Getting advice on adverts/websites - and thread deletion.
Getting advice on adverts/websites - and thread deletion.
Author
Discussion

Anatol

Original Poster:

1,392 posts

265 months

Sunday 18th October 2009
quotequote all
I posted a topic yesterday (here in the Business forum) asking for some advice on whether or not some ad copy was too tongue-in-cheek.

Thank you to all that contributed your thoughts.

The post did not include any ads, just links to where the files were hosted on the web.

The thread has now been deleted. I've not been given any reason why. I assume that someone has interpreted (possibly because we're an automotive business) that we were doing so for our own commercial gain. Anyone actually reading the thread, and seeing how we responded to each piece of advice with an altered advert layout would probably have realised we were actually after the feedback.

There are plenty of threads still running on "what do you think of my website?" etc, all of which drive readers to look at the OP's advertising.

So what's the cut-off? Why is it ok for one poster to ask for feedback on their advertising, and not another?

I rather value the input we got, and I'd like to access that resource again, but I'm not looking to either abuse the system, or have more threads deleted or get banned.

Presumably there are mods watching this forum, their input would be welcome.

Thanks again for those who shared their thoughts.

Tol


Simpo Two

93,122 posts

296 months

Sunday 18th October 2009
quotequote all
Anatol said:
There are plenty of threads still running on "what do you think of my website?" etc, all of which drive readers to look at the OP's advertising.
Yes, I agree that seems odd. On several occasaions I've thought that the (suddenly numerous) 'What do you think of my website?' posts were thinly disguised advertising, or to try get more hits, but I did not think that in your case.

I know from my own experience that deleted threads can be reinstated so I hope they do so with yours.

Hunky Dory

1,096 posts

236 months

Sunday 18th October 2009
quotequote all
Simpo Two said:
On several occasaions I've thought that the (suddenly numerous) 'What do you think of my website?' posts were thinly disguised advertising, or to try get more hits,
I agree - I hardly ever look at such threads now for that reason.

Simpo Two

93,122 posts

296 months

Sunday 18th October 2009
quotequote all
I find it inconsistent that a thread regarding a website for a valeting company is allowed to run to two pages, but that a thread regarding a website for a scratch repair company is deleted without explanation, either at the time or subsequently on request.




Perhas there has been no explanation because there is none?

jeff m

4,066 posts

289 months

Monday 19th October 2009
quotequote all
I also thought this was a genuine post and not an attempt at advertising.
So I've given this a bump.




silver.fox.2008

820 posts

221 months

Monday 19th October 2009
quotequote all
I think it was abit harsh deleting the post.

It clearly wasn't advertising, just a genuine request for peoples opinions.