are allRegistered Design Vs Patents
are allRegistered Design Vs Patents
Author
Discussion

Four Cofffee

Original Poster:

11,838 posts

266 months

Sunday 4th October 2009
quotequote all

Reading the IPO web site it seesm to me that a Patent application is long and drawn our and basically requires you to bare all, and wait ages in the hope of getting a patent.

The Registered design seems less water tight, more hard product orientated, but less onerous.

How come the Dragons Den bods bang on about patents when the tortous route to a full patent seems to be 2.5-4.5 years by which trime most technology and customers will have moved on? Do you get any protection while the patent is proceeding?

Ghisallo

1,258 posts

209 months

Monday 5th October 2009
quotequote all
Four Cofffee said:
Reading the IPO web site it seesm to me that a Patent application is long and drawn our and basically requires you to bare all, and wait ages in the hope of getting a patent.

The Registered design seems less water tight, more hard product orientated, but less onerous.

How come the Dragons Den bods bang on about patents when the tortous route to a full patent seems to be 2.5-4.5 years by which trime most technology and customers will have moved on? Do you get any protection while the patent is proceeding?
Between filing and grant (or abandonment) a patent application is 'pending'. You only bare all at around 18 months (usually) when the patent application is published and from this point you will have “provisional” protection which can be acted on after the grant of the patent. If there are potential infringers on the go early on during your application you can request early publication so that the provisional protection commences from the earliest date possible. By marking products as 'patent pending' potential infringers will (should!) know that they may be liable for damages (including back-dated royalties), seizure, and/or injunction once the patent is granted.

Although the UK Intellectual Property Office might indicate 2.5-4.5 years to grant I've had UK patents granted within 8 or 9 months. I've also seen up to 10 years pending before the grant of a European Patent for fairly straightforward mecahnaical engineering invention.

You are right about registered designs; they are straightforward to obtain as they are not examined per se but they only protect the appearance of products and do not protect any technical function. Unless someone has totally copied your registered design, enforcing can at times feel pretty hairy, the question of infringement and validity can seem quite subjective.



Four Cofffee

Original Poster:

11,838 posts

266 months

Monday 5th October 2009
quotequote all
Ghisallo said:
Four Cofffee said:
Reading the IPO web site it seesm to me that a Patent application is long and drawn our and basically requires you to bare all, and wait ages in the hope of getting a patent.

The Registered design seems less water tight, more hard product orientated, but less onerous.

How come the Dragons Den bods bang on about patents when the tortous route to a full patent seems to be 2.5-4.5 years by which trime most technology and customers will have moved on? Do you get any protection while the patent is proceeding?
Between filing and grant (or abandonment) a patent application is 'pending'. You only bare all at around 18 months (usually) when the patent application is published and from this point you will have “provisional” protection which can be acted on after the grant of the patent. If there are potential infringers on the go early on during your application you can request early publication so that the provisional protection commences from the earliest date possible. By marking products as 'patent pending' potential infringers will (should!) know that they may be liable for damages (including back-dated royalties), seizure, and/or injunction once the patent is granted.

Although the UK Intellectual Property Office might indicate 2.5-4.5 years to grant I've had UK patents granted within 8 or 9 months. I've also seen up to 10 years pending before the grant of a European Patent for fairly straightforward mecahnaical engineering invention.

You are right about registered designs; they are straightforward to obtain as they are not examined per se but they only protect the appearance of products and do not protect any technical function. Unless someone has totally copied your registered design, enforcing can at times feel pretty hairy, the question of infringement and validity can seem quite subjective.
Thanks for that. I think that I probably cannot protect the invention with a Patent as it was developed from another idea which is well documented and used in the public domain. Given the speed of development these days it seems odd that you cannot get a more rapid patent than 18 months ( or even 9 months) because we need to be at market in 3-6 months when the world will see what we have anyway. The registered design seems to offer some protection from people copying the 'look' of the product.



Ghisallo

1,258 posts

209 months

Monday 5th October 2009
quotequote all
Four Cofffee said:
Ghisallo said:
Four Cofffee said:
Reading the IPO web site it seesm to me that a Patent application is long and drawn our and basically requires you to bare all, and wait ages in the hope of getting a patent.

