Is it only the Bastert UK that has National Insurance?
Is it only the Bastert UK that has National Insurance?
Author
Discussion

cardigankid

Original Poster:

8,880 posts

243 months

Friday 28th August 2009
quotequote all
Is anyone aware of any other country that has this system of daylight robbery?

Stitch

933 posts

248 months

Friday 28th August 2009
quotequote all
probably

And it's probably only the bd UK that provides six months unemployment benefit with no questions asked and a state old age pension for everyone/anyone(and their spouse) who has paid NI, whilst maintaining an income tax rate of c20% for the vast majority of people.

What's your beef?

ETA - just seen you're Scottish - you've got even less reason to complain - your mickey mouse parliament gives out more generous handouts for your country folk, safe in the knowledge that the English and Welsh tax payers will foot the bill

Edited by Stitch on Friday 28th August 14:55

mmm-five

12,402 posts

315 months

Friday 28th August 2009
quotequote all
A lot of the Nordic countries have a social tax which pays for their care in old age and their welfare during their working life.

They can pay upto 60% of their earning in taxes (including what we'd call National Insurance) - although they do tend to get paid more.

TonyToniTone

3,929 posts

280 months

Friday 28th August 2009
quotequote all
In Ireland you pay PRSI and a Health Levy, yet you still have to pay to see a doctor and pay full for your prescriptions.

mmm-five

12,402 posts

315 months

Friday 28th August 2009
quotequote all
TonyToniTone said:
In Ireland you pay PRSI and a Health Levy, yet you still have to pay to see a doctor and pay full for your prescriptions.
It's about the same in the UK.

You pay this 'insurance' yet you only get 'emergency' treatment free - anything else, prescriptions, dentist, doctor, etc. you end up paying for yourself. Although you only pay a set price for prescriptions which means for things like paracetemol you're better off buying off the shelf rather than with a scrip - for the expensive stuff then the standard scrip charge is worth it.

My local doctor & dentist surgeries are full so I have to pay to go private whenever I want something done/looking at - which makes the point that I'm 'never' ill quite handy.

jamesuk28

2,176 posts

284 months

Friday 28th August 2009
quotequote all
Stitch said:
probably

And it's probably only the bd UK that provides six months unemployment benefit with no questions asked and a state old age pension for everyone/anyone(and their spouse) who has paid NI, whilst maintaining an income tax rate of c20% for the vast majority of people.

What's your beef?

ETA - just seen you're Scottish - you've got even less reason to complain - your mickey mouse parliament gives out more generous handouts for your country folk, safe in the knowledge that the English and Welsh tax payers will foot the bill

Edited by Stitch on Friday 28th August 14:55
Well said that man! IIRC Glasgow has the highest rate of benefit pay outs per head (and also the highest rate of benefit fraud) in the UK if not Europe.

I seem to recall a story a few weeks back where the Scottish parliment were calling for all Scottish residents to be vacinated against Swine flue, yet they insisted on Westminster paying for it!

NI is a pain in the arse, yet as Stitch pointed out the benefits are worth it, esp if you are Scottish by the way the numbers seem to add up

TheEnd

15,370 posts

219 months

Friday 28th August 2009
quotequote all

ExChrispy Porker

17,763 posts

259 months

Friday 28th August 2009
quotequote all
I have got more out than I have paid in!

TonyToniTone

3,929 posts

280 months

Friday 28th August 2009
quotequote all
mmm-five said:
It's about the same in the UK.
Its different in Ireland as its about €70 to see a GP plus prescription charge (up to a €100 month?), UK its free to GP and prescription is £7 per item or £120 for the year



cazzer

8,883 posts

279 months

Saturday 29th August 2009
quotequote all
Stitch said:
probably

And it's probably only the bd UK that provides six months unemployment benefit with no questions asked and a state old age pension for everyone/anyone(and their spouse) who has paid NI, whilst maintaining an income tax rate of c20% for the vast majority of people.

What's your beef?
How about the fact that I've paid in about £100k of NI since I started work...and now I'm unemployed I get 62 quid a week. Thats a st return.

Simpo Two

93,111 posts

296 months

Saturday 29th August 2009
quotequote all
NI was set up originally to pay gor the NHS. So the deal was you pay one and tuppence into the pot then get free healthcare for life.

