How do I avoid upsetting my clients...
How do I avoid upsetting my clients...
Author
Discussion

Goughie

Original Poster:

616 posts

220 months

Saturday 26th September 2009
quotequote all
...when all three of my main ones are pushing hard for me to work for them full time, (i.e. as an employee)? I really don't want to work for someone else again, yet I'm being put under great pressure to commit to them on a permanent basis.

Now I know that there are lots of people struggling to find a job, and this is in no way meant as a knock to anyone, but I'm happy with my current arrangement as a Ltd company and really value the choices this gives me in life.

Any ideas on how I should approach this issue?


AyBee

11,365 posts

233 months

Saturday 26th September 2009
quotequote all
Goughie said:
...when all three of my main ones are pushing hard for me to work for them full time, (i.e. as an employee)? I really don't want to work for someone else again, yet I'm being put under great pressure to commit to them on a permanent basis.

Now I know that there are lots of people struggling to find a job, and this is in no way meant as a knock to anyone, but I'm happy with my current arrangement as a Ltd company and really value the choices this gives me in life.

Any ideas on how I should approach this issue?
Is it specifically you they want, or just the expertise your company can give them? i.e. Could you take on some employees, train them up, and spread your company love around? tongue out

UpTheIron

4,058 posts

299 months

Saturday 26th September 2009
quotequote all
Sounds like you've made your mind up. You value what you currently do, and how you do it more than a PAYE position with any of these three companies. If all three were no longer your client, how would you feel then?

Kermit power

29,622 posts

244 months

Saturday 26th September 2009
quotequote all
Running your own business, you have the potential for expansion and great wealth if you choose to take that path.

In your position, I'd probably set about writing a long-term business plan showing where you expect to be in 5 or 10 years. Share that with your clients, and ask them if they are willing to pay you the equivalent of seeing your plans materialise, along with giving you the flexibility of working for yourself.

When presented with a realistic plan showing why you would be mad to work for them full time, I'd expect most of them to be reasonable in understanding your motivations.

Of course, given that this would guarantee your future and remove the risk, if one of them said yes, I'd seriously consider taking them up on it! hehe

GreenV8S

31,027 posts

315 months

Saturday 26th September 2009
quotequote all
Kermit power said:
In your position, I'd probably set about writing a long-term business plan showing where you expect to be in 5 or 10 years. Share that with your clients, and ask them if they are willing to pay you the equivalent of seeing your plans materialise, along with giving you the flexibility of working for yourself.
I wouldn't. It's not their decision it's yours, and you don't need to justify it in any way. Turning down an employment offer isn't an insult, it just means you have better opportunities elsewhere. The offer is flattering and shows they appreciate you, but if somebody is offended that you won't join their company they're probably not somebody you want to work for anyway.

jimmyb

12,254 posts

247 months

Saturday 26th September 2009
quotequote all
Agree with V8s. you dont have to justify yourself to them per se for turning them down. I would suggest meeting with the managers from each company who are pressuring you into becoming full time and have a face to face convo. Simply point out that as generous as their offer is you plan on staying self employed due to reasons you have given on here and point out you hope it causes no offence or ill feeling etc.

Seems the simplest option to me. Simply telling them no will leave them wondering why and possibly offended and a letter is just impersonal.I can see no reason for them to object or be offended so long as you are straight with them they will appreciate it.

davidjpowell

18,708 posts

215 months

Saturday 26th September 2009
quotequote all
The obvious risk of saying no, is that they will look for someone with your skill sets who will say yes. IF you cannot afford that to happen I fear that you may be in a bit of a sticky position at this point.

As to your question, How do I avoid upsetting my clients... you say "Yes", but it's not really an option.

Goughie

Original Poster:

616 posts

220 months

Saturday 26th September 2009
quotequote all
Some good advice here chaps, thanks.

I am currently a one man Ltd co. and my skill set is pretty unusual within my field so training up (after taking on) new employees isn't much of a goer at the moment, and doesn't really help in my short term predicament.

I've thought long and hard about what it would mean to lose these clients, and I'd be OK if I only had one of the three on board - that makes my discussions somewhat easier, but doesn't remove the fact that my desire to stay independant does not completely square with their own plans for future expansion (with me as a key player in these plans).

As has been touched on, it may be that certain clients aren't actually a good fit for my business aims, and I need to get better at selecting more compatible clients. I set my business up to work on a set number of days/month so it'll just be an adaptation of this strategy to focus on client profiles, too...

ymwoods

2,194 posts

208 months

Sunday 27th September 2009
quotequote all
what is it exactly that you do that is so bespoke that no one else could be trained yet you are invaluable to these companies? of course if that question can't be asked for whatever reason feel free to decline.

TooLateForAName

4,935 posts

215 months

Sunday 27th September 2009
quotequote all
Goughie said:
my desire to stay independant does not completely square with their own plans for future expansion (with me as a key player in these plans).

As has been touched on, it may be that certain clients aren't actually a good fit for my business aims, and I need to get better at selecting more compatible clients. I set my business up to work on a set number of days/month so it'll just be an adaptation of this strategy to focus on client profiles, too...
I'm interested to know more about what you are bringing to this. How large are your clients and how significant are your skillset/knowledge/contacts to their plans?

Are you in a position to enter into formal joint ventures rather than being a contractor? Would they consider buying you out/appointing you as a director?

