Closing a Ltd Co with debts to HMRC
Closing a Ltd Co with debts to HMRC
Author
Discussion

jezzaaa

Original Poster:

1,951 posts

290 months

Thursday 24th September 2009
quotequote all
Chaps - hypothetical question smile

Supposing Acme Ltd had ceased trading (just through running low on customers), and with it's last revenue and bank reserves, paid all it's creditors except some NI and CT payments due to HMRC. Let's say that the amounts involved are fairly low...a couple of thousand at most.

The company has no cash, no assets and no chance of any further revenue.

What will HMRC do in this case? Are the directors in any danger of being pursued for the debt? If HMRC forces the company to close and writes off the debt, can there be any comeback on the directors/secretary in terms of bad personal credit ratings etc? Or any ability for them to ban the directors/secretary from becoming a director for another company?

Opinions would be much appreciated.

Cheers,
J.

CatherineJ

9,586 posts

274 months

Thursday 24th September 2009
quotequote all
Well then technically the business is insolvent. I would think HMRC would get a winding up order and then the matter will be passed to the insolvency service


Edited by CatherineJ on Thursday 24th September 15:46

jezzaaa

Original Poster:

1,951 posts

290 months

Thursday 24th September 2009
quotequote all
CatherineJ said:
Well then technically the business is insolvent. I would think HMRC would get a winding up order and then the matter will be passed to the insolvency service


Edited by CatherineJ on Thursday 24th September 15:46
Hi Catherine - thanks for this.

So would the insolvency service be able to pursue the directors, assuming no foul play had occurred (i.e. the directors didn't empty the company bank accounts before telling the revenue it had no money, but equally could have chosen to pay the revenue ahead of it's other creditors)?

Cheers,
J.

john_p

7,073 posts

281 months

Thursday 24th September 2009
quotequote all
CatherineJ said:
Well then technically the business is insolvent. I would think HMRC would get a winding up order and then the matter will be passed to the insolvency service
This.

Unless there was absolutely stonking psstake fraud by the directors (withdrew £2m from the bank account the day before sort of thing) then no chance of a director ban.

Insolvency service would interview you about a year after the business was liquidated and get the basic details, which they'd then use to decide what happens to you.

Edited by john_p on Thursday 24th September 15:53

maser_spyder

6,356 posts

213 months

Thursday 24th September 2009
quotequote all
Sounds like a good, honest, company failure.

No chance of a ban from this, they probably wouldn't even chase a couple of thousand.

The winding up petition costs around £800 alone, so the chances are, they wouldn't even bother.

You could just write to HMCE and tell them the score, either;

1) They'll do nothing, you wait, don't file an annual return, and eventually Companies House will dissolve the company (this can take 12 -18 months), job done, or;

2) They'll order a winding up petition, liquidator will be assigned, you tell him the details, he writes a report, the company is dissolved and debts written off.

Assuming it's a limited company, they won't chase you personally for the debts, and for a few thousand, the won't give you a ban.

Companies fail all the time, often taking millions of revenue from HMCE, if it's an honest failure for a small amount, it's really not worth their efforts chasing it, so they likely won't. Apparently, they are human in these departments after all!

I've never been through this myself, but, better the devil you know, and all that.

CatherineJ

9,586 posts

274 months

Thursday 24th September 2009
quotequote all
As has been said unless they suspect fraud it is unlikely they will be persued. It is one of the benefits of having a Limited Company, unless of course you have given personal guarantees (although those are normally for just getting credit).

Do you know how much they owe HMRC?





Edited by CatherineJ on Thursday 24th September 16:06

jezzaaa

Original Poster:

1,951 posts

290 months

Thursday 24th September 2009
quotequote all
All - many thanks for the excellent responses...much appreciated.

J.

jezzaaa

Original Poster:

1,951 posts

290 months

Thursday 24th September 2009
quotequote all
CatherineJ said:
As has been said unless they suspect fraud it is unlikely they will be persued, it is one of the benefitts of having a Limited Company, unless of course you have given personal guarantees (although those are normally for just getting credit).

