How long will the public sector pain last?
How long will the public sector pain last?
Author
Discussion

Four Cofffee

Original Poster:

11,838 posts

266 months

Friday 16th April 2010
quotequote all
I think we all recognise that whoever is in power, the public purse is in for a tightening for some time. But for how long? Is it a 2-3 year thing or will publis sctor spending have to be tight for years beyond that?


Most of my business is recruiting in the public sector but we have reserves to see out 2 or 3 years if need be.

I am wondering if I should spend the quiet time developing new product ready for when the wider ecomony and the public spending increases again. I did that in the private sector during the worst of the recession, and it seesm to have worked out quite well.

NORTS

633 posts

251 months

Friday 16th April 2010
quotequote all
Hard to say until May the 6th. Although i work in the Public sector and we've been told to make 20% cut backs throughout this year, beyond this hasn't been announced.

rich1231

17,340 posts

291 months

Friday 16th April 2010
quotequote all
I hope the suffering is eternal.

Four Cofffee

Original Poster:

11,838 posts

266 months

Friday 16th April 2010
quotequote all
I see Cameron is under attach=k for some of the things he said about waste in policing last night. His '400 police officers in the HR dept. in the Met includes;

208 - police officers teaching new police officer recruits, specials and probationers
26 - police officers training new PCSO's
63 - police officers in the Driver Training School teaching and assessing advanced and response driver training
55 - police officers in various other training roles
30 - police officers undertaking Sergeant and Inspector assessments and other work in the Career Management Unit
8 - police officers in the Police Federation, Superintendents' Association and Staff Support Associations
8 - police officers in Positive Action, recruitment, Community Engagement, Duties and other areas of HR work.

An MPS spokesperson said in 2010/11 the number is 370.

A Conservative spokesperson said Mr Cameron was simply pointing out the scale of the MPS HR department and questioned whether this was the best use of uniformed officers' time.

randlemarcus

13,646 posts

262 months

Friday 16th April 2010
quotequote all
Four Cofffee said:
208 - police officers teaching new police officer recruits, specials and probationers
Fairy nuff.
Four Cofffee said:
26 - police officers training new PCSO's
Sack the bloody lot of em.
Four Cofffee said:
63 - police officers in the Driver Training School teaching and assessing advanced and response driver training
Does it have to be uniform? Get the retired lot in again smile
Four Cofffee said:
55 - police officers in various other training roles
Hmm, which differs from the other 280 because?
Four Cofffee said:
30 - police officers undertaking Sergeant and Inspector assessments and other work in the Career Management Unit
Does this have to be fully staffed by real coppers? Isnt most of it paperwork?
Four Cofffee said:
8 - police officers in the Police Federation, Superintendents' Association and Staff Support Associations
Take a fricking career break.
Four Cofffee said:
8 - police officers in Positive Action, recruitment, Community Engagement, Duties and other areas of HR work.
Waste of air.

mybrainhurts

90,809 posts

286 months

Friday 16th April 2010
quotequote all
Four Cofffee said:
Most of my business is recruiting in the public sector
Traitor....hehe

randlemarcus

13,646 posts

262 months

Friday 16th April 2010
quotequote all
mybrainhurts said:
Four Cofffee said:
Most of my business is recruiting in the public sector
Traitor....hehe
Not a wholly unreasonable comment. Ask yourself if 52% of the workforce spending a percentage of the monies earned by the other 48% is, in any way, sustainable, and base your business plans around that.
I'd suggest that if you are increasing quality recruitment, there's still a place for you, but its not as big under a blue rosette.

Four Cofffee

Original Poster:

11,838 posts

266 months

Saturday 17th April 2010
quotequote all
randlemarcus said:
Four Cofffee said:
208 - police officers teaching new police officer recruits, specials and probationers
Fairy nuff.
Four Cofffee said:
26 - police officers training new PCSO's
Sack the bloody lot of em.
Four Cofffee said:
63 - police officers in the Driver Training School teaching and assessing advanced and response driver training
Does it have to be uniform? Get the retired lot in again smile
Four Cofffee said:
55 - police officers in various other training roles
Hmm, which differs from the other 280 because?
Four Cofffee said:
30 - police officers undertaking Sergeant and Inspector assessments and other work in the Career Management Unit
Does this have to be fully staffed by real coppers? Isnt most of it paperwork?
Four Cofffee said:
8 - police officers in the Police Federation, Superintendents' Association and Staff Support Associations
Take a fricking career break.
Four Cofffee said:
8 - police officers in Positive Action, recruitment, Community Engagement, Duties and other areas of HR work.
Waste of air.
I suspect there will be self defence, Chemical/nuclear/bilogical and firearms trainers in there, but the Met must be one of the few forces still using police officers in the driving school, although I suspect it is pursuit, armed response and surveillance driver training where experience in those areas is critical. I would have thought retired officers or civilian trainers on two thirds the wage could do most of the driver training the job (they do elsewhere). Those in sgt and insp assessments may be part of the promotion system assessing those seeking promotion as I recall they are using workplace based assessments now.


I think that the National Police Improvemnet Agency can expect a right kicking if DC gets in power because he is already saying he wants rid of quangos, and NPIA is one awfully big quango. Their CEO has just resigned (I think he leaves in September). Forces have taken student officer training back in-house so God knows what NPIA now do on the training side except make things more complicated. I see in last weeks 'Times' that Sir Norman Bettison (chief Constable West Yorks Police) was suggesting senior officers were over paid, so he might make a good champion as the new CEO. He's also not afraid of a fight and doesn't fit the mould of an intellectual wet rag, which some chief oficers are made from.