How much do the various clients overlap - is there any concern about competing interests?

Basically, I think that I would want to know if they want you on board to reduce costs or as a strategic move. That really depends on how you should think about their offers and how you should respond.

ringram

14,702 posts

279 months

Sunday 27th September 2009
quotequote all
Exactly, sell them a stake in your business!

Goughie

Original Poster:

616 posts

220 months

Sunday 27th September 2009
quotequote all
ymwoods said:
what is it exactly that you do that is so bespoke that no one else could be trained yet you are invaluable to these companies? of course if that question can't be asked for whatever reason feel free to decline.
I didn't say my skill set is unique, just very unusual. I work with SME's in the food sector and bring a blue chip level of cost-based technical competencies to these companies along with a large contact book of supermarkets and suppliers. In other words, I facilitate the transfer from supplying small(er) clients (such as retaurant and food service groups) to large, multinational clients (such as supermarkets). My appeal lies in the fact that I have a reputation for getting things done within the major multiples, with the ability to talk to technical and sales managers on their level - these two roles are normally (but not always) mutually exclusive within the retail sector. As a result, most of my current work is via recommendations from supermarket head offices around the world.

Having just read that back a lot of people are going to say "what a lot of management talk BS" - think what you like, I am a go to guy in my field... biggrin

Goughie

Original Poster:

616 posts

220 months

Sunday 27th September 2009
quotequote all
TooLateForAName said:
I'm interested to know more about what you are bringing to this. How large are your clients and how significant are your skillset/knowledge/contacts to their plans?

Are you in a position to enter into formal joint ventures rather than being a contractor? Would they consider buying you out/appointing you as a director?

How much do the various clients overlap - is there any concern about competing interests?

Basically, I think that I would want to know if they want you on board to reduce costs or as a strategic move. That really depends on how you should think about their offers and how you should respond.
Clients are SME's (excluding one which is c. £25-30m). There is no overlap in client interest - I've been very careful about that - indeed some clients are seperated by continents! All the offers are for a combination of cost reductions (technical competencies) and strategic purposes (contacts and business development).

ymwoods

2,194 posts

208 months

Monday 28th September 2009
quotequote all
Goughie said:
ymwoods said:
what is it exactly that you do that is so bespoke that no one else could be trained yet you are invaluable to these companies? of course if that question can't be asked for whatever reason feel free to decline.
I didn't say my skill set is unique, just very unusual. I work with SME's in the food sector and bring a blue chip level of cost-based technical competencies to these companies along with a large contact book of supermarkets and suppliers. In other words, I facilitate the transfer from supplying small(er) clients (such as retaurant and food service groups) to large, multinational clients (such as supermarkets). My appeal lies in the fact that I have a reputation for getting things done within the major multiples, with the ability to talk to technical and sales managers on their level - these two roles are normally (but not always) mutually exclusive within the retail sector. As a result, most of my current work is via recommendations from supermarket head offices around the world.

Having just read that back a lot of people are going to say "what a lot of management talk BS" - think what you like, I am a go to guy in my field... biggrin
I get it, your the guy with the book of contacts thats also able to talk the talk when needed and known for making sure things get done, no bullsttin and no fanying about.

The perfect guy and someone that I think millions of businesses wish they had. No wonder they are all lining up as if they get you, they get your contacts, and of course your reputation. Then on top of that the cost savings I am assuming aswell.

In terms of training someone up i see your problem...you need another you, another person with your rep and abilities and preferably for them to have those skills/qualitys "straight out of the box" so to speak otherwise straight away your clients will decide to only converse with you or go elsewhere.

Tricky situation to be honest, but if you love being your own boss, and the company is still viable if all but one pulled out then I think you already know your decision. You love your company, what you have built up and most of all you love doing it your way. In the meantime be on the look-out for the other you!

Edited by ymwoods on Monday 28th September 08:27

TooLateForAName

4,935 posts

215 months

Monday 28th September 2009
quotequote all
Goughie said:
TooLateForAName said:
I'm interested to know more about what you are bringing to this. How large are your clients and how significant are your skillset/knowledge/contacts to their plans?

Are you in a position to enter into formal joint ventures rather than being a contractor? Would they consider buying you out/appointing you as a director?

How much do the various clients overlap - is there any concern about competing interests?

Basically, I think that I would want to know if they want you on board to reduce costs or as a strategic move. That really depends on how you should think about their offers and how you should respond.
Clients are SME's (excluding one which is c. £25-30m). There is no overlap in client interest - I've been very careful about that - indeed some clients are seperated by continents! All the offers are for a combination of cost reductions (technical competencies) and strategic purposes (contacts and business development).
In that case I would suggest that you recruit pdq. I would assume that you could fairly easily pick up people with the technical competence from your contacts? If you could get others with the strategic stuff even better.

I would be looking at becoming a consultancy organisation rather than an individual consultant. Perhaps talk that through with the clients, explaining that the strategic side of what you can offer would be degraded if you became a full time employee for one client? I dont know the contractual basis of your relationships, retainers, long term contracts, piece work (in effect). You could perhaps move to a situation with better guarantees/visible work flow?

The only reason for joining one of the clients would be if you would be doing so at a senior enough position that you would derive significant benefits from what you deliver. Not just financially but in terms of industry positioning. Would you want to run one of the clients in time?