Why do commercial rents remain so high?
Discussion
I've just been looking at various commercial properties in my area, these are units that have been empty for the last couple of years, and although there are incentives available the asking rents remain just as high as they were two years ago. Why do the owners prefer that their properties remain empty, rather than reduce the asking rent?
I believe the same problem afflicts the high streets of many towns- rents are too high, the business rates are a fixed proportion of these, and so there are large numbers of empty shops. Do the laws of supply and demand not mean anything to the landlords of these properties?
I believe the same problem afflicts the high streets of many towns- rents are too high, the business rates are a fixed proportion of these, and so there are large numbers of empty shops. Do the laws of supply and demand not mean anything to the landlords of these properties?
^^^ what he said 
It is a bit of a false premise though. If you value properly to take account of the reduction in rent and incentives given away to attract a tenant, then you are still going to see a reduction in value. Someone has just signed up in the City for a big chunk of space on a 15 year lease with a 4 or 5 year rent free period. Anyway you look at it that has got to hurt, but landlords don't want to admit their properties have gone down in value anymore than you or I want to admit that our houses are worth less than they used to be.

It is a bit of a false premise though. If you value properly to take account of the reduction in rent and incentives given away to attract a tenant, then you are still going to see a reduction in value. Someone has just signed up in the City for a big chunk of space on a 15 year lease with a 4 or 5 year rent free period. Anyway you look at it that has got to hurt, but landlords don't want to admit their properties have gone down in value anymore than you or I want to admit that our houses are worth less than they used to be.
Whereabouts are you?
Only in the West End and the City markets have there been massive falls in rents. Outside of these areas rents never rose the same way that they did in the city so have come off less. (i'm referring to the office market).
Are these the rents being quoted, or what they are actually prepared to do a deal at?
If the propertys are owned by big landlords, they won't want to do a deal at a low rent as this will crystallise any paper loss they have. This will result in the value of that asset being reduced. People will then look at their other assets and assume that their paper values for those assets should also be redued by the same amount. This could cause serious issues if it leads to them breaching their banking covenants.
So whilst it might seem ridiculous, there's a bigger picture they're concerned with.
If the units are owned by small investors, they are more likely to be feeling the pinch and will be more likely to do a deal.
Only in the West End and the City markets have there been massive falls in rents. Outside of these areas rents never rose the same way that they did in the city so have come off less. (i'm referring to the office market).
Are these the rents being quoted, or what they are actually prepared to do a deal at?
If the propertys are owned by big landlords, they won't want to do a deal at a low rent as this will crystallise any paper loss they have. This will result in the value of that asset being reduced. People will then look at their other assets and assume that their paper values for those assets should also be redued by the same amount. This could cause serious issues if it leads to them breaching their banking covenants.
So whilst it might seem ridiculous, there's a bigger picture they're concerned with.
If the units are owned by small investors, they are more likely to be feeling the pinch and will be more likely to do a deal.
Are you looking to rent premises or commenting on the commercial property market?
As has been suggested above, landlords are reluctant to admit that their premises have dropped in rental value and therefore quoting rents will remain at previous levels. There are however plenty of deals to be done out there at present, it's just a case of negotiation. Think of it like a Moroccan souk.
As has been suggested above, landlords are reluctant to admit that their premises have dropped in rental value and therefore quoting rents will remain at previous levels. There are however plenty of deals to be done out there at present, it's just a case of negotiation. Think of it like a Moroccan souk.
There is a one reason for this which hasn't been discussed yet as well, which is that for a lot of institutional landlords or major holders there is a financial reason for leaving a vacant unit.
Frequently portfolio valuations are conducted every year, and yes you are correct in that rents and market conditions have declined over the past year, but for those prop co.'s there debt funding is based on their last valuation, realising a lower value by letting at a reduced rate forces an updated portfolio valuation and thus brings the investment value down - which in the current climate is taking a lot of landlords close to breaking their debt convenants (forcing for some, like SEGRO a rights issue).
