Mortgage renewal..any advice
Mortgage renewal..any advice
Author
Discussion

KevF

Original Poster:

1,996 posts

229 months

Thursday 6th August 2009
quotequote all

My fixed rate mortgage is due for renewal in the middle of September, I gues now would be the time to start shopping around.
Did have a mortgage advisor but he has shut up shop.

Anyone got recommendations or is there a PH'er that is currently an advisor?

Landlord

12,689 posts

288 months

Thursday 6th August 2009
quotequote all
Have a chat with PHer scotal

maser_spyder

6,356 posts

213 months

Thursday 6th August 2009
quotequote all
KevF said:
My fixed rate mortgage is due for renewal in the middle of September, I gues now would be the time to start shopping around.
Did have a mortgage advisor but he has shut up shop.

Anyone got recommendations or is there a PH'er that is currently an advisor?
Hey Kev,

Don't know any brokers, sorry, but be careful with this.

We looked to re-mortgaging at the end of some deals on our properties, only to find a new mortgage was going to work out more expensive than the standard variable rate on the existing one, even though discounts had ended. Once you added fees on (which have gone up A LOT), the overall cost would have gone up a lot more than just staying on SVR.

Obviously a broker won't tell you that, as they're looking to earn their fee on a new deal.

If you're looking for a long term fixed, then it's probably worth looking now, rates certainly aren't going to go much lower than they are currently.

I'm paying 1.09% on a couple of mine (.59 over base) at the moment, which is far, far cheaper than a new deal. We're making over-payments like crazy whilst the rates are so good!

KevF

Original Poster:

1,996 posts

229 months

Thursday 6th August 2009
quotequote all
Cheers for that.

Looking to get new mortgage with the intention of paying off 50% maybe in a year or twos time. So would it be advisable to go with a fixed mortgage again for say 2 years.
When the funds become available, if the 2 years fixed rate hasnt finished, I could invest the funds until the period has ended. I guess, otherwise Id be hit with a penalty for paying a lump sum off.


cannedheat

953 posts

306 months

Thursday 6th August 2009
quotequote all
KevF said:
Cheers for that.

Looking to get new mortgage with the intention of paying off 50% maybe in a year or twos time. So would it be advisable to go with a fixed mortgage again for say 2 years.
When the funds become available, if the 2 years fixed rate hasnt finished, I could invest the funds until the period has ended. I guess, otherwise Id be hit with a penalty for paying a lump sum off.
What's the standard variable rate for your current mortgage provider??

quyen

592 posts

225 months

Monday 10th August 2009
quotequote all
maser_spyder said:
I'm paying 1.09% on a couple of mine (.59 over base) at the moment, which is far, far cheaper than a new deal. We're making over-payments like crazy whilst the rates are so good!
Unless you can't find anything else to do with your money that will give you a better return than 1.09%, I can't understand why you would want to make overpayments in this situation.

If someone were to offer me money at a rate of 1.09%, I would take as much money off them as I can and would certaintly not want to return any of it while I can get 4%-5% from a saving account!

KevF

Original Poster:

1,996 posts

229 months

Monday 10th August 2009
quotequote all


Well, current dal runs out end of September. Currently its 5.75% but if I do nothing it will go to 7.45%.
First direct will renew on a new deal at 6.48% fixed over three years.

On shopping around I have found these:

3 yr tracker of 2.49% above base (2.99%) £995 added, and free legals monthly payment .

Offset lifetime tracker 2.97% £1499 added £200 cashback,

2 yr fix 3.98% £896 added, £99 upfront,

3 yr fix 4.78% 896 added £99 upfront,

4 yr fix 5.09% £1050 added £430upfront £200 cashback,

Think I will choose between the tracker ones. Still waiting to hear what the penalties are if I want to pay off a lump sum though...





Think

maser_spyder

6,356 posts

213 months

Monday 10th August 2009
quotequote all
quyen said:
maser_spyder said:
I'm paying 1.09% on a couple of mine (.59 over base) at the moment, which is far, far cheaper than a new deal. We're making over-payments like crazy whilst the rates are so good!
Unless you can't find anything else to do with your money that will give you a better return than 1.09%, I can't understand why you would want to make overpayments in this situation.

If someone were to offer me money at a rate of 1.09%, I would take as much money off them as I can and would certaintly not want to return any of it while I can get 4%-5% from a saving account!
Because this is a long term investment.

