Estate Agents stuff...
Estate Agents stuff...
Author
Discussion

pontypool

Original Poster:

615 posts

270 months

Tuesday 4th August 2009
quotequote all
I had my house for sale last summer but took it off the market in the October having written and given 4 weeks notice to cancel the instruction to the estate agent (who was sole agency)...

However, recently the agent called up and said "hello, we have someone that might like your house, can we bring them round for a look?" - so round they came and have made an offer.

As the agent is not under contract is there any obligation for me to give them a fee - especially if I contacted the buyer personally and left out the agent all together? At no point in the informal process over the last couple of weeks has anyone mentioned a fee or contract or what might happen if a sale went through......

touching cloth

11,706 posts

270 months

Tuesday 4th August 2009
quotequote all
It will depend upon the initial contract you had with them, more than likely it will cover them for a sale also at a later date to any buyer they themselves have introduced. Ultimately however, they have done their job so why would you not want to pay them?

bonsai

2,015 posts

211 months

Tuesday 4th August 2009
quotequote all
Go back through your contract with a fine tooth comb. I can pretty much guarantee they will have sewn this up in the sole selling rights - something along the lines of.




The Client will be liable to pay remuneration to the Agent, in addition to any other costs or charges agreed, in each of the following circumstances:

if a purchaser first introduced by the Agent goes on to buy the property (whether or not through another agent), in circumstances where that purchaser was introduced less than six months after the date this agreement ended.




If they find out, they will sue you and they will win. Your only hope is to do it craftily enough that they don't cotton on. This will be hard now that an offer has been made (presumably via them)

Edited by bonsai on Tuesday 4th August 11:20

pontypool

Original Poster:

615 posts

270 months

Tuesday 4th August 2009
quotequote all
just want to know the leaglities - I totally appreciate they would be owed something for the previous effort and would not proceed without giving them something, but on the basis of what I feel their contribution is worth and not based on what we agreed on to sell in the "boom"

pontypool

Original Poster:

615 posts

270 months

Tuesday 4th August 2009
quotequote all
Interestingly have reviewed the contract over and over this morning but nowhere does it mention anyhting about "if we introduce......"

and the cancellation was well in excess of 6 months ago

Plotloss

67,280 posts

301 months

Tuesday 4th August 2009
quotequote all
If it gets legal and it probably will, consider the reasonable impartial party view of the situation.

Would you have had the offer without the agent introducing them to you?

No.

So they've earnt a fee by any reasonable definition, even in lieu of a contract covering the time of the introduction.

What the fee is I would suggest is open to an element of negotiation though.

Tiggsy

10,261 posts

283 months

Tuesday 4th August 2009
quotequote all
Bit scummy to try and rip off the bloke taht sold your house isnt it? Whats the next post.."is it ok to take my lightbulbs when i move out"

pugwash4x4

7,684 posts

252 months

Tuesday 4th August 2009
quotequote all
You have accepted an offer which you wouldn't have been able to do without this agents intervention- surely you'd be happy to pay them for the work?

unless of course you agreed a silly fee in the first place- i would have thought 1-1.25% would have been fair,

pontypool

Original Poster:

615 posts

270 months

Tuesday 4th August 2009
quotequote all
the original fee was 2% + vat which I feel is quite strong and hence wanted to know where the land lies..


touching cloth

11,706 posts

270 months

Tuesday 4th August 2009
quotequote all
pontypool said:
I had my house for sale last summer but took it off the market in the October
pontypool said:
not based on what we agreed on to sell in the "boom"
I am not sure I would call last summer the boom, apart from anything else it would have sold surely?
Rates have been on the rise during the downturn, harder sales = more work = bigger fees (not to mention less turnover meaning they need to make more per transaction). Having said that I do think 2% is quite strong even for now let alone last year, you would have got 1% in what was the real boom time. Now I think around 1.5% is fair and anything under is good. If you haven't accepted yet then it would be fair to open the rate discussion in conjunction with possible acceptance of the offer. i.e I can sell at that price if the fee is 1.25% but can't if it's still 2% - realistically they haven't had to do much with yours this time so it's still money in the bank for them now.

