Eperian credit report, does not give credit score!
Eperian credit report, does not give credit score!
Author
Discussion

69 coupe

Original Poster:

2,459 posts

242 months

Monday 12th October 2009
quotequote all
Thought i'd do a credit report on myself, decided to go for the £2 fee delivered report.
I was expecting to see a score report i.e somewhere between 0-1000, but no all my Experian report shows is a 2-3 page report, showing my address, was I on the electoral roll, and two or three companies who last looked at my credit history last one been RBS insurance quote, their was also a linked address of a property I lived at 6 odd years ago, report shows nothing about credit cards (very rarely use them). Waste of money me thinks.
So how do i get my score??
I thought Experian were the main players in this field?.



Maybe this shoud be in finance or the lounge, who knows! wobble

Edited by 69 coupe on Monday 12th October 14:07

bga

8,134 posts

282 months

Monday 12th October 2009
quotequote all
Companies use the data provided by one or more credit agencies to score you based on their risk criteria. Two companies can score you differently.

I know a couple of guys who work for Experian and they reckon that the sites which give you a score are a waste of money for that reason.

69 coupe

Original Poster:

2,459 posts

242 months

Monday 12th October 2009
quotequote all
IL_JDM said:
69 coupe said:
Thought i'd do a credit report on myself, decided to go for the £2 fee delivered report.
I was expecting to see a score report i.e somewhere between 0-1000, but no all my Experian report shows is a 2-3 page report, showing my address, was I on the electoral roll, and two or three companies who last looked at my credit history last one been RBS insurance quote, their was also a linked address of a property I lived at 6 odd years ago, report shows nothing about credit cards (very rarely use them). Waste of money me thinks.
So how do i get my score??
I thought Experian were the main players in this field?.



Maybe this shoud be in finance or the lounge, who knows! wobble

Edited by 69 coupe on Monday 12th October 14:07
You clicked the wrong one.

The credit report is around £5. You just asked for a printed version of what you get online.
Doh!, have you got the exact link farked if i can find it!

69 coupe

Original Poster:

2,459 posts

242 months

Monday 12th October 2009
quotequote all
IL_JDM said:
69 coupe said:
IL_JDM said:
69 coupe said:
Thought i'd do a credit report on myself, decided to go for the £2 fee delivered report.
I was expecting to see a score report i.e somewhere between 0-1000, but no all my Experian report shows is a 2-3 page report, showing my address, was I on the electoral roll, and two or three companies who last looked at my credit history last one been RBS insurance quote, their was also a linked address of a property I lived at 6 odd years ago, report shows nothing about credit cards (very rarely use them). Waste of money me thinks.
So how do i get my score??
I thought Experian were the main players in this field?.



Maybe this shoud be in finance or the lounge, who knows! wobble

Edited by 69 coupe on Monday 12th October 14:07
You clicked the wrong one.

The credit report is around £5. You just asked for a printed version of what you get online.
Doh!, have you got the exact link farked if i can find it!
Is it not the big orange thing when you log in? £5.95..

Also when you view your online report (free version) there's a tickbox to include the £5.95 report, either way, you'll have to enter credit card details.

https://www.creditexpert.co.uk/mccscorecentre.aspx

Edited by IL_JDM on Monday 12th October 14:20
Ahh, I did the £2 thing because I didn't want to sign up and then cancel before 30 days, I don't have a login I did it all through the www.experian.com site, your link takes me to a different place http://www.creditexpert.co.uk even though they are the same company. The sneeky little tikes.smile

69 coupe

Original Poster:

2,459 posts

242 months

Monday 12th October 2009
quotequote all
IL_JDM said:
Ah, I always assumed they were the same company (CreditExpert are part of the experian group).