Frequently portfolio valuations are conducted every year, and yes you are correct in that rents and market conditions have declined over the past year, but for those prop co.'s there debt funding is based on their last valuation, realising a lower value by letting at a reduced rate forces an updated portfolio valuation and thus brings the investment value down - which in the current climate is taking a lot of landlords close to breaking their debt convenants (forcing for some, like SEGRO a rights issue).
TimCrighton said:
There is a one reason for this which hasn't been discussed yet as well, which is that for a lot of institutional landlords or major holders there is a financial reason for leaving a vacant unit.
Frequently portfolio valuations are conducted every year, and yes you are correct in that rents and market conditions have declined over the past year, but for those prop co.'s there debt funding is based on their last valuation, realising a lower value by letting at a reduced rate forces an updated portfolio valuation and thus brings the investment value down - which in the current climate is taking a lot of landlords close to breaking their debt convenants (forcing for some, like SEGRO a rights issue).
Think i touched on this above. It's certainly the major reason i've seen at the moment for units lying empty.Frequently portfolio valuations are conducted every year, and yes you are correct in that rents and market conditions have declined over the past year, but for those prop co.'s there debt funding is based on their last valuation, realising a lower value by letting at a reduced rate forces an updated portfolio valuation and thus brings the investment value down - which in the current climate is taking a lot of landlords close to breaking their debt convenants (forcing for some, like SEGRO a rights issue).
I'm not looking to rent any other premises at the moment, but it is something I will need to think about in the near-term future. Fortunately my sort of business (kit cars) can be happily run from a farm (as long as the track isn't too bumpy!)
I admit to having had a look on eg property link this morning at some of the places I looked at 2 years ago and the adverts were still pretty much the same, although most of the photos don't show the weeds growing up in front of the entrances.
So it would seem, unless I am misunderstanding, that the rents remain at previous levels for reasons that are paperwork related rather than anything real. I must say I approve of the fact that the owners have to pay business rates on empty premises, goodness knows how many empty units there would be if that wasn't the case.
I admit to having had a look on eg property link this morning at some of the places I looked at 2 years ago and the adverts were still pretty much the same, although most of the photos don't show the weeds growing up in front of the entrances.
So it would seem, unless I am misunderstanding, that the rents remain at previous levels for reasons that are paperwork related rather than anything real. I must say I approve of the fact that the owners have to pay business rates on empty premises, goodness knows how many empty units there would be if that wasn't the case.
EG Property Link isn’t an indicator of what’s going on in the market. You’re simply looking at what rents and terms are being quoted, not what deals are being done. As I assume you’re out of town, rents aren’t coming down that much. If you call the agents on any of the properties you are looking at, they will give you and indication of where the deal lies.
As has been mentioned before though, institutional landlords have a big reason for not letting at a low value. The empty rates legislation is a double edged sword and not a very effective one. The idea behind it was to ensure landbanked properties were let rather than standing idle and to force landlords into accepting lower rents. In reality, landlords are in a catch 22. Either; leave the property empty, fail to pay the empty rates and go bust, or let it cheaply to cover the empty rates, breach the banking covenants and go bust.
Even if either of the above happen, it’s questionable whether the banks will let the property cheaply, they don’t seem to be at the moment, as this would result in them admitting to a loss.
To be honest, it’s all a mess and is going to take quite some time to work through.
As has been mentioned before though, institutional landlords have a big reason for not letting at a low value. The empty rates legislation is a double edged sword and not a very effective one. The idea behind it was to ensure landbanked properties were let rather than standing idle and to force landlords into accepting lower rents. In reality, landlords are in a catch 22. Either; leave the property empty, fail to pay the empty rates and go bust, or let it cheaply to cover the empty rates, breach the banking covenants and go bust.
