Business rates challange companies question
Business rates challange companies question
Author
Discussion

Eggle

Original Poster:

3,609 posts

267 months

Tuesday 7th July 2009
quotequote all
Has anyone used any company who has promised to reduce the business rates on commercial property?
We have been approched by one who is suggesting a reduction in rates for a fee and a percentage of the saving.
Is there any pit falls in using this kind of service?

koolchris99

12,541 posts

210 months

Tuesday 7th July 2009
quotequote all
if you can prove to the rates people you arnt using a space you can get a 3 - 12 month reduction. we have downsized alot and are still tied into the studio rent but as we arnt using 80% of the space we have a rates reduction.


davidjpowell

18,707 posts

215 months

Tuesday 7th July 2009
quotequote all
Ask if they are a member of the RSA or the RICS. They should provide a sheet, which explains a reduction is not guarenteed, could even cause an increase. DO NOT PAY ANY FEE UPFRONT OR ON ACCEPTANCE OF A VALID APPEAL.

There are cowboys out there so be careful.

soxboy

7,574 posts

250 months

Tuesday 7th July 2009
quotequote all
The ones which approach you are far mor expensive than if you were to go to a more reputable high street surveyor.

Your business rates are based on the rateable value (RV) of your building, this should be the rental value of the building as at April 2003. Before looking at signing up with anyone have a look and compare your RV with your rent and also at similar properties nearby, check on www.voa.gov.uk

If the RV is noticeably higher than the rent then you may stand a chance.

If you think there's a saving to be made, go for it, but be wary of making any upfront payments. I would suggest you speak to a reputable local rating surveyor who could advise whether you are wasting your time or not. These rating challenge companies have a poor reputation in the industry, whether it is warranted or not I don't know.

Edited to add, I agree with David above wholeheartedly.

Edited by soxboy on Tuesday 7th July 14:43

Eggle

Original Poster:

3,609 posts

267 months

Wednesday 8th July 2009
quotequote all
Thanks David and Sox.
Will look into the local guys and "test the water" first.

Eggle

Original Poster:

3,609 posts

267 months

Wednesday 8th July 2009
quotequote all
The company asking to take on is
DPS consultant surveyors ltd
www.dpsconsultantsurveyors.co.uk

davidjpowell

18,707 posts

215 months

Wednesday 8th July 2009
quotequote all
Not the best website I have seen, and never heard of the firm. (I used to be a surveyor working in the rating department of a national surveying practice).

If you would like a recommendation just give me a shout.

Ken Sington

3,964 posts

269 months

Wednesday 8th July 2009
quotequote all
Ask them if they are going to achieve a reduction in the rateable value of your premises or the rates payable? A lot of businesses got scammed this way in the late 90's.

swansea v6

1,285 posts

256 months

Wednesday 8th July 2009
quotequote all
Sorry to hi-jack the thread but at the moment im looking at taking over some premises for my new venture. At the moment the building, which has been empty for 18 months has a rateable value of around £20k pa and is assessed as "warehouse and premises"

I am looking to convert the building to a fitness suite for special populations. i.e. gp referral/cardiac patients, disabled etc any ideas if the rates would change because of this? My application is currently with the planners but they weren't exactly forthcoming with any other info???? cheers and sorry for the hi-jack!!

soxboy

7,574 posts

250 months

Wednesday 8th July 2009
quotequote all
swansea v6 said:
Sorry to hi-jack the thread but at the moment im looking at taking over some premises for my new venture. At the moment the building, which has been empty for 18 months has a rateable value of around £20k pa and is assessed as "warehouse and premises"

I am looking to convert the building to a fitness suite for special populations. i.e. gp referral/cardiac patients, disabled etc any ideas if the rates would change because of this? My application is currently with the planners but they weren't exactly forthcoming with any other info???? cheers and sorry for the hi-jack!!
The rates will change as there is a material change in the building as it is no longer a warehouse. Rates are soon to be reassessed from April 2010, with new valuations being released around this October.

With effect from April 2008 industrial premises are no longer exempt from empty rates liabilities so you may be able to use this as a tool to get a better deal.

Chrisgr31

14,298 posts

286 months

Wednesday 8th July 2009
quotequote all
I work for one of the the largest rating surveying practices in the country and am a member of the RICS, the IRRV and the RSA but have never heard of the firm the OP mentions. Personally I would not use a local firm to do your rates either, mainly because the law is now so complex you need to be a specialist to deal with every angle. As an indication ee work on a rates saving basis and the standard fee is upto 20% of the saving in rates payable, the actual percentage is dependent on the RV. No saving no fee.

