Yellow Pages ?
Author
Discussion

Chipper

Original Poster:

1,540 posts

248 months

Sunday 12th July 2009
quotequote all
I've been advertising with Yellow Pages since i was 19. I'm now 31. I started paying around £4k on adverts in several books and gradually over the years this went up to just under 20k about 6 years ago, but for the last 4 years the whole Yellow Pages idea seems to be dying.

I've got each booked linked to a phone number so i can monitor the results but some books are just not getting any results whatsoever. I'd like to add that my clients are generally over 60 and alot of them dont use the interet yet.

Aftr much stewing over and the fact that i woundnt have to deal with their smug bloody reps who seem more interested in their new company car than my adverts ive decided to knock them on the head and put that budget into local paper and internet website adverts.


Just trying to get a feeling what others are finding.

Regards

Chipper


Martial Arts Man

6,703 posts

217 months

Sunday 12th July 2009
quotequote all
I cancelled my yellow pages ads 2 years ago.

Made no difference whatsoever, surprisingly.

Have you seen the size of the books these days? My local one, Birmingham Central, must be half the size it was only 4 years ago.

Yell is done and dusted, I am certain.

Ken Sington

3,964 posts

269 months

Sunday 12th July 2009
quotequote all
Agreed^^^^. The central London YP is now 1/4 of the size it used to be. None of my competitors advertise in it anymore. I gave up 2 years ago. The last time I used it I was talked into one of their monitoring phone numbers so I could see how many enquiries came from it. It took some cajoling of the rep to get him to produce the report when renewal time came round, and the reason was that for a 1/4 page ad, just 20 calls had been received across the year, with some months showing none at all. I just use Yell.com now.

Chipper

Original Poster:

1,540 posts

248 months

Sunday 12th July 2009
quotequote all
Martial Arts Man said:
I cancelled my yellow pages ads 2 years ago.

Made no difference whatsoever, surprisingly.

Have you seen the size of the books these days? My local one, Birmingham Central, must be half the size it was only 4 years ago.

Yell is done and dusted, I am certain.
Very good point. They split most books to increase revenue but i think it was a major mistake down to pure greed! You just don't get the same feeling that you will find everything you need these days and its also now similar in size to Thompsons etc.....


Mojooo

13,291 posts

211 months

Sunday 12th July 2009
quotequote all
I still look in the yellow pages for tradesmen like plumbers etc - I find that a lot of (most) of them don;t have decent websites so i have to resort to the YP).

A decent website is always the first port of call though of course

stuart-b

3,651 posts

257 months

Sunday 12th July 2009
quotequote all
Chipper said:
Martial Arts Man said:
I cancelled my yellow pages ads 2 years ago.

Made no difference whatsoever, surprisingly.

Have you seen the size of the books these days? My local one, Birmingham Central, must be half the size it was only 4 years ago.

Yell is done and dusted, I am certain.
Very good point. They split most books to increase revenue but i think it was a major mistake down to pure greed! You just don't get the same feeling that you will find everything you need these days and its also now similar in size to Thompsons etc.....
We cancelled too and so did all our clients.

Just to give you an idea, one of our clients got a few phone calls within a 3 month period from YP, didn't amount to anything much.

The same money spent on Google advertising grossed them £80k of business in areas they wouldn't have advertised in with Yellow Pages (work in Chelsea/London area, Bristol, etc), being that Google advertising took place across the whole of the UK.

You can also control and quantify online advertising much better.

If you have a very small advert in Yellow Pages (the £350-£500 jobby), then spend the rest online/local newspapers etc, you'll do a lot better.

I think these days you need the whole marketing mix; rather than just "stick it in yellow pages" and low and behold you have lots of enquiries.

If you were a retail business you could even consider social networking sites, applications like Spotify, as a good opportunity to target very specific demographics. (Facebook has more members aged 34+ than any other demographic age group).

Marketing a business successfully across all mediums has definately become more complex imho.

davidjpowell

18,707 posts

215 months

Sunday 12th July 2009
quotequote all
I'm interested in this, as I am currently being badgered by Yell. Cost would be £850 for the year to be in the 2nd top spot in listings with website link.

I'd be interested to see if anyone has had positive results - I'm not saying no, but I am suspicious about the effectiveness.

stuart-b

3,651 posts

257 months

Sunday 12th July 2009
quotequote all
davidjpowell said:
I'm interested in this, as I am currently being badgered by Yell. Cost would be £850 for the year to be in the 2nd top spot in listings with website link.

I'd be interested to see if anyone has had positive results - I'm not saying no, but I am suspicious about the effectiveness.
I'd put money on Google providing you more leads for £850 of PPC.