Four Cofffee

Original Poster:

11,838 posts

266 months

Saturday 17th April 2010
quotequote all
randlemarcus said:
mybrainhurts said:
Four Cofffee said:
Most of my business is recruiting in the public sector
Traitor....hehe
Not a wholly unreasonable comment. Ask yourself if 52% of the workforce spending a percentage of the monies earned by the other 48% is, in any way, sustainable, and base your business plans around that.
I'd suggest that if you are increasing quality recruitment, there's still a place for you, but its not as big under a blue rosette.
I think it has been a charmed life.

Oddly, as they cut HR depts. it may open up oportuiunities. When things are quiet, eventually they disband HR depts and that leaves them de-skilled for when they are needed.

I am amazed at some of the nonsense jobs they advertise. My favourite was 'South Asian Dance Development Officer', at the same time they cut the meals on wheels service!

Reality check on the way I think.

Edited by Four Cofffee on Saturday 17th April 08:04

Four Cofffee

Original Poster:

11,838 posts

266 months

Saturday 17th April 2010
quotequote all
So, how long with the 'nil by mouth 'last?

Beardy10

25,477 posts

206 months

Saturday 17th April 2010
quotequote all
Four Cofffee said:
So, how long with the 'nil by mouth 'last?
My guess is 2 or 3 years is the absolute minimum for the public sector .....we have unprecedented levels of liquidity being pumped into the system and the economy is barely growing. Whoever gets the job next month has to tread a very fine line.....

Four Cofffee

Original Poster:

11,838 posts

266 months

Saturday 17th April 2010
quotequote all
Beardy10 said:
Four Cofffee said:
So, how long with the 'nil by mouth 'last?
My guess is 2 or 3 years is the absolute minimum for the public sector .....we have unprecedented levels of liquidity being pumped into the system and the economy is barely growing. Whoever gets the job next month has to tread a very fine line.....
That was my thought. I went through the last squeeze in the mid 1980's and to be frank it was mainly about cutting overtime budgets, not replacing equipment or staff who left, having no 'project' money and restricting the optional mileage on vehicles, a 2-5% a year sort of way. There was no pain like redundancy but I think this one will be much, much harsher. Anyhing over 3% in cuts and I have doubt jobs will go.

But they have been preapring for 12 month or more. I have noticed jobs going unfilled, departments being merged to be more flexible when staff have to be cut, projects going out of the window or being managed internally. But I have also seen them rushing to get contracts signed on some pretty big flagship projects to secure them. Might stop the meetings and free lunches culture.

randlemarcus

13,646 posts

262 months

Saturday 17th April 2010
quotequote all
I'd agree with the timeframe, and with the depth of cuts. I think the Civil Service have internally recognised the need to become more efficient (thus the actions you've noted), but it's not going to be enough.

Cuts have to be made that will eliminate capability, not just allow them to do everything they want at skeletal staff until they're allowed to spend willy nilly again.

cymtriks

4,561 posts

276 months

Saturday 17th April 2010
quotequote all
The pain will last, in bursts and in stages, until we learn to live without debt or accept much higher taxes.

The way things are now we will rack up debt to fund the gravy train until it becomes a big problem then go through pain to reduce the problem then let it drift up again.

Only by not having any state debt or by raising the money by tax can this be permanently stopped.

So far the election campaign has blatantly ignored the massive elephant in the room. Arguing over 6 billion in savings or NI increases is farcical in the face of debt increasing by half a billion every day. The whole muppet show clearly shows that they dare not speak the truth.

Four Cofffee

Original Poster:

11,838 posts

266 months

Sunday 18th April 2010
quotequote all
I wonder what action they will (can) take on public sector pensions? I would have thought the first thing might be to stop new entrants.

Simpo Two

93,078 posts

296 months

Sunday 18th April 2010
quotequote all
cymtriks said:
The pain will last, in bursts and in stages, until we learn to live without debt or accept much higher taxes.
Or lower public spending. It's frightening how many people live off the taxpayer - and there aren't enough taxpayers to go round. Problem is - the swivel servants will all go on strike and bring the country to a standstill. I can't see a nice way out of the mess.

Andrew[MG]

3,360 posts

229 months

Monday 19th April 2010
quotequote all
I don't think (hope) public spending will ever go back to the way it's been for the past 13 years. I wouldn't mind if we actually got good value for money and good services but clearly we have one of the most inefficient public services in Europe. With the number of managers increasing and the number of workers decreasing then I don't even see how reducing the budget will help - we're just going to end up with terrible service at a lower cost. We need some actual reform and that could easily take a decade to even get started.

I've not heard anyone talking about the huge burden that all these PFI schemes have left us with. Many of these deals only last for 20 years meaning that in 10 years time we are going to be hit with huge new contracts to pay for schools and hospitals that are starting to fall apart.

bogie

17,106 posts

303 months

Monday 19th April 2010
quotequote all
forever hopefully .....my local council (where I worked 20 years ago) was 600 strong when I was there...they sold off various large depts and outsourced them (housing etc) but recently I note they have >1000 employees ....so what are all these people doing...as services provided seem to get less each year ?

no-one has an issue with NHS, Police, Armed forces etc ...but the whole civil service/local government is just one big job creation scheme paid for by everyone else ......

Graham

16,381 posts

315 months

Friday 30th April 2010
quotequote all
Four Cofffee said:
Most of my business is recruiting in the public sector but we have reserves to see out 2 or 3 years if need be.
Public sector consulting for us.... Im thinking of a career change !!!!