Is there really any point??
Is there really any point??
Author
Discussion

thisislife

Original Poster:

344 posts

214 months

Thursday 13th August 2009
quotequote all
I have just had an email come through to my eBay account from a guy who has set up his own eBay type business.

http://www.getitorsellit.com/

I have taken a look but there is barley anything for sale. I don’t know if I’m being cynical here, but what is the point?? eBay are so huge, there might have been an inkling of a chance at getting somewhere in the early years but i would say the online auction market is well sown up now.

Back in the day you had Lycos auctions, freeserve auctions, to name a few but they all got washed away or snapped up by the "bay".

I admire people for wanting to have a go at something and putting it out there but really????......I can’t see this making it. Why do some people chase the impossible dream?



Maxf

8,444 posts

272 months

Thursday 13th August 2009
quotequote all
I suppose you only need a few months of good publicity to obtain more users and lots. The end game surely isn't to become like ebay, but to maybe take 0.1% of their income/lots and get bought by them.

JustinP1

13,364 posts

261 months

Thursday 13th August 2009
quotequote all
Maxf said:
I suppose you only need a few months of good publicity to obtain more users and lots. The end game surely isn't to become like ebay, but to maybe take 0.1% of their income/lots and get bought by them.
The problem is the ebay model works because of the fact that there are millions of sellers and buyers.

They reached the tipping point years ago which now means they dominate the market.

The reason why you don't just run an auction on your driveway is you would only get a few people turn up and even less interested in what you are selling. Unless you will get more for auctioning on Site X rather then ebay, then it is a non-starter for sellers. And to get that they need to supply more buyers.

It is dead in the water IMHO.

jon-

16,534 posts

247 months

Thursday 13th August 2009
quotequote all
There's a very good reason yahoo auctions doesn't exist in this country any more. Setup in 1998 when yahoo was still a MAJOR traffic site it died a death in 2002.

If yahoo, one of the highest traffic internet portals after MSN can't do it, I'm not sure anyone can at the moment.

DonnyMac

3,634 posts

234 months

Thursday 13th August 2009
quotequote all
To get traffic you need content.

First thing that springs to mind is to aggregate content from ebay - get a developer to spider the site and get the new adverts as they go up and place them on new site.

Have the site pm the ebay listing owner saying don't worry if you get enquiries from newsite.com your listing is completely free and we're not charging a % of sale either (for now).

You just got content and an advertiser base prior to launch.

I'd imagine that the content copywrite is owned by the advertiser not ebay, so as long as you gave them the option to de-list then that should be okay.

escargot

17,123 posts

248 months

Thursday 13th August 2009
quotequote all
If the funds were there, allowing people to auction & buy items completely free for a decent period of time before invoking fair charges could do a lot to drive traffic to the site.

jon-

16,534 posts

247 months

Thursday 13th August 2009
quotequote all
escargot said:
If the funds were there, allowing people to auction & buy items completely free for a decent period of time before invoking fair charges could do a lot to drive traffic to the site.
I'm fairly sure yahoo auctions was entirely ad supported (ie no charges to list or buy) and that's still dead!

Edited by jon- on Thursday 13th August 15:28

Maxf

8,444 posts

272 months

Thursday 13th August 2009
quotequote all
jon- said:
escargot said:
If the funds were there, allowing people to auction & buy items completely free for a decent period of time before invoking fair charges could do a lot to drive traffic to the site.
I'm fairly use yahoo auctions was entirely ad supported (ie no charges to list or buy) and that's still dead!
The thing is, ebay started up and was actually better than yahoo in terms of usability and people naturally moved over. Now ebay has changed and is forcing out the individual sellers in favour of the bulk traders so another 'yahoo' would probably do quite well.

Surely it is only a matter of time until google-auction opens?

thisislife

Original Poster:

344 posts

214 months

Thursday 13th August 2009
quotequote all
Google are the only firm I could see actually being able to rival eBay.

I'm sure many PH'ers are familiar with PayPal and might of even had the absolute pleasure of having money held for no reason etc. Google came up with their own web payments provider which by all accounts is much better than PayPal but eBay won’t allow it on their site.

As they own PayPal they won’t allow any other payments provider on the site and demand that EVERYONE has a PayPal account if they are to sell on eBay.

Surly this is a monopoly and worth a look in from the competition commission?