Number 5

2,761 posts

226 months

Sunday 12th July 2009
quotequote all
Chipper what type of product/service are you selling? We too spend a fair bit on the yellow pages and I'm having my doubts now but we also spend a fair bit on the local rags which still bring a fair bit of new business in, we are considering buying databases next for direct mailing.

elster

17,517 posts

241 months

Sunday 12th July 2009
quotequote all
davidjpowell said:
I'm interested in this, as I am currently being badgered by Yell. Cost would be £850 for the year to be in the 2nd top spot in listings with website link.

I'd be interested to see if anyone has had positive results - I'm not saying no, but I am suspicious about the effectiveness.
I signed up a couple of years ago. Cancelled this year, pretty damn pointless.

I got one garden centre call for some Portable Appliance testing. So that has almost paid for the advert.

I just rely on word of mouth now and calling round people I know. Works much better.

Chipper

Original Poster:

1,540 posts

248 months

Monday 13th July 2009
quotequote all
Number 5 said:
Chipper what type of product/service are you selling? We too spend a fair bit on the yellow pages and I'm having my doubts now but we also spend a fair bit on the local rags which still bring a fair bit of new business in, we are considering buying databases next for direct mailing.
I sell medical devices. Just recently i spent £750 buying a database for an area i have a shop in. Instead of a 3 day event it turned into about 9 days. The problem is that most of the people were just coming out for a jolly and had no intension of buying. I don't know even if it paid for the cost of mailing and time which came in at around £2500.

I might do a trial with a few Yell.com areas and spend a bit with Google.

stuart-b

3,651 posts

257 months

Monday 13th July 2009
quotequote all
Chipper said:
Number 5 said:
Chipper what type of product/service are you selling? We too spend a fair bit on the yellow pages and I'm having my doubts now but we also spend a fair bit on the local rags which still bring a fair bit of new business in, we are considering buying databases next for direct mailing.
I sell medical devices. Just recently i spent £750 buying a database for an area i have a shop in. Instead of a 3 day event it turned into about 9 days. The problem is that most of the people were just coming out for a jolly and had no intension of buying. I don't know even if it paid for the cost of mailing and time which came in at around £2500.

I might do a trial with a few Yell.com areas and spend a bit with Google.
Get a microsite built (A microsite is a dedicated website, designed with one purpose, to sell a particular set of products ONLY, a bit like a movie website marketing one film).

Then advertise that website on Google.

Set up an Adwords campaign, initially set the budget very low, say, £5 per day, £0.50p per click. Put in a few keywords, such as "medical devices" or the name of the product(s) you are selling. Google will tell you how many people are searching for those keywords and what cost per click they are. This is almost free market research from the internet.

A quick search of Google reveals: http://www.google.co.uk/search?q=medical+devices&a...

How many of these people are your competitors?

Medical health equipment - www.meditelle.co.uk
Medical Devices - www.sfm.de Your partner for medical technologies. Worldwide.
Expert Medical Device CRO
www.medvance.co.uk Global leader in clinical research. Clinical, Regulatory and Training.

http://www.meditelle.co.uk/?gclid=COS4xpee0psCFZkA...

Meditelle almost has a complete monopoly on Google, being one of the ONLY .co.uk companies advertising on Google for what you're selling.

That tells me the cost per click will be far lower than many other industries.

If you had spent £2500 on that, rather than a database, and mailing, I believe you would of have a better result.

Simpo Two

93,096 posts

296 months

Monday 13th July 2009
quotequote all
I agree that 60+ folk are unlikely to head straight for Google when they want something.

We have a rather badly-printed A5 thingy that comes round every month or so free to every house. It's full of useful adverts from every kind of local tradesman, and I keep a copy just for that. The bloke who does my carpets only advertises there and he's made a decent living from it.

So - do you get a rather badly-printed A5 thingy? It could be the answer!

anonymous-user

85 months

Monday 13th July 2009
quotequote all
Simpo Two said:
I agree that 60+ folk are unlikely to head straight for Google when they want something.
Don't under estimate the retired, going on the dopey sts we had to deal with when selling PC's it is compulsory when you retire to visit the nearest computer shop an send thousands of pounds on PC's scanners, printers and god knows what! Yellow Pages? Whenever we ran adds it paid fot itself-just. However for a new start it got our name anout. We stopped years ago, they then tried to push Yell.Com, fact is most people head for Google. I think it really depends on trade, plumbers, sparkies etc then yellow pages will still work, anything that really should have a website is pointless IMO.

the prescotts

394 posts

224 months

Monday 13th July 2009
quotequote all
This article was in last weeks Marketing magazine:-

When JR Hartley found a copy of his book Fly Fishing in the well-known 1983 television ad, he had Yellow Pages to thank.