Even if either of the above happen, it’s questionable whether the banks will let the property cheaply, they don’t seem to be at the moment, as this would result in them admitting to a loss.
To be honest, it’s all a mess and is going to take quite some time to work through.
The way property is valued is, in reality, a shambles. As mentioned above asking rents remain high, Focus (a comparable site used by property agents) is full of deals that are confidential. Its questionable why say yo9u have done a deal when everything about it is confidential! But the only person that benefits from a confidential transaction is the Landlord. The last thing a landlord wants is his other tenants finding out what deals he has done to attract new tenants as that will stuff him at rent review lease renewal time. Equally his interest is in maintaining the headline rent, as, in theory, thats what affects the capital value. So landlords will always quote headline deals as comparables, anyone taking a unit MUST find out what incentives were behind that deal, and they are frequently extensive (even in the days the economy was doing well).
The problem is even worse as most landlords have borrowed money to buy the property, and as indicated if the value of the property drops below the amount borrowed the bank is going to want its money back. However in reality the banks want to help Landlords through this period as if they have to get their money back they will be cristallising their loses in the property world, and the bankswill lose £100s of millions of pounds. So at the moment the rumour is as long as Landlords can pay the interest on a loan, the banks are not looking too heavily into what is going on.
I must admit the requirement to do regular pension fund and property valuations does appear to do no favour to the current crisis. As far as I can see the value f both are cyclical, a drop in share prices is bad for a pension fund, but over time share prices will come back, and the pension fund value increase. Taking emergency action to sort it in an economic crisis only adds to the problems businessses are suffering, and who benefits if a company goes bust because of a pensions black hole which may just be cyclical? The same applies to property, its cyclical, with an added disadvantage that in bad times valuers are aware that anyone they are providing valuations too will, if it goes tits up, be looking to the valuers insurance policy to pay up! Therefore they will be conservative!
So at the end of the day negotiate on rents har, always ensure you speak to other occupiers, and on rent review, lease renewal work with the other occupiers. Ideally you should always appoint a surveyor to help as they should know the market. It is vitally important that you do not just accept a revised rent because the Landlord has dropped the suggested rent 10 or 20%, unless you KNOW its a good deal.
Oh and on a per square foot basis rents on farms are often higher than local industrial estates!
The problem is even worse as most landlords have borrowed money to buy the property, and as indicated if the value of the property drops below the amount borrowed the bank is going to want its money back. However in reality the banks want to help Landlords through this period as if they have to get their money back they will be cristallising their loses in the property world, and the bankswill lose £100s of millions of pounds. So at the moment the rumour is as long as Landlords can pay the interest on a loan, the banks are not looking too heavily into what is going on.
I must admit the requirement to do regular pension fund and property valuations does appear to do no favour to the current crisis. As far as I can see the value f both are cyclical, a drop in share prices is bad for a pension fund, but over time share prices will come back, and the pension fund value increase. Taking emergency action to sort it in an economic crisis only adds to the problems businessses are suffering, and who benefits if a company goes bust because of a pensions black hole which may just be cyclical? The same applies to property, its cyclical, with an added disadvantage that in bad times valuers are aware that anyone they are providing valuations too will, if it goes tits up, be looking to the valuers insurance policy to pay up! Therefore they will be conservative!
So at the end of the day negotiate on rents har, always ensure you speak to other occupiers, and on rent review, lease renewal work with the other occupiers. Ideally you should always appoint a surveyor to help as they should know the market. It is vitally important that you do not just accept a revised rent because the Landlord has dropped the suggested rent 10 or 20%, unless you KNOW its a good deal.
Oh and on a per square foot basis rents on farms are often higher than local industrial estates!
I haven't heard of a new letting forcing a valuation before. I don't this is a common banking covenant, although I deal with multilets.
