Firing an Employee???
Firing an Employee???
Author
Discussion

ItsTony

Original Poster:

960 posts

248 months

Sunday 23rd August 2009
quotequote all
Hi,

Just wanted to ask some advice on firing an employee.

He has worked for me for about 6/7 months.

Is ones punctuality a fair grounds for dismissal if he is consistently late for work. There are other reasons such as his attitude towards work, sloppiness, laziness etc etc, but if I want to protect myself from getting bit in the backside, what is the correct procedure to go about this.

If I write him a letter explaining how he is always late etc and then also state in the letter that he has 2 weeks to start turning up on time. If in two weeks he is still late (albeit not as late) can I still fairly sack him. Is there anything else I need to do to cover myself or is there always the fact that he can lie and say I just sacked him without notice.

Thanx

Conian

8,030 posts

232 months

Sunday 23rd August 2009
quotequote all
how vital is it that he is on time? is there a reason why he is always late?
does he appreciate that he's late and make up the minutes?

Rollcage

11,345 posts

223 months

Sunday 23rd August 2009
quotequote all
ItsTony said:
Hi,

Just wanted to ask some advice on firing an employee.

He has worked for me for about 6/7 months.

Is ones punctuality a fair grounds for dismissal if he is consistently late for work. There are other reasons such as his attitude towards work, sloppiness, laziness etc etc, but if I want to protect myself from getting bit in the backside, what is the correct procedure to go about this.

If I write him a letter explaining how he is always late etc and then also state in the letter that he has 2 weeks to start turning up on time. If in two weeks he is still late (albeit not as late) can I still fairly sack him. Is there anything else I need to do to cover myself or is there always the fact that he can lie and say I just sacked him without notice.

Thanx
If he has worked for you for less than a year ,very broadly speaking you can just get rid ,as long as you are not discriminating in any way.

ItsTony

Original Poster:

960 posts

248 months

Sunday 23rd August 2009
quotequote all
Its more to do with the fact that I'm unhappy with his attitude towards everything as an employee. I've had words with him about being late, but nothing changes. I think that he has the ideaI need him to run the business so he's trying his luck since he doesn't think I'll fire him. Either that, or he's just ignorant and lazy. Either way, I want to grow the business and don't want an employee such as him especially when I'm looking to take on another member of staff.

Also, shouldn't it be the employers agreement of what time he starts work. If he's paid for 8 hours he shouldn't turn up 30 minutes late (sometimes longer) regardless of what he thinks.

siscar

6,887 posts

248 months

Sunday 23rd August 2009
quotequote all
In my experience if someone is incapable of turning up on time you are best to cut your losses and get someone who can. It's not just the time it's the attitude, if you have someone who is like that you will have a lot of problems with them.

At 6/7 months you can just tell them to go. If you want to give them a chance and warn them that is an option, but you are in your rights just to dismiss. Things change at 12 months but before then there is no issue so long as pregnancy or discrimination isn't involved.

Rollcage

11,345 posts

223 months

Sunday 23rd August 2009
quotequote all
ItsTony said:
Its more to do with the fact that I'm unhappy with his attitude towards everything as an employee. I've had words with him about being late, but nothing changes. I think that he has the ideaI need him to run the business so he's trying his luck since he doesn't think I'll fire him. Either that, or he's just ignorant and lazy. Either way, I want to grow the business and don't want an employee such as him especially when I'm looking to take on another member of staff.

Also, shouldn't it be the employers agreement of what time he starts work. If he's paid for 8 hours he shouldn't turn up 30 minutes late (sometimes longer) regardless of what he thinks.
Sit him down and tell him ,quite clearly your expectations .Then give him a written copy ,and give hime a timescale to improve and meet those expectations. Get him to sign a copy of everything ,and then when he does nothing to change ,sack him! Not that you need to do any of that - you can terminate without notice within 12 months except for certain limited scenarios .

ItsTony

Original Poster:

960 posts

248 months

Sunday 23rd August 2009
quotequote all
One other thing. If he hasn't taken any paid holidays, will I need to pay him for the proportionate amount of days still owed.



spikeyhead

20,655 posts

228 months

Sunday 23rd August 2009
quotequote all
ItsTony said:
One other thing. If he hasn't taken any paid holidays, will I need to pay him for the proportionate amount of days still owed.
Yes

UpTheIron

4,058 posts

299 months

Sunday 23rd August 2009
quotequote all
Do you want rid and you are using the lateness as an excuse, or if his timekeeping was sorted out would you then be happy?

I'm assuming you are his employer, rather than his manager and therefore you haven't got a Human Remains dept to help you out? I'm guessing you don't have a documented disciplinary procedure either?

