Internet Sales: Shop at Amazon or Yahoo ?
Discussion
Hi all,
I have noticed that there are some successful internet entrepreneurs here and would appreciate some advice.
I aim to start a second business in the internet.
Starting out I want to keep costs low, utilizing their relatively easy shop building instruments, and benefit from the advantages that, figuratively speaking, renting a shop in a well visited department store can offer when you are still unkown.
Later if things work and I have a name and a customer base a standalone website makes sense, but for now the choice is down between Amazon or Yahoo. (I don't want to do Ebay as I want to offer fixed price products, and also as Ebay seems to be getting quite some bad press lately, and as their visitor numbers seem to be on the way down.)
http://www.kirotv.com/money/20149393/detail.html
So, what would your preference be, Yahoo or Amazon ?
Do you have experience with either or both of them you'd like to share ?
Do you think there are clear advantages of using one over the other, or is it more a question of taste ?
How can I find out not their visitor numbers, but the respective sales of people selling on them, or would those numbers be confidential.
Many many thanks in advance !!!
I have noticed that there are some successful internet entrepreneurs here and would appreciate some advice.
I aim to start a second business in the internet.
Starting out I want to keep costs low, utilizing their relatively easy shop building instruments, and benefit from the advantages that, figuratively speaking, renting a shop in a well visited department store can offer when you are still unkown.
Later if things work and I have a name and a customer base a standalone website makes sense, but for now the choice is down between Amazon or Yahoo. (I don't want to do Ebay as I want to offer fixed price products, and also as Ebay seems to be getting quite some bad press lately, and as their visitor numbers seem to be on the way down.)
http://www.kirotv.com/money/20149393/detail.html
So, what would your preference be, Yahoo or Amazon ?
Do you have experience with either or both of them you'd like to share ?
Do you think there are clear advantages of using one over the other, or is it more a question of taste ?
How can I find out not their visitor numbers, but the respective sales of people selling on them, or would those numbers be confidential.
Many many thanks in advance !!!
A1 said:
I wouldnt rule out ebay matey. We are on ebay, website and amazon. Ebay alone generates a six figuare sum for us and so there are plenty of people buying on ebay. If your price is right and have a great product your on to a winner!
Hi A1, sounds great what you are doing on Ebay, didn't want to put that down, I'm just - at least for now - looking at a fixed price store.Edited by A1 on Monday 10th August 14:29
My plan is to have one homepage with my URL, but rather than hosting and marketing that alone for now it will simply open as a shop on either Amazon or Yahoo.
But so far at least my initial impression seems to be corroborated by the replies, most people associate Amazon with shopping, while yahoo isn't there yet.
So Amazon looking more like it at the moment.
Thanks for all the replies so far, please keep them coming, particularly if you have good or bad experiences to share about selling on Amazon.
Btw, just to round things off, this is Yahoos ecommerce site:
http://smallbusiness.yahoo.com/ecommerce/
hi Maser,
actually I'm in Germany and would like to trade off of either of the Amazons or Yahoos US sites, as in Germany we've got a bit of a situation with freak law firms going on a cease-and-desist rampage for even the silliest of things, it's just how they make their money, going after internet ecommerce sites. Bit of an open legal loophole lawmakers haven't addressed yet.
So, prefer to base it on original US sites if that's possible.
Fees shouldn't be everything if the cheaper shop doesn't generate much traffic, but can make quite a bottom line difference if traffic isn't too different.
A thought on Yahoo as a shop...
Wouldn't they as a search engine drive traffic to you anyway even if people do not think of Yahoo as a shop yet ?
Because their variable transaction fees, ie the fees they charge you for every single product you sell, are much lower than Amazons:
Yahoo depending on volume from 1.5% down to 0.75% per product sold added on.
http://smallbusiness.yahoo.com/ecommerce/plans.php
Amazon charge a whopping 15% selling fee per product as they call it !
http://www.amazonservices.com/content/sell-on-amaz...
Now that is a huge difference.
Fixed Monthly costs on Yahoo go from 40 bucks to 300 depending on sales, Amazon is always a fixed 40 bucks.
Price wise that has Yahoo in front right because the variable costs added to every product will over time make a far greater difference than the slightly higher fixed costs of Yahoo that also only need to go up as your business is growing.
Want to get this right starting out.
actually I'm in Germany and would like to trade off of either of the Amazons or Yahoos US sites, as in Germany we've got a bit of a situation with freak law firms going on a cease-and-desist rampage for even the silliest of things, it's just how they make their money, going after internet ecommerce sites. Bit of an open legal loophole lawmakers haven't addressed yet.
So, prefer to base it on original US sites if that's possible.
Fees shouldn't be everything if the cheaper shop doesn't generate much traffic, but can make quite a bottom line difference if traffic isn't too different.
A thought on Yahoo as a shop...
Wouldn't they as a search engine drive traffic to you anyway even if people do not think of Yahoo as a shop yet ?
