purposes my business pays small fees (£10)to people to complete surveys and questionnaires.

For a number of technical reasons I now want to start using the same people 4 or 5 times a year and pay them £25-£40 a time.

How should I handle the PAYE? I had intended to make sure they signed to say they knew there was an obligation to inform the HMRC and leave it at that but this niggling doubt says I should cover my back as I did last time with a leter from HMRC saying it was Ok to do as I had planned.

I gather minimum personal data (some times I have paid in cash (agreed by HMRC) because of the nature of the work we do where people are reluctant to leave us with personal details ( I think they think we give it to HMG as some of the work is for them) so we try not to push them.

So, get another letter from HMRC (and hope they don't start insisting on me filling in forms)or keep my head down and get them to agree to tell HMRC on their own surety?

Edited by Brown and Boris on Monday 6th July 18:51


Edited by Brown and Boris on Monday 6th July 18:52

Pobolycwm

330 posts

211 months

Monday 6th July 2009
quotequote all
For casual students that I employ in the summer I was advised by accountant to do the following

It depends upon whether the employee pays tax or not on any of his earnings, if they are students etc and earn below tax threshold then all you have to do is get them to sign a P46 stating this, this puts responsibility for tax thresholds on the employee, you keep the P46 should you be asked for it by HRMC at a later date etc
If the employee states he is paying tax on other earnings on the P46 then you have to inform HRMC by sending in the P46 to HMRC and be aware/handle PAYE etc

Brown and Boris

Original Poster:

11,838 posts

266 months

Monday 6th July 2009
quotequote all
Pobolycwm said:
For casual students that I employ in the summer I was advised by accountant to do the following

It depends upon whether the employee pays tax or not on any of his earnings, if they are students etc and earn below tax threshold then all you have to do is get them to sign a P46 stating this, this puts responsibility for tax thresholds on the employee, you keep the P46 should you be asked for it by HRMC at a later date etc
If the employee states he is paying tax on other earnings on the P46 then you have to inform HRMC by sending in the P46 to HMRC and be aware/handle PAYE etc
They won't be students, they could be anyone but probably not students ( I can't get themj to do the work for £6 an hour.)

Tuscanless Ali

2,187 posts

240 months

Monday 6th July 2009
quotequote all
If they are students then they should complete a P38 if their total earnings during the year is not going to exceed £6475.

Otherwise get them to complete a P46 and pay them via the payroll, if they have to pay tax then so be it.

Brown and Boris

Original Poster:

11,838 posts

266 months

Tuesday 7th July 2009
quotequote all
Tuscanless Ali said:
If they are students then they should complete a P38 if their total earnings during the year is not going to exceed £6475.

Otherwise get them to complete a P46 and pay them via the payroll, if they have to pay tax then so be it.
Putting them all on the payroll is what I am trying to avoid. These people are out there in cyber space (all may not be UK based) and there will be hundreds of them all geting £25 just 2, 3 or 4 times a year. When it was aone off £10 HMRC basically said forget it.

The alternative is to go via an agency and let them sort it out.

Edited by Brown and Boris on Tuesday 7th July 10:49

Tuscanless Ali

2,187 posts

240 months

Tuesday 7th July 2009
quotequote all
Brown and Boris said:
Tuscanless Ali said:
If they are students then they should complete a P38 if their total earnings during the year is not going to exceed £6475.

Otherwise get them to complete a P46 and pay them via the payroll, if they have to pay tax then so be it.
Putting them all on the payroll is what I am trying to avoid. These people are out there in cyber space (all may not be UK based) and there will be hundreds of them all geting £25 just 2, 3 or 4 times a year. When it was aone off £10 HMRC basically said forget it.

The alternative is to go via an agency and let them sort it out.

Edited by Brown and Boris on Tuesday 7th July 10:49
Why are you trying to avoid putting them on the payroll? Is it because they will only work cash in hand, or is it because you don't currently run a payroll and think it is going to be a lot of hassle?


Mr POD

5,153 posts

223 months

Tuesday 7th July 2009
quotequote all
DHL were advertising a 'Job Opening' for a Self employed Courier.

Because it is casual and paid by the 'sale' or number of deliveries, they treat you as they would any other small trader.

In your case, you should treat casual labour in the same way.

On the HMRC website, search IR35 and try to understand how the Revenue attempt to shut down the loopholes of Full Time Permanent Contractors, running as Limited companies when the revenue considers them employees and ask yourself whether 5 days a year justifies putting anyone on the payrole.