Trading - how much capital?
Trading - how much capital?
Author
Discussion

Stitch

Original Poster:

933 posts

248 months

Monday 17th August 2009
quotequote all
Looking to dip my toe into the world of spread bet/CFD trading.

Currently doing my research and reading as much as possible.

Ultimately I may be looking at trading to provide my sole income and my question is, in order to do that what level of capital would I need to invest in my trading activities?

I appreciate that to a certain extent this is a bit of a 'how long is a piece of string question' but working on the basis that with traditional investments if I wanted to earn £75,000 pa and assumed that I could achieve 7.5% return pa I would need to invest £1 million, what would be a reasonable figure under the leverage that spread betting/CFD's allow?

jdw1234

6,021 posts

246 months

Monday 17th August 2009
quotequote all
Isn't this like dipping your toe into juggling and learning with chainsaws?


Stitch

Original Poster:

933 posts

248 months

Monday 17th August 2009
quotequote all
should have put on my original post -

I am FULLY researching this and would be grateful for opinions from people who have some relevant knowledge/experience.

FFS why clog up the forum with inane comments?^^^^

I have already said that I am dipping my toe in the water - didn't think I would need to say that I am not going to go in with £100K on day 1 - but that is always assuming that people can read and comprehend others posts

Thurbs

2,782 posts

253 months

Monday 17th August 2009
quotequote all
Surely it kind of depends how good you are? Make a 75,000% gain on a pound each year and your laughing...

The greater the pot, the less % gain you will have to make in order to achieve your goal.

Stitch

Original Poster:

933 posts

248 months

Monday 17th August 2009
quotequote all
Yes you're probably right - oh, hang on - I think I covered that in the original post, yes I did, said that it was a bit of an open question but then talked about a 7.5% return.

Of course if you hit on something that goes up my 75,000% you only need a quid, but how likely is that?

I really was hoping for comments from people who actually do this for a living, rather than people who want to state the bleedin' obvious to try and get their post count up.

Chilli

17,320 posts

267 months

Monday 17th August 2009
quotequote all
TBH mate, you can read up all you like...doesn't mean you'll get it right!
There are so many variables here...
What's the plan?
What are you going to "invest in"
How long do you intend to keep each position?
How far will you have your stops set?
Do you have a certain p/l for each position?
Will this move given market conditions?
Will you react to market news, or market moves?
Will you hedge?
Will you diversify or keep to one industry?
Which news source?

Can you afford to lose you're entire pot?

I've been dabling for a while. made some very good money, but lost a fortune too. You probably already know (or you should do) that the market no-longer moves as expected, given certain news. You'll also hopefully know, that no-one knows how the market will react...really. People think, and will happily tell you this after the event, but they don't know!

Good luck with it though. If I could make a serious living...I would be!
Cheers.



ShadownINja

80,187 posts

313 months

Monday 17th August 2009
quotequote all
Where to start? Read all the threads on trading in this section first. Never call it investing. That makes you sound clever and when you think you are clever then the market will prove you're not. wobble

Read up on the psychology of trading and money management. Risk a little bit first (5p per pip) or demo trade. No point risking £1/pip if you have no idea what you're doing. It can take anything between 6 months and 2 years to become successful as a retail trader. Most people by then have blown their account.

Stitch

Original Poster:

933 posts

248 months

Monday 17th August 2009
quotequote all
Cheers Shadow.

Saw an earlier post of yours and have set up a dummy account with Party Market to have a play about with, Amazon have received a big order for reading material and I am getting everything that I can off the 'net - I am not going to go in blind and will work on the old gambling adage of only betting what I can afford to lose.

I have my eyes open to the risks and would say that I am naturally risk averse. I expect my biggest problem will actually be in placing money.

limpsfield

6,682 posts

284 months

Monday 17th August 2009
quotequote all
Stitch

Can you switch on the ability for someone to send you email via PH

Mattt

16,664 posts

249 months

Monday 17th August 2009
quotequote all
Stitch said:
I really was hoping for comments from people who actually do this for a living, rather than people who want to state the bleedin' obvious to try and get their post count up.
You're less likely to receive useful advice with comments like that.