I already have investment in my own businesses, my properties are a long term investment, and given the cost of borrowing is so low, it's a perfect time to pay off the capital. Rents haven't gone down, just the cost of borrowing. Ultimately, we're going to have to pay for these cheap interest rates at some point, and rents won't catch up with borrowing costs quickly when the tide turns.

Basically, I would rather be gearing my portfolio at 50% with interest rates at 10% (which at some point they're going to have to be), I don't want to end up with mortgage payments far in excess of the rent.

If you're running this from a 'bankers' point of view, you're absolutely right, you should be using 'cheap' money to invest elsewhere, however, this is exactly the sort of behaviour that got everybody in to this mess in the first place. I'm not interested in cheap money, I don't need it. I would rather own my portfolio outright in a shorter time, and with interest rates being so low, this is the best time to do it.

You think my money is safer with an Icelandic bank or AIG? And when I need it back to reduce my mortgage interest payments, you think I'll still be able to access it?.... The capital is safer where it is!

I totally appreciate that you can make 5% (!!) in a savings account, however, I already have a whole lot more money in my own businesses that makes over 400% a year at the moment, my properties simply aren't run that way.

And show me a savings account at 5%!

maser_spyder

6,356 posts

213 months

Monday 10th August 2009
quotequote all
KevF said:
if I do nothing it will go to 7.45%
yikes

6.95% over base!!!!!!

Flipping 'eck, I bet they're hoping you don't leave....

Given you can't get much worse than that, I think any deal would do!

From all the figures coming out, it's probably fair to say rates aren't going to go up significantly for a year or two at least, then will more than likely start to pick up a pace (maybe with a change of government?) rather quickly.

I would certainly be surprised if base rate isn't 10% in the next 2-3 years, so might be worth looking at a long term fixed rate. I doubt a short term fix is going to make much difference given the state of things at the moment, and the lack of 'real' good news.

As is always the way, simply nobody knows, just make sure it's something you're happy with now, and if it turns out to be the wrong decision, you can hardly kick yourself later!

SJobson

13,916 posts

295 months

Monday 10th August 2009
quotequote all
maser_spyder said:
given the cost of borrowing is so low, it's a perfect time to pay off the capital.
Sorry, I don't understand this - surely the time to pay off capital is when interest rates are high. If it costs you nothing to borrow then use the capital for something which makes you money. Or at least keep it safe elsewhere because you'll then always have it available to pay off some capital later.

Mortgagees are not reknowned for giving you back your overpayments if you need them later.

maser_spyder

6,356 posts

213 months

Monday 10th August 2009
quotequote all
SJobson said:
maser_spyder said:
given the cost of borrowing is so low, it's a perfect time to pay off the capital.
Sorry, I don't understand this - surely the time to pay off capital is when interest rates are high. If it costs you nothing to borrow then use the capital for something which makes you money. Or at least keep it safe elsewhere because you'll then always have it available to pay off some capital later.

Mortgagees are not reknowned for giving you back your overpayments if you need them later.
Yes, sure, but I have a regular income from tenants, the interest is a tiny fraction of the rent, so I use the rest of the rent to pay off the mortgage.

I know, technically, I should take this extra cash and put it in a higher interest account, (as you say, keep it safe elsewhere) but where do you put it? Who do you trust? AIG? Lloyds shares? Kaupthing? Allan Stanford? Bernard Madoff?

Quite simply, it's better off, and safer, going off the capital.

I already explained, my properties are a small part of my entire business interests, I already have lots invested elsewhere earning me around 400% a year, I simply don't need to put a few quid extra from rental income in to an account that makes me an extra few hundred pounds a year. Simply, I don't need the money for the risk involved.

I would rather my properties are 'safe' investments, that I own outright. They are ultimately my backup for everything else.

As with all my investing, I spread it thin, keep equity everywhere possible, and if one or two things fail, you have something to fall back on elsewhere.

My properties are just one of my safety nets, so the sooner I own them all outright, the better.

It may not be to your liking, and may not be the normal way of investing, but it's safe, if not completely efficient. And quite simply for this investment, I don't need efficiency, I need safety.


I have other assets with a completely different view on though....


Edited by maser_spyder on Monday 10th August 23:54

quyen

592 posts

225 months

Tuesday 11th August 2009
quotequote all
maser_spyder said:
show me a savings account at 5%!
Cahoot 18 Month Fixed Rate Bond 4%
Nationwide 5 Year e-Bond 4.96%

http://www.moneysupermarket.com/savings/

maser_spyder said:
If you're running this from a 'bankers' point of view, you're absolutely right, you should be using 'cheap' money to invest elsewhere
I agree


maser_spyder said:
however, this is exactly the sort of behaviour that got everybody in to this mess in the first place.
I disagree, the problem that you mentioned is related to borrowing cheap money short-term and lending long-term. When the cheap short-term money dried up, the bank could not fund the long-term lending.

