Hypothetical manufacturer-retailer question
Hypothetical manufacturer-retailer question
Author
Discussion

singlecoil

Original Poster:

35,893 posts

277 months

Saturday 5th September 2009
quotequote all
Let us suppose that my wife wishes to start a cake baking business. She knows she can bake a very good cake, but wants to get her sister to do the actual selling.

The plan is to sell cakes to her sister, who will then sell them to the end users. How will they decide what the price to the end user should be, and what her sister's margin should be. Obviously the more money each of them wants, the greater the cost to the end user and the lower the number of cakes that will be sold.

Let's suppose, for the sake of this particular question, that neither manufacturer nor retailer can easily deal with other manufacturers or retailers.

Some industries have standard mark-ups, certainly the musical instrument retailing business does, but in an industry where such a standard does not exist, how could one be established?



Marcellus

7,210 posts

250 months

Saturday 5th September 2009
quotequote all
How much does your wifes sisters competitors sell their cakes for?

singlecoil

Original Poster:

35,893 posts

277 months

Saturday 5th September 2009
quotequote all
Marcellus said:
How much does your wifes sisters competitors sell their cakes for?
Good starting point, but their cakes are too different to be much help here, inasmuch as they range (for the sake of argument) from £2 to £20.

Simpo Two

93,111 posts

296 months

Saturday 5th September 2009
quotequote all
You have to see what the competition is doing. If you want to charge more than they do, your product has to be better somehow, either real or perceived. Even if the price is the same, you have to find a way to persuade prospects to buy your cake and not the rival's.

Start at the end (ie retail) then work back to see what the margins are. Already you have two margins in the mix (doh!) (I mean dough!).


ETA following you last post - then you will have to do some research to see what the market is willing to pay.

Edited by Simpo Two on Saturday 5th September 09:33

Marcellus

7,210 posts

250 months

Saturday 5th September 2009
quotequote all
there must be some competitors somewhere unless your wife has found a totally revolutionary cake style..

Example - we wanted "cup cake type things" for our wedding last year;


Individually you're looking at £9 per cup cake from some of the posh cake makers.... we then found someone who made cup cakes in Lincolnshire for £0.50......... 50 guests x 1 cake each + spares = £500 or £25..... we would have paid the £500 after all in the scheme of things not much money.. but everyone likes a bargain!!

SO coming back to your question you have to start with research on competitors as they will be some out there somewhere especially these days of interweb!!

singlecoil

Original Poster:

35,893 posts

277 months

Saturday 5th September 2009
quotequote all
OK, if we are not going to make any progress until the retail price is established, let's decide on a reatil price of £10.

Marcellus

7,210 posts

250 months

Saturday 5th September 2009
quotequote all
OK so you've set your selling price of £10 per unit.

Cost price of a standard cake (loaf tin size) is around the £1.

Gross profit is £9.

Sense of fairness says says £4.50 each?

singlecoil

Original Poster:

35,893 posts

277 months

Saturday 5th September 2009
quotequote all
Problem is, the more cakes produced, the unit cost goes down. On the other hand, finding customers for more cakes might be difficult. On the third hand, the sister's advertising costs per unit may well go down on a greater volume. So no one knows what the profit is until the number of units has been decided.

I'm going to guess that there simply isn't an answer to this problem. And yet it must be one of the oldest business problems in existence.


Marcellus

7,210 posts

250 months

Saturday 5th September 2009
quotequote all
surely as your wife has no business if it weren't for her sister and vice verse why don't they form a partnership and share the profits?

No need for wife to sell to sister just one company working together for mutual benefit?

singlecoil

Original Poster:

35,893 posts

277 months

Saturday 5th September 2009
quotequote all
Marcellus said:
surely as your wife has no business if it weren't for her sister and vice verse why don't they form a partnership and share the profits?

No need for wife to sell to sister just one company working together for mutual benefit?
Not necessarily fair. Suppose it took three times as long to make a cake than it did to sell it? What if the capital costs of setting up the cake-making kitchen were 10 times those of doing the selling? What if these were the other way around?

In any case, it is a hypothetical question, the situation that prompts me to start the thread isn't actually to do with cake making or relatives, but that doesn't matter as the principles are exactly the same.

Marcellus

7,210 posts

250 months

Saturday 5th September 2009
quotequote all
ok, but as neither can succeed without the others investment and vice verse why don't both share the investment/risk/success....

singlecoil

Original Poster:

35,893 posts

277 months

Saturday 5th September 2009
quotequote all
Marcellus said:
ok, but as neither can succeed without the others investment and vice verse why don't both share the investment/risk/success....
Yes indeed, but they would be doing that even if they weren't financially linked. A manufacturer won't get very far without retailers, and the retailers need stock.


Let's suppose, for the sake of the argument, that each party's costs and profits are not known to the other party, and that, in any case, each cannot know how easy or difficult, or how much time it takes for each party to do their thing with each unit sold.