Because their variable transaction fees, ie the fees they charge you for every single product you sell, are much lower than Amazons:
Yahoo depending on volume from 1.5% down to 0.75% per product sold added on.
http://smallbusiness.yahoo.com/ecommerce/plans.php
Amazon charge a whopping 15% selling fee per product as they call it !
http://www.amazonservices.com/content/sell-on-amaz...
Now that is a huge difference.
Fixed Monthly costs on Yahoo go from 40 bucks to 300 depending on sales, Amazon is always a fixed 40 bucks.
Price wise that has Yahoo in front right because the variable costs added to every product will over time make a far greater difference than the slightly higher fixed costs of Yahoo that also only need to go up as your business is growing.
Want to get this right starting out.
Dash928 said:
A1 said:
I wouldnt rule out ebay matey. We are on ebay, website and amazon. Ebay alone generates a six figuare sum for us and so there are plenty of people buying on ebay. If your price is right and have a great product your on to a winner!
Hi A1, sounds great what you are doing on Ebay, didn't want to put that down, I'm just - at least for now - looking at a fixed price store.Edited by A1 on Monday 10th August 14:29
I buy the majority of my purchases via the internet so can give some general feedback.
If I was looking for an item I would not look at yahoo (wasn't aware they had shops), definately ebay and possibly amazon (although I still view amazon the same as I did 5 or so years ago when you had to pay loads for postage). If I was looking to buy a CD/DVD/Video game/ Blu Ray I always look at the play traders on play.com as have got some big bargains of late from them.
If I was looking for an item I would not look at yahoo (wasn't aware they had shops), definately ebay and possibly amazon (although I still view amazon the same as I did 5 or so years ago when you had to pay loads for postage). If I was looking to buy a CD/DVD/Video game/ Blu Ray I always look at the play traders on play.com as have got some big bargains of late from them.
Hi guys,
Dave, yup, I do see your point and think that makes sense, but I suppose the main reason I think going to a shop vs just going it alone is that imo it will be easier - at least at the start -driving traffic to your site if you have a strong partner.
Take a site like www.usaveontime.com that goes on to open in a Ebay store.
(No connection whatsoever with me btw, just as an example).
Only found him because I was searching for something on Ebay, don't think I would have found him through a search engine alone.
Now he can build a business there, build a customer base, and then maybe one day do both, ie sell via his own web page and via ebay etc.
Abloke, yes, I am aware of Ebay doing fixed price stores these days as well. Ebay seem to have quite some support here, so should maybe have another closer look at them as well.
What I like with Amazon I guess is that buyers have 100% guarantees, that they take care of credit card sales etc, will pack and ship for you, stuff like that, but prio number for me is the total safety for buyers which seems to be a nice value added feature.
Bullet, very true, no, it's definitely not a unique product, so I do realize it will be marketing, price and service that makes the difference.
Thanks fro feedback so far.
:-)
Great site this.
Dave, yup, I do see your point and think that makes sense, but I suppose the main reason I think going to a shop vs just going it alone is that imo it will be easier - at least at the start -driving traffic to your site if you have a strong partner.
Take a site like www.usaveontime.com that goes on to open in a Ebay store.
(No connection whatsoever with me btw, just as an example).
Only found him because I was searching for something on Ebay, don't think I would have found him through a search engine alone.
Now he can build a business there, build a customer base, and then maybe one day do both, ie sell via his own web page and via ebay etc.
Abloke, yes, I am aware of Ebay doing fixed price stores these days as well. Ebay seem to have quite some support here, so should maybe have another closer look at them as well.
What I like with Amazon I guess is that buyers have 100% guarantees, that they take care of credit card sales etc, will pack and ship for you, stuff like that, but prio number for me is the total safety for buyers which seems to be a nice value added feature.
Bullet, very true, no, it's definitely not a unique product, so I do realize it will be marketing, price and service that makes the difference.
Thanks fro feedback so far.
:-)
Great site this.
Mx, specialty stores, makes sense too.
Ebay fees aren't exactly low either are they for stores:
Fixed subscription fees from $ 16 to 300 month depending on what you want.
plus
Insertion fees that come up new every 30 days of from 0.03 to 0.1 $ per listing.
plus
[b]Final value fee
Item not sold
No fee
$1.00 - $25.00
12.00% of the closing price
$25.01 - $100.00
12.00% of the initial $25.00 ($3.00), plus 8.00% of the remaining closing value balance
$100.01 - $1,000.00
12.00% of the initial $25.00 ($3.00), plus 8.00% of the initial $25.01 – $100.00 ($6.00), plus 4.00% of the remaining closing value balance $100.01 – $1,000.00
Over $1,000.01
12.00% of the initial $25.00 ($3.00), plus 8.00% of the initial $25.01 – $100.00 ($6.00), plus 4.00% of the initial $100.01 – $1,000.00 ($36.00), plus 2.00% of the remaining closing value balance ($1,000.01-closing value).[/b]
http://pages.ebay.com/help/sell/storefees.html
Ebay fees aren't exactly low either are they for stores:
Fixed subscription fees from $ 16 to 300 month depending on what you want.
plus
Insertion fees that come up new every 30 days of from 0.03 to 0.1 $ per listing.