At the time, the phone book took pride of place in households throughout the UK; when difficult times struck, the last thing businesses cut back was on their Yellow Pages ad. However, times have changed. The business model of the directories company is unlikely to survive in the long term.

In a world dominated by Google, the likes of Yell.com may eventually shrink into insignificance - and the printed version of the Yellow Pages is nowadays often used as a doorstop, if not dumped straight into the recycling bin.

Yell and its cousins were once the darlings of private-equity investors, who acquired them because they were lucrative and resilient. Yet all good things must come to an end, and this is certainly the case with Yell's model.

Last week, it emerged that Yell plans to initiate talks with lenders about restructuring its near £4bn debt, just eight months after a previous covenant renegotiation. It also warned that earnings would fall by almost a third in the second quarter.

While the recession may be partly to blame, Yell's problems are deeper than the financial tide. They are structural, and many of its issues will still be there when the economy recovers. The internet has transformed the directories market. While Yell has made efforts online, it will never conquer Google, which offers businesses a global brand, worldwide exposure and easy navigation - all for relatively low prices.

Yell.com may have attracted 20% more advertising sales in 2008, and
now offer 2m UK business listings and 217,000 searchable advertisers, but this is by no means enough.

The company's debt pile will eventually catch up with it. Its stock market value is now just £206m - a fraction of its £4bn debt load.

Yell made the mistake of acquiring TPI, the Spanish directories business, in 2006. It was the biggest deal the directories group had struck since it was spun out of BT in 2001, costing it £2.3bn - and it admitted earlier this year that it has already written down its Spanish arm's value by £1.27bn.

Yell believes it has solutions. It seems to have adopted the mentality of 'If you can't beat 'em, join 'em' by opting to work with its apparent enemy, Google. This is a welcome move, but should have happened a lot earlier.
For years, it had championed its online operations as a force strong enough to compete with Google and the answer to the print version's decline. However, the recent news that it has joined forces with the internet giant and become an authorised re-seller of Google Ad-Words is surely Yell admitting defeat.

The Google deal effectively transforms Yell's business model into a media-buying agency. The step follows Yell's launch of NetReach, a service that charges small businesses £180 to advertise on a number of websites. These deals should have come earlier.

Yell may recover and become lucrative when the recession is over, but I have serious doubts whether its glory days will ever return in its current form.The recession has been blamed for the failure of many companies in recent months but, when markets recover, we will be reminded of the structural issues that companies like Yell were facing before the credit crunch hit.

It seems the famous Yellow Pages 2006 slogan 'Let your fingers do the walking,' should be changed to 'Make sure advertisers don't do the walking'.

Amanda Andrews is media editor at The Daily Telegraph, Sunday Telegraph and telegraph.co.uk

Simpo Two

93,096 posts

296 months

Monday 13th July 2009
quotequote all
the prescotts said:
This article was in last weeks Marketing magazine
That opens a second aspect - either Yell is failng because its product doesn't work, or because it was financially stupid. Hence the possible demise of Yell doesn't directly mean that you can only use Google.

It all depends what/who your target market is. Get out into the street and ask some 60+ folk where they'd look if they wanted to buy your product - then you can proceed from fact not guesswork smile

2 5HAN

702 posts

262 months

Monday 13th July 2009
quotequote all
Has anyone had success in getting a discount from them on the advertising? They always seem so positive that the price is fixed and that its final?

I have considered saying OK lets cancel this year but I don’t really want to do that.

Anyone with any inside knowledge??? Or anyone been successful?

superlightr

12,920 posts

294 months

Monday 13th July 2009
quotequote all
we stopped using them about 6 years ago. no neg impact from doing that at all.

pete a

3,799 posts

215 months

Monday 13th July 2009
quotequote all
2 5HAN said:
Has anyone had success in getting a discount from them on the advertising? They always seem so positive that the price is fixed and that its final?

I have considered saying OK lets cancel this year but I don’t really want to do that.

Anyone with any inside knowledge??? Or anyone been successful?
exactly the above i have tried for years to get discounts with no luck, just placed a £41000 order schedule don't want to cancel it as it does work for my industry, however with their current trade at present has anyone forced a discount????

Funk

27,815 posts

240 months

Monday 13th July 2009
quotequote all
Pete, are you talking about Yellow Pages or Yell.com (or a combination of the two)?