Lease advice needed
Lease advice needed
Author
Discussion

Chris77

Original Poster:

956 posts

225 months

Tuesday 14th July 2009
quotequote all
Hi guys, My business property lease is being renewed, got a call off my landlady who said if we go to a 5 year lease instead of the usual 3 year she would fix the cost the same as it is at present and not increase it.

Fair enough I thought, not planning to move or stop trading so said OK. She then said to keep costs down she would get her solicitor to draw up the lease same as before and we just sign so we don't need to pay our solicitor.....mmm ok I thought, been here 6 years and had no problems, we are left to our own devices and had no problems.

Today I got a bill from her solicitor for £500.00 ??????? my question is, is this normal practice for the tenant to pay the solicitor of the landlord, Spoke to landlady she isn't happy at my protest saying it is normal and she will put rent up if I'm going to be funny.

Being a small business this is not an insignificant amount to me, especially in the current climate.

Advice appreciated smile

CHIEF

2,270 posts

313 months

Tuesday 14th July 2009
quotequote all
She shouldn't be increasing it at all to be honest.

I'd call her bluff and say you'll look for alternative premises (unless she's really cheap) there is an abundance of To Let properties out there at the moment begging for tenants.

Say she has to advertise and it takes two months to let then she is gonna be losing a fair bit. Tell her its not open to discussion and either she holds the price and pays the solitors fees or your off.

You cannot be held to ransom like that.

Edited by CHIEF on Tuesday 14th July 11:07

Ken Sington

3,964 posts

269 months

Tuesday 14th July 2009
quotequote all
No, it's not normal in this market. I act for a lot of tenants in negotiating property leases before they are passed on to solicitors and block any such attempts to pass on legal costs to the tenant. Imho she is taking the pee, so depending upon how strongly you feel, ask her if she would prefer to have the property empty and have to try to find another tenant.

Davel

8,982 posts

289 months

Tuesday 14th July 2009
quotequote all
If she said that the lease will be as the previous lease, did you pay the costs then?

If not then query it or offer to meet 50% of the costs.

Chris77

Original Poster:

956 posts

225 months

Tuesday 14th July 2009
quotequote all
To be honest I couldnt really afford to move at the moment, so if I do try and call her bluff I can only go so far

Chris77

Original Poster:

956 posts

225 months

Tuesday 14th July 2009
quotequote all
Davel said:
If she said that the lease will be as the previous lease, did you pay the costs then?

If not then query it or offer to meet 50% of the costs.
I really cant remember as I paid my solicitor to deal with it all, Im sure I would have questioned it previously had it been the case.

davidjpowell

18,707 posts

215 months

Tuesday 14th July 2009
quotequote all
If it is not written in the previous lease that you would be responsible for legal fees and it has not been discussed it is difficult to see how you can be liable for legal costs instructed by your landlord.

You need to decide whether you can put up with the pain should they get arsy if you stand your ground.

My position when acquiring property for clients is simple like Ken's - Each party pays own costs.

Solicitors get very expensive when someone else is paying their costs in my experience.

Piglet

6,250 posts

286 months

Tuesday 14th July 2009
quotequote all
I'd agree that unless you confirmed that you would contribute to her fees then you don't pay anything.

The solicitor of course couldn't act for you as they would be conflicted so what you are paying is a bung towards her fees that (unless they put something in the lease?) you are not responsible for.

Have you signed the new lease?

Unless you agreed to pay then they are her fees and she is responsible for them.

Wacky Racer

41,415 posts

278 months

Tuesday 14th July 2009
quotequote all
Many leases on shops, (especially in large shopping precincts) state the ingoing tenant is responsible for both parties legal costs.....

Completely unfair of course, but what can you do, other than look elsewhere and tell them to stick it where the sun don't shine?..................

biggrin

davidjpowell

18,707 posts

215 months

Tuesday 14th July 2009
quotequote all
Wacky Racer said:
Many leases on shops, (especially in large shopping precincts) state the ingoing tenant is responsible for both parties legal costs.....

Completely unfair of course, but what can you do, other than look elsewhere and tell them to stick it where the sun don't shine?..................

biggrin
Easy - you say no chance. It's usually a try on.

Chrisgr31

14,298 posts

286 months

Tuesday 14th July 2009
quotequote all
We are talking about a lease renewal here and therefore the terms are potentially open to negotiation. Without knowing the type of property, its locaton etc it is impossible to say whether the rent should have gone up or down, however given that the landlord is seeking to tie the OP into a longer lease at the same rent I guess she assumes rents have in fact fallen.

We also don't know if the OP is protected by the L and T Act 1954, and if his old lease has expired. If it has not and he is protected I would suggest he speaks to a suitably qualified Chartered Surveyor and gets some professional advice. Yes it will cost something but most will work on an incentive based fee. So if they save him nothing he pays nothing.

I don't know how often the Surveyors on this forum have to recommend people get professional advice from an expert. It invariably pays for itself! How many people don't employ accountants?

Because its property people seem to think its easy, its not there all all sorts of pitfalls for the unwary, and of course loophalls that can be exploited by the professional.

Give a location and property type and those here might be able to suggest a suitable surveyor.