Your mortgage is a longterm loan and seem very cheap to me (Base+0.59%). Your position is very different to that of Northern Rock e.t.c!

maser_spyder said:
I'm not interested in cheap money, I don't need it.
OK. All I am saying is that if I did have access to cheap money at 1.09%, I would be able to make almost risk free profit by investing it in a fix term saving bond as listed above. If I had a business and needed to borrow money to set it up / run it, then I would want to borrow at the cheapest rate possible.

maser_spyder said:
I would rather own my portfolio outright in a shorter time
I would argue that the best way to do this would be to invest the "overpayment" money elsewhere at more than 1.09%. For example in the fixed term saving bonds listed above or your own business (but of course at greater risk). The overpayment invested in this way will accumulate to the required capital value faster than if you had used it to pay off the mortage.

maser_spyder said:
You think my money is safer with an Icelandic bank or AIG? And when I need it back to reduce my mortgage interest payments, you think I'll still be able to access it?.... The capital is safer where it is!
Cahoot is owned by Santander and the Nationwide is the biggest building society in the UK. They are not risk free but are safe enough for me.

maser_spyder said:
I totally appreciate that you can make 5% (!!) in a savings account, however, I already have a whole lot more money in my own businesses that makes over 400% a year at the moment, my properties simply aren't run that way.
It sounds like you have much bigger fishes to fry then making a few pennies from investing your overpayment money elsewhere to make more than the 1.09% return that you are currently getting.

maser_spyder

6,356 posts

213 months

Tuesday 11th August 2009
quotequote all
quyen said:
maser_spyder said:
show me a savings account at 5%!
Cahoot 18 Month Fixed Rate Bond 4%
Nationwide 5 Year e-Bond 4.96%

http://www.moneysupermarket.com/savings/
Good good, but 5 year bond, and rates will go up before then, and I would need the capital back to reduce gearing....
quyen said:
maser_spyder said:
If you're running this from a 'bankers' point of view, you're absolutely right, you should be using 'cheap' money to invest elsewhere
I agree
quyen said:
maser_spyder said:
however, this is exactly the sort of behaviour that got everybody in to this mess in the first place.
I disagree, the problem that you mentioned is related to borrowing cheap money short-term and lending long-term. When the cheap short-term money dried up, the bank could not fund the long-term lending.

Your mortgage is a longterm loan and seem very cheap to me (Base+0.59%). Your position is very different to that of Northern Rock e.t.c!
Sure, but I meant more about financial trickery (albeit very simple in this case), in effectively robbing Peter to pay Paul. Capital in B&M is fairly safe in the UK.

quyen said:
maser_spyder said:
I'm not interested in cheap money, I don't need it.
OK. All I am saying is that if I did have access to cheap money at 1.09%, I would be able to make almost risk free profit by investing it in a fix term saving bond as listed above. If I had a business and needed to borrow money to set it up / run it, then I would want to borrow at the cheapest rate possible.
Yes, but fixed term means you can't access it to reduce gearing should you need to at an unspecified later date. Anyway, I can make a damned sight more than 4.96% investing in my own businesses if I want to!

quyen said:
maser_spyder said:
I would rather own my portfolio outright in a shorter time
I would argue that the best way to do this would be to invest the "overpayment" money elsewhere at more than 1.09%. For example in the fixed term saving bonds listed above or your own business (but of course at greater risk). The overpayment invested in this way will accumulate to the required capital value faster than if you had used it to pay off the mortage.

maser_spyder said:
You think my money is safer with an Icelandic bank or AIG? And when I need it back to reduce my mortgage interest payments, you think I'll still be able to access it?.... The capital is safer where it is!
Cahoot is owned by Santander and the Nationwide is the biggest building society in the UK. They are not risk free but are safe enough for me.
Yes, but WHERE. You say Santander and Nationwide, but AIG 2 years ago was perceived to be rock solid, as were most of the Icelandic banks until very shortly before they went under. Who's to say?

quyen said:
maser_spyder said:
I totally appreciate that you can make 5% (!!) in a savings account, however, I already have a whole lot more money in my own businesses that makes over 400% a year at the moment, my properties simply aren't run that way.
It sounds like you have much bigger fishes to fry then making a few pennies from investing your overpayment money elsewhere to make more than the 1.09% return that you are currently getting.
Yup, fishes like the big carp in the news this week!