The Registered design seems less water tight, more hard product orientated, but less onerous.

How come the Dragons Den bods bang on about patents when the tortous route to a full patent seems to be 2.5-4.5 years by which trime most technology and customers will have moved on? Do you get any protection while the patent is proceeding?
Between filing and grant (or abandonment) a patent application is 'pending'. You only bare all at around 18 months (usually) when the patent application is published and from this point you will have “provisional” protection which can be acted on after the grant of the patent. If there are potential infringers on the go early on during your application you can request early publication so that the provisional protection commences from the earliest date possible. By marking products as 'patent pending' potential infringers will (should!) know that they may be liable for damages (including back-dated royalties), seizure, and/or injunction once the patent is granted.

Although the UK Intellectual Property Office might indicate 2.5-4.5 years to grant I've had UK patents granted within 8 or 9 months. I've also seen up to 10 years pending before the grant of a European Patent for fairly straightforward mecahnaical engineering invention.

You are right about registered designs; they are straightforward to obtain as they are not examined per se but they only protect the appearance of products and do not protect any technical function. Unless someone has totally copied your registered design, enforcing can at times feel pretty hairy, the question of infringement and validity can seem quite subjective.
Thanks for that. I think that I probably cannot protect the invention with a Patent as it was developed from another idea which is well documented and used in the public domain. Given the speed of development these days it seems odd that you cannot get a more rapid patent than 18 months ( or even 9 months) because we need to be at market in 3-6 months when the world will see what we have anyway. The registered design seems to offer some protection from people copying the 'look' of the product.
It can be long enough depending on the technical field and other factors e.g. the rigours of search and examination, the examiner's work load...


If your improvements over the older idea are not in the public domain they may well be patentable. If you need any further specific advice PM me sure.


Four Cofffee

Original Poster:

11,838 posts

266 months

Monday 5th October 2009
quotequote all
Ghisallo said:
Four Cofffee said:
Ghisallo said:
Four Cofffee said:
Reading the IPO web site it seesm to me that a Patent application is long and drawn our and basically requires you to bare all, and wait ages in the hope of getting a patent.

The Registered design seems less water tight, more hard product orientated, but less onerous.

How come the Dragons Den bods bang on about patents when the tortous route to a full patent seems to be 2.5-4.5 years by which trime most technology and customers will have moved on? Do you get any protection while the patent is proceeding?
Between filing and grant (or abandonment) a patent application is 'pending'. You only bare all at around 18 months (usually) when the patent application is published and from this point you will have “provisional” protection which can be acted on after the grant of the patent. If there are potential infringers on the go early on during your application you can request early publication so that the provisional protection commences from the earliest date possible. By marking products as 'patent pending' potential infringers will (should!) know that they may be liable for damages (including back-dated royalties), seizure, and/or injunction once the patent is granted.

Although the UK Intellectual Property Office might indicate 2.5-4.5 years to grant I've had UK patents granted within 8 or 9 months. I've also seen up to 10 years pending before the grant of a European Patent for fairly straightforward mecahnaical engineering invention.

You are right about registered designs; they are straightforward to obtain as they are not examined per se but they only protect the appearance of products and do not protect any technical function. Unless someone has totally copied your registered design, enforcing can at times feel pretty hairy, the question of infringement and validity can seem quite subjective.
Thanks for that. I think that I probably cannot protect the invention with a Patent as it was developed from another idea which is well documented and used in the public domain. Given the speed of development these days it seems odd that you cannot get a more rapid patent than 18 months ( or even 9 months) because we need to be at market in 3-6 months when the world will see what we have anyway. The registered design seems to offer some protection from people copying the 'look' of the product.
It can be long enough depending on the technical field and other factors e.g. the rigours of search and examination, the examiner's work load...


If your improvements over the older idea are not in the public domain they may well be patentable. If you need any further specific advice PM me sure.
Thanks for that, and the offer. I have booked an appointment with an IPO lawyer now who knows the product as there are some licensing/contractual issues as well as the IP stuff.