Ken Sington

3,964 posts

269 months

Wednesday 15th July 2009
quotequote all
Chrisgr31 said:
I don't know how often the Surveyors on this forum have to recommend people get professional advice from an expert. It invariably pays for itself! How many people don't employ accountants?

Because its property people seem to think its easy, its not there all all sorts of pitfalls for the unwary, and of course loophalls that can be exploited by the professional.
Listen to this man, for he speaks righteously, even though he is nicking bits off my own song sheet! hehe

bad company

21,920 posts

297 months

Wednesday 15th July 2009
quotequote all
I had a very similar situation when my lease was renewed.

I simply wrote back to the solicitor pointing out that his client was responsible for his fees.

Soovy

35,829 posts

302 months

Wednesday 15th July 2009
quotequote all
Chris77 said:
Hi guys, My business property lease is being renewed, got a call off my landlady who said if we go to a 5 year lease instead of the usual 3 year she would fix the cost the same as it is at present and not increase it.

Fair enough I thought, not planning to move or stop trading so said OK. She then said to keep costs down she would get her solicitor to draw up the lease same as before and we just sign so we don't need to pay our solicitor.....mmm ok I thought, been here 6 years and had no problems, we are left to our own devices and had no problems.

Today I got a bill from her solicitor for £500.00 ??????? my question is, is this normal practice for the tenant to pay the solicitor of the landlord, Spoke to landlady she isn't happy at my protest saying it is normal and she will put rent up if I'm going to be funny.

Being a small business this is not an insignificant amount to me, especially in the current climate.

Advice appreciated smile
Have you SEEN how much commercial rents have dropped?


You've been fu ked up the ar5e mate.


V8TVR1978

895 posts

221 months

Wednesday 15th July 2009
quotequote all
Chris77 said:
Hi guys, My business property lease is being renewed, got a call off my landlady who said if we go to a 5 year lease instead of the usual 3 year she would fix the cost the same as it is at present and not increase it.

Fair enough I thought, not planning to move or stop trading so said OK. She then said to keep costs down she would get her solicitor to draw up the lease same as before and we just sign so we don't need to pay our solicitor.....mmm ok I thought, been here 6 years and had no problems, we are left to our own devices and had no problems.

Today I got a bill from her solicitor for £500.00 ??????? my question is, is this normal practice for the tenant to pay the solicitor of the landlord, Spoke to landlady she isn't happy at my protest saying it is normal and she will put rent up if I'm going to be funny.

Being a small business this is not an insignificant amount to me, especially in the current climate.

Advice appreciated smile
If you haven't signed the lease papers find a GOOD realtor for your area. Ask them to do a search of what you need in your area and if the costs per square foot have gone up or down since you last signed a lease. Another question to ask is "length of time these properties have been vacant and on the market." Compare apples to apples. You may prefer not moving due to costs or not wanting to notify customers of new address but it just might be your best option. By standing up to the landlord as you did and then signing the lease, you have to live with that landlord for the next 5 years. I would have been looking 6 months in advance for other places to know where I stood before dealing with your landlord. In most cases it is best for both parties to have knowledge before hand on costs and availability before coming to the table. I bet the landlord did their homework.

TimCrighton

996 posts

247 months

Wednesday 15th July 2009
quotequote all
I assume by the fact the landlord's solicitor has served the invoice you've completed the new lease??!

In which case its too late to negotiate. If the new lease has not been completed then its definitely worth looking to renegotiate, either through new terms or at least by ensuring the landlord covers the legal and professional costs arising from their aspect of the transaction. You should also bare in mind that the market has moved, particularly for retail, and thus it may be that whilst rents haven't changed incentives have improved, so you could be looking at a rent free period etc. Its a tricky one, as a lease renewal has an element of 'special purchaser' about it, in that you are located there already and thus have costs to move out, but it should still be relatively comparable to an open market letting.

Where abouts are you based? smile

Jasandjules

72,688 posts

260 months

Wednesday 15th July 2009
quotequote all
Chris77 said:
Hi guys, My business property lease is being renewed, got a call off my landlady who said if we go to a 5 year lease instead of the usual 3 year she would fix the cost the same as it is at present and not increase it.

Fair enough I thought, not planning to move or stop trading so said OK. She then said to keep costs down she would get her solicitor to draw up the lease same as before and we just sign so we don't need to pay our solicitor.....mmm ok I thought, been here 6 years and had no problems, we are left to our own devices and had no problems.

Today I got a bill from her solicitor for £500.00 ??????? my question is, is this normal practice for the tenant to pay the solicitor of the landlord, Spoke to landlady she isn't happy at my protest saying it is normal and she will put rent up if I'm going to be funny.

Being a small business this is not an insignificant amount to me, especially in the current climate.

Advice appreciated smile
You don't have a contract with the solicitor. Tell him to f**k off.

Call her again, (record it) and ask her why this has happened when she specifically told you that she would be paying for the solicitor........

bad company

21,920 posts

297 months

Friday 17th July 2009
quotequote all
Jasandjules][quote said:
You don't have a contract with the solicitor. Tell him to f**k off.

Call her again, (record it) and ask her why this has happened when she specifically told you that she would be paying for the solicitor........
Spot on.;)

Edited by bad company on Friday 17th July 17:15