You do not want to pay an upfront fee, you do not want to pay for savings in rateable value. Also unless I am mistaken the company the OP mentions is seeking to sign you up for 15 years. That is in breach of the code of practice for rating surveyors.

If the OP wants to pm me his address and post code or post it here I'll have a quick look at the assessment to see whether an appeal is on the face of it justified.


Chrisgr31

14,298 posts

286 months

Wednesday 8th July 2009
quotequote all
swansea v6 said:
Sorry to hi-jack the thread but at the moment im looking at taking over some premises for my new venture. At the moment the building, which has been empty for 18 months has a rateable value of around £20k pa and is assessed as "warehouse and premises"

I am looking to convert the building to a fitness suite for special populations. i.e. gp referral/cardiac patients, disabled etc any ideas if the rates would change because of this? My application is currently with the planners but they weren't exactly forthcoming with any other info???? cheers and sorry for the hi-jack!!
Yes it will change although whether it will go up or down is another question! It will depend on the precise details of what you are planning to do.

curtisl

1,406 posts

237 months

Thursday 9th July 2009
quotequote all
you can actually make an application against the rateable value yourself with the VO and it is free of charge. go to the VOA.gov.uk website and on there you can find you local valuation office. give them a call and they will help you. basically you will be appealing against the last valuation which was 01.04.05. if the premises has changed since then. ie smaller then you have a good case. if you are only using part of the premises you can also apply for a section 44a which is a temporary split/revaluation of the property so you just pay for the part that is occupied.

to the OP, i have heard so many people saying that they paid £400+ to a firm that promised lower rates and didn't get anywhere. personally i would do it myself, one call, maybe a few forms, and the VOA does the rest for you and will let you know. if you are sucessful it can be backdated to the date of the last valuation (01.04.05) and any credits can be claimed from the council with interest.

Good luck

davidjpowell

18,707 posts

215 months

Thursday 9th July 2009
quotequote all
curtisl said:
you can actually make an application against the rateable value yourself with the VO and it is free of charge. go to the VOA.gov.uk website and on there you can find you local valuation office. give them a call and they will help you. basically you will be appealing against the last valuation which was 01.04.05. if the premises has changed since then. ie smaller then you have a good case. if you are only using part of the premises you can also apply for a section 44a which is a temporary split/revaluation of the property so you just pay for the part that is occupied.

to the OP, i have heard so many people saying that they paid £400+ to a firm that promised lower rates and didn't get anywhere. personally i would do it myself, one call, maybe a few forms, and the VOA does the rest for you and will let you know. if you are sucessful it can be backdated to the date of the last valuation (01.04.05) and any credits can be claimed from the council with interest.

Good luck
If only it was that easy. You may get a reduction this way, but it may well not be the most available. You are relying on the good nature of the Valuation Officer. The rating system is complex, and takes many moons to understand. Most reputable agents charge a percentage of payable savings, so if the save nothing you pay nothing.

Chrisgr31

14,298 posts

286 months

Thursday 9th July 2009
quotequote all
davidjpowell said:
curtisl said:
you can actually make an application against the rateable value yourself with the VO and it is free of charge. go to the VOA.gov.uk website and on there you can find you local valuation office. give them a call and they will help you. basically you will be appealing against the last valuation which was 01.04.05. if the premises has changed since then. ie smaller then you have a good case. if you are only using part of the premises you can also apply for a section 44a which is a temporary split/revaluation of the property so you just pay for the part that is occupied.

to the OP, i have heard so many people saying that they paid £400+ to a firm that promised lower rates and didn't get anywhere. personally i would do it myself, one call, maybe a few forms, and the VOA does the rest for you and will let you know. if you are sucessful it can be backdated to the date of the last valuation (01.04.05) and any credits can be claimed from the council with interest.

Good luck
If only it was that easy. You may get a reduction this way, but it may well not be the most available. You are relying on the good nature of the Valuation Officer. The rating system is complex, and takes many moons to understand. Most reputable agents charge a percentage of payable savings, so if the save nothing you pay nothing.
Yup David is right. Whilst the VO has a duty to be fair and reasonable he rarely is. He puts unqualified staff up against unrepresented ratepayers who often will try to get the proposal withdrawn. Sometimes if agents have appealed ither properties in the area then an unrepresented ratepayer will get the same deal, but the unrepresented ratepayer will not necessarially get the right answer.

In the OPs case I suspect that to get any reduction is going to be difficult. The cowboys who charge upfront fees often just phone up the VO and ask if there is anything in it, if the VO says there isn't they just withdraw! Tyhe OP may be due a reduction but it is going to be a hard battle and the savings will be modest.