There's a free 14 day trial and cashback via quidco/cashbackkings to be had with CreditExpert wink

Edited by IL_JDM on Monday 12th October 14:44
I thank you thumbup

mcflurry

9,192 posts

284 months

Monday 12th October 2009
quotequote all
The scores are worth zip IMHO, as each lender assesses using their own internal secret scoring methodology smile

Marf

22,907 posts

272 months

Monday 12th October 2009
quotequote all
mcflurry said:
The scores are worth zip IMHO, as each lender assesses using their own internal secret scoring methodology smile

69 coupe

Original Poster:

2,459 posts

242 months

Monday 12th October 2009
quotequote all
mcflurry said:
The scores are worth zip IMHO, as each lender assesses using their own internal secret scoring methodology smile
What about Letting agents/landlords, how do they decide if your a decent fellow chapess, say if you've never rented before or just came back from a long trip abroad. Especially in todays climate lost your job ect, aren't they going to class you as dole scum.

mrmr96

13,736 posts

235 months

Monday 12th October 2009
quotequote all
I used to work for one of the biggest UK highstreet retail banks designing their credit score cards. (I.e. the mechanism which takes our knowlege about you and applies rules to come up with a score.)

I worked in the overdrafts team but the loans/credit cars/mortgage teams worked similarly. Because we are a retail bank I was able to use the internally generated data on customers, not just the stuff availible from credit reference agencies. So we had all the info about how you use your current account and all your cards, not just the stuff on that experian report.

Basically we'd choose a sample of people who have been customers for 12m+. We'd classify them as either 'good' or 'bad' based on their performance in the last 12 months. Then we'd rewind back to 12 months ago and see what we knew about those people then, i.e. at the start of the 12m period. We would then use some stats software to work out what the good people and the bad people had in common before they actually went good or bad.

The idea then is that when a new customer wants a product we can compare them to the pool of people who turned out good and those who turned out bad, to see if this new customer looked like someone likely to go bad in the next 12months or not.

The actual mechanic of this was to choose 12 or so characteristics which were most significatly different in the good vs bad pool, and then assign them a score based on how influential/common/frequent each thing was. (Things like age, time account held, number of direct debits, etc. Not allowed to use postcode or sex.) To get your score you get a different number of points depending on your value for each of the 12 characteristics. Add them up and that's your score. We could then use the score to determine what products to offer, and what rates. The bench mark score to get a product could then be raised or lowered depending on what the market was doing. If we want more customers, lower the bar. If we want fewer, raise the bar.

So although the credit reference agencies can give you a score, it is not a 'universal' score. It's just their score. Your bank will have a different score for you, as it has info on you that the agencies don't. Other banks will score differently as they will have different scorecards.

So an equifax score will be a reasonable indication of your financial 'health' but you can't wave it under the nose of a bank and tell them to lend to you, becasue they will have their own scorecard which will use different criteria (if availible) and no doubt use it differently.

Hope that goes some way towards answering why an agency credit score isn't as useful as it appears to be, as there's no such thing as 'your score' since it varies by lender and varies over time.

Happy to answer most questions if people have any.

Edited by mrmr96 on Monday 12th October 16:50

eyebeebe

3,875 posts

264 months

Monday 12th October 2009
quotequote all
I used to work for Experian in the division which punts scorecards to financial institutions. It's true that the big players would have their own customised scorecard, but it was nearly always based on the 'generic' scorecard, with a few tweaks for that institution's risk profile and priorities.

Smaller places would just buy the much cheaper generic scorecard. I can't say for sure now, but when CreditExpert was launched they just used the generic scorecard. Therefore the score you get from that website should give you a reasonable indication of a likely outcome.

mrmr96

13,736 posts

235 months

Monday 12th October 2009
quotequote all
eyebeebe said:
It's true that the big players would have their own customised scorecard, but it was nearly always based on the 'generic' scorecard, with a few tweaks for that institution's risk profile and priorities.
Ours were always built from scratch. But having over 14 million current account customers meant we had the data to do this. You're dead right that smaller places wouldn't have sufficient data to build their own properly, so generic ones are used either as a base or used outright.

I'm not saying an agency one is wrong, but just pointing out that there's no such thing as 'your score' as it varies by institution and by date.

amir_j

3,579 posts

232 months

Tuesday 13th October 2009
quotequote all
eyebeebe said:
I used to work for Experian in the division which punts scorecards to financial institutions. It's true that the big players would have their own customised scorecard, but it was nearly always basedP on the 'generic' scorecard, with a few tweaks for that institution's risk profile and priorities.