Most funds are valued annually, half yearly or quarterly for banking purposes (depending on banking agreements), with more frequent valuations sometimes carried out for other purposes, such as unit pricing. Many funds are examining their banking covenants and moving the frequency of valuations to the least frequent allowed - in order to avoid breaching LTV covenants for as long as possible. Many banks don't want to know either, as obviously their LTV issues are also crystalised.
But, that's digressing...
Gross rents have stayed fairly high, but net effective rents (ie, after all incentives have been taken off) have dropped, and continue to. As mentioned earlier, transparancy is a real issue and even when details can be obtained, there are sometimes private side letters which further deviate from the lease.
In the retail property market rents have become very difficult to track, but have dropped substantially. Where perhaps a unit would fetch £100psf deals are now being done at a % of turnover only - how do you compare a turnover deal done to company A to company B? You can't as even the landlords don't really know how much they will receive!
The only reason I have seen for landlords willing to keep properties empty is to maintain the overall rental levels in their other properties (as valuers 'tone' stretches of units such as malls in a shopping centre, based on the latest deals). Aside from longer term asset strategies of course. Of course many landlords will do 'temp lets' which can be at any level, sometimes only covering costs, as these don't get used as evidence for longer term deals.
Empty rates are a massive issue for landlords as they significantly affect values - probably too extremely - but we have to value how the market does, and at the moment the market takes a very dim view of income being washed away by outgoings.
Most funds are valued annually, half yearly or quarterly for banking purposes (depending on banking agreements), with more frequent valuations sometimes carried out for other purposes, such as unit pricing. Many funds are examining their banking covenants and moving the frequency of valuations to the least frequent allowed - in order to avoid breaching LTV covenants for as long as possible. Many banks don't want to know either, as obviously their LTV issues are also crystalised.
But, that's digressing...
Gross rents have stayed fairly high, but net effective rents (ie, after all incentives have been taken off) have dropped, and continue to. As mentioned earlier, transparancy is a real issue and even when details can be obtained, there are sometimes private side letters which further deviate from the lease.
In the retail property market rents have become very difficult to track, but have dropped substantially. Where perhaps a unit would fetch £100psf deals are now being done at a % of turnover only - how do you compare a turnover deal done to company A to company B? You can't as even the landlords don't really know how much they will receive!
The only reason I have seen for landlords willing to keep properties empty is to maintain the overall rental levels in their other properties (as valuers 'tone' stretches of units such as malls in a shopping centre, based on the latest deals). Aside from longer term asset strategies of course. Of course many landlords will do 'temp lets' which can be at any level, sometimes only covering costs, as these don't get used as evidence for longer term deals.
Empty rates are a massive issue for landlords as they significantly affect values - probably too extremely - but we have to value how the market does, and at the moment the market takes a very dim view of income being washed away by outgoings.
Edited by Maxf on Monday 10th August 08:18
Chrisgr31 said:
The problem is even worse as most landlords have borrowed money to buy the property, and as indicated if the value of the property drops below the amount borrowed the bank is going to want its money back. However in reality the banks want to help Landlords through this period as if they have to get their money back they will be cristallising their loses in the property world, and the bankswill lose £100s of millions of pounds. So at the moment the rumour is as long as Landlords can pay the interest on a loan, the banks are not looking too heavily into what is going on.
Absolutely correct. Interest cover is the main issue at the moment. I wouldnt like to speculate how many commercial property loans are currently under water (ie LTV breached) but I would suggest anything bought from 2006 onwards at least, which is a heck of a lot of property. The banks wouldnt want the properties back - they arent property managers and wouldn't know what to do with them. As long as interest is being paid they dont want to rock the boat.
Maxf said:
I haven't heard of a new letting forcing a valuation before. I don't this is a common banking covenant, although I deal with multilets.
Most funds are valued annually, half yearly or quarterly for banking purposes (depending on banking agreements), with more frequent valuations sometimes carried out for other purposes, such as unit pricing. Many funds are examining their banking covenants and moving the frequency of valuations to the least frequent allowed - in order to avoid breaching LTV covenants for as long as possible. Many banks don't want to know either, as obviously their LTV issues are also crystalised.
