Equity stake in a startup ... How to put a value on it ?
Equity stake in a startup ... How to put a value on it ?
Author
Discussion

205

Original Poster:

76 posts

259 months

Thursday 1st October 2009
quotequote all
Good day champions of commerse! Your assistance please..

I am about to start helping a new business market itself and will be introducing this new business to it's end users/customers.

I've been offered as payment an equity stake in the company and I am due to go back to them to discuss my percentage.

I'll hold my hands up and say I'm completely out of my depth in discussing these sorts of terms as I've only previously worked as an employee for various firms and paid via PAYE and share options.

The company has been started by 3 guys who are equal investors.

How do I value what I am bringing to table and hence what percentage of the company's eventual equity I am entitled to ??

V8mate

45,899 posts

220 months

Thursday 1st October 2009
quotequote all
How screwed would they be if you walked away?

205

Original Poster:

76 posts

259 months

Thursday 1st October 2009
quotequote all
It'll take them a year or so to reach the people I can get them in front of immidiately. They know that which is why they want me on board.




steve z

1,245 posts

253 months

Thursday 1st October 2009
quotequote all
If you're saying you get an equity stake for your advice and you don't have to put any capital in then what have you got to lose (not sure if you have liabilities as an equity partner should it all go tits up - i'd get legal advice on this).

Sounds like the business can't work without your knowledge and therefore i'd be pitching for an equal stake (i.e. 25% as a minimum)

jeremyc

28,411 posts

315 months

Thursday 1st October 2009
quotequote all
You do realise that the flipside of this opportunity is that your equity stake could be worth nothing, don't you?

If you're happy with an equity arrangement then go for the largest possible stake you can get away with; trying to equate it to a nominal value of an early stage startup is almost impossible. The important factor is what it might be worth in a few years when some kind of transaction to provide liquidity for your equity occurs (an acquisition or IPO). smile


205

Original Poster:

76 posts

259 months

Thursday 1st October 2009
quotequote all
thanks steve.. I will difinately be checking out the legalities for any potential liability on my part.

I'm sure they could get it working eventually without me but it would certainly take them some time to get in front of the right people to make it really fly..

I have not contributed a penny and won't do. Initial discussions were 5% which I fobbed off until I could do a bit of research. Felt way too low.

flyingjase

3,095 posts

262 months

Thursday 1st October 2009
quotequote all
How much of your time will you be putting into it? Is it a full timec oommitment? What is the opportunity cost of that time?

205

Original Poster:

76 posts

259 months

Thursday 1st October 2009
quotequote all
exactly jeremy. 100% of nothing is...

I intend to push for a bigger chunk in the hope that 2-3yrs down the line that will be worth a sizable sum.

I'm very sure it will be, funding is not an issue, potential revenue relative to their investment is huge.

205

Original Poster:

76 posts

259 months

Thursday 1st October 2009
quotequote all
I am already commited full time.
I will be arranging/attending meetings with them in my spare time.

therealpigdog

2,592 posts

228 months

Thursday 1st October 2009
quotequote all
If it's an equity stake in a limited liability company, then you should be ok as regards to personal liability.

In terms of going for a percentage, then go for as high as you can get. What's the projected value of the company in say three years, and what do you think your contribution is worth over those three years - it's as good a starting point as any. At the end of the day you just need to barter hard to get as much as possible, but you should be realistic if they are going to put most of the leg work in.

Whatever stake you get, do seriously consider a professionally prepared shareholders' agreement which can be used to give you the power of veto over certain things, sets out how share transfers are carried out, and what happens on death etc. This can negate any issues regarding low % shareholdings as to control or management of the company, and your rights to see accounts etc.

Best of luck

steve z

1,245 posts

253 months

Thursday 1st October 2009
quotequote all
205 said:
I am already commited full time.
I will be arranging/attending meetings with them in my spare time.
Are you getting a salary as well then?

205

Original Poster:

76 posts

259 months

Thursday 1st October 2009
quotequote all
Steve, I'm committed to another company full time. I won't be taking a salary from the startup. There won't be any conflict of interest so there should not be a problem with my employer.