I've been thinking about this problem for a few days now, and I'm rapidly coming to the conclusion that the only way it can be done is for each party to set their own price and to keep it as low as they reasonably can. If things go well then they can re-negotiate later. Trouble is, if one side or the other is doing particularly well out of the deal, they may not want to renegotiate it!

Marcellus

7,210 posts

250 months

Saturday 5th September 2009
quotequote all
In which case if you're the manufacturer then think of your selling price and negotiate hard... if your the distributor think of buying price and negotiate hard!!

HiRich

3,337 posts

293 months

Saturday 5th September 2009
quotequote all
A partnership is the way to go. As to your profit split, work out a formula

Capital costs:
- Oven, cooking equipment
- Car/Delivery van
May be a business contribution rather than whole cost. The decision to buy new capital is something they can agree (including what to buy, how much the business contributes)

Variable Costs
- Ingredients
- Packaging
- Marketing
- Fuel (petrol and electricity)
- Other running costs (contribution to insurance, car tax, etc.)

Deduct these, and you have a profit to share. I would suggest that business value added (ideas, etc.) would be 50:50, so it can be split by hours of work. A further allowance might be made for capital input if one puts more seed money up (allow for payback plus an interest rate).

Write out the rules and agree them. Remember that (particularly if you haven't got shares in a Ltd. Co., you can always revise the rules every year or six months if it becomes clear one is having to do more than the other.

Pity it isn't cakes, as there is a very interesting business model in Surrey.

stuthemong

2,536 posts

248 months

Saturday 5th September 2009
quotequote all
It's all about market though. Ultimately consumers CAN choose to go to other retailers, so you can't look at this business in isolation. Retail price will be pretty much set depending on quality/service of cake - if the balance isn't right, customers will go elsewhere.

You say you can't buy / sell to other people in your chain - but in reality this is what drives EVERYTHING.

If the marketer can get prices on two identical cakes, one from supplier a) (the baker sister) and one from supplier b) (A.N.Other supplier) and the sister's cake is 3X the price of the A.N.Other - then the sister baker has a lot of inefficiency / is making too much profit. The business as a whole is already doomed. The retail sister is fighting a losing battle from day one against the other resellers of A.N.Other cakes, as the other retailer has 1/3 the cost price. Retail sister will sell very few cakes, and therefore baking sister will bake few cakes.

Of course, as mentioned, you can look to differentiate these cakes by service et.c. but ultimately it all comes down to the wider market. There are a few independant sandwich/food sellers in cambridge, cooperatives and hippy whatnots. It's no surprise they all seem to sell a lunch around the £3-5 mark - more and people won't buy 'em - less and it's not going to be worth it for the businesses, or they'd just lower prices and get mega-sales volume.


singlecoil

Original Poster:

35,893 posts

277 months

Saturday 5th September 2009
quotequote all
stuthemong said:
It's all about market though. Ultimately consumers CAN choose to go to other retailers, so you can't look at this business in isolation. Retail price will be pretty much set depending on quality/service of cake - if the balance isn't right, customers will go elsewhere.
No argument with any of that, but I'm trying to focus more on the split between manufacturer and retailer.

If we assume that the retail price is in line with the market, and that the offering is attractive, then the question that remains is what proportion of what the end user pays should go to the manufacturer, and what proportion to the retailer.


HiRich said:
A partnership is the way to go. As to your profit split, work out a formula
Let's further assume that a partnership is completely out of the question, for all sorts of reasons. The two parties might not be in the same country, and each might well have other business interests.

Marcellus

7,210 posts

250 months

Saturday 5th September 2009
quotequote all
even more so, if partnership/collaborative agrement is not possible then negotiation is the only feasible route.... market prices, cost prices, investments, time etc etc are leverage points!

pokethepope

2,667 posts

219 months

Saturday 5th September 2009
quotequote all
I get the impression this is (for the start at least) a small venture? So why not just have a gentlemans ladies agreement between the two, at least until it starts to get serious?

singlecoil

Original Poster:

35,893 posts

277 months

Saturday 5th September 2009
quotequote all
pokethepope said:
I get the impression this is (for the start at least) a small venture? So why not just have a gentlemans ladies agreement between the two, at least until it starts to get serious?
Not particularly small, and some of the numbers could easily get into 4 figures (point of view thing I supose, some people would consider that small), but there still needs to be some kind of division of the proceeds, and that's what I've been wondering about.



Actually, I had a thought earlier while I was washing my hands (I often have thoughts while carrying out mundane tasks, washing my hair is another one that often produces something interesting idea-wise) and that is that the unit price from manufacturer to retailer should drop as more units are sold, thus encouraging the retailer to keep the volume up (by keeping his/her prices keen) and benefitting the manufacturer because his/her cost per unit will always drop as more units are made.

Marcellus

7,210 posts

250 months

Saturday 5th September 2009
quotequote all
OK, I'll bite......... please detail how the manfacturers cost will reduce with volume.