JCB123

2,265 posts

227 months

Tuesday 4th August 2009
quotequote all
I may be way off the mark - but the estate agent may have arranged for a phantom viewer to show you that they now have interest in your house and that you should put it back on the market with them.....it happens!

touching cloth

11,706 posts

270 months

Tuesday 4th August 2009
quotequote all
Are you suggesting it's a phantom offer also then, cos that's pretty serious and I doubt they would be so bold.

jas xjr

11,309 posts

270 months

Tuesday 4th August 2009
quotequote all
touching cloth said:
Are you suggesting it's a phantom offer also then, cos that's pretty serious and I doubt they would be so bold.
i have had an estate agent inform me of two phantom offers, funnily enough at the full asking price. they are not to be trusted

touching cloth

11,706 posts

270 months

Tuesday 4th August 2009
quotequote all
Maybe I am being naive or stupid, but what do they seek to gain from putting phantom asking price offers forward to a vendor?

jas xjr

11,309 posts

270 months

Tuesday 4th August 2009
quotequote all
touching cloth said:
Maybe I am being naive or stupid, but what do they seek to gain from putting phantom asking price offers forward to a vendor?
maybe stops the vendor seeking a better agent maybe? both offers were at the full asking price and both were withdrawn within a week. they did manage to sell the property but seemed to be acting for the buyer rather than me on occasion. i accepted a below asking price offer on the basis that i would not reduce the price, no matter what was unearthed on survey. agent called and said ,right the survey is in and...i stopped him there and reminded him of my conditional acceptance. went through in the end

soxboy

7,574 posts

250 months

Tuesday 4th August 2009
quotequote all
pugwash4x4 said:
You have accepted an offer which you wouldn't have been able to do without this agents intervention- surely you'd be happy to pay them for the work?

unless of course you agreed a silly fee in the first place- i would have thought 1-1.25% would have been fair,
Agreed. The alternative is that somebody could have walked into their branch, asked for a house that matched your criteria but they may not have had on your books and they could have said 'sorry, haven't got any, goodbye'.

Instead they were a little more creative, remembered your house from before and had the courtesy to call you up to introduce a purchaser. I would be minded to pay a full fee if they can get a decent price for you, say over and above what you may be expecting in this market, otherwise it's a case of negotiation.

TimCrighton

996 posts

247 months

Wednesday 5th August 2009
quotequote all
Absoutely, and perhaps the applicant remembered your house being on the market - we've done that before, gone in to the agent, said "I know you had XXXX on the market a while ago, what happened to it, did it sell?" it transpired it didn't and we asked if they would mind contacting the vendor and asking if we could view. We did and the agent was great about it, shame the vendor wasn't going to be realistic on price (the market had moved significantly in the interim and we couldn't agree on a figure), but it was worth seeing.

And for what its worth you would certainly be liable for a fee, as by permitting a viewing through the agent you effectively created a client/agent relationship. In case law terms you'd be liable for a fee, which may be based on that you've priorly agreed - however it might be worth talking to them about it. 2% is not unusual for a 'good' agent - ie a Strutt & Parker/Savills/Knight Frank or a good independent.

pontypool

Original Poster:

615 posts

270 months

Wednesday 5th August 2009
quotequote all
Thanks for your input Tim, sounds like you know what you're talking about...

If it all went ahead then if we could all agree on a 1% fee then it might be fair to everyone.

C Lee Farquar

4,239 posts

247 months

Wednesday 5th August 2009
quotequote all
You seem to assume that their costs should be reduced because your introduction was straightforward, but they have substantial costs in running the business that enabled them to find your buyer. On top of that they have shown initiative and salesmanship, which let's face it is rare these days. You should pay the 2% and a bonus to the person who did the deal. Any negotiation should have been done when they suggested they introduce a buyer.