I intend to go down the route of taking proffessional advise as they intend to set up a shareholder's agreement.

Any suggestions on who to consult ?

steve z

1,245 posts

253 months

Thursday 1st October 2009
quotequote all
This would look like a good place to start for some free advice and then you can take from there:-

http://www.startups.co.uk/6678842907462807641/free...

Also, do you know your full time employer is fine with this? You may think there isn't a conflicy of interests but they may. To 100% cover yourself you may want to let them know what you're doing and give them the assurance that this will not impact in anyway your ability to do your full time job.

HiRich

3,337 posts

293 months

Thursday 1st October 2009
quotequote all
205 said:
It'll take them a year or so to reach the people I can get them in front of immidiately. They know that which is why they want me on board.
To value your input, work on a 10% commission on any business resulting from your input. Factor that £-value over say three years of financial forecasting to put a monetary value against your input. Now proportion that against the contributions by the other investors (hours worked, value of the idea, cash investment, etc.) to give an initial share split.

Twaek for the importance of each input (they could go without you, they could not go without the patent holder). Consider accepting a share option/bonus scheme so your stake starts lower and rises if you actually deliver the business - if they do £1m business in the first year, you receive an extra share bonus increasing your stake by 2%.

Four Cofffee

11,838 posts

266 months

Thursday 1st October 2009
quotequote all
I had a similar offer recently. Basically they offered me, and a number of other people with niche techie skills, 5% of free equity at start up. In return I had to work for expenses and a much reduced/free day rate in helping them get the business up and running, and then I could also charge a full day rate.

In the end I walked away in favour of simply acting as a day rate consultant because enquiries I made about the existing directors suggested they were ALREADY stripping the profits out of their current business to start the new one, taking the best intellectual property on to their new venture (which they were claiming as their own despite the fact it had been developed while they were at the company), and leaving the previous 5% equity holders with 5% of nothing of any real value. I figured that if they had done it once, they would do it again. I knew they would want a few days a month from me for free, so I was down £1200-£1500 a month to start with. May be short sighted of me, but a bird in the hand....


In summary, what do you have X% of and what is stopping them taking the value out?

JustinP1

13,364 posts

261 months

Thursday 1st October 2009
quotequote all
When someone freely offers you something it is only because they value what they are getting from you more than what they are offering.

1

2,732 posts

267 months

Thursday 1st October 2009
quotequote all
JustinP1 said:
When someone freely offers you something it is only because they value what they are getting from you more than what they are offering.
confused

This is known as stating the bleeding obvious.

No one would buy or sell anything unless they valued what they were getting more than what they were giving or vice versa.

The second rule of business is earn more than you spend.

I have lots more and will be here all week.


StevieBee

15,521 posts

286 months

Thursday 1st October 2009
quotequote all
Some good advice here.

Would also add that you need to factor in some kind of management condition – that is to say that you have an input in how the business is running to ensure that your investment is secure.

JustinP1

13,364 posts

261 months

Friday 2nd October 2009
quotequote all
1 said:
JustinP1 said:
When someone freely offers you something it is only because they value what they are getting from you more than what they are offering.
confused

This is known as stating the bleeding obvious.

No one would buy or sell anything unless they valued what they were getting more than what they were giving or vice versa.

The second rule of business is earn more than you spend.

I have lots more and will be here all week.
That's not always obvious at all, as it is very easy to get caught into discussions without considering *why* the other party wants the deal - because this will often be the deciding factor on whether you get what you want.

The OP was looking for advice pushing him in the right direction.

IMHO my thoughts would be of protecting my interests. It *could* be the case that they want a fair deal - but it also may be the case that the directors know fully that an equity stake will pay the OP for less than if he just got paid for the job.

therealpigdog

2,592 posts

228 months

Friday 2nd October 2009
quotequote all
205 said:
I intend to go down the route of taking proffessional advise as they intend to set up a shareholder's agreement.

Any suggestions on who to consult ?
whistle