Back in 1948 when the population was smaller, people died younger and we didn't have to pay for all the sick foreigners, it must have seemed like a good idea.

karona

1,928 posts

217 months

Saturday 29th August 2009
quotequote all
Bulgaria has a state medical fund, contributions are the equivalent of UKP 60 a year. This provides basic health care for around UKP 1.50 per doctor's appointment. The UK, however, is picking up the tab for my wife's MRI and a hernia op in a state of the art university teaching hospital on Monday. Total waiting time between seeing the GP, a Neurologist and a Surgeon, and the referral to the hospital: 12 hours. A Bulgarian national would have paid around 200 quid.

What would the waiting time have been in the UK?, and what would private treatment in the UK have cost?

mmm-five

12,402 posts

315 months

Saturday 29th August 2009
quotequote all
TonyToniTone said:
mmm-five said:
It's about the same in the UK.
Its different in Ireland as its about €70 to see a GP plus prescription charge (up to a €100 month?), UK its free to GP and prescription is £7 per item or £120 for the year
I meant to say that it was about the same in the UK 'for me' as I'm not on any single doctor/dentist books due to 1) not using the doctor enough, so that he prioritised his 'clients'; and 2) the dentist didn't have enough spaces, so just allocated his 'book' on a first come first served basis.

I just pay when & if I need treatment and claim it against my private medical insurance.

Sagacitas

290 posts

247 months

Saturday 29th August 2009
quotequote all
The US has Social Security - which is a tax just like NI.

northwick

104 posts

207 months

Monday 31st August 2009
quotequote all
Sagacitas said:
The US has Social Security - which is a tax just like NI.
Yep. And Medicare and Medicaid are wonderful services.

dcb

6,070 posts

296 months

Monday 31st August 2009
quotequote all
Simpo Two said:
NI was set up originally to pay gor the NHS. So the deal was you pay one and tuppence into the pot then get free healthcare for life.

Back in 1948 when the population was smaller, people died younger and we didn't have to pay for all the sick foreigners, it must have seemed like a good idea.
I've never really understood why it's a good idea to have
my Government provide my health care.

I don't think they are particularly well equipped or skilled
or efficient enough to do it well. I think some market forces,
to encourage competition and choice, would help.

Given the UK Gov's appalling track record on big IT projects, it's
not hard to see how the health care provision soaks up a big
fraction of the total tax budget.

Most other countries in Europe operate health care on an insurance basis.
I think it would be a good idea to cherry pick the best systems
across Europe and copy them here.

This would lead to a dramatic reduction in tax bills and an increase
in health insurance premiums.

At very least, the hundreds of pounds per month that the NHS costs
us all in taxes, you would be able to *see* it being paid in health
insurance premiums, without UK Gov getting it's special brand
of bone headed stupidity in the way.

In this way, health insurance would be like car insurance,
every has to have it, but the market place provides it.

Andrew[MG]

3,360 posts

229 months

Monday 31st August 2009
quotequote all
dcb said:
Simpo Two said:
NI was set up originally to pay gor the NHS. So the deal was you pay one and tuppence into the pot then get free healthcare for life.

Back in 1948 when the population was smaller, people died younger and we didn't have to pay for all the sick foreigners, it must have seemed like a good idea.
I've never really understood why it's a good idea to have
my Government provide my health care.

I don't think they are particularly well equipped or skilled
or efficient enough to do it well. I think some market forces,
to encourage competition and choice, would help.

Given the UK Gov's appalling track record on big IT projects, it's
not hard to see how the health care provision soaks up a big
fraction of the total tax budget.

Most other countries in Europe operate health care on an insurance basis.
I think it would be a good idea to cherry pick the best systems
across Europe and copy them here.

This would lead to a dramatic reduction in tax bills and an increase
in health insurance premiums.

At very least, the hundreds of pounds per month that the NHS costs
us all in taxes, you would be able to *see* it being paid in health
insurance premiums, without UK Gov getting it's special brand
of bone headed stupidity in the way.

In this way, health insurance would be like car insurance,
every has to have it, but the market place provides it.
This idea is nice in theory but unlikely to work in practice. The UK has an appalling record in any kind of privatisation and would undoubtedly mess up any big changes to the NHS. If you look at how Denmark managed to privatise their railways and how we did it, it's easy to see that we are incapable of managing such a process. We'd just get shafted by big business....we'd save money for the first couple of years and then the price would go up, up and up!

cardigankid

Original Poster:

8,880 posts

243 months

Monday 31st August 2009
quotequote all
jamesuk28 said:
Stitch said:
probably

And it's probably only the bd UK that provides six months unemployment benefit with no questions asked and a state old age pension for everyone/anyone(and their spouse) who has paid NI, whilst maintaining an income tax rate of c20% for the vast majority of people.