Smaller places would just buy the much cheaper generic scorecard. I can't say for sure now, but when CreditExpert was launched they just used the generic scorecard. Therefore the score you get from that website should give you a reasonable indication of a likely outcome.
Not so straightforward as depends on type of company and purpose and size of amounts involved. Your typical estate agent may look at the score and number of zeros but anyone of any note will have a custom risk scoring process which will include a whole lot more.

Talking from experience as worked directly with external consultants as they fine tuned the system for a hire purchase company.

Bearing in mind people put car payments second only to mortgAge in times of distress and the right to reclaimvehicle, they still went to great lengths of detail.

bga

8,134 posts

282 months

Tuesday 13th October 2009
quotequote all
mrmr96 said:
Not allowed to use postcode or sex.
Out of interest is this due to legislative requirements or an internal policy?
From a credit point of view I would guess that they have a bearing on overall risk rating.

mrmr96

13,736 posts

235 months

Tuesday 13th October 2009
quotequote all
bga said:
mrmr96 said:
Not allowed to use postcode or sex.
Out of interest is this due to legislative requirements or an internal policy?
From a credit point of view I would guess that they have a bearing on overall risk rating.
Legislation.

Indeed we would have loved to be able to use them as these characteristics would have certainly been statistically significant. However these are deemed to be things outside of a persons control and therefore it wouldn't be 'fair' to use them in a credit scorecard. Couldn't use race either, obviously, not least because we didn't have the data. That, and the fact that it would be incredible non-pc. I wouldn't like to guess as to whether race would be a significant determinant in any case. But that aside, there's a few things people can't control which we can't use (sex/postcode), but curiously we could use age though.

I've always been intrigued as to why age is something with is allowed to be used for credit scoring, but sex and postcode isn't. Also, I have never worked in insurance but empirical evidence suggests that sex and postcode are used to determine the policy price for things like car insurance. Why insurers can use sex/postcode but banks can't is a bit of a puzzle to me.

Edited by mrmr96 on Tuesday 13th October 11:18

amir_j

3,579 posts

232 months

Tuesday 13th October 2009
quotequote all
mrmr96 said:
Not allowed to use postcode or sex.
hmmmm, suprising as I knew at least one company that uses postcode inorder to find the typical household income...

mrmr96

13,736 posts

235 months

Tuesday 13th October 2009
quotequote all
amir_j said:
mrmr96 said:
Not allowed to use postcode or sex.
hmmmm, suprising as I knew at least one company that uses postcode inorder to find the typical household income...
For what purpose though? If it's to credit score individuals then it's not allowed. (Or at least it wasn't when I was working.)

mrmr96

13,736 posts

235 months

Tuesday 13th October 2009
quotequote all
Having said that, I've just found this:
https://www.checkmyfile.com/articles/186/neighbour...
website said:
LOANS
Neighbours who borrow recklessly can damage your chances of getting a loan or credit card.
Barry Stamp, joint managing director of credit information service checkmyfile.com, says: 'In general, people tend to live near like-minded people. There is a good correlation between where you live and your credit rating.'
Credit reference agencies give each postcode its own score, ranging from 500 to 1,000 based on the risk of bad debts.
Stamp says: 'The data comes from sources such as credit files, county court judgments and bankruptcy orders.'
Lenders use postcode data in different ways. Chris McDonald, an assistant general manager at Cumberland Building Society, says: ' Postcodes play no part in credit-scoring a mortgage. It is all down to the individual information on an application form.'
But your postcode may be more relevant if you are applying for quick credit, such as for a mobile phone contract, a mail order account or a storecard, where automated credit scoring systems are used.
It contradicts what I was told at the time, but that was a few years ago...

bga

8,134 posts

282 months

Tuesday 13th October 2009
quotequote all
mrmr96 said:
Legislation.
Thanks smile

I'm sure it would have made sense to someone once upon a time...