Apparantly this is legal (tax query)... how is it?
Apparantly this is legal (tax query)... how is it?
Author
Discussion

Dupont666

Original Poster:

22,982 posts

223 months

Monday 24th August 2009
quotequote all
An accountant that as he puts it:

accountant said:
' have been a qualified member of the chartered association of certified accountant (FCCA) since 1989 and I am subject to their rules and standards.
There is no licensing system for tax advisers in the UK. The company is registered with HMRC for money-laundering purposes.'
Has come up with a way for me to make sure I dont get too stung on the tax I pay for my company and states:

accountant said:
How you are paid:
- you are employed and paid a salary (this satisfies minimum wage requirements, among other things) from which tax and NI are deducted.
- the rest of your remuneration is paid into a trust in your name in the Isle of Man. You are then 'loaned' the money by the trust. The trustees must act in your best interest so will never ask for the money back. As this is a tax-free loan, you will be taxed each year on the interest saved, which is equivalent to 1-2% of the amount of the loan. The loan can be forgiven when your employment ceases. As you no longer have an employment relationship at that stage, it is not income and there is no tax to pay.
the words loan and trust have been mentioned here which I have been warned against doing, the thing is I dont know why I have been warned against doing them other than to be told its risky, so why is this avoided?

Is this legal?

Why are more people not doing it?

It mentions employment, surely this means that its an IR35 issue now and they can come and claim it?

Sorry for all the queries, but any help would be good.

zippy3x

1,384 posts

298 months

Dupont666

Original Poster:

22,982 posts

223 months

Monday 24th August 2009
quotequote all
zippy3x said:
Thank you, that is the answer Im looking for.... I would rather pay the 30-35% than the 18% he is suggesting and not be chased by Winky McfkNut cause our beloved Winky has decided to close the loophole and retro fit it 10 years, or that the company may sell my debt on to someone else and are not 100% above board.

Does that cover all the downflaws of it?

Mx_Stu

837 posts

254 months

Monday 24th August 2009
quotequote all
Dupont666 said:
An accountant that as he puts it:

accountant said:
'There is no licensing system for tax advisers in the UK. The company is registered with HMRC for money-laundering purposes.'
If you are looking for a tax adviser then you either go for a chartered tax adviser or a member of the association of taxation technicians.

Members of both are bound by professional guidelines in the same way that a chartered or certified accountant is.

Dupont666

Original Poster:

22,982 posts

223 months

Monday 24th August 2009
quotequote all
Mx_Stu said:
Dupont666 said:
An accountant that as he puts it:

accountant said:
'There is no licensing system for tax advisers in the UK. The company is registered with HMRC for money-laundering purposes.'
If you are looking for a tax adviser then you either go for a chartered tax adviser or a member of the association of taxation technicians.

Members of both are bound by professional guidelines in the same way that a chartered or certified accountant is.
So this is the company:

http://www.amlimited.com/

as Im a contractor is it a case of:

a) Use something like the above and stick 2 fingers up at GB.
b) Be company single salaried and hope they dont notice im the only person in the company with one client, but none of the benefits?
c) Tell them and then watch and cry as they take off more tax than usual cause GB wants his money and I end up paying 40%+ total (usual is 30%+) which means its never really worth being a contractor.

Or is there a d) that I havent noticed?

UpTheIron

4,058 posts

299 months

Wednesday 26th August 2009
quotequote all
Dupont666 said:
accountant said:
How you are paid:
- you are employed and paid a salary (this satisfies minimum wage requirements, among other things) from which tax and NI are deducted.
- the rest of your remuneration is paid into a trust in your name in the Isle of Man. You are then 'loaned' the money by the trust. The trustees must act in your best interest so will never ask for the money back. As this is a tax-free loan, you will be taxed each year on the interest saved, which is equivalent to 1-2% of the amount of the loan. The loan can be forgiven when your employment ceases. As you no longer have an employment relationship at that stage, it is not income and there is no tax to pay.
The scheme is legal. The risk is that you may not declare/pay tax that HMRC expect you to.

