Can anyone recommend a good commercial lawyer?
Can anyone recommend a good commercial lawyer?
Author
Discussion

seaninog

Original Poster:

513 posts

220 months

Tuesday 25th August 2009
quotequote all
I'm having trouble with an investment. I acquired shares in the company through the takeover of a company I had invested in as part of a cash/equity deal. The company is registered in the UK but largely run out of the Netherlands and the US. The company has submitted no accounts to Companies' House for 2 years, the Board are ignoring my requests to look at the Register of Members and now they are planning a transaction to spin off the only profitable section of the business, awarding themselves (the management) generous shareholdings in the new debt-free entity while the rest of us shareholders in the Holding company are left with a minority stake in the new entity, all the debt from the entire group and the less profitable (ie loss making) sections of the company.

So what I need is someone who knows the Companies' Act 2006 inside-out and can quote me chapter and verse on what rights I have to stop this destruction of value in my shareholding to the benefit of the management and guide me on how best t proceed. I'm guessing some sort of injunction against the spin-off may also be required.

Happy to pay for this advice, of course, just would prefer to get someone who came recommended. Can you help?

The jiffle king

7,550 posts

289 months

Wednesday 26th August 2009
quotequote all
YHM

Mx_Stu

837 posts

254 months

Wednesday 26th August 2009
quotequote all
I’m not a lawyer in any way shape or form but do see legal action from time to time.

Other than a s.994 claim (effectively protection of minority interests) remembered this article which should give some food for thought regarding bringing claims against directors rather than the company:

http://www.bytestart.co.uk/content/legal/35_2/comp...

seaninog

Original Poster:

513 posts

220 months

Wednesday 26th August 2009
quotequote all
Thanks Mx_stu. I was aware of the nature of derivative claims (would you believe I've actually read through the entire Companies' Act 2006??!!) but I don't think that's what I need here immediately. I don't intend to submit a vexatious claim; I just need these guys to submit accounts to shareholders and to Companies' house. A couple of things I have learned when dealing with the law is a) don't get emotional or angry, just keep making pragmatic decisions based on the facts and how you perceive them and b) what you think is 'right' or 'wrong' is different to how the law works.

I noted in the London Gazette last month that a notice was placed to strike the company off for just this reason, however they had it rescinded a day later (presumably bought themselves some time) and are still yet to file.

I think it's all quite staggering really.

Mx_Stu

837 posts

254 months

Wednesday 26th August 2009
quotequote all
seaninog said:
a) don't get emotional or angry, just keep making pragmatic decisions based on the facts and how you perceive them
Best bit of advice I ever got was that, if you get angry or emotional it effects the ability to think logically and also means the 'other side' has already won!

Good luck!

therealpigdog

2,592 posts

228 months

Wednesday 26th August 2009
quotequote all
seaninog said:
would you believe I've actually read through the entire Companies' Act 2006??!!
Wow, that is commitment to the cause!

I think the possibility of a derivative claim is useful here, as is the threat of misfeasance proceedings against directors if they are breaching their duties. Very difficult to judge with limited information, but from what you are saying then there would appear to be at the very least an argument.

Would also need to consider the solvency of the company (admittedly difficult without day to day involvement or a set of accounts) as this may affect any advice.

rlw

3,590 posts

268 months

Wednesday 26th August 2009
quotequote all
You could try a guy called Robert Davis - robert@glinertdavis.com - who is deeply into this kind of thing. He's a client but that isn't why I recommend giving him a call - he's a good, straight down the line bloke.

johnfm

13,752 posts

281 months

Wednesday 26th August 2009
quotequote all
So, you invested in Company X. Company X owns shares in company Y.

Company Y is the company that you think will be left holding all the debt and no value?

How much voting right do you have in COmpany X? How much do they have in company Y/

What rights do the aricles give the directors of company Y to do what they are planning?

seaninog

Original Poster:

513 posts

220 months

Wednesday 26th August 2009
quotequote all
johnfm said:
So, you invested in Company X. Company X owns shares in company Y.

Company Y is the company that you think will be left holding all the debt and no value?

How much voting right do you have in COmpany X? How much do they have in company Y/

What rights do the aricles give the directors of company Y to do what they are planning?
Not entirely correct. I invested in Company X which was then bought out by Company Y in a cash and equity deal, leaving me with shares in Company Y.

Company Y has 3 divisions: 2 loss making, one just about profitable (and supposedly with a bright future). The management of Company Y are giving its shareholders no information on how the company is going (no accounts filed for over 2 years) but have told us that they are spinning off the profitable section on (a foreign) stockmarket. This new entity will not carry any debt from Company Y (and my suspicion is there is a LOT of debt), will seek new equity investment to fund its growth (thereby diluting Company Y's holding in it) and as part of the deal are awarding the management of Company Y about 20% of the equity as a reward for their efforts. Company Y is left with about only 40% of the spun-off (profitable) entity and still carries the debt for the group.

The Articles of Association don't refer to any rights the Directors have in this regard and, to be honest, this is my quandary as I don't know what they are entitled to do either (hence the need for a good lawyer) and how I might go about stopping them. Oh, the AoA does also say that if you own more than 1% of the equity you are entitled to get quarterly management accounts 21 days after the quarter finishes. You won't be surprised to hear this hasn't happened either...

I think you can see the pickle I'm in.

Edited by seaninog on Wednesday 26th August 22:47