But, that's digressing...
Gross rents have stayed fairly high, but net effective rents (ie, after all incentives have been taken off) have dropped, and continue to. As mentioned earlier, transparancy is a real issue and even when details can be obtained, there are sometimes private side letters which further deviate from the lease.
In the retail property market rents have become very difficult to track, but have dropped substantially. Where perhaps a unit would fetch £100psf deals are now being done at a % of turnover only - how do you compare a turnover deal done to company A to company B? You can't as even the landlords don't really know how much they will receive!
The only reason I have seen for landlords willing to keep properties empty is to maintain the overall rental levels in their other properties (as valuers 'tone' stretches of units such as malls in a shopping centre, based on the latest deals). Aside from longer term asset strategies of course. Of course many landlords will do 'temp lets' which can be at any level, sometimes only covering costs, as these don't get used as evidence for longer term deals.
Empty rates are a massive issue for landlords as they significantly affect values - probably too extremely - but we have to value how the market does, and at the moment the market takes a very dim view of income being washed away by outgoings.
A new letting may not force a valuation, but will give the valuer an up to date deal on which to base the value. If it is a low deal it will reduce value. For the funds who have to have regular valuations (or even plc occupiers) this will catch up with them quickly.Most funds are valued annually, half yearly or quarterly for banking purposes (depending on banking agreements), with more frequent valuations sometimes carried out for other purposes, such as unit pricing. Many funds are examining their banking covenants and moving the frequency of valuations to the least frequent allowed - in order to avoid breaching LTV covenants for as long as possible. Many banks don't want to know either, as obviously their LTV issues are also crystalised.
But, that's digressing...
Gross rents have stayed fairly high, but net effective rents (ie, after all incentives have been taken off) have dropped, and continue to. As mentioned earlier, transparancy is a real issue and even when details can be obtained, there are sometimes private side letters which further deviate from the lease.
In the retail property market rents have become very difficult to track, but have dropped substantially. Where perhaps a unit would fetch £100psf deals are now being done at a % of turnover only - how do you compare a turnover deal done to company A to company B? You can't as even the landlords don't really know how much they will receive!
The only reason I have seen for landlords willing to keep properties empty is to maintain the overall rental levels in their other properties (as valuers 'tone' stretches of units such as malls in a shopping centre, based on the latest deals). Aside from longer term asset strategies of course. Of course many landlords will do 'temp lets' which can be at any level, sometimes only covering costs, as these don't get used as evidence for longer term deals.
Empty rates are a massive issue for landlords as they significantly affect values - probably too extremely - but we have to value how the market does, and at the moment the market takes a very dim view of income being washed away by outgoings.
Edited by Maxf on Monday 10th August 08:18
In a ideal world valuers should be reflecting the reduced values in any case, but without evidence it can be difficult.
Empty Rates are a red herring. Where a landlord is paying out of their own pocket they can be a massive drain. Equally the funds will pay the rates (or use legal avoidance to minimise them) rather than see the value of their investmens fall be low deals.
davidjpowell said:
Empty Rates are a red herring. Where a landlord is paying out of their own pocket they can be a massive drain. Equally the funds will pay the rates (or use legal avoidance to minimise them) rather than see the value of their investmens fall be low deals.
Values are calculated to 'market value' (sorry if thats teaching egg sucking) which is as the market prices, so complex avoidance schemes are generally avoided (in valuations) as are payments from other accounts. Rates payments which fall to the landlord are generally deducted from the rent roll by valuers - hence the importance in filling the voids as £1m rent becomes £750k rent is there is £250k of empty rates due (however it is paid in practice).
Maxf said:
davidjpowell said:
Empty Rates are a red herring. Where a landlord is paying out of their own pocket they can be a massive drain. Equally the funds will pay the rates (or use legal avoidance to minimise them) rather than see the value of their investmens fall be low deals.