What's your beef?
Well said that man! IIRC Glasgow has the highest rate of benefit pay outs per head (and also the highest rate of benefit fraud) in the UK if not Europe.

I seem to recall a story a few weeks back where the Scottish parliment were calling for all Scottish residents to be vacinated against Swine flue, yet they insisted on Westminster paying for it!
So the freeloaders are ok then?! cursefurious I couldn't help noticing that when we account for our monthly tax and NI, NI for most employees is significantly more than tax, yet people continuously argue that UK is competitive on tax against most other countries. I don't think it is. It is just a huge shabby con trick.

I also notice that staff payslips and P60 forms are very careful to obliterate any reference to the higher 'Employer's Contribution' so people don't realise how much they are actually paying, although that is of course tax as well. What a scam!

If you are foolish enough to accept their inoculation, you are probably foolish enough to help dig your own mass grave and stand at the edge waiting to be shot.



Edited by cardigankid on Monday 31st August 18:45

dcb

6,070 posts

296 months

Monday 31st August 2009
quotequote all
Andrew[MG] said:
The UK has an appalling record in any kind of privatisation and would undoubtedly mess up any big changes to the NHS.
I don't think that's true.

Some (most ?) privatisations have gone well, giving choice and competition
to the consumer.

Andrew[MG] said:
If you look at how Denmark managed to privatise their railways and how we did it, it's easy to see that we are incapable of managing such a process.
I don't think that stands any serious analysis either.

Independent of whether a small Scandinavian nation of about six million
folks did the railways right, the UK is much bigger and we are talking
NHS here.

Andrew[MG] said:
We'd just get shafted by big business....we'd save money for the first couple of years and then the price would go up, up and up!
Like it hasn't already.

At least with competition, you've got choice of provider.
From what I've seen of the NHS, the whole lot needs an army
of time'n'motion folks breathing down their necks.

I can't see that happening while they are sole provider.

Andrew[MG]

3,360 posts

229 months

Monday 31st August 2009
quotequote all
dcb said:
Andrew[MG] said:
The UK has an appalling record in any kind of privatisation and would undoubtedly mess up any big changes to the NHS.
I don't think that's true.

Some (most ?) privatisations have gone well, giving choice and competition
to the consumer.
Like railways, buses, coal, steel and power? Granted they have all had extra investment that they probably wouldn't have had under have had under a nationalised system, but you surely can't say that they have gone well? The railways make a profit by providing the most efficient service possible at the cost of customer service. The railways could provide a great way of reducing pollution and congestion on the roads but all they do is provide a very limited service. Even this success story is in jepordy with many of the franchises now struggling.

dcb said:
Andrew[MG] said:
If you look at how Denmark managed to privatise their railways and how we did it, it's easy to see that we are incapable of managing such a process.
I don't think that stands any serious analysis either.

Independent of whether a small Scandinavian nation of about six million
folks did the railways right, the UK is much bigger and we are talking
NHS here.
Sorry for the railways examples but it's one of the most recent cases of UK privatisation so it's all we've got to go on. The NHS is a much more complicated machine so there are far more areas for problems to occur.

The reason why Denmark managed to make a relative success wasn't because of the size of the country - it was more about how they went about the process. Part of the contracts stopped the cutting of routs, reduction in carriages and hiking of prices like we see happening in the UK.

There are only two ways that companies could keep increasing profits from the NHS year on year.....cut unprofitable service or increase the charges. Maybe the current system is inefficient but at least the country/government can do something about it 9if the political will exists). Once it is privatised then this option is gone.

dcb said:
Andrew[MG] said:
We'd just get shafted by big business....we'd save money for the first couple of years and then the price would go up, up and up!
Like it hasn't already.

At least with competition, you've got choice of provider.
From what I've seen of the NHS, the whole lot needs an army
of time'n'motion folks breathing down their necks.

I can't see that happening while they are sole provider.
I'm sure we could both rant about his all day smile I'm not some mad socialist but I do think there are some things that are better run for the country rather than for profit. Telecoms works much better in the private sector....