As yourself:
1. What if the trustees change their mind and decide to recall the loans?
2. The trustees are replaced by an administrator who recalls the loans?
3. HMRC will have something to say about loans being written off and the benefit not being recognised as a taxable gain.
4. "It is not income"? Really? How do they work that one out?

Do it, but with your eyes open. If you are in for years, be prepared for a six figure tax bill and a fight through the courts. By which time the scheme administrator will have legged it with 10 - 20% of your income as their "fee".

Or don't, and pay about 5-10% more tax. Sleep easy.

Edited by UpTheIron on Wednesday 26th August 18:08

Plotloss

67,280 posts

301 months

Wednesday 26th August 2009
quotequote all
Can anyone who is a Director 'benefit' from this type of scheme or is it purely something peculiar to 'personal service companies'?

UpTheIron

4,058 posts

299 months

Wednesday 26th August 2009
quotequote all
Plotloss said:
Can anyone who is a Director 'benefit' from this type of scheme or is it purely something peculiar to 'personal service companies'?
Nothing to do with Ltd companies. What is posted above is correct - you become a PAYE employee of a UK subsidary of an IoM/offshore company. The client then has a contract with the UK company.

The individual receives a salary from the UK company, plus loans from the offshore company. To avoid unfavourable tax treatment, these loans are discretionary.

The issues are:
- you have no control over your money, and there are plenty of cases of schemes shutting up shop and leaving people out of pocket, "forgetting" to pay tax bills etc
- you pay 10%+ in fees to the scheme administrator
- if/when you leave the scheme, retire, die, if the loan is written off then it becomes a taxable gain.

Plotloss

67,280 posts

301 months

Wednesday 26th August 2009
quotequote all
Ahh right, so the IoM trust isnt in your control, its an umbrella type setup?

UpTheIron

4,058 posts

299 months

Wednesday 26th August 2009
quotequote all
Plotloss said:
Ahh right, so the IoM trust isnt in your control, its an umbrella type setup?
Yup, and as an employee not being in control is key to the tax advantage IIRC.

I dare say that it would be possible to construct a trading organisation that sets up its own trust etc, but I would expect it to be the preserve of larger organisations and the super rich.

TooLateForAName

4,935 posts

215 months

Wednesday 26th August 2009
quotequote all
I have to say that I think you are mad to look at schemes like this. Go ltd and pay dividends. You get plenty of money and get to sleep nights. Go to a decent accountant. SJD or similar.


You will be an employee. The discretionary trust loans you money. So how does the money get from the company to the trust? What taxation applies at this point? Presumably iom based for low CT? There will be BIK.

The company has an obligation to act in the interests of the company (and I think this applies to the IoM as well as the uk). It is difficult to see how passing money to a discretionary trust fulfils this obligation.

The entire set up is obviously for the sole purpose of avoiding tax. HMRC has the powers to disregard the arrangement for this reason.

Do you really want an HMRC investigation? You'll get them. Go google Norla EBT and find the people who are getting investigation letters and who are developing brown underwear. Go read up on the people caught by the currency/interest rate swap schemes (loans made in currencies which are in free fall - eg nigerian)

Read http://www.hmrc.gov.uk/manuals/eimanual/EIM21743.h...

Oh, and ask the 'tax advisor' to confirm what they will make from getting you into this scheme.




Dupont666

Original Poster:

22,982 posts

223 months

Wednesday 26th August 2009
quotequote all
Already decided against this a long time ago.... it was a query as to how it worked rather than using it.

PLUS winky McfkNut has decided IoM falls under the UK legislations and as such it wont work for much longer and then you get charged 15% by the company and then get stung for everything else under normal employee schemes.


UpTheIron

4,058 posts

299 months

Wednesday 26th August 2009
quotequote all
Dupont666 said:
Already decided against this a long time ago...
thumbup