Values are calculated to 'market value' (sorry if thats teaching egg sucking) which is as the market prices, so complex avoidance schemes are generally avoided (in valuations) as are payments from other accounts. Rates payments which fall to the landlord are generally deducted from the rent roll by valuers - hence the importance in filling the voids as £1m rent becomes £750k rent is there is £250k of empty rates due (however it is paid in practice).
In practice though when doing deals, I still find that landlords where they are desperate are doing silly deals, but where it's not hurting the landlord directly they will hold out rather than drop the asking rent.
There is a big argument at the moment about 'value preservation', which rather perversely often means keeping units vacant so as not to agree low evidence vs just doing the deals you can and reducing the general 'feel' of the scheme.
A good example would be a shopping centre keeping a few units vacant (or with temp traders in) vs doing whatever deals they can and being stuck with poundland/poundworld/poundshop in their prime mall. Short term, the numbers work, but less so when the market recovers and you are trying to tempt Arcadia back in!
A good example would be a shopping centre keeping a few units vacant (or with temp traders in) vs doing whatever deals they can and being stuck with poundland/poundworld/poundshop in their prime mall. Short term, the numbers work, but less so when the market recovers and you are trying to tempt Arcadia back in!
Sorry Johnny - I missed that comment - the perils of speed reading a thread!
It is a tricky situation - I'm doing some consultancy for a local authority at the moment dealing with the increasing number of vacant retail units in the old City Centre (pre new retail development on the edge of the city centre with some shed retail next door) which has had to face the pressure of the new retail development and the current climate. The Council are keen to facilitate temporary or philanthropic uses where possible but its tough to convince the landlords and the agents to look at these uses, for the reasons above - but the council don't want to understand the commercial view, and they are obviously, and rightfully concerned with the perception of the City Centre to visitors and residents. Its my first time working within Public Sector and its certainly a change in attitude! Interesting though!
Its good to see all the PH property guys come out of the 'wings'! Should have a PH Property lunch!
It is a tricky situation - I'm doing some consultancy for a local authority at the moment dealing with the increasing number of vacant retail units in the old City Centre (pre new retail development on the edge of the city centre with some shed retail next door) which has had to face the pressure of the new retail development and the current climate. The Council are keen to facilitate temporary or philanthropic uses where possible but its tough to convince the landlords and the agents to look at these uses, for the reasons above - but the council don't want to understand the commercial view, and they are obviously, and rightfully concerned with the perception of the City Centre to visitors and residents. Its my first time working within Public Sector and its certainly a change in attitude! Interesting though!
Its good to see all the PH property guys come out of the 'wings'! Should have a PH Property lunch!
Maxf said:
There is a big argument at the moment about 'value preservation', which rather perversely often means keeping units vacant so as not to agree low evidence vs just doing the deals you can and reducing the general 'feel' of the scheme.
A good example would be a shopping centre keeping a few units vacant (or with temp traders in) vs doing whatever deals they can and being stuck with poundland/poundworld/poundshop in their prime mall. Short term, the numbers work, but less so when the market recovers and you are trying to tempt Arcadia back in!
Mind you the empty rates change was brought in to stop Landlords keeping units empty! Of course it had nothing to do with illing a black hole in public sector finance!A good example would be a shopping centre keeping a few units vacant (or with temp traders in) vs doing whatever deals they can and being stuck with poundland/poundworld/poundshop in their prime mall. Short term, the numbers work, but less so when the market recovers and you are trying to tempt Arcadia back in!
Do the PH valuers really think that values will return to their previous values especially in retail? I can't help but feel that there has been far too much retail development in recent years, and that there are now too many retail units for occupiers. With the proliferation of ineternet shopping, the supermarkets moving in to more and more sectors we are going to find more High Streets turning into a wasteland.
Gassing Station | Business | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