Do you have other staff, and is their timekeeping better?

I'd suggest sitting him down and find out why he is late. Be as understanding as possible, but explain that it is not acceptable (assuming his reasons don't change things). Back this up in writing as a written warning of unacceptable conduct.

Then see what happens next.

Four Cofffee

11,838 posts

266 months

Sunday 23rd August 2009
quotequote all
I would sit him down, detail all of the problems, see if he has any excuses, see what he offers to do to improve them then set a date at which you will review it (a month?) and what imrovement there must be. If he signs up to the improvements (and I would get him to sign that he will do the things and that he recognises the implications of not doing so) and then things don't improve or at least not to the standard required get rid.

ItsTony

Original Poster:

960 posts

248 months

Monday 24th August 2009
quotequote all
I have employed him for about 6 months and haven't really threatened him with dismissal if he didn't turn up on time (only short and quick words). I know he needed to drop his child off at school, but then he still has another hour to get to work. I accepted this and reminded him whenever he was really late, such as 45minutes, but he normally turns up 30 minutes late anyway. I notice that whenever I have words with him, he tries to turn up 10 minutes earlier, but this fizzles out within days. Come summer holidays when he doesn't need to take his child to school, he has plenty of time to come in on time but still turns up 30 minutes late.

I believe that I pay him very fairly and I he wont walk into a similar job if he didn't work here. I also think that he's abusing the fact that he's my only employee so he thinks that I won't dismiss him or I won't be able to trade, but an employee with that sort of attitude is probably not worth keeping. I will be taking a risk by firing him and will need to spend the time and effort to train up another member of staff, but after long thoughts I feel like this is worth the sacrafice. I'm 23 and started this business a year after finishing university. I've probably made every mistake I can make in the book but I'm trying to learn from my mistakes and make better decisions.

cazzer

8,883 posts

279 months

Monday 24th August 2009
quotequote all
Couple of questions.
Does he need to be there at 9 (or whatever his start time is)? Do phones need answering etc?
Or is he behind the scenes?
If so, does he do his job well when he is there? Does he put the contracted hours in or is he doing half an hour less a day?

If he's a good employee and does a good job for you, does it affect the business if he isn't there til half past?

Don't cut your nose off to spite your face just because you want him there at a certain time.
If there's no real reason for it then offer him different hours.

Course if he is taking the piss, then get shut.


pugwash4x4

7,684 posts

252 months

Monday 24th August 2009
quotequote all
ItsTony said:
I've probably made every mistake I can make in the book but I'm trying to learn from my mistakes and make better decisions.
Been in exactly the same position as you- 23 and wondering should i fire my employees.

Trust me just fire him- it will be the best decision you make. you are too young and too early in your business career to be worrying about helping and carrying employees. you need dyanmic hard working people- be a man, give him a weeks notice, tell him why and move on.

even if he has legitimate reasons for being late, its not working for YOUR business and as such the relationship should end.

The biggest regrets i haev from my early business days are not sacking employees when i knew that they were taking the piss- my lack of decisiveness effected both my other employees and myself.

Soovy

35,829 posts

302 months

Monday 24th August 2009
quotequote all
ItsTony said:
Hi,

Just wanted to ask some advice on firing an employee.

He has worked for me for about 6/7 months.

Is ones punctuality a fair grounds for dismissal if he is consistently late for work. There are other reasons such as his attitude towards work, sloppiness, laziness etc etc, but if I want to protect myself from getting bit in the backside, what is the correct procedure to go about this.

If I write him a letter explaining how he is always late etc and then also state in the letter that he has 2 weeks to start turning up on time. If in two weeks he is still late (albeit not as late) can I still fairly sack him. Is there anything else I need to do to cover myself or is there always the fact that he can lie and say I just sacked him without notice.

Thanx
I never cease to be amazed.

I assume as an employer you have a staff handbook, and a contract of employment??


Read those, they might help!!



FFS yikes

cazzer

8,883 posts

279 months

Monday 24th August 2009
quotequote all
Just read the OP about sloppyness and laziness......get shut.

Stitch

933 posts

248 months

Tuesday 25th August 2009
quotequote all
As above, Providing you are not open to charge of discrimination, you can get rid now. Needs 12 months service to raise an Employment Tribunal claim

Probably best to provide him with a letter setting out the reasons (keep it to tangible things like the late arrivals).


Marlon

735 posts

289 months

Saturday 29th August 2009
quotequote all
ItsTony said:
Hi,

Just wanted to ask some advice on firing an employee.

He has worked for me for about 6/7 months.

Is ones punctuality a fair grounds for dismissal if he is consistently late for work. There are other reasons such as his attitude towards work, sloppiness, laziness etc etc, but if I want to protect myself from getting bit in the backside, what is the correct procedure to go about this.