For me, it's not a question of a few dollars and cents, it's a question of risk.

I 'risk' capital in my own business.

I 'risk' capital in assets.

I have no desire to 'risk' more capital in investing with troublesome banks that may, or may not return my capital at the end of a long period. For me, property is a backup for other interests, I would rather forego a few hundred poonts a year in lost interest from investing with fixed term bonds that don't have instant access, and know that I am increasing my equity in properties that I will soon own outright.

You've made perfectly valid points here, and are absolutely right regarding the most financially astute way of using over-payments, however, it's not for me in this instance. Would probably work for others though, and is good advice.

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 11th August 2009
quotequote all
KevF said:
Cheers for that.

Looking to get new mortgage with the intention of paying off 50% maybe in a year or twos time. So would it be advisable to go with a fixed mortgage again for say 2 years.
When the funds become available, if the 2 years fixed rate hasnt finished, I could invest the funds until the period has ended. I guess, otherwise Id be hit with a penalty for paying a lump sum off.
Don't know what the mortgage/LTV is but if fairly large & you have money doing nothing look at offset mortgages. Fixed rates really aren't that good at the moment(best i found was post office 5 year fix at 4.9%-that deal is long gone). First time i haven't been fixed.

KevF

Original Poster:

1,996 posts

229 months

Tuesday 11th August 2009
quotequote all
Dave,

I agree, if the lump sum was available now, then I would pay it off. Unfortunately, it will not come to me for around 1-2 years time.

I am with you in that, this will be the first time I havent gone for a fixed rate mortgage........


Kev

SJobson

13,916 posts

295 months

Tuesday 11th August 2009
quotequote all
maser_spyder said:
Yes, sure, but I have a regular income from tenants, the interest is a tiny fraction of the rent, so I use the rest of the rent to pay off the mortgage.
That's not very tax efficient then - you can only offset the mortgage interest against the rent, not any capital repayments.

Not teaching you how to suck eggs here, but your risk aversion doesn't sound terribly efficient.

maser_spyder

6,356 posts

213 months

Tuesday 11th August 2009
quotequote all
SJobson said:
maser_spyder said:
Yes, sure, but I have a regular income from tenants, the interest is a tiny fraction of the rent, so I use the rest of the rent to pay off the mortgage.
That's not very tax efficient then - you can only offset the mortgage interest against the rent, not any capital repayments.

Not teaching you how to suck eggs here, but your risk aversion doesn't sound terribly efficient.
But I have large income elsewhere, my income from property is tiny in comparison. There's also a lot less risk in investing in how I know, than letting some spotty London public schoolboy loose with my millions.

And who said I'm in the UK and pay tax? wink

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 11th August 2009
quotequote all
KevF said:
Dave,

I agree, if the lump sum was available now, then I would pay it off. Unfortunately, it will not come to me for around 1-2 years time.

I am with you in that, this will be the first time I havent gone for a fixed rate mortgage........


Kev
Arhh sorry, i must admit i skeeted through the thread & thought you had the ££ now but didn't want to spend it just yet(so offset was ideal as you still have the ££ but it earns it's keep!)

Shed_Jensen

128 posts

258 months

Tuesday 11th August 2009
quotequote all
Try Natwest of all people - they have a fixed for 2/2.5yrs at 3.44% I think. Best I could find when looking 4-6wks ago. 75% LTV limit though I think...

Cheers,

Steve

JMT1

60 posts

254 months

Tuesday 11th August 2009
quotequote all
KevF said:
Well, current dal runs out end of September. Currently its 5.75% but if I do nothing it will go to 7.45%.
First direct will renew on a new deal at 6.48% fixed over three years.

On shopping around I have found these:

3 yr tracker of 2.49% above base (2.99%) £995 added, and free legals monthly payment .

Offset lifetime tracker 2.97% £1499 added £200 cashback,

2 yr fix 3.98% £896 added, £99 upfront,

3 yr fix 4.78% 896 added £99 upfront,

4 yr fix 5.09% £1050 added £430upfront £200 cashback,

Think I will choose between the tracker ones. Still waiting to hear what the penalties are if I want to pay off a lump sum though...





Think
7.45%! Where have you got this figure from? and are you currently with First Direct?
If you got the figure from the original Key Facts Illustration, it may be that this was the Standard Variable Rate AT THAT TIME. If so, you may find that you'll drop down onto something much more attractive, with no penalties or fees to pay...worth checking the paperwork/making a phone call to your current provider to check what the CURRENT rate is that you would revert to...