The UK's leading supplier of XYZ
The UK's leading supplier of XYZ
Author
Discussion

sam.r

Original Poster:

2,379 posts

259 months

Thursday 16th July 2009
quotequote all
Just a quick question...

Does that statement have to be backed by anything? Or can it be used for marketing...

The said company probably is the best however can't really prove it.

R.I.F.

8,786 posts

226 months

Thursday 16th July 2009
quotequote all
I'd expect it to be "proven" but I'd still take it with a pinch of salt anyway.

sam.r

Original Poster:

2,379 posts

259 months

Thursday 16th July 2009
quotequote all
Ok thanks.

StevieBee

15,513 posts

286 months

Thursday 16th July 2009
quotequote all
There's no legal requirement as it cannot be proved one way or another so there is no way it could be defended or challenged in court - unless a competitor is also using it.

It is simply an "aspirational marketing statement".

BA Famously used the tag line "the world's favourite airline" along the same lines. It couldn't be proved that it was or wasn't but the message stuck in people's mind and the more it was used, the more it became fact.

If you state "we sell more XYZ than anyone else" or "cheapest", "best", "quickest" ,etc...- that needs to be proven.

Word of warning though, if you are going to use that approach, you need to deliver on expectation and there's no point in using the phrase if your competitors are companies like IBM or whatever.



sam.r

Original Poster:

2,379 posts

259 months

Thursday 16th July 2009
quotequote all
Yes of course!

Many thanks for the reply.

Ghisallo

1,258 posts

209 months

Thursday 16th July 2009
quotequote all
If the statement was "The UK's BEST supplier of XYZ" it would surely be puffery however I would have thought that 'leading supplier' might well be quantifiable (perhaps measuarable in terms of numbers supplied, number of customers, turnover, scale, etc.) and so shouldn't be used unless accurate?

StevieBee

15,513 posts

286 months

Thursday 16th July 2009
quotequote all
Ghisallo said:
If the statement was "The UK's BEST supplier of XYZ" it would surely be puffery however I would have thought that 'leading supplier' might well be quantifiable (perhaps measuarable in terms of numbers supplied, number of customers, turnover, scale, etc.) and so shouldn't be used unless accurate?
Not really.

"Best" can be quantified against set benchmarks; best materials compared to competitors, less returns, better customer service, etc..

"Leading" cannot be quantified in the same way unless you align it to a specific virtue such as quality, price, etc. The statement is more one of perception than absolute fact.



You'll find that this is the leading reply to this topic!

Ghisallo

1,258 posts

209 months

Thursday 16th July 2009
quotequote all
StevieBee said:
Ghisallo said:
If the statement was "The UK's BEST supplier of XYZ" it would surely be puffery however I would have thought that 'leading supplier' might well be quantifiable (perhaps measuarable in terms of numbers supplied, number of customers, turnover, scale, etc.) and so shouldn't be used unless accurate?
Not really.

"Best" can be quantified against set benchmarks; best materials compared to competitors, less returns, better customer service, etc..

"Leading" cannot be quantified in the same way unless you align it to a specific virtue such as quality, price, etc. The statement is more one of perception than absolute fact.



You'll find that this is the leading reply to this topic!
Interesting stuff. I'm relying on distant memories of a law course some years ago but I thought that the term ‘the best’ (as an expression of opinion) the can be used in puffery and where there is no selective comparison made.

HiRich

3,337 posts

293 months

Thursday 16th July 2009
quotequote all
StevieBee said:
There's no legal requirement as it cannot be proved one way or another so there is no way it could be defended or challenged in court - unless a competitor is also using it.

It is simply an "aspirational marketing statement".

BA Famously used the tag line "the world's favourite airline" along the same lines. It couldn't be proved that it was or wasn't but the message stuck in people's mind and the more it was used, the more it became fact.
I'm not sure that's correct. If it relates to ASA-controlled material, the advertiser must be able to substantiate claims (direct or implied) that are capable of objective substantiation.

"Favourite" is ambiguous, not vague. It implies and would be expected to mean one of the following:
  • Most often chosen (ie seats booked)
  • Highest rated in a survey
  • Most commonly chosen in a survey.
When the slogan was used in the 1980s I seem to remember that it was challenged, and was substantiated (AFAIR on both 1 and 3). I think the tag was dropped before Charles & Maurice took the account with them from Saatchi & Saatchi, when it became harder to justify.

If "The Leading" was used in advertising, I believe the ASA would expect substantiation, in terms of market share, traffic, awareness or satisfaction, as leading is implied in at least one of these categories.

JustinP1

13,364 posts

261 months

Thursday 16th July 2009
quotequote all
StevieBee said:
There's no legal requirement as it cannot be proved one way or another so there is no way it could be defended or challenged in court - unless a competitor is also using it.

It is simply an "aspirational marketing statement".

BA Famously used the tag line "the world's favourite airline" along the same lines. It couldn't be proved that it was or wasn't but the message stuck in people's mind and the more it was used, the more it became fact.

If you state "we sell more XYZ than anyone else" or "cheapest", "best", "quickest" ,etc...- that needs to be proven.

Word of warning though, if you are going to use that approach, you need to deliver on expectation and there's no point in using the phrase if your competitors are companies like IBM or whatever.
BA actually backed up their 'favourite airline' slogan by stating that they were the favourite based upon total miles flown per customer.

What they failed to mention was that this was pretty much by default because at the time they were under (or just left) government backing and still had a monopoly over the long haul routes!