Do you know how much they owe HMRC?
Hi Catherine - the err hypothetical company you mean?! smile About £1000 in employee NIC and another £1000 in CT, although the tax return for the last year should wipe out that CT liability since it will almost certainly have made a loss.

CatherineJ

9,586 posts

274 months

Thursday 24th September 2009
quotequote all
Well the business will have to be wound up somehow and although it can stop trading, it can't just shut up shop when it owe's money.


jezzaaa

Original Poster:

1,951 posts

290 months

Thursday 24th September 2009
quotequote all
CatherineJ said:
Well the business will have to be wound up somehow and although it can stop trading, it can't just shut up shop when it owe's money.
Well indeed...and the directors were very careful to make sure it's employee and other private businesses that it owed money too were settled first.

CatherineJ

9,586 posts

274 months

Thursday 24th September 2009
quotequote all
The only problem that I see with that is you are not allowed to show preference to any one creditor.

Edited by CatherineJ on Thursday 24th September 17:13

maser_spyder

6,356 posts

213 months

Thursday 24th September 2009
quotequote all
CatherineJ said:
The only problem that I see with that is you are not allowed to show preference to any one creditor.

Edited by CatherineJ on Thursday 24th September 17:13
Hardly going to matter for £1000, they honestly won't be interested.

I shouldn't lose any sleep over it, really, they have bigger fish to fry!

Olf

11,978 posts

249 months

Thursday 24th September 2009
quotequote all
jezzaaa said:
CatherineJ said:
Well the business will have to be wound up somehow and although it can stop trading, it can't just shut up shop when it owe's money.
Well indeed...and the directors were very careful to make sure it's employee and other private businesses that it owed money too were settled first.
Which as I understand it is wrong. Revenue and Customs get first dibs.

jezzaaa

Original Poster:

1,951 posts

290 months

Thursday 24th September 2009
quotequote all
Olf said:
jezzaaa said:
CatherineJ said:
Well the business will have to be wound up somehow and although it can stop trading, it can't just shut up shop when it owe's money.
Well indeed...and the directors were very careful to make sure it's employee and other private businesses that it owed money too were settled first.
Which as I understand it is wrong. Revenue and Customs get first dibs.
I don't believe that's the case. It used to be the case that the Revenue got first dibs along with the banks etc. However, I believe legislation changed and they were removed from the list of first pickers...which resulted in them becoming much more draconian about recovering debts, or so I remember being told.

CatherineJ

9,586 posts

274 months

Thursday 24th September 2009
quotequote all
Yes thats right. They are pretty much treated as any other creditor in terms of preference.

Olf

11,978 posts

249 months

Thursday 24th September 2009
quotequote all
CatherineJ said:
Yes thats right. They are pretty much treated as any other creditor in terms of preference.
That really does surprise me given the steady power escalation of HMRC.

CatherineJ

9,586 posts

274 months

Thursday 24th September 2009
quotequote all
Olf said:
CatherineJ said:
Yes thats right. They are pretty much treated as any other creditor in terms of preference.
That really does surprise me given the steady power escalation of HMRC.
They used to have what is known as crown preference. I think it changed in September 2003, but don't quote me on that.

jamesuk28

2,176 posts

284 months

Thursday 24th September 2009
quotequote all
Olf said:
jezzaaa said:
CatherineJ said:
Well the business will have to be wound up somehow and although it can stop trading, it can't just shut up shop when it owe's money.
Well indeed...and the directors were very careful to make sure it's employee and other private businesses that it owed money too were settled first.
Which as I understand it is wrong. Revenue and Customs get first dibs.
Not anymore, HMRC have to wait inline with the rest of the unsecured creditors. Its basically the banks that get paid out first along with any other secured debts.

Eric Mc

125,972 posts

296 months

Friday 25th September 2009
quotequote all
Correct. HMRC are no longer a ranked preferential creditor.

pork n beef

1,026 posts

208 months

Friday 25th September 2009
quotequote all
The figures being talked about here are relatively low.
What if the company owed the VAT man £10,000 and another £10,000 in corporation tax?
Surley this would be chased, or if it was a genuine company failure, would this be written off too?