Somewhatfoolish

5,104 posts

217 months

Monday 17th August 2009
quotequote all
I would say it's much easier to start trading in the real market and then spread bet on the side than vice versa. Twenty grand should be enough to be a one lot willy on most futures contracts.

Somewhatfoolish

5,104 posts

217 months

Monday 17th August 2009
quotequote all
Incidentally regarding return if you're shifting non institutional levels of cash and you do it well you'll be making three figures per centage wise. For example I am shortly going to be training someone on our trading grad scheme and capitalised with thirty grand I'll be astounded if that account hasn't made sixty grand profit in the first year.

stneville

93 posts

207 months

Monday 17th August 2009
quotequote all
You first need to start reading buy some books and have a read through the trading forums like trade2win.com before you trade with any money. Paper trade to begin with and then once you have got a feel for things move on to very small amounts.

I would forget about percentages of return and how much money you want to earn. You will be doing well just to make anything most people who trade loose money.

As Nija said it’s not going to be a quick process from loosing money to making money. You will loose money there is no guarantee that you will actually make money most people don’t.

whythem

773 posts

208 months

Monday 17th August 2009
quotequote all
So as a bit of a thread hijack question. So what are the steps that a novice would have to take to go from being a total novice, to retail trader skill level?. ie how do the proffessionals train for the job?
Sorry for the hijack Stich, but it is still releventsmile

Edited by whythem on Monday 17th August 20:19

Chilli

17,320 posts

267 months

Monday 17th August 2009
quotequote all
There's no substitute for experience. Open an account, practice one if needed, and crack on.

Fittster

20,120 posts

244 months

Monday 17th August 2009
quotequote all
Probably wise to paper trade at first.

ShadownINja

80,187 posts

313 months

Monday 17th August 2009
quotequote all
Practice account is paper trading but on the computer so you don't forget about things like spread and commission. A small account is better cos you don't take stupid gambles.

Stitch

Original Poster:

933 posts

248 months

Tuesday 18th August 2009
quotequote all
limpsfield said:
Stitch

Can you switch on the ability for someone to send you email via PH
Done

matsmith

1,166 posts

240 months

Tuesday 18th August 2009
quotequote all
Stitch the how much capital question really is an impossible one, it all depends on your circumstances. It is possible to make a lot of money with very little money, but its not easy

what kind of attitude to risk do you have? would you be going for the beaten up risky small companies who have massive potential returns but just as massive a risk of disappearing, or would you be playing it... ahem... "safe" and going for blue chips?

id say that you should probably have enough money set aside that you could live on for 2 years no matter what happens, and use discretion for how much of the remainder to put into your trading account

il be interested to hear if there are any other opinions on this but i dont think using leverage is a good idea for a newcomer, there will be days where you will make big returns using it but there will also be crushing days where you make big losses because of it. my advice would be if you have £1000 then buy £1000 of shares, not £10,000

johnfm

13,751 posts

281 months

Tuesday 18th August 2009
quotequote all
matsmith said:
Stitch the how much capital question really is an impossible one, it all depends on your circumstances. It is possible to make a lot of money with very little money, but its not easy

what kind of attitude to risk do you have? would you be going for the beaten up risky small companies who have massive potential returns but just as massive a risk of disappearing, or would you be playing it... ahem... "safe" and going for blue chips?

id say that you should probably have enough money set aside that you could live on for 2 years no matter what happens, and use discretion for how much of the remainder to put into your trading account

il be interested to hear if there are any other opinions on this but i dont think using leverage is a good idea for a newcomer, there will be days where you will make big returns using it but there will also be crushing days where you make big losses because of it. my advice would be if you have £1000 then buy £1000 of shares, not £10,000
Surely that is what stop losses are for.

You plan a buy trade, and you can set the stop to equate to the loss you were prepared to incur if you bought the stock. If the trade goes the wrong way, your loss is the same whether a spread bet or non-leverage stock purchase.

Only advantage to the stock purchase is the set fee - rather than the fee being a spread multiplied by your bid/point.