plus
[b]Final value fee
Item not sold
No fee
$1.00 - $25.00
12.00% of the closing price
$25.01 - $100.00
12.00% of the initial $25.00 ($3.00), plus 8.00% of the remaining closing value balance
$100.01 - $1,000.00
12.00% of the initial $25.00 ($3.00), plus 8.00% of the initial $25.01 – $100.00 ($6.00), plus 4.00% of the remaining closing value balance $100.01 – $1,000.00
Over $1,000.01
12.00% of the initial $25.00 ($3.00), plus 8.00% of the initial $25.01 – $100.00 ($6.00), plus 4.00% of the initial $100.01 – $1,000.00 ($36.00), plus 2.00% of the remaining closing value balance ($1,000.01-closing value).[/b]
http://pages.ebay.com/help/sell/storefees.html
Edited by Dash928 on Tuesday 11th August 13:59
Dash928 said:
in Germany we've got a bit of a situation with freak law firms going on a cease-and-desist rampage for even the silliest of things, it's just how they make their money, going after internet ecommerce sites. Bit of an open legal loophole lawmakers haven't addressed yet.
You couldn't do me a favour and elaborate on this a little?I'll then reply with my uninformed, unreliable, ad-hoc 'reckon' on your store (for what it's worth)

Hi Maser,
terribly sorry for the very late reply.
Situation is basically that we have a lot of consumer protection laws here, and originally it was mainly competitors suing you if you broke existing laws.
That part was OK.
Eg you couldn't go selling some dubious powder and in your advertisements claim that your product was going to rejuvenate and shave years off your age while also reducing your weight without getting someone coming after you with a cease and desist order which always comes accompanied by a hefty legal bill thats payable unless the accusation was unfounded.
Ignore the cease and desist order and you get sued.
But once law firms figured out that they don't really need to wait for your competitors to push cease and desist orders they went a bit wild.
Get small stuff wrong, even inadvertently, like not including postage fees with your price offer and they'll come after you, or leave out VAT, etc.
I mean even that part is still understandable, if I was a consumer I'd also want to know what the total price is straight away, and not have the occasional nasty awakening like with the cheap airlines we have here these days, where they lure you in with one price, but at the end of the day what with fees for this and fees for that you end up paying sthg totally different.
Get any part wrong that details your buyers rights, including detailed info on how long they'll have to wait for products - out of your hand if you're drop shipping say - or your impressum, or guarantees, or customers rights to give products back, or get the general terms and conditions (German AGB) wrong, which in turn are constantly being changed due to court decisions, and you're liable to be at the receiving end of a cease and desist order and legal bill, so it's all a bit of a mine field right now.
The original intention was good, protect consumer rights, but the system is being abused by lawyers that found a way to make some extremelly easy money.
The federal government and lawmakers here are aware of the abuse, and I should expect that in the next legislative period we'll start seeing some improvements, but at the moment for these reasons I'd prefer selling not in Germany, but elswhere on the web.
Doesn't that make sense anyway, trying to sell in as big a marketplace as possible ?
Why just limit yourself to your own country if you can sell to the world at no additional cost because thats what the web allows one to do right ?
Looking forward to your reply.
terribly sorry for the very late reply.
Situation is basically that we have a lot of consumer protection laws here, and originally it was mainly competitors suing you if you broke existing laws.
That part was OK.
Eg you couldn't go selling some dubious powder and in your advertisements claim that your product was going to rejuvenate and shave years off your age while also reducing your weight without getting someone coming after you with a cease and desist order which always comes accompanied by a hefty legal bill thats payable unless the accusation was unfounded.
Ignore the cease and desist order and you get sued.
But once law firms figured out that they don't really need to wait for your competitors to push cease and desist orders they went a bit wild.
Get small stuff wrong, even inadvertently, like not including postage fees with your price offer and they'll come after you, or leave out VAT, etc.
I mean even that part is still understandable, if I was a consumer I'd also want to know what the total price is straight away, and not have the occasional nasty awakening like with the cheap airlines we have here these days, where they lure you in with one price, but at the end of the day what with fees for this and fees for that you end up paying sthg totally different.
Get any part wrong that details your buyers rights, including detailed info on how long they'll have to wait for products - out of your hand if you're drop shipping say - or your impressum, or guarantees, or customers rights to give products back, or get the general terms and conditions (German AGB) wrong, which in turn are constantly being changed due to court decisions, and you're liable to be at the receiving end of a cease and desist order and legal bill, so it's all a bit of a mine field right now.
The original intention was good, protect consumer rights, but the system is being abused by lawyers that found a way to make some extremelly easy money.
The federal government and lawmakers here are aware of the abuse, and I should expect that in the next legislative period we'll start seeing some improvements, but at the moment for these reasons I'd prefer selling not in Germany, but elswhere on the web.
Doesn't that make sense anyway, trying to sell in as big a marketplace as possible ?
Why just limit yourself to your own country if you can sell to the world at no additional cost because thats what the web allows one to do right ?
Looking forward to your reply.
Gassing Station | Business | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


