Domain name dispute
Domain name dispute
Author
Discussion

jamesuk28

Original Poster:

2,176 posts

284 months

Thursday 17th September 2009
quotequote all
We have a client who owns a lot of domain names, one in particular is a partial name for a competitor e.g competitornamebusinesssector.com (big competitor ie £38million turnover PA)

To cut a long story short our client has agreed to transfer the domain name to the competitor for a fee. Are they entitled to charge a market value for the domain name ie £5k or will they have to relinquish the domain name for next to nothing.?

rpguk

4,520 posts

315 months

Thursday 17th September 2009
quotequote all
When you say competitornamebusinesssector.com do you mean mcdonaldsburgers.com or just burgers.com? If it includes their trademark or could be construed as passing off then he's in the wrong and should just hand it over.

If it's just a generic term for the business sector then he should be fine but it'd be a good idea to call in legal advice.

JustinP1

13,364 posts

261 months

Thursday 17th September 2009
quotequote all
It comes down to this:

If it mentions the competitor's exact business name, it is likely that if the competitor pushed it, that they may get the domain for nothing over the course of weeks or months anyway.

However, if the fee in reasonable and the company have cash they may just buy it to save the hassle. However, if your client went in too bolshy or asked for a silly amount, then they may end up getting a nasty letter from a good IP solicitor...


Boosted LS1

21,200 posts

291 months

Friday 18th September 2009
quotequote all
Is it relevant who came first? If so that person has probably got an advantage.

silver.fox.2008

820 posts

221 months

Friday 18th September 2009
quotequote all
Don't think its relevant. I think its more to do with the fact if the dispute shows that the person selling is infringing the others trademark.

If its generic to the industry the company can go whistle. If it contains the company name and the company can show that consumers are getting confused with their business then it is likely that the can claim that the other person is cyber squatting.


JustinP1

13,364 posts

261 months

Friday 18th September 2009
quotequote all
It depends.

If you have had a domain name which is reasonably generic, then it would be difficult to claim passing off, for example:

FirstDebtRecovery.com

Could legitimately be used, and if it were used and then First Debt Recovery Limited start trading then they still would have no rights to it.

However if you have registered:

ASDASupermarket.com

Then any reasonable person can see that you can have to legitimate use for this other than to cybersquat it, or use it to 'pass off' as a connection to ASDA to drive traffic.