'Cowboy Customers'
Discussion
Poor show (although the bloke presenting was good for a builder - can see him getting more TV work) I heard him on 5 live and it was clear they had legal issues with doing what they wanted i.e door stepping people or setting them up ala Rouge Traders. Its also never going to change the law because the consumer groups hav more power than the business groups....and perhaps rightly so - i expect there are far more ripped off buyers than sellers.
Simpo Two said:
Tiggsy said:
Rouge Traders
Wholesale make-up suppliers?
Back on topic, we're are in the midst of a simialr issue with one customer. Slightly different in that he's 99% paid up to date but now threatening all sorts of spurious defences to a CCJ which is in process.
In this case and many others, the root cause will be that the customer is in severe financial trouble, to the extent that any tactic which delays payment or might even shake some sort of settlement out of the tree is, in their eyes, worth a try.
Met a guy on a cruise ship who admitted he found something to complain about onn every cruise and they always gave him vouchers off his next cruise. In fact he depressed me with his moaning and I avoided him thereafter.
I also knew a guy who deliberately specified a certain sand cement mix in a large wall he had being built and took samples of the mortar each night. One sample didn't have the right mix; he refused to pay for the wall claiming it had not been built to the agreed spec and had to be knocked down and rebuilt to the spec. Of course after negotiation he ended uop with the wall at a knock down price to avoid the cost to the brickies of rebuilding.
I also knew a guy who deliberately specified a certain sand cement mix in a large wall he had being built and took samples of the mortar each night. One sample didn't have the right mix; he refused to pay for the wall claiming it had not been built to the agreed spec and had to be knocked down and rebuilt to the spec. Of course after negotiation he ended uop with the wall at a knock down price to avoid the cost to the brickies of rebuilding.
Edited by Four Cofffee on Wednesday 9th September 13:00
I've been working with a lot of tradesmen over the last 2 or 3 years while I've been doing my barn conversion and almost all of them at some point have complained about customers who don't pay but they rarely mention any of the customers specific reasons for non-payment.
I've quite happily withheld or reduced payments to certain tradesmen when their work has not been up to scratch, where remediation work has been done (by me or other tradesmen) or if they have caused me expense in other ways (delays etc).
I absolutely believe that some customers will just not pay because they can't or don't want to. But most tradesmen, in my experience, will complain about customers ripping them off when in actual fact, said tradesman might have done something to warrant a change in the payments.
Example:
My slater accused me of trying to rip him off when he demanded full payment of the amount he had originally quoted me. I found out from a plasterer that the slater had been bad-mouthing me and had specifically warned him to "be careful about payments" if he was going to work for me.
The slaters scope of work had been vastly reduced (install 12 velux windows instead of 21, reslate 12m2 instead of 20m2 were the biggest changes). The slater demanded full payment based on his original quote (about £7k for the full scope of work). I paid him what i felt was a fair amount for the work he had done. I had kept a note of the hours he had worked and used that to calculate roughly what the revised price should be.
So it's important to get both sides of the story before believing everything a tradesman says about non-paying customers.
Another example - the boiler went tits-up in one of my flats (which was empty at the time).
I took a day off work (I'm a self employed consultant) on the Thursday to wait in for the central heating guy to turn up. He didn't appear and wouldn't answer my calls. He later apologised on the phone (in the evening) and promised to be back first thing next day. So I took another day off and he appeared after lunchtime. Couldn't fix it there and then but I needed it done asap as a prospective tenant was coming to view it the following Tuesday.
The plumber said he could come back on the Monday morning but as it was a bank holiday there would be an emergency call-out fee. I agreed to that, took another day off on the Monday and he didn't appear until 4pm. He fixed the boiler in 20 minutes and sent me a bill for about £500.
With the time I had wasted off work (all day Thursday, Friday morning and most of the Monday) I had lost significantly more income than the cost of the repairs. I wrote the company a letter explaining this and enclosed a cheque for £120 which was enough to cover the parts and the VAT on the parts but none of the labour or the call-out charge. I got several abusive phone calls and a few arsey letters but in the end they left it.
I've quite happily withheld or reduced payments to certain tradesmen when their work has not been up to scratch, where remediation work has been done (by me or other tradesmen) or if they have caused me expense in other ways (delays etc).
I absolutely believe that some customers will just not pay because they can't or don't want to. But most tradesmen, in my experience, will complain about customers ripping them off when in actual fact, said tradesman might have done something to warrant a change in the payments.
Example:
My slater accused me of trying to rip him off when he demanded full payment of the amount he had originally quoted me. I found out from a plasterer that the slater had been bad-mouthing me and had specifically warned him to "be careful about payments" if he was going to work for me.
The slaters scope of work had been vastly reduced (install 12 velux windows instead of 21, reslate 12m2 instead of 20m2 were the biggest changes). The slater demanded full payment based on his original quote (about £7k for the full scope of work). I paid him what i felt was a fair amount for the work he had done. I had kept a note of the hours he had worked and used that to calculate roughly what the revised price should be.
So it's important to get both sides of the story before believing everything a tradesman says about non-paying customers.
Another example - the boiler went tits-up in one of my flats (which was empty at the time).
I took a day off work (I'm a self employed consultant) on the Thursday to wait in for the central heating guy to turn up. He didn't appear and wouldn't answer my calls. He later apologised on the phone (in the evening) and promised to be back first thing next day. So I took another day off and he appeared after lunchtime. Couldn't fix it there and then but I needed it done asap as a prospective tenant was coming to view it the following Tuesday.
The plumber said he could come back on the Monday morning but as it was a bank holiday there would be an emergency call-out fee. I agreed to that, took another day off on the Monday and he didn't appear until 4pm. He fixed the boiler in 20 minutes and sent me a bill for about £500.
With the time I had wasted off work (all day Thursday, Friday morning and most of the Monday) I had lost significantly more income than the cost of the repairs. I wrote the company a letter explaining this and enclosed a cheque for £120 which was enough to cover the parts and the VAT on the parts but none of the labour or the call-out charge. I got several abusive phone calls and a few arsey letters but in the end they left it.
Edited by Lefty Guns on Wednesday 9th September 12:42
Four Cofffee said:
I also knew a guy who deliberately specified a certain sand cement mix in a large wall he had being built and took samples of the mortar each night. One sample didn't have the right mix; he refused to pay for the wall claiming it had not been built to the agreed spec and had to be knocked down and rebuilt to the spec. Of course after negotiation he ended uop with the wall at a knock down price to avoid the cost to the brickies of rebuilding.
I wonder what he'd do if somebody did it to him? Fly into an insane rage I expect. What an unpleasant git; I hope he gets piles.Lefty Guns said:
So it's important to get both sides of the story before believing everything a tradesman says about non-paying customers.
Completely agree.Ive was shafted by a local carpet fitter.
A long story cut short - i was delayed moving due to them not turning up to fit the carpets on the agreed dates and after that had them back 3 times to refit areas as they were cut and laid incorrectly.
I ended up paying 90% of the bill and wrote a full letter of explanation why i wasnt paying the full amount, but would if the problems were sorted.
Cue aggressive phone calls and letters threatening court action etc. The guy who runs the company even phoned my land lord, slagged me off, accused me of tax avoidance and ripping my landlord off which simply didnt make sense given the situation.
Still, i think it was easier than paying the full amount and trying to recover compensation.
The customers concerned in the documentary did seem to be pretty dodgy, but in the majority of circumstances id be very interested to hear both the trader and customers point of view.
Gassing Station | Business | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



