Service charge con
Discussion
One of my shop properties is managed by a big London Agent. I have had a run in with them before over items in the service charge budget. I believe that they are trying to con the tenants with a particular charge - they are charging £6630 for an Energy Performance Audit of the building. I have called the company that did the audit and they quoted me £400 + vat to perform this service. Where do I stand?
Banner said:
One of my shop properties is managed by a big London Agent. I have had a run in with them before over items in the service charge budget. I believe that they are trying to con the tenants with a particular charge - they are charging £6630 for an Energy Performance Audit of the building. I have called the company that did the audit and they quoted me £400 + vat to perform this service. Where do I stand?
Well, what did you negotiate in your lease as regards this stuff? The problem with most standard leases is that the landlord has absolutely no incentive to keep these costs down, as s/he just recharges them to you. In most cases, you have to specifically negotiate-in suitable clauses. Residential lease legislation doesn't apply.In fairness, if you've been stiffed because your lease doesn't contain any provisions whatsoever to keep the landlord honest, you might have a claim against your solicitor for negligence, but it might be a long-shot.
Going back to the EPA, however, how big is the building? I assume the £6k+ is for the total building, to then be split amongst the tenants? For one of my buildings - a pretty simple 6500 square foot - we're looking at a lot more than £400 for the job - can you tell us which company you've spoken with and what the size of the building is, as I may want to hire them?!
The really big question is, however, this: why are existing tenants being asked to pay for an EPA when it is only required so that the landlord can let the property? IMHO there should be no way that this is a service charge item; this is a cost the landlord must pick up as a cost of being in the business of being a landlord, and is entirely unconnected with the habitation of the building by the tenants. I would be looking to challenge it on those grounds first and foremost. I presume, for instance, that the landlord's legal fees in letting part of the building are not a service charge item?
The whole building comprises 2 lock up retail units, 1 of apx 2000 sq ft and mine which is apx 1000 sq ft. There is also a suite of offices above the units. I contacted the company that provided the EPC to the managing agent and even slightly exagerated the size of the building. I have their quotation in writing - to travel to the premises, complete survey 2 - 3 hrs, provide written report, £400 + vat. PM me if you would like the name of the company.
Thanks Skwdenyer, I hadn't considered it was a charge that shouldn't be passed on.
Thanks Skwdenyer, I hadn't considered it was a charge that shouldn't be passed on.
The whole building comprises 2 lock up retail units, 1 of apx 2000 sq ft and mine which is apx 1000 sq ft. There is also a suite of offices above the units. I contacted the company that provided the EPC to the managing agent and even slightly exagerated the size of the building. I have their quotation in writing - to travel to the premises, complete survey 2 - 3 hrs, provide written report, £400 + vat. PM me if you would like the name of the company.
Thanks Skwdenyer, I hadn't considered it was a charge that shouldn't be passed on.
Thanks Skwdenyer, I hadn't considered it was a charge that shouldn't be passed on.
Morning.
How old is your lease? You ought to check with the landlord or the managing agent as to whether the service charge is prepared in line with the RICS Service Charge Code of Practice 2007. This provides for best practice and is aimed at improving transparency.
What exactly was provided? A EPC is ONLY required for a property being let or sold. A lot of landlords are trying to slide EPC provisions through under the S/C, depending on the S/C clauses in the lease. It COULD be argued, but may be tricky that the provision of an EPC constitutes an 'improvement' under the S/C (Fluor Daniel Properties Ltd v Shortland Investments Ltd (2001)) but I think you'd have a big task on your hands to get it to stick. Its likely that they have the power to enforce statutory requirements (an EPC) just as they do H&S requirements etc. You may be able to dispute that an EPC relevant to whole property is not appropriate as it would be entirely possible to get the individual suite being let or sold assessed individually. Its a common problem. I think your best route would be to confirm EXACTLY what has been done, and why - the managing agent should be able to tell you, then you can decide whether to raise an issue with this - the Code of Practice is intended to introduce best practice and places a responsibility of care on the managing agent to tender works in pursuit of best value.
If you need a hand there are several surveyors on here, including the chaps above, that will be able to help I'm sure.
Tim
How old is your lease? You ought to check with the landlord or the managing agent as to whether the service charge is prepared in line with the RICS Service Charge Code of Practice 2007. This provides for best practice and is aimed at improving transparency.
What exactly was provided? A EPC is ONLY required for a property being let or sold. A lot of landlords are trying to slide EPC provisions through under the S/C, depending on the S/C clauses in the lease. It COULD be argued, but may be tricky that the provision of an EPC constitutes an 'improvement' under the S/C (Fluor Daniel Properties Ltd v Shortland Investments Ltd (2001)) but I think you'd have a big task on your hands to get it to stick. Its likely that they have the power to enforce statutory requirements (an EPC) just as they do H&S requirements etc. You may be able to dispute that an EPC relevant to whole property is not appropriate as it would be entirely possible to get the individual suite being let or sold assessed individually. Its a common problem. I think your best route would be to confirm EXACTLY what has been done, and why - the managing agent should be able to tell you, then you can decide whether to raise an issue with this - the Code of Practice is intended to introduce best practice and places a responsibility of care on the managing agent to tender works in pursuit of best value.
If you need a hand there are several surveyors on here, including the chaps above, that will be able to help I'm sure.
Tim
Service Charges are extremely difficult to challenge. You need to read the service charge provisions of your lease in detail to see how the landlords can justify including an EPC in the service charge.
Most leases will make tenants comply with statute as it develops, but to my mind the legislation relating to EPC does not make it mandatory for the tenant to obtain unless they are marketing the property themselves.
Service Charge clauses do sometimes when the lawyers have been awake have a 'reasonableness' clause in. If you could have obtained it for £400 I think that it would be hard to argue that £6,600 is reasonable.
Whatever you do, if you end up taking legal advice do be careful. I have seen disputes get carried away and the solicitors charge far more than the disputed sum.
Most leases will make tenants comply with statute as it develops, but to my mind the legislation relating to EPC does not make it mandatory for the tenant to obtain unless they are marketing the property themselves.
Service Charge clauses do sometimes when the lawyers have been awake have a 'reasonableness' clause in. If you could have obtained it for £400 I think that it would be hard to argue that £6,600 is reasonable.
Whatever you do, if you end up taking legal advice do be careful. I have seen disputes get carried away and the solicitors charge far more than the disputed sum.
Banner said:
I'm pleased. The landlord has agreed to remove the charge for the EPC. However as said above he was trying to charge £6330 for a job that cost £400. Is there an Ombudsman I can report him to? He may be adding a profit to other charges too.
Well done. As regards the other charges, there is no "ombudsman" as such if these are tenancies entered-into outside of the landlord and tenant act - is yours one such tenancy? Basically the contract / tenancy agreement is everything, apart from the usual common-law principles of fair dealing, rasonableness, honesty, and so on.So, the most important thing is this (once again): what does your tenancy agreement say? If it says, for instance, that the landlord may charge such expenses as he reasonably incurs, you should have a right to ask for a detailed breakdown of those costs (and possibly to evidence, too) to support his contention that such charges are reasonable.
If you can, copy/paste the relevant clauses up here and I'll let you know what I think.
Banner said:
The lease is within the Landlord & Tenant Act.
In terms of service charges I have only a paper copy. It would take too long to type out fully. Could I scan it and email you?
Hi. Sorry for the delay. You could indeed do that. I'll send you a PM with an email address to use - please don't just PM me through here otherwise the nasty email filters will probably eat it In terms of service charges I have only a paper copy. It would take too long to type out fully. Could I scan it and email you?

Rgds
Gassing Station | Business | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