If I write him a letter explaining how he is always late etc and then also state in the letter that he has 2 weeks to start turning up on time. If in two weeks he is still late (albeit not as late) can I still fairly sack him. Is there anything else I need to do to cover myself or is there always the fact that he can lie and say I just sacked him without notice.

Thanx
Tony,

First, I hope things work out for you. To be employing even one person at 23 is to be commended. It's a learning curve that most people never reach the top of, but that's the satisfying thing about it too - you'll never stop learning. Best of luck.

Second, please double-check any advice you receive on this forum. Your local Business Link or Chamber of Commerce should be able to help. Employment law and legislation changes quite frequently, and some of the advice provided on these pages is quite - how shall I put it - out of date!

You cannot simply "fire someone". If the employee has an employment contract with you, then whether they've been with you for two weeks or two years, you can be found guilty of wrongful dismissal if you do not follow due-process. Being "lazy" and "having the wrong attitude" are not admissible grounds to dismiss someone... if only that were true! wink

A lot of employees won't know their rights any more than a lot of employers (and it's frightening how few employers that I speak to know how "close to the wind" they sail at times) but it only takes one tribunal to screw things for you, and you really don't need to take the risk.

Search on Google - there are sites that will advise on the process that you should follow. It doesn't need to be a long or difficult process. Knowing the ins-and-outs will make you a better employer and a better boss, and help you to steer-clear of problems when your business grows.

Well done for asking in the first place, but I really suggest that you get some basic "professional" advice (it shouldn't cost you anything).

pugwash4x4

7,684 posts

252 months

Saturday 29th August 2009
quotequote all
sometimes its better to get rid of a member of staff and pay any "costs" than it is to keep the staff in the job!

Conian

8,030 posts

232 months

Sunday 30th August 2009
quotequote all
is he gone yet?

siscar

6,887 posts

248 months

Sunday 30th August 2009
quotequote all
Marlon said:
Tony,

First, I hope things work out for you. To be employing even one person at 23 is to be commended. It's a learning curve that most people never reach the top of, but that's the satisfying thing about it too - you'll never stop learning. Best of luck.

Second, please double-check any advice you receive on this forum. Your local Business Link or Chamber of Commerce should be able to help. Employment law and legislation changes quite frequently, and some of the advice provided on these pages is quite - how shall I put it - out of date!

You cannot simply "fire someone". If the employee has an employment contract with you, then whether they've been with you for two weeks or two years, you can be found guilty of wrongful dismissal if you do not follow due-process. Being "lazy" and "having the wrong attitude" are not admissible grounds to dismiss someone... if only that were true! wink

A lot of employees won't know their rights any more than a lot of employers (and it's frightening how few employers that I speak to know how "close to the wind" they sail at times) but it only takes one tribunal to screw things for you, and you really don't need to take the risk.

Search on Google - there are sites that will advise on the process that you should follow. It doesn't need to be a long or difficult process. Knowing the ins-and-outs will make you a better employer and a better boss, and help you to steer-clear of problems when your business grows.

Well done for asking in the first place, but I really suggest that you get some basic "professional" advice (it shouldn't cost you anything).
It's ironic that the one post that says, quite rightly, not to take stuff on a forum at face value is also so wrong in the other advice given.

Firstly the Chamber of Commerce is a membership organisation, not a general source of advice. Business Link is a more generalised source of advice but they won't give you specific legal advice, they will just refer you to a solicitor. (Be grateful for that, BL ranks amongst the most useless wastes of time and money there is).

Meanwhile "it only takes one tribunal to screw things for you", well no, it doesn't. Tribunals find for employers as well as employees and even if you do go there and lose it's not the end of the world. Sometimes going to tribunal is exactly the right thing to do from the employer's perspective, sometimes it's better to put your case to a tribunal than let an employee walk all over you.

"You cannot simply "fire someone".", well you need to follow whatever it says in the contract, so long as there is a contract. In the first year of employment, unless you have a stupidly worded contract, you will need to pay a week's notice. So you can talk to them, say that they timekeeping is not up to scratch, that you are dismissing them and paying them a week's notice. Failure to pay the week's notice is when they could take you to tribunal where you will be told to pay a week's notice.

"Being "lazy" and "having the wrong attitude" are not admissible grounds to dismiss someone", well actually they are, they are performance issues and if someone is not performing to an adequate standard in their role then you can dismiss them. You have to follow the proper process laid down in their contract or meet the minimal legal standard, if they have been with you for more than a year you may need to go through several warnings, but you can do that and if the behavious persists you can dismiss them.