What do you say when you get touted for advertising?
What do you say when you get touted for advertising?
Author
Discussion

JustinP1

Original Poster:

13,364 posts

261 months

Friday 17th July 2009
quotequote all
After having not used print and magasine advertising for a few years due to a low response rate, I bit the bullet and did a deal.

Since the advert came out I have had half a dozen calls from competitor publications who have obviously got our details from the ad and are touting for advertising. Some of these publications are big, some free, some paid for, but they all tell me how much response their clients get from adverts and how much they would like to have our business.

The bottom line is though, I don't know them from Adam, and have even less idea whether factors like who is actually reading their magasine, and how they read it is going to be any use.

So I give them a counter offer:

The facts are I don't know them from Adam. I would like to believe that I will get a great response, but I can spend my money with a proven return elsewhere. If the response is so great, I am more than happy for you to run one of our ads for free, then if it works as they have promised we are in a win-win situation. They would then have a long term customer because I would be stupid to turn away a value of business which is a multiple of what a paid for ad is now proven to bring.


How many out of the half dozen wanted to discuss this?

plasticpig

12,932 posts

256 months

Friday 17th July 2009
quotequote all
At a rough guess zero?

Windsorphil

888 posts

293 months

Friday 17th July 2009
quotequote all
I find that brinkmanship helps - prices tumble very quickly towards the close date - I have a deal that the deadline was today with a leading baby magazine - the ratecard price was £6950 they first rang about a month ago, then they offered 50% off about a week later, I said I was interested but was still too pricey, etc, etc...they kept trying and on Wednesday I agreed at £750 for the same insertion. As for measurement - it has a special offer code so should be able to track results over time.


JustinP1

Original Poster:

13,364 posts

261 months

Friday 17th July 2009
quotequote all
That was pretty much what I did with the magasine I ended up working with.

They explained that they couldn't do it whilst there were paid advertisers, and I left it until deadline day, and we did a deal where we paid just over cost price for putting some A4 inserts in the mag and got a free 1/4 page ad.

We have got about £12k of work from it so far from what cost us including printing the flyers about £700.

They are going to get our business again - maybe not at their silly 'book' rate which they know they inflate to make the real rate sound cheap, but at a decent one.


Out of the half a dozen advertisers since phoning us, 2 considered it and kept us on file. 4 couldn't wait to get off the phone.

All it has proven to me is that 4 out of the 7 in total either have no confidence in the 'proof in the pudding' despite the bravado, or cannot see past their own end of month commission cheque.

Anatol

1,392 posts

265 months

Friday 17th July 2009
quotequote all
Our standard response whenever we get spam calls from online directories and the like is to state that we are only taking on new marketing where payment is on a per-lead basis, and obviously if their offering is as good as they say it is, they'll have no problem with that.

The conversation tends to end very shortly thereafter...

Tol